8 ms·
Random harmful mutations have happened all day every day as long as life has existed. We are basically designed for dealing with it. But worst case, we can elim
by im3w1l 7y ago
Random harmful mutations have happened all day every day as long as life has existed. We are basically designed for dealing with it. But worst case, we can eliminate harmful mutations from being passed on to subsequent generations through screening. I wouldn't worry about the long term problems of that, it's fairly easy to solve.
What I would worry about is:
a) Short term suffering from failed experiments.
b) Reduced genetic diversity as everyone scrambles to get "the best" genes.
- Fjolsvith 7y ago> we can eliminate harmful mutations from being passed on to subsequent generations through screening. And the truly bad mutations should self-correct before passing to subsequent generations.
- PhasmaFelis 7y ago> And the truly bad mutations should self-correct before passing to subsequent generations. That's an awfully euphemistic way to say "The kids'll die before they grow up."
- Fjolsvith 7y agoI didn't want to say, "Survival of the fittest."
- roenxi 7y agoWe live in a world where kids die before they grow up. Gene editing technologies will almost surely reduce the number of children who die before they grow up and lead to higher quality of life for everyone else. I'm not necessarily for gene editing. I think it is probably a long-term certainty and a net good, but it makes me uneasy because it is one of the maybe-this-one-ends-humanity style technologies. That being said, the suffering that a gene edited baby and its parents go through is meaningful - we learn from it, we improve. At the moment if a baby is born with random congenital problems there is similar suffering and it is completely pointless; we don't really learn anything or change anything. When both paths lead through suffering, anyone who knowingly chooses the path of greater long term suffering is a monster. Even if they want to claim they are acting for some sort of moral reason. We can't get hung up if a few children die when dealing with technologies of this consequence. There are just more important issues to work through.
- imtringued 7y agoWhy would it end humanity? It may cause greater suffering than any war in history but it is not a serious threat to humanity.
- roenxi 7y agoMight create something better. It depends what we define as human and how quickly the technology develops.
- smallgovt 7y ago> But worst case, we can eliminate harmful mutations from being passed on to subsequent generations through screening Are you suggesting that we should prohibit these babies from reproducing when they reach adulthood? If not, how do you suggest we prevent harmful mutations from being passed on with "screening"?
- mytailorisrich 7y ago> Are you suggesting that we should prohibit these babies from reproducing when they reach adulthood? That's currently the only reasonable thing to do.
- xvedejas 7y agoAdults only pass on half of their genes during reproduction. I imagine at least in the case of in vitro fertilization there's a fair amount you can do to make sure the harmful genes aren't the ones passed along, so long as the parent doesn't have two copies of an autosomal dominant harmful mutation. I wouldn't be surprised if more advanced methods exist either; as a carrier for a rare genetic disease maybe I should figure this out.
- wahern 7y agoYou can't argue with the "but what if" line of reasoning because there's always another hypothetical that could lead to the destruction of humanity or, at the very least, one more mutant baby than anticipated. And that's the problem here: these arguments boil down to "too dangerous", but that's not a characteristic amenable to empirically grounded, reasoned debate. We can only have a scientifically constructive discussion within the context of a concrete, particularized therapy--disease, editing vector, gene, etc. Even then it's difficult, but at least you can reach a point at which you can agree to disagree on an actual, concrete scientific question. Everything else is philosophy and politics. I think what people are trying to justify is an a priori assumption that gene editing (or germline editing if they're a little less cautious) is special and distinct. But I don't think you can scientifically justify that distinction from a harm avoidance perspective. Just because the technique is medically and scientifically distinguishable doesn't mean it's analytically distinguishable. And of course one of the principal drivers of these therapies, at least initially, is stopping the types of mutations that are feared but which already exist in nature. So it's simply a belief that you hold; full stop. It's a legitimate belief, and may even be strongly informed by science, but it's like believing in God or aliens or the utility of Mars colonization--we might as well just put labels on our foreheads so we know where the argument will end up without actually having to argue. Knowing the other person's starting point, and assuming the best versions of their likely arguments, most of us here can arrive at the other person's conclusions independently.
- PhasmaFelis 7y ago> Short term suffering from failed experiments. By "short term" you mean "only until the kids die of their mutations"?
- im3w1l 7y agoWell I was thinking more along the lines of disabilities, weakness and abnormalities, but I guess death too.
- neuronic 7y agoYou guess harming a human baby to the point of death might be a problem?
- imtringued 7y agoThe goal of gene therapies isn't to kill their patients but it wouldn't surprise me if introducing a lesser disease in exchange for curing a serious disease would be considered an acceptable outcome even if it means that people who have not been seriously ill will now suffer from the lesser disease more frequently.
- neuronic 7y agoBut the problem with all of this aren't these strategic questions about eradicating disease and improving the human condition. It's that all of this is happening within a frame of ignorance with regards to the insane, elusive complexity that is genetics. Somehow the idea that changing genes at will can be predictable isn't dying off.
- adrianN 7y agoI wouldn't worry so much about reduced diversity. Once we're good enough at creating genetically manipulated babies we can recover any diversity we want in one generation.
- everdev 7y agoWe'll still need adults to raise this next generation. So, if we realize we swung the pendulum too far towards uniformity, it'll take 16+ years for the next "diverse" generation to mature and become self-sufficient. Unfortunately, diseases typically run their course much faster than that meaning it would be possible for a disease to devastate a genetically homogenous population before they can raise the next generation and maintain population levels.
- dbtx 7y agoWill that be genuine or superficial? Will 'verifying the integrity of that DNA after these edits' become the new cryptomining? Here's a hard problem: 'integrity' and 'verfiy' and "good enough at creating" are ill-defined at best. It almost reminds me of ...me. "I don't need to study and get good at studying, I just need to get good at self-hypnosis and instruct my brain to absorb things faster and remember things better." Want to know how that turned out? It didn't.
- imtringued 7y agoThat doesn't make any sense. Right now every single human is a gene designer and each of them is using a benchmark that is specific to their environment. There is no way you can replicate that without building a parallel society of gene designers.
- IanSanders 7y agoI'd be more worried about subtle long-term mutations which won't have obviously observable effects at first but will severely disadvantage us in the long run. Or only become enabled in combination with some future mutations. If a gene increases chances of a disease by 5%, how soon do you identify that? Once a gene is widespread enough, good luck preventing gene carriers from reproducing. Most people won't care enough to screen potential partners, or even worse, it could create social tension.
- IanSanders 7y agoAlso, why this is worse than a similar mutation in the wild, is because it will be coupled with "branded" genotype, which will be treated specially. People will potentially want to pursue certain genotype (with tall height, blue eyes etc), not caring about health implications, which I can almost guarantee won't be properly disclosed, even if known. Just like dog breeding. And you can judge how much people care about appearances by the success of plastic surgery business.