7 ms·
>> Now a self driving car does not need to have general human level intelligence, but a self driving car is certainly a lower bound on human level intelligence.
by phkahler 7y ago
>> Now a self driving car does not need to have general human level intelligence, but a self driving car is certainly a lower bound on human level intelligence.
This is exactly the misconception that allows people to believe in fully autonomous cars.
Following a lane is easy (in good weather). Stopping when the car ahead does is easy. Route planning when you have detailed maps and GPS is reasonable.
Understanding what unusual things might be lying in the road and what to do about them is hard. Navigating a construction zone with a flag man directing you on the opposite shoulder requires a brain, not pattern matching. Opening the window and following verbal directions...
The range of scenarios we encounter when driving requires AGI to cope with.
- AstralStorm 7y agoMost of the unexpected do not - human drivers handle it on reflex - but there is enough that does. The manually directed traffic example would require some sort of workaround for instance - map update or protocol to tell it to the car. Human drivers utilise informal protocols in such situations including blinking signals, voice communication and formal ones like policeman signals. None of which actually requires AGI to handle, and actually educated guesswork to figure out. Think of it as a human driver in another country - they have to learn the behavior from the observed subset to not stick out, but it's not actually too hard or involving. It's not AGI, but it is sparse dictionary learning (bounded set of allowed behaviors) which is hard anyway. And a bunch of high grade logical inputs as context. Figuring out outdated map such as not driving into a lake, damaged or unfinished road can be done without AGI reasonably well, as can predicting potential accidents and dangers and pre-planning responses. Fun part would be the car asking for directions with voice synthesis then trying to execute them. I want to see that working in practice, still not AGI really. It'd be really freaky the first few times it happens, especially if it's driverless. Mind you, human drivers tend to do stupid and unlawful things because they're intelligent too.
- taneq 7y ago> human drivers handle it on reflex I'm not sure we can write off human subconscious behaviour as "not general intelligence". It might not be the conscious, self-analytical reasoning that we tend to think of as 'intelligence' but there's a whole bunch of things that humans 'just know how to do' after practice without being able to explain how we do it. > Figuring out outdated map such as not driving into a lake, damaged or unfinished road can be done without AGI reasonably well Yeah, I think a lot of that could be solved by having a hierarchy of different classifiers (maybe they do this already?) so instead of trying to identify every individual object in the world, you can just detect "something large in front of me" and hit the brakes. You don't have to care particuarly what it is, you just have to not hit the thing.
- AstralStorm 7y agoReflexes are indeed trained, but they're not what is defined as general intelligence. They trigger in specific cases, both low reflexes and high ones. Now if you required the car to gain new reflexes on its own then it's an entirely different thing and yes, that is probably a big chunk of AGI. Essentially that means the car would have to write its own control logic in an essentially unlimited way, yet do so safely. That is not exactly necessary for safe travel.
- xyzzy_plugh 7y agoI used to disagree, then one day I was showering and thought I heard something I couldn't possibly have heard (a train crossing bell). False positive, my audio neural net heard some sound and with all the distortion got it wrong. My other facilities quickly ruled it out and concluded that it was unlikely that a train was in my apartment, but also that there is no train crossing there either. This problem (pattern matching, cross referencing experiences, deducing truth) mirrors the SDV problem pretty well. Can they tell that the plastic bag on the road is safe to drive over? Can they infer that if the truck in front of them is overflowing with poorly-secured tools and equipment/soon-to-be debris, to maybe keep more distance? If a human waves to indicate they should go around, or the road ahead is closed, or they need help, will the car understand? The way to solve self-driving cars in a few years is to start building roads and infrastructure for such automation. Maybe even have a human driving multiple cars, computer assisted, simultaneously from a remote office.
- leoc 7y ago> The way to solve self-driving cars in a few years is to start building roads and infrastructure for such automation. Maybe even have a human driving multiple cars, computer assisted, simultaneously from a remote office. Even if the system took one driver-hour per vehicle-hour, with every vehicle controlled by one human driver at all times and each human driver controlling only one vehicle at a time, there would be significant benefits in terms of cost and availability from having all the taxi drivers working from a single ops centre, instantly assignable to any vehicle anywhere on demand. Any driver-hour-per-vehicle-hour reductions would be gravy on top of that. (However the system would certainly need some level of autonomous driving to at least halt the vehicle safely in the event of a communications failure or the like.) (It's probably a coincidence that Musk happens to be building something which might be extremely valuable as a component of such a remote-driving system https://www.starlink.com/ https://www.starlink.com/ , but perhaps it is not. 35mm of latency in each direction https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2018/02/spacexs-satellite-broadband-nears-fcc-approval-and-first-test-launch/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2018/02/space... is probably not a showstopper in this application http://www.brake.org.uk/component/tags/tag/thinking-time http://www.brake.org.uk/component/tags/tag/thinking-time , especially if it can be compensated for by a professional and tightly-monitored driver pool, reduced speed limits and/or failsafe locally-controlled AI braking. The need to rely on autonomous driving and/or a supplementary ground-based network in tunnels and under bridges would likely be a bigger drawback.)
- scandox 7y agoIt's not even perfectly clear that human level intelligence is enough for driving. We accept a lot to get it over the line: 1.25 million deaths and 30-50 million injuries. We broadly accept the benefits outweigh the negatives (lives extended, saved, flexibility of social organisation etc..). But still no-one thinks the average driver is good at it.
- lopmotr 7y agoIt's OK for a human to take over in those cases for level 4. Maybe you have some fold-out control pad to drive at low speeds through the complex situation or a remote driver controlling many cars as needed.
- svara 7y agoGreat point, but for this to work you still need the car to know when it doesn't know enough to continue. This is not trivial at all with neural networks. There's going to be a trade-off between giving control back to the driver too much or too little, and that's going to be highly safety critical.
- AstralStorm 7y agoWhy do you want a car with an inscrutable decision logic? The first thing that has to happen is a black box that has to explain the why of any disturbance or crash. It is notoriously hard to actually extract the reasons for any action from an ANN...
- fleetingmoments 7y agoWhat if initially the AI could just hand over control to a remote human agent temporarily when it finds itself in an unsure state? Jesús, take the wheel!
- icebraining 7y ago> Navigating a construction zone with a flag man directing you on the opposite shoulder requires a brain, not pattern matching. Why? Waymo cars can already follow the hand instructions of traffic cops[1], why couldn't they follow that too? [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OopTOjnD3qY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OopTOjnD3qY
- _Understated_ 7y agoI can think of two scenario's that played out in my area fairly recently that AGI has no chance of dealing with (in the next decades at least): 1. There was a burst water main on the country road near my house and when I got there the waterboard had not long arrived. There was a man stopping traffic and trying to get them to turn around on a tiny road. No GPS updates, no notifications prior to this, just a bunch of pissed-off drivers having to do a U-turn at the behest of this puny human telling them to go back. 2. Roadworks with a detour that didn't work properly: they had put one of the yellow "Detour" signs in the wrong place but since I knew the area, I went a different way. Will AGI even be able to read a detour sign and know what it is in reference to the journey I am currently trying to make? I love the concept of AI but it's an absoulte joke these days with everything claiming to be "AI"... case in point: I have been looking at headphones lately and found a pair (Sony I think!) that claimed to have AI to help noise cancelling! WTF? Even the reviews said that it only worked with constant noise like engines... so they invert the sound waves to cancel each other out? Where's the AI?
- majewsky 7y agoMy main takeaway from your story is that fully autonomous driving requires a universal deployment of a system which allows police and emergency services to deploy updates to the road network map in real time. (Sure, it would be nicer if the car was intelligent enough to understand a man waving at it, but that's the lower bound that I take from these reports.)
- _Understated_ 7y agoYep and the problem I have with that is that you can be sure it will be used for everything else including tracking my movements in real time and using them against me at some point or for insurance companies or some other org I don't currently know about.
- Ntrails 7y agoThe builders blocking a road for a delivery of bricks are not emergency services. The Water company is not an emergency service. The actual emergency services do not have time to spend their time micro managing every ad hoc road blockage that will come about (and for damned sure someone will forget to turn the blockage off again). You are not going to get perfect centralised road status information for driving cars.
- baxtr 7y agoA while back a friend of mine rushed through the city, always a bit above speed limit and going to limits what is legal driving behavior and what is not (I sat next to him). He drives very safely and we made it on time for our meeting even though the city streets were quite busy. Afterwards I thought: a self-driving car would have never done that because its tolerance level and its non-existing "judgement" of a situation would not have allowed for.
- jacquesm 7y agoAnd that would actually be one of those cases where a self driving car would be an improvement over human drivers who feel they are able to 'bend the rules' to satisfy their personal needs instead of simply leaving on time.
- baxtr 7y agoI don't know, depending on your definition of improvement, yes. But would you want to live in a world where humans are bound to rules 100%? Where "bending the rules" to the smallest extent is punished?
- lazylizard 7y agoYes. I'd like ppl who increase their chance of killing me 10 fold because they were late for a meeting to be prevented from doing so.
- simonh 7y agoIt very much depends on what exactly we mean by 'self driving car'. The Wikipedia description of the Levels of autonomy doesn't help much. Level 5, steering wheel optional, gives the example of a self-driving taxi but we pretty much already have those in highly controlled environments. Assumptions about the situations such a car would be expected to be autonomous are critical to clear communication and analysis of this issue. An autonomous car expert saying we are 30 to 50 years from fully autonomous vehicles by itself doesn't mean much when we actually have fully autonomous vehicles on some roads, for some tasks already[0]. Equally Musk wasn't saying we would have level 5 driving capability in all situations by 2020, he was just taking about highway cruising. The exact parameters of the driving situations we are talking about make all the difference. Both Musk can be right and the autonomous vehicles expert can be right depending on the context. [0] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-einride-autonomous-sweden/driverless-electric-truck-starts-deliveries-on-swedish-public-road-idUSKCN1SL0NC https://www.reuters.com/article/us-einride-autonomous-sweden...
- computerex 7y agoHere's what Wikipedia actually says about Level 5: > under all roadway and environmental conditions that can be managed by a human driver There is no autonomous vehicle deployed today that is true to that statement. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-driving_car#Classification https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Self-driving_car#Classificatio... > Equally Musk wasn't saying we would have level 5 driving capability in all situations by 2020, he was just taking about highway cruising. Actually he specifically said that by this time the car would be able to do a cross U.S trip autonomously, which I hope you understand consists of more than just highway driving. As far as the T-Pod driverless truck thing you linked: > An operator, sitting miles away, can supervise and control up to 10 vehicles at once. The T-Pod has permission to make short trips - between a warehouse and a terminal - on a public road in an industrial area in Jonkoping, central Sweden, at up to 5 km/hr, documents from the transport authority show. A remotely supervised truck permitted to travel at 3 mph in a highly controlled and scripted path - warehouse to terminal - is hardly what anyone thinks of or means when we talk about autonomous vehicles.
- 7y ago
- olalonde 7y agoI'd argue you are massively underestimating the complexity of AGI (or overestimating the complexity of self driving). > Navigating a construction zone with a flag man directing you on the opposite shoulder requires a brain, not pattern matching. Opening the window and following verbal directions... Both of those things seem very much in the realm of what's possible with today's AI tech. I'd bet a lot of money that self-diving cars will predate AGI by quite a bit.
- computerex 7y ago> I'd bet a lot of money that self-diving cars will predate AGI by quite a bit. I think that may be true, but I don't think they will get there merely by on-board computers/radars/lidars/machine vision. I don't think Level 5 autonomous driving is possible with just the aforementioned technologies. The laymen have a vastly inflated sense of what today's "AI tech" is and its capabilities, which boil down to curve fitting. At best, we may get geo-fenced cars that operate under highly controlled conditions. Whilst I think self-driving is a great problem to solve and is probably helping push the envelope of AI, I think using AI to solve this problem is fundamentally the wrong approach. I think we may need to take a leaf from aviation if we really want autonomous vehicles to become a reality. Airplanes don't use machine vision to land for instance, they use radionavigation. I think cars having transponders of some type to detect other cars, and defining where drivable paths are based on some radio signal supported by the infrastructure is the way to go for reliable and robust autonomous driving.
- mamcx 7y agoA better test of self-driving: You will send a baby (ALONE) with the car? That is something we do with a human involved. But we can trust the self-driving car? Because we can take risk for OURSELVES but something is safe only when can be extended to our beloved ones.
- pwinnski 7y agoI'm pretty sure that the guy who was watching a Harry Potter movie in his car and was decapitated for his troubles[0] would have been happy to send a baby alone in the same car. Not everybody does risk-assessment the same way, and humans are really, really bad at risk assessment. [0] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/jul/01/tesla-driver-killed-autopilot-self-driving-car-harry-potter https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2016/jul/01/tesla-dri...