4 ms·
>By seizing control of the website, police will have been able to "take a good look at what the site has been up to, including who has bought the illegal items"
by pbhjpbhj 7y ago
>By seizing control of the website, police will have been able to "take a good look at what the site has been up to, including who has bought the illegal items", said Prof Alan Woodward, a cyber-security expert from the University of Surrey. //
When did the law pass making owning software illegal, as opposed to using it for nefarious means? (Last time I looked CMA required use.)
Anyone have details of the exact charge?
- heyyyouu 7y agoThis was my thought as well. It has to be some sort of UK law? But I can't find it. The laws apply to surreptitiously installing the software on someone else's phone or computer. But then owning (and/or buying) the software shouldn't be illegal and the site shouldn't have been able to come down. Hacking tools aren't illegal by default, that I know of anyway.
- Symbiote 7y agoThe Europol press releases says the arrested developer and employee were in Australia and Belgium, so it's probably law of those countries that's most relevant. The website had Australian phone numbers. https://www.europol.europa.eu/newsroom/news/international-crackdown-rat-spyware-which-takes-total-control-of-victims%E2%80%99-pcs https://www.europol.europa.eu/newsroom/news/international-cr...
- jstanley 7y ago> The NCA said properties in Hull, Leeds, London, Manchester, Merseyside, Milton Keynes, Nottingham, Somerset and Surrey were among those searched. Presumably there would have to be some allegation of UK law-breaking in order to get a search warrant for properties in the UK.
- salad77 7y agoNo, just a mutual aid request from an agency recognized under law enforcement treaty. There are many agreements for mutual recognition and execution of legal process across national boundaries (normally added as part of trade treaty negotiations but sometimes in things like extradition treaties). Lots of FBI raids outside the US are conducted this way - local police do the raid and have FBI 'observe' them in action. In this case, an EU police force and a 5-Eyes nation like Australia will be zero-friction recipient of assistance.
- celticninja 7y agoI imagine it's dependent on how the software is marketed. If you advertise it as a way to spy on others and steal passwords and banking logins, then it's pretty obvious it was built and sold with that intent. I imagine it becomes more grey if there are people who use it nefariously but you market it as a security analysts tool. Also it seems like taking down the website stopped the software working. If it was centralised then there is a link between the theft of bank logins and the associated fraud directly to the website. Of course it might just be dialing in and checking the license as opposed to the website facilitating functionality. Edit. Just seen an archived page for the tool, looks like a legitimate network access and monitoring tool. If that's the case then arresting the dev seems excessive. I did note that the page provided support, so I wonder if there was some entrapment along the lines of "how do I monitor for bank logins ?" Perhaps with enough info to make it clear the tool was being used to perform illegal activity, and that support is what fucked the dev?
- joe_the_user 7y agoThis. A large portion of common law revolves around intent - I think the technical term is "mens rea" (mentioned by another poster). If a site sold knives as "neighbor killers", with the comment "use this and you can definitely kill your neighbor, $19.95", then all the same considerations would come into play. And knives aren't illegal, at least to cook with.
- matthewheath 7y agoThis is covered by the Computer Misuse Act 1990 — specifically Section 3A which covers obtaining articles for use with related offences covered in Sections 1, 3, and 3ZA of the Act. It's a crime to own the software intending to use it even if you don't actually use it. Arguably, the purchaser intended to use it at the point they made the purchase; people don't typically purchase software like this accidentally (of course there are obvious exceptions like perhaps security researchers wanting to decompile it to understand how to block it in the future, etc.)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoI think it's 3ZA(1)(c) that's changed - by the Serious Crimes Act 2015 - in that this allows that an action can simply "create a serious risk of, damage of a material kind". AFAIR that's different to how the act was prior to SCA2015. Indeed this section including "material kind" strongly suggests that the original intent was that the Act would punish material damage, rather than a trumped up suggestion by the CPS (on whomevers behalf) that an act might be reckless as to whether it creates an increased risk of serious damage. This legislation seems to work like "well you went on a road near some property, which is exactly what a criminal who was going to destroy that property would do, so you're clearly guilty". It seems somewhat over-reaching to me.
- matthewheath 7y agoThe whole of 3ZA is new — that didn't exist before the Serious Crimes Act 2015. However, they do have to actually take action and material damage is defined by s3ZA(2) with "damage to human welfare" (s3ZA(2)(a)) constrained by s3ZA(3). It is unlikely that the threshold for a charge under S3ZA would be met. The more likely charge is S1 (unauthorised access) or S3A(3) which makes it an offence to obtain any article intending to use it to commit, or to assist in the commission of, an offence under section 1, 3 or 3ZA — you don't even have to actually use the software to be criminalised, merely possessing it is enough provided the prosecution can prove your intent beyond reasonable doubt. You can read the Explanatory Notes for the SCA 2015 amendments that altered the CMA 1990 at http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2015/9/notes/division/3/2 http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2015/9/notes/division/3/... for background on why these changes were made.
- moksly 7y agoIt’s not a U.K. thing it’s an Europol thing: https://www.europol.europa.eu/newsroom/news/international-crackdown-rat-spyware-which-takes-total-control-of-victims’-pcs https://www.europol.europa.eu/newsroom/news/international-cr... No idea what law it breaks, but apparently the developer of a similar Trojan got 30 months in prison in a similar case: https://thehackernews.com/2018/10/hacking-tool-luminositylink.html?m=1 https://thehackernews.com/2018/10/hacking-tool-luminositylin... I’m sure glad that wasn’t a thing when I was a teenager and cult of the dead cow was cool.
- rwmurrayVT 7y agoI met him at FCI Morgantown. He's fairly bright, but a bit.. off. He's very young.
- omginternets 7y ago>It’s not a U.K. thing it’s an Europol thing I really don't mean to flame-bait, but I've noticed HN has a mild pro-EU/anti-Brexit bias, so I would be remiss if I didn't draw attention to the fact that this is part of what Brexiteers are against. Here we (apparently) have a case in which the law of the land is at odds with EU regulation. I leave it as an exercise to the reader to research how EU regulations are drafted and ratified. Disclaimer: I'm a remoaner, but I'm also trying to understand just WTF is going on.
- matthewheath 7y agoNot sure how UK law is at odds with EU regulation on this matter. The offences outlined in the article are covered by the Computer Misuse Act 1990 — specifically Sections 1 and 3.
- dfawcus 7y agoI'm not aware of any EU regulations relating to computer "misuse". Also AFAIK Europol is a co-operation facility, not a front line policing organisation. It is a means by which the member states co-operate and share intelligence, but not (yet) a source of rules and regulations. Also the UK relations to Europol is a a bit freestanding, and we opted out of the Justice and Home Affairs stuff, then asked to opt back in to making use of Europol.
- matthewheath 7y agoNo charges seem to have been brought yet – but it's an offence under Section 3A of the Computer Misuse Act 1990 (CMA) to obtain articles for use in offence under Sections 1, 3, or 3ZA CMA, even if you don't actually use them. Obviously, the prosecution would need to prove intent but it's possible the mere presence of the software could suffice for mens rea — people don't typically buy this software accidentally. Presumably most people who bought the software will have used it, making a prosecution under S1 CMA more likely. It's probable that the CPS will only charge people they are likely to get an S1 conviction from and discard any S3A charges as S3A charges will be difficult to prove.
- mirimir 7y agoWhat about HackingTeam, NSO Group, etc? I guess that it's OK if you're a "government" user. Edit: To unpack that a little, I've read that repressive/authoritarian governments have used these sorts of malware to harass, arrest, and kill people. And furthermore, I wouldn't be surprised if the UK government itself is using these sorts of malware.
- TACIXAT 7y agoThat is exactly what it is though. The authors probably could have sold to governments (their tool may not have been sophisticated enough though) and never had any trouble.
- matthewheath 7y agoAs in any area of law, (glibly) it only matters if you get caught. The Security Services of the UK Government have statutory exemptions allowing them to use these tools. These statutory exemptions are contained within the Intelligence Services Act 1994 Section 5 and the Investigatory Powers Act 2016 Section 99.