4 ms·
It seems to me, actually, the body position that seems most incorrect (eg in the Monarch poster). The body remains largely horizontal, and "above" the wings. I
by pbhjpbhj 7y ago
It seems to me, actually, the body position that seems most incorrect (eg in the Monarch poster). The body remains largely horizontal, and "above" the wings.
I saw this post first time around (on HN) and bought the complaint completely. But, having now looked at lots of slow motion butterfly flight pictures I think she's over-stating it a little.
Look at this [1], or a slow-mo of Monarchs: the white & black Tree Nymph (I think it's called) in particular, especially at first take off, or when gliding, has quite a swept forward wing. Perhaps about 120deg spacing.
Other butterflies, of the ones I saw it was smaller ones but the OP observes the contrary, have greater than 180deg spacing. That made me wonder if the wing sweep was more to do with flight conditions (wind speed, etc.)?
Projection, the angle you observe from, is a key factor in the apparent shape too.
[1] https://youtu.be/aBfJtTm_XD4 https://youtu.be/aBfJtTm_XD4
- dkersten 7y agoJust going from that video, it seems to me that the wings are inly really forward for the upwards portion of when they flap their wings, which is only a portion of the positioning while flapping, and that at-rest the wings are not forward. (I only watched that one video and only once, though, so perhaps I’m incorrect)
- sfink 7y agoI dunno, to me it makes the most sense to portray an at-rest butterfly as it would appear by choice, when it is resting with its wings fully extended (whether for display, or to soak up sunlight, I don't know). And those seem to nearly universally have overlapped wings, as the author describes. As for snapshotting a butterfly in flight, the wings are so briefly spread fully that it seems more problematic to show such a brief, flat angle all the time. All in all, though, I kinda hate this post. I can't unsee it now. I still find it to be a great, well-stated, and thought provoking, though.
- Mathnerd314 7y agoMy impression is that at-rest butterflies usually have their wings folded together, like this: https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Melanargia_galathea_bottom_MichaD.jpg https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Melanargia_galathea_... When they're sunning themselves it's a more relaxed position, similar to https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Man_with_a_backpiece_Christian_and_Enlightenment_tattoo._Color.jpg https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Man_with_a_backpiece... Overall though all the positions seem good and it's more of an artistic choice. The "dead butterfly" pose shows off the wing patterns better and it's close enough to positions the butterflies assume in daily life. You don't often see spread-eagle positions in photos either but nobody would mind using it to show off some full-body tattoos.
- marcosdumay 7y agoLooks like they move their wings like birds, there is a forward movement that avoids pushing any air, and a backwards movement where they push the air back. If so, the more effort they are making (so, at take off, hoovering, and against the wind), the longer they will push their wings ahead. (I did never notice this before, and it's kind of surprising because most insects move differently. But it does make a lot of sense, because they have large wings and can not really fly like a mosquito.)