4 ms·
this is why i'm against property tax. I m all for a sales tax - because a sale reveals the true value of a property, and thus can tax it accurately.
by chii 7y ago
this is why i'm against property tax. I m all for a sales tax - because a sale reveals the true value of a property, and thus can tax it accurately.
- seanmcdirmid 7y agoThe lack of a property tax allows for property to be used as an asset rather than used productively. The lack of a property tax in China has already wreaked led to this kind of behavior there en masse, with lots of empty apartments even in hot markets being used as basically gold bars hidden under a bed.
- felipellrocha 7y agoI think the issue is a bit more nuanced than that
- SEMW 7y agoYou may be interested in Harberger tax, which is a proposal for a kind of property tax that incentivizes the owner to declare its true value. https://academic.oup.com/jla/article/9/1/51/3572441 https://academic.oup.com/jla/article/9/1/51/3572441
- gamblor956 7y agoIronically, this is why I support a property tax but not a sales tax. Sales taxes are regressive and inhibit economic activity. Property taxes target accumulated wealth and incentivize the most efficient use of real property.
- zepto 7y agoYou support property taxes because a miscalculation can cause people to pay more and is hard to detect?
- Gibbon1 7y agoIf one ignores the orthodox propagandizing from economists. You end up with the unremarkable idea that the value of ordinary property is based mostly on the amount of public goods and services tied to it. Which are paid for and maintained by the state. Stands to reason that state should then impose a property tax to pay for all that. The connection between sales taxes and public goods and services is a lot more tenuous.
- iudqnolq 7y agoOne example of a clear connection between a sales tax and public goods and services is a gas tax. It doesn't work perfectly, especially given advances in vehicle efficiency and electric vehicles, but it used to pretty reliably charge people for road maintenance based on their usage. It was also a regressive tax, because poorer people spend more of their income on purchases like gas. "Orthodox propagandizing from economics" has come up with some things that you might not immediately think of when reasoning from first principles.
- gamblor956 7y agoYou support property taxes because a miscalculation can cause people to pay more and is hard to detect? [Replying to dead comment] Actually, yes. Property taxes are paid for by the people best able to afford the tax. And with property taxes, its easier to catch errors and errors are individualized, meaning that the error is easier to correct once found. After all, this one was caught, and corrected, quite easily. Further to note: it was inappropriate for the related jurisdictions to use the erroneous property tax numbers as the basis for their budgets without first vetting the numbers. A jump in the property tax base that large should have triggered an automatic audit.
- perl4ever 7y agoYou have to ask what you really want. Haven't you ever lived in a place where the tax base has rotted away? How do you force people to buy a property that was seized for back taxes? The poorest areas end up with the highest tax rates, and no money. I like the idea (and it's not new) of taxing the unimproved value of the land (because taxing it can't decrease the amount) and not taxing the improvements (because it's to everyone's benefit to improve property and you don't want to discourage that). If I was made dictator of San Francisco, that's what I'd try.
- seriesf 7y agoThe art of transferring control of property without a “sale” is already well known and widely practiced, rendering transfer taxes useless in every jurisdiction in America.
- adrianmonk 7y agoThis actually doesn't accomplish the thing you're hoping it would! Here in Texas, there is a sales tax of 6.25% when you sell a car. They found that people were doing stuff like saying they sold their car to their neighbor for $100 so that the neighbor would have to pay 6.25% of $100 instead of 6.25% of $2500. And maybe the neighbor agrees to some untraceable off-the-record compensation like painting your house for you. There's an incentive to create this kind of deal because neither party loses money to taxes, benefiting both. So realizing they were losing out on revenue, the state changed the law and created something called Standard Presumptive Value. Some method exists to look at comparable cars to estimate the value of a car (based on model, mileage, etc.). Now you pay 6.25% on the actual sale price or the SPV, whichever is higher. Sometimes the car is in worse than average condition (not running, wrecked, etc.), and the SPV is too high, and yes, there's a procedure for that involving a professional appraisal.
- reaperducer 7y agothis is why i'm against property tax You're against property taxes because a clerk might make a typo somewhere? That's an oddly specific phobia.
- chii 7y ago> a clerk might make a typo somewhere? not just a typo, but a mis-valuation. If no money is exchanged, the value of the property is indeterminate. And i also don't like taxing wealth - after all, that wealth was already taxed when you used your existing money to purchase it. If the land is making an income, then by all means tax such an income. If you sell the land, and make a gain, then tax the gains (commonly refered to as capital gains). But to tax existing wealth just because you have it is ass backwards.
- perl4ever 7y agoWealth requires maintenance. Actual property taxes may be based on the idea of property being accessible to tax more than anything else, but in principle, all your property requires the apparatus of the state to preserve, so some percentage fee is appropriate. That's separate from income taxes, because that can be justified by the principle that being part of civilization provides a multiplier.