7 ms·
Someone high up at Toyota bet on fuel cells 20 years ago and can't back down now without losing too much face. That's the only explanation. Hydrogen just doesn'
by taneq 7y ago
Someone high up at Toyota bet on fuel cells 20 years ago and can't back down now without losing too much face. That's the only explanation. Hydrogen just doesn't make sense from any engineering viewpoint other than "make sure there are still gas stations and a fuel distribution network no matter the cost."
- ianai 7y agoI think they see the writing on the wall for their services business with solid state tech and wanting to fight the trend. Or, building engines are just such a core part of their company that they’re essentially petrol heads looking for a replacement as near as possible. But I’m low information on that and just speculating. Fuel cells are neat tech though. I also understand the argument they made with respect to using nickel hydride batteries over lithium. See their CFOs recent remarks.
- Aloha 7y agoHydrogen Fuel Cells are electric.
- ianai 7y agoYes, and they wear out and must be replaced. The drive train is powering an electric motor. Toyota might be expecting to get more service work out of fuel cells than batteries. Just throwing things at the wall for their motives though.
- darksaints 7y ago> Yes, and they wear out and must be replaced. Doesn't everything? Some production fuel cells have a service life of >50000 hrs. That's way more than you can expect out of batteries.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoThey should have been well placed to adopt EV's with their experience making the Prius. It's mind boggling to me that they didn't take advantage of that.
- Aloha 7y agoI can see a hybrid vehicle with both batteries and fuel cells as a future option however. I don't think we're doing to slay this problem with just one technology.
- tigershark 7y agoWhy on earth would you need that for a normal car?
- hutzlibu 7y agoWhy on earth was this downvoted? Because I think that concept already exists as prototypes. A small fuel cell for example can serve as a range extender. So for short drives you charge and use the batterie (cheap energywise). For long ranges the fuel cell adds power to charge the batterie. Methan or hydrogen is fast refueld and has a much bigger energy storage capacity compared to batteries.
- _ph_ 7y agoIf you look at the range of Teslas, it is close to the one of hydrogen fuel cell vehicles. The problem is, that hydrogen pressure tanks are large. Compare a Mirai to a Tesla Model 3. Even the recharging of the Tesla is close to the speed of hydrogen stations. (The refueling with hydrogen is faster, but then there are about 15 minutes in which the fuel pump has to repressure itself)
- ericalexander3 7y agoThat's not the Toyota way. From a Westrum "Three Cultures Model" perspective Toyota would fall into the Generative classification, not Pathological or Bureaucratic. Based on the discussion in the article I think Toyota is saying they've learned EVs are not scalable and are not a solution to all customer needs Toyota currently services. They're betting hydrogen is the solution.
- nihonde 7y agoPart of the reason that Toyota continues to pursue hydrogen fuel has to do with a Japan’s energy needs. It’s a pragmatic approach that acknowledges that energy needs to be stored and shipped long distances in order to avoid generating fuel in-country. Also, the idea that Toyota isn’t all over battery tech is a complete misunderstanding. All one needs to do is read their public strategy, which is available. They’ve been working on personal and ultra compact EVs, people movers, trucks, etc. They tend to release domestically first and move thoughtfully (cf. Tesla), as US consumers have proven to be very fickle, prone to nationalism, and so on.
- theluketaylor 7y agoI think there is a future in hydrogen fuel cells, but not for personal transportation. Heavy machinery operated in remote areas like farming equipment have pretty intense energy needs and downtime for charging could ruin a harvest. Batteries are also very heavy and soil compaction is a real issue for modern farming. I think we're approaching a time where the marginal cost of energy will be 0, but there will still be costs associated with using energy at a specific time or place. I would like to see a lot more dollars being spent on technology and facilities that can ramp their energy consumption up and down extremly quickly to absorb extra power on the grid. Hydrolysis seems like a fantastic candidate since the process is highly interruptible and the result is portable.
- the8472 7y agoTrains too, there are some experimental fuel cell lines replacing diesel locomotives in germany and they ordered more, so it seems to be working. Presumably it's cheaper than electrifying branch lines.
- Reason077 7y agoBattery electric trains also greatly reduce the cost of rail electrification. They can charge when running under the wires, then use battery power on unnelectrified sections and branch lines.
- taneq 7y agoI’d imagine you would only need a relatively short section of powered rail around each station, plus maybe some boosters for long inter-station runs or hills. I’m surprised this approach isn’t more common.
- api 7y agoI've always wondered why you couldn't just string a wire from a tower down to a combine, tractor, or other piece of farm equipment and run it right off the grid. Using very high voltage could allow the wire to not be that heavy.
- eddieh 7y ago> Hydrogen just doesn't make sense from any engineering viewpoint other than "make sure there are still gas stations and a fuel distribution network no matter the cost." There are gas stations and a fuel distribution network, so it makes sense to use the existing infrastructure.
- marcosdumay 7y agoOur current fuel containers are completely unable to hold hydrogen. Neither can the fuel transportation infrastructure.
- scythe 7y agoFuel cells might be able to compete in that small slice of the market that needs deep-cold compatible vehicles. There are millions of people who live in places like Edmonton or Novosibirsk where temps can drop below -40. I don’t know if current HFCs can handle that but since gas solubility is higher at low temperatures it seems like a possibility. Lowering battery operating temperatures seems to be a hard problem.
- GeertB 7y agoBattery management systems deal with this by using some energy to heat the pack. So dealing with cold temperatures is just a measure of insulation and some vampire drain. While driving, or parked in a garage, there are no issues of course. Note that Norway is the European country where Tesla cars are most popular, so the problem seems to be nonconsequential in practice.
- kwhitefoot 7y agoNorway is rather warmer than Novosibirsk. Annual average temperature in Drammen is 6 C, Novosibirsk 1 C. January average in Drammen is -3.6 C, Novosibirsk -17.3 C. See https://en.climate-data.org/asia/russian-federation/novosibirsk-oblast/novosibirsk-459/ https://en.climate-data.org/asia/russian-federation/novosibi... and https://en.climate-data.org/europe/norway/buskerud/drammen-9882/ https://en.climate-data.org/europe/norway/buskerud/drammen-9... But generally speaking you are correct. My Tesla S 70D has active battery temperature management and can be set to precondition the battery and heat the cabin at set times every day so that it is ready to go when you commute to work.
- woodandsteel 7y agoA problem with that idea is that the total numbers would be so small that there would never be any real economies of scale, and so the cars would be too expensive for most people to afford.
- woodandsteel 7y ago>Someone high up at Toyota bet on fuel cells 20 years ago and can't back down now without losing too much face That's it exactly. At the time li-ion batteries were pretty poor, so fuel cells seemed like a good bet. Since then batteries have progressed much faster than fuel cells, and now are way ahead, and no doubt that will continue in the future. Many observers have commented over the decades that Japanese corporations have great difficulty admitting they have made a mistake, and this seems to be another case of that.
- new_realist 7y agoGermany, Korea, Australia and China are also all over hydrogen.
- sumedh 7y agoDoes Australia even have a car industry?
- tomwilson 7y agoIt did. It died.
- _ph_ 7y agoI don't see much of hydrogen here in Germany. Volkswagen, the biggest car manufacturer has clearly set the bets on battery electric. Mercedes has a hydrogen car, but only leases it out, doesn't sell it. Of course, everyone who missed the battery electric car market so far is still talking about hydrogen as "the future".
- woodandsteel 7y agoHow many hydrogen charging stations are there in Japan and all those countries combined, as compared with how many electric charging stations? Li-ion ev's outsell hydrogen ones about a hundred to one, and the numbers are going to greatly increase in the coming years. Hydrogen for cars has never gone anywhere and it never will.