28 ms·
Tesla Cybertruck may be unsafe for other road users: Australian safety chief
- gberger 7y agoAll trucks are unsafe for pedestrians, period.
- ramenmeal 7y agoDon't forget the lifted trucks. If one of those runs into the side of my car, it's bumper directly hitting my face.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoUnpopular opinion: Lifted trucks should be illegal.
- varenc 7y agoThey are in Australia! (Where the ANCAP is from). Or rather, lifts beyond a few inches require special certification. Same goes for larger tires and after market bullbars.
- keyle 7y agoHeck in Australia I don't think it's even legal to have tyres that come outside the width of the mud guards.
- grecy 7y agoOf course it isn't, that's seriously dangerous.
- gberger 7y agoWhat is ANCAP? I only know this term as meaning anarcho-capitalism.
- peter_tonoli 7y agoAustralasian New Car Assessment Program https://www.ancap.com.au/ https://www.ancap.com.au/
- tus88 7y agoWhat Australia are you living in?
- keyle 7y agoThey are in many parts of the world!
- ericmcer 7y agoIn cities lifted trucks and motorcycles and cars without sufficient muffling should be illegal. Engineers have spent so much time and money trying to solve problems around noise, pollution and safety so that we can operate internal combustion engine vehicles in crowded cities without ruining each others lives. Then someone can just lift their truck and take the muffler off for vanity reasons? Seems insane
- dharmab 7y agoThose _are_ illegal already. It's just that in many places the police don't actively enforce the laws because they have more important work to do.
- diogenescynic 7y agoNot disagreeing with your point, but a what is the more important work they’re supposedly working on? In SF cops aren’t enforcing traffic laws, drug laws, or really even patrolling so what are cops actually spending their time on?
- gberger 7y agoPresumably, violent and property crimes.
- Reason077 7y agoI think the only solution for this is to phase out ICE vehicles entirely. No matter how quiet they are when they leave the factory, there is always some idiot who's gonna modify the exhaust because he thinks that making extra loud noises makes him cool.
- banana_giraffe 7y agoAnd some companies that will modify the non-ICE cars to make more noise: https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1180877114226008064 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1180877114226008064 Though, the first time I hear a Tesla making the coconut noise from Monty Python I will no doubt laugh. The second time? Yeah, it'll get old fast.
- ianai 7y agoCrazy bright LED headlights at eye level of other vehicles need to be illegal too.
- syshum 7y agoEven more Unpopular Opinion: pedestrians and non-motorized traffic should be illegal on road ways
- imtringued 7y agoYes what we need is a law so extreme that it even prohibits us to walk accross the parking lot to the store.
- philwelch 7y agoYeah, this is why semi-trucks have the Mansfield bar that runs level with the bumper of a normal passenger car. (Named after Jayne Mansfield, who died in a car crash with a semi truck.)
- jka 7y agoThat may unfortunately be true (and to some extent, is likely a problem with large & weighty road vehicles in general). But the article points out that this one may also be unsafe for passengers, if it lacks an effective way to absorb energy in a collision. Quoting from the link: "Because the cold-rolled steel is undentable it does not allow for crumple zones that reduce the impact of the force of an accident for occupants."
- themagician 7y agoThis is true of a lot of small cars, like the Smart Car and the Fiat 500. They have pretty rigid structures but no crumple zones. The car survives, but everyone suffers massive internal bleeding. If any part of the car itself touches your head or chest in an accident, you basically die instantly.
- Reason077 7y agoNCAP crash testing works by placing sensors on test dummies and measuring the impact forces on their "bodies" under various crash scenarios. In Euro NCAP testing, the Fiat 500 has a 3 star rating[1], and the Smart fortwo has a 4 star rating[2]. So while not among the safest cars on the market, they are certainly not the deathtraps you suggest. The Smart in particular offers very respectable occupant protection for its size. [1] https://www.euroncap.com/en/results/fiat/500/26307 https://www.euroncap.com/en/results/fiat/500/26307 [2] https://www.euroncap.com/en/results/smart/fortwo/7894 https://www.euroncap.com/en/results/smart/fortwo/7894
- lonelappde 7y ago> The Smart in particular offers very respectable occupant protection That's reassuring > for its size. That's not. Passengers risk rises with the size of the incoming car, not the car they are riding in.
- Reason077 7y ago"Passengers risk rises with the size of the incoming car, not the car they are riding in." There are much larger cars that perform worse on occupant protection tests than the Smart does. For example, the Jeep Wrangler: https://www.euroncap.com/en/results/jeep/wrangler/34192 https://www.euroncap.com/en/results/jeep/wrangler/34192
- baddox 7y agoCars too.
- corodra 7y agoI wonder... some people claim the "negative press" of the glass shattering was by design because it creates a larger narrative, that if they handle properly, keeps the truck in the public's ears and eyes everyday (which is has) and if they "fix it" makes them look like they care about their customer bases voice. If I agreed/believed that, this could be a part 2 to that plan. I bet a discussion will come up how government regulations don't allow the public to have bullet-RESISTANT vehicles (no such thing as "bulletproof", especially if you don't get 3rd party standardized testing to back up your claim). Along with trying to rewrite vehicle laws/standards to benefit Tesla. Personally, don't care either way. But I always get this uneasy feeling whenever Musk does anything.
- modoc 7y agoSince when can the public not have bullet resistant vehicles? There are several companies that armor civilian vehicles.
- generatorguy 7y agoHere is a piece of bulletproof glass used on bullet proof cars that takes 18 rounds and isn’t pierced. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=_FN5xzeVluc https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=_FN5xzeVluc I have a water resistant watch and I understand I can’t go diving with it, but I feel like maybe this glass is more than resistant enough to qualify as “proof”?
- fredophile 7y agoMultiple impacts do degrade the performance but the calibre of bullet is also a factor. The video was using a .223 (5.56mm) which is pretty standard for AR15 derived assault rifles. A slightly larger 7.62mm round will have more force and might be able to penetrate the glass. Bigger rounds like .338 lapua or a .50 cal would have even more energy and be more likely to penetrate the glass, especially if it was weakened by previous impacts.
- hackermailman 7y agoBulletproof is a reason that we will see black pr about this truck because many places like Australia/Canada have tried to outlaw these mods due to well known gangsters using them the police are too incompetent to arrest. For example it's illegal to sell bulletproof vests here. Everytime I read some critic of this truck it's from a place that has these laws in place, Musk needs to counter this onslaught of blackPR from 'unfree' countries such as my own who can't arrest known felons so resort to punishing everybody else trying to ban or make illegal these features.
- empath75 7y agoThe fact that the body is undentable and glass is unbreakable makes it sound worse for occupants, too. If it doesn’t crumple, you’re going to be in for a bad time in a car accident.
- nyolfen 7y agopresumably it must pass the same crash safety tests as every other car sold in the US
- clouddrover 7y agoUS safety tests aren't very good in comparison to the rest of the world. In particular, US car safety tests don't emphasize the safety of pedestrians and cyclists to the same extent as the European and Australian test programs do: https://www.forbes.com/sites/tanyamohn/2019/10/20/starflationus-car-safety-ratings-once-best-in-the-world-now-lag-behind/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/tanyamohn/2019/10/20/starflatio...
- bbmario 7y agoBla bla US sucks bla bla bla.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't post unsubstantive or flamebait comments here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- nyolfen 7y agoyes, that is what the article is about, but the post i was replying to was speculating that it would be less safe for occupants
- cglace 7y agoIt sounds like a difference in priorities and not an indictment on the tests.
- knolan 7y agoAs someone who commutes by bike and has been hit twice by cars, the first thought that crossed my mind when seeing the CyberTruck was ‘ouch’.
- donjoe 7y agoI think this car will seriously hurt the car insurance industry. Just imagine a car that cannot get scratches and/or mailbox dents which cost thousands of dollars in repair by simply... not colouring the car and making the surface more scratch-resistant. Awesome! As a fellow bike-communter myself I had exactly the same thoughts regarding pedestrian safety though.
- tehwebguy 7y agoPeople try very hard to avoid using their insurance for small things, everyone is terrified of their rates going up. Cybertruck might not need comprehensive or uninsured motorist coverage but it looks like it would annihilate anything it hits. You’ll want plenty of bodily injury, collision, property damage and PIP.
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoWonder if laser etching the Cybertruck will become a popular way of personalizing the vehicle.
- zaroth 7y agoMore likely vinyl wrap. There are already companies announcing various options for this. And because Cybertruck isn't curved, the wrap is much easier to apply.
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoUgh, I can envision led panels being attached to it for rolling advertising.
- 7y ago
- tus88 7y agoI was thinking about this the other day. Will they let a armored tank on the road?
- modoc 7y agothey let armored cars, dump trucks, snow plow trucks, cement trucks, etc... on the road..
- freehunter 7y agoThose things typically require special drivers licenses though.
- symplee 7y agoBack to the original post, will they have a dedicated "Tank" license?
- threeseed 7y agoAll of those are: a) Not driven by the general public. b) Niche and not as common on the road as the Cybertruck is planned to be. c) Slow to accelerate meaning it's much harder to drive them dangerously.
- jeffdavis 7y agoThey let armored cars on the road.
- m0zg 7y agoTanks are legal to own in the US IIRC (with a federal permit). Arnold Schwarzenegger has one. They are also street-legal in some jurisdictions if rubberized tracks are installed and the tank is less than 50 tons. Here's a dude buying some fastfood in one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vvkLaa9bogU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vvkLaa9bogU. Here's an APC: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v5tTSfWMeNo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v5tTSfWMeNo
- ananonymoususer 7y agoI ordered one last week. I wonder how many of the specifications advertised will actually be met by the production version. 500 mile range, faster than a vette, 100cu feet of storage, seats 6, sledgehammer proof body, bullet proof glass, etc. It all sounds too good to be true for only $70k.
- ogre_codes 7y agoThe value they are delivering with this truck seems uncharacteristic of Tesla who’s product line is largely dominated by “expensive but you’ll love it anyhow” vehicles.
- dreamcompiler 7y agoI'd be very concerned about that glass. If your car has a collision and the doors jam, a firefighter can get you out of an ordinary vehicle by breaking the glass with a $5 tool. If the glass is shatterproof, they can still get you out but perhaps not before you burn to death.
- symplee 7y agoFirefighters will now be required to carry steel spheres the size of a baseball and be trained to chicken-arm throw it at the window at approximately 3 mph.
- elliekelly 7y agoCurious if you’ve ever owned a truck before or if this will be your first? I’ve seen a lot of articles saying that Tesla is great at bringing in new customers but that the truck drivers are notoriously resistant to change and much more brand loyal than typical car buyers.
- topspin 7y ago> 500 mile range When you go to https://www.tesla.com/cybertruck https://www.tesla.com/cybertruck the advertised figure in "300+MI". I don't know where one finds 500 but that's not the top line figure that appears on front page of the official site...
- Silhouette 7y agoThis was my immediate reaction when I first saw it: how is anything remotely like that design ever going to be road-legal here in the UK, unless it has some innovative ways to do better than standard, possibly even legally-required safety features that don't seem to have been mentioned? There are certainly reasonable alternatives to things like wing mirrors. For example, it's not hard to imagine a camera-and-screen arrangement in a vehicle from Tesla. However, giving the vehicle a solid shell pretty much implies that the full force of any impact is transmitted to the occupants on one side and the impactee on the other because physics, which is going to be a concern given the great emphasis on the materials used. Then there's the angular styling, which appears to have edges practically designed to cause serious injury to anyone vulnerable that might be hit by the vehicle, not to mention the potential to act as a ramp sending the victim of a frontal collision up the front or even over the top of the vehicle. It definitely looks like a case of form-over-function so far, but it's hard to believe no-one at Tesla has considered these kinds of issues, so surely they must have something up their sleeves to deal with them (unless <conspiracy theory>it's all been a very successful publicity stunt and they never really intended to bring a vehicle like this to market</conspiracy-theory>).
- lrem 7y agoFor a good start, it's over the weight limit of the regular driving license in Europe.
- Silhouette 7y agoHas the weight been officially confirmed anywhere? That and the breakover angle were notable only for their absence in anything I've seen so far.
- cardinalfang 7y agoThe weight of a Model X (2.5t) and the Truck's 1.6t payload is easily above the 3.5t gross a European car licence is limited to.
- 7y ago
- Marsymars 7y agoIn an idealized economy, the owner of a dangerous-to-others truck would be paying enough for liability insurance to cover their negative safety externalities. Does that play out in reality?
- TomMarius 7y agoDefinitely, at least in my country (EU)
- henryfjordan 7y agoWhat's the price on the life of a pedestrian? Some negative externalities can never really be covered by money.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- asdfadsfgfdda 7y agoIn most of America, the minimum liability insurance is far too low. For example, California only requires $15k per person in liability insurance. If someone is killed or seriously injured, there's easily millions in damages. This effectively is a subsidy to car driving (and bad drivers). But politically, it seems impossible to fix this. Red states want less government intervention, and blue states don't want to "penalize" poor people.
- syshum 7y agoYou know most "Red States" have higher minimums that CA right? Further the insurance minimums does not limit a person liability just the amount the insurance company will pay, if you are stupid and dont have enough insurance then your other assets (like your home) can be seized and your wages garnished to recover the liability This is also why one should have good Uninsured and Under insured coverage However saying all of that, one of the reasons for the Low Minimums on Liability in some states as they have gone to a "No Fault" system so your insurance would pay your costs so it is up to you to buy the amount you want to be covered for, it does not matter what the "other guy" has
- caconym_ 7y agoNews flash: all trucks and large SUVs are unsafe for other road users.
- tasty_freeze 7y agoWhenever I hear someone say that they feel so much safer driving SUVs and how they can see traffic better, I always think: yeah, and it comes at my expense. To my ears, it is like someone exclaiming how it is so much better to stand up in the movie theater because the view is better that way.
- threeseed 7y agoNews flash: The world isn't black or white. You can have trucks that are safer than others.
- caconym_ 7y agoWhat's your point? Do you think the Cybertruck is more dangerous than every truck and large SUV out there on the road right now?
- _notdan_ 7y agoI've definitely been thinking the same thing. It's super heavy and has a massive battery..
- willmadden 7y agoWill Australia also be banning semi trucks? Collision detection is far more important than body construction in terms of risk to pedestrians and other vehicles. This reads like regulatory overreach to me, and cherry picking.
- analbumcover 7y agoThat's Australia for you. We're the prototypical "big government nanny state" that conservative Americans fear. This could also be motivated by the Australian government's radical opposition to clean tech.
- drivingmenuts 7y agoIt’s just plain ass-ugly, to my eyes. I grew up around pickups and owned one until it became a pita in a parking garage. The VW Tarok concept truck is a far better looking pickup than the Tesla monstrosity. The Neuron T/One looks more futuristic and usable. The Lordstown Endurance looks more standard (and has a bloody expensive sounding name). The Atlis XT looks as conventional as it gets (but still way better than the Tesla). I think the Tesla is going to be another Humvee, if it goes to market: more about wasted money and contrarian looks than being actually useful. A toy for the uselessly rich.
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoWhen I lived in a midrise in the middle of town we had a Hummer driver move into the building. He started parking in the handicap space on the ground level because the Hummer's turning radius was too large to be able to make the corners in the parking deck to his leased parking spot. So much for being able to go anywhere in the Hummer. It never was a very practical vehicle. Other than the low polygon looks, the Cybertruck seems inline with the functionality of trucks in the F150 to F250 range. Probably won't be a problem performing tasks that those trucks already perform.
- ctdonath 7y agoI expect the autopilot parking will be widely used.
- retardFaggots 7y agoYeah, gee, gotta worry about this polygon design. By the way, time to jump into my pathetic crumple sedan and share the road with 18 wheeler tractor trailers, massive fuel oil hauling tanker trucks, garbage trucks, armored cars, box trucks, military vehicles, reinforced cop cars, fire trucks, panel vans with ladders and assorted pipes strapped haphazardly to the roof. But yeah, gee, look at that one autobody design that shall represent less than 1% of all accidents each year.
- nickpeterson 7y agoI think instead of a focus on mpg (which electrics make murky anyway), we should restrict weight. Eventually the goal is lightweight cars with reasonable safety features. People who want to drive 5000lb cars should have their danger to others health baked into their insurance premiums.
- syshum 7y ago>>Eventually the goal is lightweight cars Who's goal is that? Not mine >>People who want to drive 5000lb cars should have their danger to others health baked into their insurance premiums. it already is...
- nickpeterson 7y agoI'm sorry, but the arms race of heavier vehicles makes everyone less safe. It's an extremely irresponsible thing for society to engage in.
- syshum 7y agoMy reasoning for wanting a large vehicle has nothing to do with safety. Nor am I concerned with what is "responsible" for society.
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoUnfortunately trees, concrete pillars, and brick walls are unlikely to comply with safety restrictions on weight. Georgia was ridiculed a few years back for prohibiting trees between the road and the sidewalk under the theory that a car that wanders off the road can recover its intended path of there aren't trees in the way. Lightweight cars would still be lethal to pedestrians but also would make the elimination of trees and street furniture between the road and the sidewalk more desirable.
- nickpeterson 7y agoWouldn’t hitting a concrete wall, in a lighter car, be safer than a heavier car, assuming no drastic difference in safety systems in the car, since the overall force is still less? The frame of the car has to absorb less force.
- torgian 7y agolol what? This is like complaining for the sake of complaining. It's obviously a prototype and i have no doubt that there will be some redesigns.
- rasz 7y ago"unsafe for other road users" might be one of the best truck advertising slogans for US market one could imagine.
- Proven 7y agoOTOH you cause a collision with another vehicle you may end up be charged with manslaughter vs. injury (if you owned another vehicle)
- StudentStuff 7y agoAll raised vehicles are a danger to other road users. Most have bumpers significantly higher than other vehicles on the road, resulting in trunks and hoods on closer to the ground vehicles (Honda Odysseys, Toyota Camrys, etc) getting severely damaged in low speed impacts. For pedestrians and cyclists, high stanced vehicles ensure they end up underneath the car rather than on the hood of the vehicle (where survival rates are much higher). A person can get hit at 20mph by a Honda Accord and walk away nearly every time, but try that with a Cybertruck and they are much more likely to die: https://usa.streetsblog.org/2016/05/31/3-graphs-that-explain-why-20-mph-should-be-the-limit-on-city-streets/ https://usa.streetsblog.org/2016/05/31/3-graphs-that-explain...
- dwd 7y agoI was in Maroochydore, Australia this morning (I don't normally go near the shops there) and the number of big American trucks in the carpark surprised me. In just the section of parking I as in there was a Dodge Ram and two F250s, all hanging a couple of feet into the road being too long for your standard car park. A 4x4 Pajaro next to one of the Fords looked small. I'm surprised a similar point hasn't been made about those models.
- growlist 7y ago> Maroochydore, Australia Lucky man! Beautiful part of the world that I was lucky enough to visit myself a while back.
- throwaway3563 7y ago
- baby 7y agoIs it me or this feels like the automobile mafia at play? They obviously feel threatened by the introduction of this véhicule.
- askvictor 7y agoNo, just standards and regulations that are enacted to ensure the general safety of the population. They're relatively common in the developed world outside of US.
- symplee 7y agoI believe OP was referring to regulatory capture [0] where special interests are prioritized over the general interests of the public. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulatory_capture
- baby 7y agoIf they were really doing their job we wouldn’t have cars driving all around us. There is obviously more at play here.
- threeseed 7y agoThe only thing at play here is your pathetic attempt to slur a safety organisation just because they dared to be critical of the Cybertruck. Their job is to look after the interests of the general public not any one company.
- baby 7y agoPathetic until you realize what is really going on? That’s just a theory in the end.
- grecy 7y agoAgree. It's hilarious when the word "May" can be in the title and it's still a headline. Though it is a fun game: "Famous president may have syphilis".
- elif 7y agoEver since the reveal, all I can think about is the instance where a Tesla ran into the broad side of a tractor-trailer. Since the panels of the cybertruck are "scored on the inside and bent", and the body is the "exoskeleton" in place of a frame, the physics of this oragami-like interaction seem predictable... And in my head, I see a grotesque rendition of the ketschup-packet-under-the-chair prank from middle school.
- rklaehn 7y agoThis is just silly. There were not many pictures of it, but the truck has a massive frunk. This frunk will just be designed to crumple and adsorb the impact from a front collision. The structural frame will not extend all the way to the front but end earlier (about above the front wheel well). Tesla will want a five star safety rating for this thing, and you can not get that without also taking pedestrian safety into account. Edit: About the raised front: the front is not any more raised that my current main car, a Volkswagen T5 Bus, which is a very common car in europe. So I don't see why it should have a worse pedestrian safety rating.
- sschueller 7y agoTo crumble for pedestrians it can't be made completely out of unbreakable stainless steel. It's one of the other.
- rklaehn 7y agoStainless steel is not some magic adamantium that is completely unbreakable. You can choose thinner steel for the part that is designed to crumple, and it will crumple or fold as intended, just like any other material. I would guess that the bonnet will move backwards and slide over the windshield, and the other part of the front (up to the front wheel wells) will be designed to crumple.
- cardinalfang 7y agoThe T5 scored 1 NCAP star for pedestrian safety.
- growlist 7y agoSo happy to see everyone not jumping to conclusions over what is just a concept car and will no doubt - like all concept cars - be considerably different to the retail version /s