4 ms·
What happens when that much energy is so cheap and every home has what amounts to a sizable bomb inside? There will sure be plenty of them which aren't actuall
by colechristensen 7y ago
What happens when that much energy is so cheap and every home has what amounts to a sizable bomb inside?
There will sure be plenty of them which aren't actually certified and the failure rate of any consumer product is never zero.
How are the positives of a distributed storage grid offset by the negatives of the technologies?
- altcognito 7y agoNatural gas leaks are worse.
- timerol 7y agoAre you comfortable parking your car inside of your garage? Even with a full tank of gas? Safety issues are real, but they have been solved before and are being solved now
- colechristensen 7y agoI've seen cars burn, they don't explode like the movies, they burn. Like a couch. Lithium batteries are much more energetic about their failures, "explode", and they can do so with only minor electrical or mechanical mistreatment. A car in my garage is cold, outside of very odd situations it is not going to spontaneously ignite. Cars burn in accidents or when you are running them, not randomly in the middle of the night. The "proper" safety for a large lithium battery pack is in a concrete sarcophagus or similar vessel capable of shielding and containing a catastrophic failure.
- steelframe 7y ago> Cars burn in accidents or when you are running them, not randomly in the middle of the night. My co-worker's nanny's car, a new Subaru, burst into flames in her driveway while it was just sitting without the engine running. Non-crash fires occur so frequently that the Highway Loss Data Institute (HLDI) produces a Noncrash Fire Losses Report, and insurance companies calculate premiums based on that data. https://www.iihs.org/media/c93b98d8-6a7d-44a1-810e-4468ec539e05/uIu4tg/HLDI%20Research/Fire%20losses/HLDI_FireLosses_1218.pdf https://www.iihs.org/media/c93b98d8-6a7d-44a1-810e-4468ec539...
- radicalbyte 7y agoWe get one car fire every other year in the neighborhood thanks to the combination of teenagers with fireworks. There are always a few dozen a year in the town (110k people). I'd have a power wall either in my garage or in a box outside the house if it would mean that we could go off-grid. Sadly that's not possible here (we've got more wind power than sun power and residential wind isn't feasible).
- jsight 7y agoThis is really wrong. Cars have been recalled as recently as this year due to fire risk when not running. Not only that, but they are actually no more energetic than gasoline. This is an example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CdaFk3w6rUY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CdaFk3w6rUY Gasoline actually has a higher risk of becoming "explosive", though as you pointed out that is not the most common outcome.
- marcosdumay 7y agoHave you seen batteries explode? They make an audible bang, and can even push things around if they are touching those, and that's all. This is because the explosion is contained in a steel sarcophagus (much more efficient than concrete) that detracts a little from portability, but is already included on the costs people are bringing to this thread.
- crdoconnor 7y agoThese technologies typically went through a period of development where safety was not a paramount concern. Once electric cars become mass market we'll probably hit that point.
- jackweirdy 7y agoYou can disconnect the other sizeable bomb - gas https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/bristol-house-gas-explosion-trampoline-woman-injuries-burn-a8794726.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/bristol-hous... https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-suffolk-48190598 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-suffolk-48190598 https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2018/dec/27/man-killed-explosion-house-collapse-andover-hampshire https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2018/dec/27/man-killed-e... https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2016/apr/06/birmingham-house-destroyed-by-gas-explosion https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2016/apr/06/birmingham-h... https://www.birminghammail.co.uk/news/midlands-news/house-destroyed-3-injured-huge-14023006 https://www.birminghammail.co.uk/news/midlands-news/house-de...
- colechristensen 7y agoYou probably couldn't though. Gas is fairly clean energy, and many of the inefficiencies of electricity distribution don't apply. It will be quite a long while before people in cold climates who need to heat their homes would switch to all electric or have anything close to local generation capable of heating their homes.
- audunw 7y ago> You probably couldn't though. Well, you clearly can. Norway hasn't used gas. At home people have used mostly electric heaters and wood. They're now switching out oil burning furnaces and wood burning furnaces in many areas with heat pumps. Sweden is burning trash for electricity and piping heat from those powerplants to nearby areas. In most areas you'd need cheaper electricity, and heat pumps should be cheaper as well. But it's definitely possible.
- colechristensen 7y agoNorway is 99% hydroelectric because of geography and low population. Sweden is 40% hydro, 40% nuclear. In neither are renewables used in significantly large ways (maybe excepting the few percent of Swedish trash burning) that are applicable to the rest of the world.
- blacksmith_tb 7y agoHmm, why wouldn't they be certified? I suppose you will get a small number of people rolling their own (which is going on right now, with people reusing 18650s), but I assume it shouldn't be hard to require all commercially available units to be certified, we do that for furnaces, water heaters, etc.
- colechristensen 7y agoIt wouldn't be hard to require, it would be very hard to enforce with high coverage. One these things become popular, just go on eBay or Amazon and buy a cheap one. There are loads and loads of electrical devices which are required to be certified which you can buy which are clearly not.
- blacksmith_tb 7y agoThat's certainly possible, anyone can walk into a Home Depot and buy a breaker box (which is certified) and install it themselves (well or badly), but realistically that doesn't seem to happen so often it's a serious problem, partly because we have home inspections to catch the unsafe botched attempts (when they try to sell their death-trap homes).
- travisporter 7y agoWhile there are certainly DIYers and the like, gas, plumbing and electricity in the US at least are all to be installed by professionals who have a license on the line, so this will be greatly mitigated. Moreover, energy density of gasoline and natural gas is significantly greater, although more meaningfully, the total energy of an EV battery is equivalent or less than a full tank of gas.
- augstein 7y agoHave you ever calculated how much energy a gas powered car or truck stores? Yet we even let everyone pour that stuff into their tanks, without any supervision whatsoever ¯\_(ツ)_/¯.
- myself248 7y agoThank goodness New Jersey and Oregon have the sense to restrict untrained operators from handling that dangerous substance!
- colechristensen 7y agoGasoline just burns. It takes a very specific state to get it to explode. Not that I'm recommending it, but you could fill a coffee can with gasoline and light it on fire and with only minimum care, be completely safe. Do the same with an equivalent-energy amount of lithium batteries and you better have a good pair of running shoes. Go watch some youtube videos of exploding laptops. The latest big MacBook battery has 100 watt hours of energy fully charged. A gallon of gasoline has 33,000 watt hours of energy. So that macbook's battery has 2.3 teaspoons, about 1 centimeter cubed, or 11 mL equivalent energy of gasoline. I have spilled that much gas on my shoe and not given it a second thought. Another way to put it is a laptop battery has about as much energy in it as a shot of vodka. I'll happily store many bottles of liquor in the cupboard without a thought of the fire risk. An equivalent battery carelessly stored is scary.
- xyzzyz 7y agoYou know that millions of homes have natural gas installation, capable of emitting essentially unlimited amounts of explosive gas with only a single leak required, right?
- radicalbyte 7y agoIt's not just that, but Carbon Monoxide poisoning from incomplete combustion is just as much of a killer. I love cooking with gas but to be completely honest I'll be happy to see the back of it.
- audunw 7y ago> What happens when that much energy is so cheap and every home has what amounts to a sizable bomb inside? There is very little correlation between the amount of energy contained in a device, and its likelihood of exploding. A container of helium does - after all - contain an enormous amount of potential energy (if fused), but that's not gonna happen all on its own. Your worry about batteries exploding, is because of your experience seeing Li-ion batteries exploding (or at least burning very quickly) in videos. But this is something specific to the Li-ion battery chemistries. It has very little to do with the energy stored in the battery. It's the flammable liquid electrolyte catching fire that's the primary cause. Solid state chemistries contain even more energy, and do not explode at all. You can cut them in two and nothing happens. Their problem is cycle life though, but that might be solved. A home battery pack will be built in a much more safe manner than a cell phone battery, they have more space to go on and they're experience less physical stress than a cell phone or even a car. One of these spontaneously catching fire is likely to be a freak accident, possible but extremely rare. And it's likely to be a fire, not an explosion, as the cells will be more contained than in a cell phone. Check out the video of Tesla setting one of their grid storage battery packs on fire. It's not very spectacular.