6 ms·
> It seems to me that remote work does a whole hell of a lot to reduce CO2 emissions Remote work involves a hell of a lot of flying in my experience... How man
by chrisseaton 7y ago
> It seems to me that remote work does a whole hell of a lot to reduce CO2 emissions
Remote work involves a hell of a lot of flying in my experience... How many car journeys do I have to have saved to pay for one flight to the office every now and again?
- tapland 7y agoAbout the distance of the flight.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- marcosdumay 7y agoAbout the distance of the flight by bus. How does the efficiency of a car compares to a bus/plane? (Both are roughly on the same mark, larger planes are usually more efficient.) If you commute 10km each way every working day, you'll move nearly 3,000km on a year.
- IggleSniggle 7y agoIf you work remote anyway, take the train! (only partly joking)
- icebraining 7y agoI've thought about this, the problem is the cost. My trip would cost 3-5 times more, which is hard to justify to the company. They'll probably just tell me they'll pay for those "CO2 compensation programs".
- api 7y agoA fully loaded aircraft gets pretty good fuel economy per person, at least as good as a Prius. I've seen figures from 50-100mpg depending on aircraft and of course how fully loaded it is. So it's basically like driving a little less than the flight distance.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- nameless912 7y agoRight, but (from what I remember from an article I read years ago) emissions from aircraft are worse, pound for pound of CO2, than those of a car because they're deposited directly into the upper atmosphere as opposed to at ground level. I don't remember exactly why, but it's worse because of its location rather than the actual amount.
- ghaff 7y agoI'm a bit skeptical that remote/distributed work (as opposed to just WFH instead of going into a local office every day) nets out to be all that green. It's hard for me to factor out travel that would have happened anyway from travel that's specifically related to being on a distributed team. But I probably do something like 10K miles/year flying that wouldn't exist if the team were co-located.
- notacoward 7y agoThis is something I have some experience with. I work from home most of the time, except for travel across the US one week a month. I was concerned about my carbon footprint, so I ran some numbers. The result I got was that I was about 8% worse than someone with an uncongested 10-mile (one way) daily commute in a typical compact car. That guy driving a Ford Compensator thirty miles each way at peak hours is way worse. Nonetheless, I wish my number could be reduced still further. The problem IMO is that too little work is truly remote. If the rest of your team is colocated somewhere else then you'll have to travel. If your team is spread all over but still relies on face to face meetings (e.g. planning sessions, "all hands" announcements, hackathons) then you'll still have to travel. If your job/role involves dealing with customers who aren't even slightly remote-friendly, you'll have to travel. If you're in or adjacent to academe, you'll have to travel to conferences. Most of these exceptions are not necessary. Unfortunately, most people and companies don't even try to avoid them. They just do what they've done, and the not-really-remote workers have to fly in.
- gbrown 7y ago> If you're in or adjacent to academe, you'll have to travel to conferences. I really think we should be working to change this - conferences are huge wastes of resources IMHO. I usually see a handful of inspiring talks, which could just as easily have been delivered as webinars (which would also allow asynchronous viewing, involving a wider potential audience). Then again, I'm antisocial and terrible at "networking", so those aspects of conferences don't really appeal to me.
- ghaff 7y ago>Then again, I'm antisocial and terrible at "networking", so those aspects of conferences don't really appeal to me. And, really, the "hallway track" is the value of going to conferences. For the most part, if someone just goes to a conference to sit in breakout sessions, they're probably better off just watching video of the sessions (if they were filmed) or a webinar version of the content.
- notacoward 7y ago
- buboard 7y ago> Remote work involves a hell of a lot of flying in my experience. I don't think that 's true in general though. Is that even remote work? There are now hundreds of companies who only meet for yearly retreats. and these are optional.
- chrisseaton 7y agoEven the most remote of the remote workers I know will go into the office at least once a quarter or so. Four trans-oceanic flights is surely going to outweigh all but the most extreme car commutes.
- icebraining 7y agoThat's curious, this hasn't been my experience. Why are they needed physically at the office so often?
- chrisseaton 7y agoTo make in-person connections and to present and teach in-person. I don't think it's particularly contentious to say that these things often work better in-person, even as someone who thinks remote work is best and has been doing it my whole career. Once a quarter also probably doesn't seem like a lot to people who are going to a conference every month or so anyway.
- icebraining 7y agoA conference every month! How do you get any work done? By teaching, do you mean workshops/classes? We generally mentor people, but never actually tried teaching. But do most developers in your company teach?
- chrisseaton 7y agoI don't do that many conferences, but I know people who do. They do work at the conferences around meeting people and presenting their work. I find I'm more productive straight after a conference. Mentoring people, yes. For very difficult topics that's definitely easier in person. Everyone teaches to some degree yeah. How do you level people up without teaching them?
- tharne 7y agoThis has been my experience as well. The amount of flying done by most remote workers is astounding. If anything, remote workers have a bigger carbon footprint than your typical commuter from all the flying. The other thing I see is a lot of remote workers moving to very sparsely populated areas that are cheap to live in, but where they end up driving 40 minutes for groceries. There are lots of great benefits to remote work, but environmentalism (in most cases) is not one of them.
- cableshaft 7y agoI (and everyone in my office, except the director, who flew once to go to corporate headquarters) have flown zero times in a year and a half of working remotely. It's not a guarantee that remote workers will necessarily do a bunch of flying. It depends on the culture of the workplace. We are able to get plenty done with conference calls and email. I can't speak for the management and executives above the director, though. They might do a decent amount of travel. But there's about 200 employees that aren't doing any travel at all for work, and only a handful of people in management above them. And from what I hear, it sounds like a lot of the other departments in the corporation don't do a whole lot of travel either.
- icebraining 7y agoI'm curious, why are those remote workers flying? I've started working remotely this year, and only flown once, at the start of the project.
- chrisseaton 7y agoAre you not flying anyway, to go to conferences and things?
- ghaff 7y agoA lot of developers really don't travel a lot for work if they don't speak to customers much. And it's not uncommon that a developer/sysadmin may get to go to one conference a year or something like that. Certainly some people I work with, whether developers or other roles, are traveling all the time. But it's not everyone.
- i_am_proteus 7y agoIt seems like a hybrid model would be ideal: teams that work from home in a metro area, with one or two "meeting days" a week at an office (which can be 20-30% the size it would be with no work from home). This is something companies could incrementally adopt with existing employees.
- defined 7y agoI think it depends on one's personality. I worked for some years using that hybrid model and really didn't like it. Now I work 99.9% from home and vastly prefer it. My only real gripe is that teleconferencing for meetings just doesn't work that well, because I find it hard to hear people that are not very close to the microphone, and background noise from the open-plan office in which the non-remote team works is very disruptive at times. Well, and that sometimes remote workers are sort-of-not-quite second-class citizens, probably because we aren't in the office for people to see every day.
- blunte 7y agoFor many of us, remote work means staying home all day and working. (Or sometimes, traveling somewhere nice and working.) But how many flights and how often is up to you. In my case, it's just 2-3 per year... and I would have probably made those flights anyway for a holiday.
- ubermonkey 7y agoThat has NOT been my experience, but mileage varies. I've worked for a virtual company -- no offices anywhere, everyone works at home -- for 12 years. The developers almost NEVER travel. The owner and I used to be on the road quite a bit (just like most software firms) -- say, through 2010 -- but then it seemed like all our clients and prospects kinda had the penny drop: they didn't NEED US on site to do implementations. GoToMeeting or Skype or WebEx or whatever was entirely sufficient, and saved a shitton of money too. I haven't visited a client site in over 3 years. I see my boss at 2 conferences a year. HE makes a few more trips -- partner conferences, a few sales trips -- but nothing like what it was in 07-10.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- chrisseaton 7y ago> I suspect a plane puts out less CO2 per person than a car going to and from the same place. Err... yeah... except I don't drive from the UK to San Francisco. The relevant comparison is a twenty minute drive a day, vs flying inter-continental a few times a year.
- UnpossibleJim 7y agoThis is in the current remote work environment. If we (the royal we) could encourage a 3 or 4 day remote in and a single day commute (preferably on a bus, but that would be too much to ask for), it would still be a local community and not make air travel necessary. There can be varying shades of remote work, even allowing for a weekly stand up =)
- fulafel 7y agoSure, this can be done eco-friendlily or not. If you prioritize co2 emissions in the remote setup, you can decide that thete will be no flying.
- clairegraham 7y agoWas this at a 100% remote company, or were you a remote worker at an in-office company? I've worked remote 15+ years and that much flying is abnormal in my experience. Some places do quarterly, but I found that rare too. A lot of them do an annual retreat, but it's often optional. Or sometimes we would do a mini-meetup at a developer conference. It also depends on the position. Most of the flying was for brainstorming sessions in the leadership / project team, but most of the team didn't need to be involved in those. I will also say I've always interviewed over either phone or google hangouts and I've never had to meet in-person before the offer. I've sometimes gone years without meeting the people I work with in-person.