8 ms·
How to solve the housing crisis: get the government out. Nobody should be forced to have an electrical outlet in the garage for an electric car and the governm
by exabrial 7y ago
How to solve the housing crisis: get the government out.
Nobody should be forced to have an electrical outlet in the garage for an electric car and the government has no business requiring that.
This is just my favorite example of thousands of silly regulations that are put in place to keep the poor from becoming owners.
No poor person can afford a Tesla, yet: https://www.greencarreports.com/news/1095076_ca-to-require-new-buildings-to-be-wired-for-electric-car-charging-stations https://www.greencarreports.com/news/1095076_ca-to-require-n...
- daveslash 7y agoAgreed. If you have enough money to own a house with a garage and electric car, you can probably afford to have an electrician run an outlet to your garage if it doesn't already have one. Similarly, I doubt anyone who owns a house and gasoline car is going car shopping and saying "Oh, honey, this car is electric, and we don't have an outlet in the garage... we can't get this..."
- cr0sh 7y agoYou have the qualifier of "probably" - but money may not be the only thing holding someone back. For instance, I want a 220 outlet in my garage so I can have a proper welder out there. I don't have an electric car (and even if someday I do own one, it won't fit in my current garage, due to various reasons - chief one being it's a conversion from a carport). That all said - I am not sure I can get such an outlet. Money isn't the issue - but it could become the issue. Because I would need an additional 220 circuit added to my existing circuits in my breaker box. But the panel is full. So I would probably need to either get a larger panel, or add on an auxiliary panel (likely the latter). But that also depends on my service from the main transformer. I might not be able to get an extra circuit if my service isn't large enough to support such an extra circuit. The only way to change that would be to have a larger capacity transformer installed. That transformer is shared between my house and the neighbor's house. I don't even want to contemplate what it would cost to change that out (thinking somewhere in the 5 figure range - but where?). So money isn't an issue - until you have an electrician come out and tell you that to run an additional line is going to require major changes to your current electrical service.
- jsight 7y agoThis was my thought on seeing the regulation as well. Although it may have been better to mandate panels leaving room for expansion instead of mandating a 240v outlet.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoThey make 120v breakers that have two switches on them and two hot terminals in order to save space in the panel. That sounds like exactly what you need.
- jjeaff 7y agoFitting in additional breakers is not usually a problem and adding an expansion panel isn't either. If the supply from the transformer isn't enough, then I don't see a regulation requiring a 220v in your garage affecting that. Whether it's new or an an upgrade later, you are going to have the same problem.
- alamortsubite 7y agoHave you checked with your electric company? Depending on where you live, it's likely they will upgrade the transformer at no cost to you.
- cookieswumchorr 7y agowhat does the average guy do in this situation? exactly, get an extender, plug it into a random outlet in the house, attach it with duct tape, job done. Regulations have made our lives safer once again
- imtringued 7y ago> "Oh, honey, this car is electric, and we don't have an outlet in the garage... we can't get this..." I have that problem. It will probably cost me $3000-$4000 to install the wall charger and then in 10 years they will probably rip it out and replace it with a whole set of wall chargers with central load balancing for a much lower cost because the cost of running a wire doesn't increase with the number of chargers. (Underground garage of an apartment complex if it wasn't obvious)
- pgcj_poster 7y agoI find this a very weird thing to be upset about. The cost is a drop in the bucket when it comes to the price of a house, and I imagine plenty of people would like having an outlet there even if they don't drive an electric car. I'm sure there are lots of pernicious regulations, but this doesn't seem like a great example of one. Electric cars are up against a vicious cycle: no one will build houses to accommodate electric cars until a lot of people have them, but most people won't buy an electric car if they can't charge it in their garage. So if you want people to drive electric cars, which the government rightly does, it makes sense to require that new houses are built with electric cars in mind. Yes, Teslas are expensive, but the expectation is that the houses will still be around once electric vehicles are more affordable, and it's cheaper to prepare for them now than to retrofit later on.
- SQueeeeeL 7y agoElectric cars are still a luxury good.....
- standardUser 7y agoYou can buy a used Leaf for under $15k. Not exactly luxury pricing.
- madhadron 7y agoFor $4k, as it happens. As I did a few weeks ago.
- 205guy 7y agoI bought a NEW Leaf for $16K (after tax credit) in 2017 when they were liquidating the 1st generation models. It has 30 kWh of battery and a range of about 120 miles. Right now, you can buy a USED Leaf under $5K, but it probably has a worn out battery with 60-70 miles of range usable: https://sfbay.craigslist.org/search/sss?query=nissan+leaf&sort=rel&max_price=5000 https://sfbay.craigslist.org/search/sss?query=nissan+leaf&so...
- crooked-v 7y ago
- tzs 7y agoThe regulation you cited only applies to new construction, and according to link you gave adds about $50 to the cost of the house. This is not going to stop anyone from becoming an owner--poor people tend to by existing house, not new construction. A level 2 charger is not much different from an electric clothes dryer as far as your house electrical infrastructure is concerned, so when putting in support for the later it is cheap and easy to put in support for the former, too.
- refurb 7y agoThat’s one example. Now add up all the other requirements.
- vkou 7y agoHow much of the $700,000-$1,500,000 price of a 15-year-old house in a coastal city is due to all of these requirements adding up? 2%? 5%? It's not the reason why I was stepping around a homeless person sprawled in the middle of the sidewalk on my Monday commute. The reason housing is unaffordable is the cost of land, availability of credit, and the self-fulfilling expectation that houses are a good investment that will grow in price.
- exabrial 7y ago*cost of land in California
- seiferteric 7y agoThat was just one example of the many new requirements that make houses more expensive. Solar panels will now be required on all new homes. Also fire sprinkler systems are required, adding somewhere between $5k-$10k in costs. Each new regulation might seem okay on its own, but all of these things add up.
- hnuser77 7y agoSpeaking of building regulations and solar, I stayed in a house that was completely powered by solar and wired with DC for lights and electronics. You can't just add an AC outlet in the kitchen for a coffee grinder, though. If you have even one AC outlet, you have to wire the entire house to code -- useless and unused AC outlets every few feet along the hallways, AC outlet in the bathroom even though the inverter can't handle most of the things (e.g. hair dryers) that would be plugged in in a bathroom.
- mywittyname 7y agoLet's not throw the baby out with the bath water. We have building regulations because buildings before regulations were dangerous or unusable to such a degree that citizens banded together to outlaw such buildings in the future. Communities don't want homes built in their neighborhoods which lack plumbing or electricity. Also, we don't build housing for the poor, we build housing for the wealthy and middle class, which later becomes available to the poor due to depreciation. I live in a city where literal mansions have been carved up into apartment buildings over the years and where poor people live in Italianate apartments with beautiful stonework.
- jfengel 7y agoComplaints about regulations always ring hollow to me, because they always seem to imagine that regulations spring into being ex nihilo. Regulations are practically always written in response to something going wrong -- frequently, involving somebody ending up dead. So often it just seems callous: this regulation is inconveniencing me, so let's remove it. If that harms other people, that's their problem. That doesn't mean that the regulations were well designed, or even if they were, that the reasons remain the same. But that's the point: regulations are removed by the same processes that create them, and they don't get into place lightly, either. So if you want a regulation removed, you need to figure out what caused it to be created in the first place. Only then can you create a better regulation that solves the problems that need to be solved.
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> So often it just seems callous: this regulation is inconveniencing me, so let's remove it. If that harms other people, that's their problem. Given that the rules are nominally in place to benefit occupants, I don't see where you're getting a conflict of interest. It's offering to suffer the alleged harm yourself in exchange for not having to pay significantly higher housing costs. > But that's the point: regulations are removed by the same processes that create them The problem is that they're not. As you say they're often imposed following some fatality. But even if the new rule is ineffective garbage, it's unlikely to be traceable to any specific deaths. The way regulations kill people is much more indirect, e.g. by making housing more expensive so that people who can no longer afford it freeze to death on the streets, or die in car crashes because they have to live somewhere with a longer commute and the additional vehicle miles turned them into a statistic. What that means is that there is a process for getting individual rules added in practice but no equivalent process for getting individual rules removed, so they accumulate over time. > Only then can you create a better regulation that solves the problems that need to be solved. A huge part of the issue is that some problems don't have cost-effective solutions. If you can prevent one death every ten years by raising housing costs by $1/month, notice that in a city with a million homes you've just spent $120M to save one life. If the value of a statistical life is something like $10M, well, we just overpaid by >1000%. And we may not know of any way to prevent that death for the less than $0.10/month cost increase it would take to make it cost effective. (You also need to verify that the rule is actually effective and not just speculate that it might work when it might not.) But local zoning boards are hardly doing that kind of cost benefit analysis every time they add a new rule to their thick book of rules, so consequently huge swathes of the existing rules come out on the wrong side of it. And since nothing ever really gets people excited about any given individual minor regulatory inefficiency until they stack up to be killing thousands of people on net, fixing that problem characteristically comes in the form of a mass culling of existing rules.
- stellar678 7y ago*Addendum: Nobody should be forced to have a garage on their house and the government has no business requiring that.
- dhimes 7y agoHave you ever been to an area that doesn't have regulations on housing? No, thank you. There will be some crappy ones, but overall it's a win.
- big_chungus 7y agoI've been to places with more and less regulation. I've noticed that while California is significantly more regulated than Kansas, I'm much more likely to see a "quirky", "fun", or "exotic" domicile in the former than the latter. The government has a much greater capacity to hinder than promote legislatively; we have seen a hindrance of normal housing and a promotion of very little in its place.
- elil17 7y agoHuston doesn't having zoning laws and they're doing fine. Have you ever been to an area that doesn't have regulations on housing?
- closetohome 7y agohttps://www.forbes.com/sites/scottbeyer/2017/08/30/did-houston-flood-because-of-a-lack-of-zoning https://www.forbes.com/sites/scottbeyer/2017/08/30/did-houst...
- elil17 7y agoThe article's title: Did Huston Flood Because of a Lack of Zoning? The article's actual content: >All the same, it doesn't seem that tight regulations, or less development, have prevented flooding in other cities. When New Orleans was hit by Hurricane Katrina in 2005, it had far less impervious surface than Houston does now; in fact, its population had been declining in every decade since 1970. Alas, the tragedy wasn’t about that anyway, but about infrastructure that collapsed and spilled water into a flood plain--a flood plain that had been developed despite New Orleans' strict zoning laws. When Hurricane Sandy hit New York City, it damaged a metro area that, overall, is both denser and more regulated than Houston. In the last decade alone, flooding has also hit Iowa, Georgia, Tennessee, Colorado, and various other regions with diverse geography and regulations.
- CalRobert 7y agoI upvoted you, but it's not black and white. The government prevents someone from opening a lead smelting plant next to a school (hopefully). They also force homes to have two exits from every room in case of fire, etc. But they also discovered manufacturing housing scarcities and _also_ making massive, lifelong loans available for housing are a GREAT way to keep your population working really hard to just barely keep a roof over their head. Want to work part time and pursue art? Want to stay home and watch your child grow up? Too bad, there's 10 more people who'll outbid you for your house, so you have to design your life around income maximization. These scarcities are created with zoning, parking minimums (maybe the most horrible part), green space (aka yard size) requirements, ridiculously large streets, density restrictions, etc. The escape is to leave the city and work remote (honestly it's amazing what having no mortgage and no rent does to your sense of agency) but that's an option open to rather few people, and probably not for long as it becomes normalized and wages adjust as a result.
- exabrial 7y agoYep. There's a difference between my example and proper fire exits. I didn't capture that in my original post, but I fully agree. Unfortunately the power to regulate these things has been abused to keep the poor out of housing permanently.
- kljoiutr 7y ago> They also force homes to have two exits from every room in case of fire, etc. That can't be true? That makes 90% of existing homes illegal to build again.
- legulere 7y agoThe problem isn't government regulation, it's bad regulation.
- big_chungus 7y agoThis smacks of the No True Scotsman problem - were all the regulations good, we wouldn't have this problem. And yet, governments are by and large incompetent, and most regulations they pass are bad. Almost all have significant unintended consequences. The ways to fix this are to minimize regulation at all levels and make regulation as hyper-local as possible.
- shkkmo 7y agoIn what way? There are many regulations that are critical to a functioning society. Seeing a set of bad regulations and saying "that's it get rid of all of them" smacks of throwing the baby out with the bathwater.
- big_chungus 7y ago> There are many regulations that are critical to a functioning society. I disagree vehemently, and believe there are very few that are necessary, aside from enforcing the harm principle and a few basic functions (i.e. diplomacy & military). Rather, most people use laws to attempt to enforce upon society their visions of how it ought to look and operate (i.e. drug bans, zoning). My motivation for getting rid of _most_ regulations is ideological (I can think of no ethical justification for the state to compel, by force, a home-owner to install an outlet in his wall), and I was attempting to illustrate a practical aspect of why; I don't believe there's much "bathwater" to be thrown out that wouldn't have been provided through other means.
- shkkmo 7y agoYour motivation may be ideological but it is not in anyway practical. If you look worldwide, places with minimal levels of regulation and enforcent tend to be more impoverished and almost no countries with a functioning government have the level of regulation that you advocate. The evidence strongly suggest that regulation tends to increase economic efficiency (at least up to a point). Perhaps you can redirect your ideological distaste to find ways to help systematically determine which regulations are effective/necessary and expediently remove those that are harmful rather than advocating for a state of affairs that ignores reality.
- GuB-42 7y agoWe never have enough outlets, and it is a good thing mandating enough of them in new constructions. In fact, at least in France, where I live, it is a common annoyance in old houses: not enough outlet. Some people add them later on, and it is not always pretty... or safe. There is now rules mandating a minimum of outlets and light fixtures for new constructions, and it is a good thing. Electric car or not, a high enough amperage outlet is good to have. And you have to think long term too. Electric cars are mostly luxury vehicles now, but things are evolving. And consider that the next owner may have an electric car if you ever want to sell your house. Of course, you can install the outlet later, but generally, doing things later in a house is a huge pain in the ass. For example, you want to drill holes and make a mess before painting and furnishing. These regulations actually make things cheaper, because you don't have to rebuild things later.
- foobiekr 7y agoA friend is remodeling (drastically) their house in Mountain View. Some of the code stuff seems crazy. Bathrooms must have motion sensor and humidity sensor enabled fans? Bathroom lights must be motion sensor enabled? I’m sure there’s something driving all of this that has some basis in a real concern (similar to sprinkler systems and networked smoke detectors) but it seems like the complex and higher cost code-driven housing requirements is basically unbounded.
- Aeolun 7y agoWhy do I want a motion sensor in my bathroom? Every time I find a house where that is the case I have to keep waving my arms about when having a dump :(
- philsnow 7y agoThat and practically disallowing the sale of incandescent light fixtures. It's all typical California insanity. You don't have to deal with that in a lot of other parts of the country.
- tstrimple 7y agoLED and CFL lights use the same fixtures as incandescent which are not banned in California. In my experience, the number of people spreading FUD about California far exceeds the craziness coming from the state itself.
- 9HZZRfNlpR 7y agoWhile this stuff can be cheap, it sounds insane. I understand that it can vary from state to state but American building code and zoning sounds so over regulated to European countries. I wonder why there isn't more pushback from people since Americans tend to prefer liberties and freedom.
- m463 7y agoBe careful - a lot of these "quick, solve the housing crisis" invite in sketchy developer practices that cut the most ridiculous corners when building. Prewiring new homes for solar or electric cars probably costs $100 when building a house. Romex is that cheap and pulling the wires before the walls have drywall is trivial. Doing it after the house is built is several orders of magnitude more expensive, and a great barrier to homeowners.
- corodra 7y agoUm, what electrician are you hiring that runs wire from roof to ground and terminates, and provides materials for just $100 bucks?
- Aeolun 7y agoI think the point is more that you are already paying them $2000 to run some wires from roof to ground, running an additional wire while they’re doing those only costs you an extra $100.
- corodra 7y agoA new trace for 3 to 8 gauge cable depending on load from roof to ground isn't a five min job nor are they cheap, both wire and labor. Hell, I charged 80/hr for low voltage pulling. High voltage is a whole different set of concerns and fire risk. This isn't something to hand wave as incidental and throw numbers around putting silly ideas in people's heads.
- yonran 7y ago> How to solve the housing crisis: get the government out. It’s not just government; private contracts often prohibit homeowners from serving more residents. In Zoning Rules! (https://www.amazon.com/Zoning-Rules-Economics-Land-Regulation/dp/155844288X https://www.amazon.com/Zoning-Rules-Economics-Land-Regulatio...), William Fischel describes how zoning can substitute for private CC&Rs, which are worse than zoning in that amendments often require supermajority of all property owners in the neighborhood instead of simple majority. Property rights that are too strong can be just as big of a problem as government regulations that are too restrictive.
- FriedBread 7y agoI can still see some value to building codes and regulations, but I really don't see what benefit the very strict zoning regulations are bringing to the table. If my neighbor and I decide to sell our land to a developer so they can build a small apartment complex we should be allowed to. If the neighbors don't like the idea of having an apartment nearby they can see if they can get in on the deal too (probably turning a tidy profit on their lot) or they can suck it. It's my land I should be able to sell it to whomever I want or build whatever I want provided the structure doesn't pose a physical risk to my neighbor or their property.
- simonsarris 7y agoBut when your neighbors bought the land they bought it priced with the knowledge that their neighbors (you) could not do that, so to them, you can suck it. (I'm for relaxing zoning laws but if you ever wanted to convince anyone this kind of argument is like the last approach you should use.)
- FriedBread 7y agoYeah I don't usually find "suck it" to be a compelling argument it's more expressive. They didn't quite price in the current zoning restrictions in that they were as changeable then as they are now. If I was particularly motivated and persuasive (or let's be honest good at grift) I could still convince my local city council to rezone my neighborhood to allow said sale. My formulation just doesn't force me to go through a middleman who, most likely, really doesn't care about my neighbor's concerns are just what their cut will be.
- CaptainZapp 7y agoWould you make the same argument if your neighbor sells their land to build a tannery or for the construction of a brothel? See, I thought not.
- dahart 7y agoThere are a lot of places in the world that have little government regulation and a huge housing crisis. What’s the evidence for government being the problem, or for getting rid of it being the solution? Nobody is being forced to have a car charging outlet in the garage. From your link: “The rule specifies that one- and two-family dwellings have a service panel with capacity for a 40-amp circuit--enough for a 32-amp charging station--and conduit that can support wiring for an 80-amp circuit. “The estimated cost of compliance is reportedly around $50, a fraction of the cost of adding the appropriate electrical service and wiring later on.” And you know Teslas aren’t the only electric cars, and that more brands are on the way, right?
- danans 7y ago> Nobody should be forced to have an electrical outlet in the garage for an electric car and the government has no business requiring that. > This is just my favorite example of thousands of silly regulations that are put in place to keep the poor from becoming owners. That one regulation is marginal compared to the effects of very restrictive zoning for density and transit, which is usually a tool most effectively implemented by highly exclusive locales.
- imgabe 7y agoThe trivial cost of adding one outlet when building a new home is not what is preventing poor people in California from buying a home. The price is in the land not the building.
- peglasaurus 7y agoDifferent areas/regions/countries have such different norms. Where I'm from if someone said a property for sale had no power in the garage I'd be genuinely surprised and wonder what went wrong during the build. The same level of surprise as if there was no roof. Power in the garage is so useful. 240 volt power at a minimum as well. That level of expectation goes back several decades. I don't own a Tesla or EV.
- zip1234 7y agoI would include things like home owner's associations as government. They only thing they are good at is maintaining shared resources. Everything else about them is counterproductive. They lock neighborhoods into being the same forever.
- subject117 7y agoThis. People miss the broader picture when they support “safety” regulations. Politicians will often amplify the outliers in order to gain public support to enact regulations that further monopolize returns for their buddies.