14 ms·
The whole topic of conversation around housing affordability is backwards. Specifically, housing affordability is 100%, entirely, a problem of artificial constr
by arcticbull 7y ago
The whole topic of conversation around housing affordability is backwards. Specifically, housing affordability is 100%, entirely, a problem of artificial constraints on supply by city councils.
(1) Americans consider housing to be an investment. An investment is only an investment if you expect a positive return over time. We generally want that investment to match or exceed inflation.
(2) That's antithetical to the idea of affordable housing. It's either affordable or an expensive, appreciating asset. It literally cannot be both at the same time. The only reason it's worked thus far is the broad-based expansion of the US economy and of specific population centers like SF has masked the problem for many, many years. Especially in conjunction with 30-year mortgages requiring 2% down. That's some serious leverage.
We don't talk about the lack of affordable AAPL shares do we? That's insane, it's an investment, we want it to go up. The less affordable, the better!
(3) Renters tend to be younger, transient and not vote. Owners tend to be older, wealthier, have deep roots in the community, and vote their asses off. They also aren't huge fans of change. They vote their interests: whatever keeps their, on average, largest investment performing well.
If you want cheap housing forget rent control. Allow developers to build up as high as the infrastructure can sustain. Allow smaller units, too, micro-apartments like whatever that place is on Mission, Panoramic. It's time to re-think the idea of housing as an "investment." We need to re-focus the narrative to make housing much more utilitarian.
This is reflected in major housing markets around the world, like Tokyo. They don't consider housing an investment, and they have some of the most affordable housing in any major metro in the world. [1]
[1] https://www.vox.com/2016/8/8/12390048/san-francisco-housing-costs-tokyo https://www.vox.com/2016/8/8/12390048/san-francisco-housing-...
- huntertwo 7y agoTwo thoughts 1) Isn't a developer also making an investment when they build these high as hell micro-apartment apartment buildings? 2) How do you avoid a race to the bottom in terms of housing quality when you allow said micro-apartments? Do we want a culture where the poor are living in barely livable wage slave pods while the rich are living in abundant villas? I'm all for affordable housing but it seems too nuanced to allow market forces to take care of it. I think the correct solution revolves around government subsidized/funded housing but that's a whole other can of beans.
- arcticbull 7y ago1) Isn't a developer also making an investment when they build these high as hell micro-apartment apartment buildings? They are but they build and then sell off, developers develop, they tend not to own those units long-term. I believe this to be true regardless of market direction. Generally in the case of condos for sale, developers manage the complexes for a couple of years until enough units are sold off and the HOA takes them over. If someone wants to run the whole building for rental, they can certainly still do that. You would just factor in that your rent would grow with inflation instead of geometrically when you're planning your building. 2) How do you avoid a race to the bottom in terms of housing quality when you allow said micro-apartments? Do we want a culture where the poor are living in barely livable wage slave pods while the rich are living in abundant villas? Indeed, that is a risk, however the current solution of not providing these folks a place to live is a punt. Re: government operation model, I actually agree with you wholeheartedly. Singapore's model where something like 80% of housing is built and managed by the HDB and 20% if totally free-market has worked very well there. I didn't want to bring that into the already-long-enough post as I felt it might distract from my point shrug. [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_housing_in_Singapore https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_housing_in_Singapore
- sokoloff 7y ago> You would just factor in that your rent would grow with inflation instead of geometrically when you're planning your building. Compounded growth at inflation is geometric growth.
- arcticbull 7y agoYeah, I bit my thumb as I wrote that haha, better-than-linear in constant-dollars instead of geometric in constant-dollars :P
- hkmurakami 7y agoFWIW there are developers who build and hold long term, but it depends on their strategy and hoe their capital structure is set up.
- jdavis703 7y agoThe problem is not 100% supply. Supply is just sub-component. In this case Oakland had been zoned for many of those buildings for decades now (Jerry Brown had a 10,000 homes plan). I'm moving in to a building that was entitled in 2007 but didn't open until a few months back... Locally developers couldn't get projects to pencil out. After SF hiked a bunch of rates Oakland suddenly became financially viable for them. There are also the issues of tenant protections (most of the unsheltered people in Oakland lived here better living on the streets, and they still have jobs here) and making sure low-income affordable housing is built.
- ummonk 7y agoYeah, for one thing we have a chicken or egg problem with construction labor being expensive due to the high cost of housing.
- Retric 7y agoI agree with what you’re saying, but that’s overly simplistic. Infrastructure costs increase as you increase density. Charging an appropriate fee for new housing rather than limiting the growth is an efficient solution, but current methods allow for local corruption. That’s just one of the hidden reasons for our current system. Another, is most people want to live as far as possible from poor people.
- pas 7y ago> Infrastructure costs increase as you increase density. They increase much slower than the efficiency gains from having a higher density and the rate of per capita costs decrease from having much more people pay for those costs.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Retric 7y agoWhen a city passes ~20,000 people per square mile the per person cost of infrastructure increases as roads stop being efficient. You start needing tunnels for roads and or subway systems. You also need deeper pipes for water etc, it’s not a deal breaker, but it is a real issue. Having existing residents subsidize new residents is a common approach, but understandably unpopular.
- sachdevap 7y agoWhere does this 20,000 number come from?
- amanaplanacanal 7y agoInfrastucture costs are higher for decreased density. This is well known. You have to lay a lot more pavement and pipe when people live farther apart. Your typical suburban subdivision doesn't even pay enough in property taxes to maintain their infrastructure, and is subsidized by the denser areas. The folks at StrongTowns have done tons of work in this area.
- pas 7y agoThere are important things to regulate to make housing affordable, and as others said rent control is not really one of them. What needs to be controlled is where information asymmetry exists. Eg. quality control, you can't post-inspect a house easily, much less a high-rise. Also usually with new real estate development there's always some fraud-ish scheming going on. Not just with the safety, but regular consumer protection shouldn't be left to the courts, because that leads to a lot of wasted energy. (So anything from the hardcore crimes of developers taking the money and disappearing to developers missing the completion date and not compensating the buyers, because "sue me", and the obvious after handover warranty.) Rent control is almost completely orthogonal to the whole problem. If lending becomes impossible people will just become owners and they will pay to banks. The problem is that it costs sooo much to build new units. (Because idiotic density limits.)
- werfds 7y ago"We don't talk about the lack of affordable AAPL shares do we? That's insane, it's an investment, we want it to go up. The less affordable, the better!" I've always found our obsession with stock price amusing. It's the dividend that technically matters (and, with risk and growth potential, what ultimately should be setting the stock price). When you sell your stock at a gain it just means that, while you owned it, the expectations of future dividends has done up. You're just bowing out of the future returns to enjoy them today. So, seeing how people need retirement funds as well, expensive [0] AAPL means people can't afford to fund their retirement. [0] What does "expensive" mean when shares are, individually, kinda cheap? First the fees to play are very high, unaffordable to low-income people. Second, it means that returns, interest rates, are low (price = return / interest rate as a quick rule of thumb). So yea, we should be complaining that, not AAPL but financial instruments, are expensive!
- sokoloff 7y agoAt least four major discount brokerages have zero commissions on stock trades. Many major mutual fund companies have had commission free trading of mutual funds for over a decade (probably more like 3+ decades.) I’m not sure which fees are “very high” in this context.
- helen___keller 7y ago> So yea, we should be complaining that, not AAPL but financial instruments, are expensive! And to the point of this topic I think this contributes to housing woes, atleast in major markets where there's a very low rental yields. I can afford to rent in my area, but I can't afford to buy because (with an identical unit in the same neighborhood) my monthly costs would go up by $1000 or $1500 or so, even with 20% down. I think low returns on financial instruments contribute to this (because on the contrary, if you could buy bonds yielding 5% why would you hold rental properties that yield less before maintenance?) All financial markets are connected, and across the board we have capital appreciation with low yield. It seems like we're headed to some kind of reckoning, but I have no idea what or when. Last year I thought it would come with rising interest rates, but that's off the table for who knows how long.
- AuthorizedCust 7y agoThe law of supply and demand notwithstanding, are there any cases where increased housing supply has been the proximate cause of a decline in housing values? By "proximate", I don't mean "my home's value dropped more after the bubble popped than I think it should have because [points to new housing]". I mean the housing built as a consequence of relaxed laws directly caused the decline. Houston seems like a good case study as it lacks zoning and vast swaths don't have deed restrictions, either.
- outside1234 7y agoThis. Thank you. The goal of housing should be price stability at a point everyone can afford, not appreciation.
- specialist 7y agoAgreeing with you: I have friends who work on housing (and related) policies. The stereotype of "Liberal Seattle" simply isn't true. One of our biggest intraparty food fights is the upzoners vs the nimbys. The tortured logic and hypocrisy of the nimbys is maddening. Yes, homelessness and affordability are acute problems, govt should do something, but increasing supply couldn't possibly work. I can't prove it, but I know it's true: Ok Boomer. All the nimbys I know (active in policy, politics) are my age and older.
- achenatx 7y agoI live in a 75% democrat area (in austin) built in the 60s/70s and the NIMBYs are boomers and are bad. The city council wants to reduce the lot size,parking, and setbacks required for duplexes and triplexes all over the city. They want to increase density for about 100 units along a transit corridor from single family to 4 units, up to 6 with affordable housing. The nimbys are going crazy, talking about lawsuits, protests etc. Many posts talk about flooded schools, huge traffic increases, and gigantic duplexes on every lot. The reality is people can already build duplexes and they dont at a huge frequency. People have even posted articles written by NIMBYs in other cities how housing pricing doesnt follow supply and demand. It is all about "neighborhood character". Im a hardcore conservative and believe upzoning is the best way to solve the affordability problem.
- arcticbull 7y ago> Im a hardcore conservative and believe upzoning is the best way to solve the affordability problem. Removing zoning restrictions is arguing for the free market, and for reducing government intervention and in this case, as a liberal, I couldn't agree more. This is an example of government being used as a cudgel of the wealthy to beat back the poor. That's not what I want the role of government to be.
- tardo99 7y agoI actually disagree with you about shares of companies. They should accurately reflect the value of the underlying company. Wanting everything to "go up" all the time is part of the problem that we face throughout the economy, not just in housing. Just as city councils have conspired to rig the process for housing, forces like central banks have rigged the process for all types of investment assets (including housing!). This will become a problem as a generation of savers/investors is unable to generate positive returns on investments to fund their lifestyles and retirements.
- generalpass 7y agoOne issue you don't mention is the urban growth boundary laws, which basically mean there is no competition for housing outside of areas that already have housing. Prior to these laws, cities absolutely could not get away with such nonsense restrictions on growth because people would move just outside of the city limits, establishing new communities not within the city's taxing region, so cities would try to accommodate to keep the taxes in the city. Now, the cities all know that people cannot move outside of cities, so they can behave as oligarchs.
- nhebb 7y ago> (1) Americans consider housing to be an investment. Apparently I'm the lone dissenter on this, but I think for many people this is a side benefit that they may hope for, but the primary objective is simply to own a home that they can live in and raise a family.
- mrep 7y agoI'm with you. Granted, I do consider it an investment in the sense that every month I pay off part of the principal and thus I can get some money back when I sell it whereas I'd get nothing if I was renting but I don't expect greater than inflation appreciation on the house. However, this could just be because I grew up in Chicago where there is endless farmland that can be developed and thus expecting greater than inflation appreciation on your house is foolish as someone else can just develop some farmland and sell it for the cost of building the house thus forever increasing the supply at the marginal cost of building a house.
- fred_is_fred 7y agoI assume that people are willing to pay more to have a better commute or live in a better town? I know that I am.
- mrep 7y ago> better commute Wasn't a big issue for us at least as we have double decker commutator trains. The one that ran through my town has 3 tracks even so the train only has to stop at a few stations and then it hops onto the middle track and drives the rest of the way downtown. Only took 30 minutes to go 20 miles downtown and going out further doesn't add much time as your just adding distance traveled at top speed. > better town Not sure what metric you are interested in that regard but if it is school wise, I went to one of the highest rated public schools and you could still find smaller more affordable homes in the school district. While there were plenty of wealthy people, I had some friends whose parents were firefighters and USPS delivery men.
- jlmorton 7y ago
- tootie 7y agoThere's a pretty solid argument to be made that as property values rise, their usefulness as investments decreases. If you sink $1M into a home, you're likely tying up a huge percentage of your net worth in something that will appreciate pretty slowly compared to equities. Homes are only really valuable investments if you are an otherwise undisciplined investor who can't hold on to liquid assets.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- keithnoizu 7y agoHousing is actually a depreciating asset in Tokyo, with a regular cycle of tearing down and rebuilding units every few decades. But the poor youth don't need to vote, they can just simmer on things long enough until they break out in riots. I mean hey massive social upheaval and unrest nearly got the FAP passed under Nixon. Let the kids burn down a few small suburbs and the government will figure out something.
- DubiousPusher 7y agoI often say people underestimate the value they get from paying taxes into welfare programs. The class conflict they prevent is invaluable especially if you're a person who owns property in or near a major city.
- keithnoizu 7y agoAgreed
- CamperBob2 7y agoWhat was the FAP? I've never heard of that legislation, and it's obviously ungoogleable.
- keithnoizu 7y agobasic income with extra steps and an unfortunate name (Family Assistance Plan) https://www.amazon.com/Failed-Welfare-Revolution-Americas-Guaranteed-ebook/dp/B005646EZA/ref=sr_1_1?keywords=the+failed+welfare&qid=1575405748&sr=8-1 https://www.amazon.com/Failed-Welfare-Revolution-Americas-Gu...
- KoftaBob 7y agoTook the words out of my mouth. Zoning laws need to be completely overhauled and changed to be planned by the state, not local government. When you let local town hall meetings give their input on every single development, it heavily hinders the ability of housing supply to keep up with demand. States need to create universal zoning laws that adapt to different situations and if a building meets it, it's automatically approved, full stop. Holding up development by town hall meeting should be for exceptional cases where there's a gray area in meeting the zoning law, not the norm. Can you imagine what NYC would look like today if they let local homeowners block every single building until their every desire was satisfied? It would be a shell of the metropolis it is today. Homeowners need to get out of their head this idea that when you buy a home, you're entitled to a neighborhood that stays frozen in time to how you liked it. The only thing they have a say on is their own property, and thats it.
- fortran77 7y agoMany people who own houses don't want the value/price of their homes to go up, because that means property taxes will go up.
- briffle 7y agoWe don't talk about the lack of affordable AAPL shares do we? That's insane, it's an investment, we want it to go up. The less affordable, the better! Isn't that pretty much what stock splits are for?
- calvinmorrison 7y ago"Micro apartments", short term rentals, lower than hotel level of service. this is what we need. These housing restrictions raise the minimum affordable rent causing people to live with their parents or find roommates which is risky. And it's funny, because times have certainly changed and got stricter in regards to minimum livability. My mom's apartment in manhatten as a child had the bathtub in the kitchen, it's still no unheard of there. Do i need a huge fridge, sink, 4 burner stove with oven and all? Not really. I don't need a window in my bedroom. I don't _need_ a private bathroom. I don't _need_ a private kitchen.
- pjmorris 7y ago> I don't need a window in my bedroom. Until there's a fire. Some regulations actually make sense.
- ogre_codes 7y ago> Specifically, housing affordability is 100%, entirely, a problem of artificial constraints on supply by city councils. Not just city councils. Residents, environmental groups, and special interest groups controlled by residents have a huge influence on limiting housing through legislation as well. Often places where housing is approved by the city are stalled in courts for years. City councils can control some of the lawsuits by reforming local laws but there is a huge number of individual residents who are willing to spend absurd amounts of money preventing people from building a new 6 unit apartment at the end of the block.
- rch 7y agoIt's worth noting that some of the groups you mention are motivated by a general opposition to rent seeking developers, and would be perfectly amenable to a 6 unit resident-owned coop in the same location.
- sagarm 7y agoAre those residents going to build that 6-unit themselves?
- rch 7y agoYes actually.
- ogre_codes 7y agoNobody ever says "I just don't want a new housing unit there". Every single one of those groups has some kind of justification for why they don't want new housing near where they are. Some say it's to prevent "Rent Seeking Developers", some say it's to improve the quality of local parks, sometimes it's because the unit they are replacing adds some "special character" to their block. In the end though they all have the exact same goal and same effect. It's all NIMBY bullshit, everyone is for affordable/ new housing unless it impacts them in the tiniest way, then suddenly they are against it.
- 7y ago
- FussyZeus 7y ago> Americans consider housing to be an investment. Not just an investment, but for many, it's the investment. For most of the 99% property ownership is seen as the only reliable motive for social mobility. It's the only way to sustained and reliable long-term financial wealth. I'm not saying you're wrong, I'm just saying asking people to give up their only solid method of upward social and financial mobility for the sake of fairness is a little callous, especially since all the other methods were discounted and are heavily tilted in favor of the 1% so they can cling to their mountains of gold just a little harder.
- wnevets 7y agoHas anyone actually stopped to think maybe city councils (and the people who vote them in) don't want you to live there and that's why they constraint the supply?
- sidlls 7y agoMulti-family buildings and commercial real estate are investments. Primary residences are not, and I think it’s actually quite rare for owners of a single family residence to view it as an investment the same way they view a 401k as an investment. They’re often been seen as a store of value and are definitely seen as a place to grow old in.
- beamatronic 7y agoI think you have a false choice in there somewhere. Yes we want housing to grow more than 2%. No we don’t need housing to grow by 500%.
- aidenn0 7y agoThat's not a false choice. If you grow faster than inflation than it's only a matter of time before your grow by 500% in total. If you e.g. grow by 4% annually then you will have quadrupled in 36 years.
- mattmaroon 7y agoIf housing grows by more than wages, it gets progressively more unaffordable. There is no number at which it is both a good investment and remains affordable because those two things are, by definition, opposite. Even in the best growing markets, like San Francisco, housing is still not a very good investment. It's only gone up about 8% per year over the last decade. That significantly underperformed the s&p 500. The real reason people want to use it as an investment is that you can get it at a very low interest loan, whereas you cannot with the s&p. this has the unfortunate effect of making well-off people more well-off, at the expense of making poor people poorer.
- StacyRoberts 7y agoThis is a very urban viewpoint. There are millions of people in rural areas who can't afford to buy a home as well. Cheap mortgages are a huge factor,I agree with that. I think city policies are a problem but nowhere near 100%. Banks and cheap risk free lending massively dwarf the impact of city policy.
- rubyn00bie 7y agoThat'd be a big no friend, since 80% of America's population lives in urban centers. It's a strictly factual viewpoint that you want to distort to fit your lens which is quite clearly in favor of your (likely) minority (rural) freeloading* living situation. America has by far and away the cheapest/easiest country to buy a home in general. * Most people who live in rural areas are subsidized in huge amounts by the government for things like telephone access, electricity, and roads. They says they "only rely on themselves" but it's bullshit.
- StacyRoberts 7y agoYou're both incorrect and out of line.
- gnopgnip 7y ago(1) does not have to be true. You can "lose" money, or break even selling a home and still come out ahead compared to renting. An example of this is "low income" homes that have strict price controls, and are in high demand with waiting lists or lotteries to buy.
- thorwasdfasdf 7y agoThis is so correct! I wish we could sticky this post at the top of every housing discussion. Progress means things become more affordable and cheaper. For instance the price of lighting up a room has come down my many orders of magnitude. It used to cost a significant portion of one's earning to buy a candle and light up a room for an hour, now it costs mere pennies. I hope some day humanity can have that kind of progress in housing as well. The way to get there is to start opening up innovation. Start letting builders build it the way they want, and allow startups to create new ways to make buildings. We can deregulate certain parts of the towns/cities or start new ones. We need to open things up and reduce barriers to entry. That's why there was an explosion of innovation on the internet: no barriers to entry and no regulations to get in the way. Let's do the same for housing and see what progress we can make.
- lukifer 7y ago> It's time to re-think the idea of housing as an "investment." Shameless policy plug: part of the reason that property tends to be a good investment is that a significant portion of its value derives not from improvements, but from "location, location, location": proximity to businesses and community services. Some economists (Henry George, Milton Friedman) have advocated shifting property tax to be based on the unimproved value of land, rather than its total/improved value, thus offsetting the (arguably unearned) benefits of sitting on a lot while the surrounding community accrues value. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism
- tick_tock_tick 7y agoLand Value Tax is one of my favorite overalls to the tax system proposed. Normal property taxes are one of those things that sounds great on paper but the actual implementation has shown us it just encourages horrible rent seeking behavior.
- giggles_giggles 7y agoI like the idea of a land value tax more than a property tax, but I feel like I'm missing something. If I sit on an empty lot while the city builds up around me, doesn't the unimproved value of my land still go up?
- nybble41 7y agoYes, exactly. A land value tax is not actually a tax on the land but rather a tax on improvements people have made in the area around the land. Literally unimproved land has no value to tax.
- giggles_giggles 7y agoThen I feel like I really must be dense. Doesn't this mean that there's still an incentive to hoard land while nearby land is improved, so that you can sell at a profit? And if that's the case, for the purpose of dissuading land hoarding and encouraging building housing how is a land value tax functionally different from a property tax? In both cases if you have an empty lot in an area that gets built up, you make a big unearned profit, right?
- btilly 7y agoThe whole topic of conversation around housing affordability is backwards. Specifically, housing affordability is 100%, entirely, a problem of artificial constraints on supply by city councils This is literally economics 101. Supply and demand curves. Anything that decreases supply, increases price. Anything that makes some of that supply available cheaply, increases price for the rest. Anything that increases development risk or reduces the profit available to landlords, decreases supply and therefore increases price. In short, drives for affordable housing mandates help cause the very problem that they intend to solve. If you want to actually improve affordable housing, build a shit ton of housing. And built it close to where people work. This will reduce prices, reduce congestion, and reduce commutes. Everyone winds up better off. And yes, the solution needs to be built in YOUR backyard. If you whine about that and whine about the problem, you're either willfully blind to facts, or a hypocrite. Get over it.
- pdonis 7y ago> Americans consider housing to be an investment. Correction: Americans who own their homes consider housing to be an investment. But that in no way prevents housing from being "affordable" for renters.
- larnmar 7y agoTokyo has a declining population. When Tokyo’s population was still increasing, housing prices there were ridiculous (there was the 80s factoid about the Imperial Palace grounds being worth more than the entire state of California). If you look at many other major cities in Asia (especially China) you will see a combination of wall-to-wall skyscrapers as desired by yimby (usually really yiseby) types, plus insanely high property prices.
- kyazawa 7y agoI don't believe this is correct. All the sources I've read say that Tokyo has a growing population. https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2018/07/12/national/japan-population-declines-fastest-pace-yet-125-2-million-government/ https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2018/07/12/national/japan-...
- vanusa 7y agoSpecifically, housing affordability is 100%, entirely, a problem of artificial constraints on supply by city councils. If this were true then cities with comparatively less zoning (e.g Houston) would comparatively speaking -- be meccas of affordability. But in reality this is of course anything but the case.