10 ms·
In my opinion you should not use ANY of the smart features of a "smart" TV. Don't give it your wifi key and don't put it on your LAN. I have about 400% more tr
by walrus01 7y ago
In my opinion you should not use ANY of the smart features of a "smart" TV. Don't give it your wifi key and don't put it on your LAN.
I have about 400% more trust of Microsoft and Sony than I do of random smart tv manufacturers. I also have a fairly high degree of confidence that the xbox one and PS4 software will remain up to date with security patches, and address critical issues quickly. I have no confidence for TVs.
Microsoft and Sony have teams of lawyers who've drafted the data collection/data sharing/opt-out policies for what their current generation game consoles track and phone home about. I've seen entirely too many reports of "smart" TVs that start reporting your entire viewing habits, and/or displaying unwanted ads.
Use the TV as a dumb display and hook it up to a PS4, Xbox One, and/or home theatre PC.
- Scoundreller 7y agoI trust cableco providers even less than random smartTV manufacturers. And those TV boxes are 2-way obligate devices...
- smileybarry 7y ago> I have about 400% more trust of Microsoft and Sony than I do of random smart tv manufacturers. It should be noted Sony's TVs are different than their game consoles in what they collect and do. They run a relatively clean version of Android TV except for "Samba TV", which is yet another piece of show-recognizing (known as ACR) analytics. However, you can apparently decline its privacy policy on initial setup and even disable the APK entirely in settings[1]. (Some people also succeeded in ripping it and other bundled video apps out via ADB) Even given all that, Sony TVs are probably still the tamest smart TVs out there. > Don't give it your wifi key and don't put it on your LAN. It entirely depends on manufacturer but I've heard of some actually seeking out open networks for internet access if you don't configure their Wi-Fi. Some people reported an unconnected TV suddenly prompted to update because the neighbour's wifi was unsecured. If you can, I'd set up a specific SSID with no LAN or WAN access just in case. [1] https://www.consumerreports.org/privacy/how-to-turn-off-smart-tv-snooping-features/ https://www.consumerreports.org/privacy/how-to-turn-off-smar...
- e2le 7y agoI'm not sure creating a network without no internet access is going to be a long term solution. It's entirely likely that they will create future functionality in these devices to cycle through open networks and networks to which they have credentials for until they find one with internet access.
- smileybarry 7y agoI guess you could then add some user-important content to the walled-off network, like a basic SMB share. Maybe it will avoid disconnecting from the user-set network if it has user content. But yes, this isn't a very stable solution.
- Bnshsysjab 7y agoNo vendor will use SMB to check for connectivity. They would check for relevant internet paths. Though I doubt the companies would be ballsy enough to connect to unsecured networks, if that breaches laws in a country that the tv is sold it may have legal ramifications for the company. Edit: then again my argument is based on logic and risk, not two factors marketing and sales teams consider very often..
- Buttons840 7y agoHDMI will share its connection through the cable as well. So if you want to use a Chromecast or a BluRay player, etc, then your TV can get internet through that.
- bitL 7y agoAgreed. My Samsung TV is not connected to Ethernet/WiFi and I have a quadcore Pentium NUC as a 4k HTPC for interacting with it. I have a full control of what I run on NUC (Ubuntu + Kodi) and TV is just a display. My Marantz is connected to Internet though (used for AirPlay) as it needs updates to its firmware, so there might be some audiophile listening...
- o-__-o 7y agoMarantz doesn’t report home if you disable reports. I also have never upgraded my marantz receivers
- generatorguy 7y agoPretty sure my 1970’s Sansui isn’t phoning home!
- yummypaint 7y agoWhen i got my samsung smart tv 4 years ago i actually read the EULA and was so disgusted i refused to agree. It lives its life as a computer monitor, and a buggy one at that. I doubt there is a way to update the firmware without agreeing. Moral of the story: dont buy smart TVs.
- ghettoimp 7y agoIf you want a TV, is there any alternative? We got a new TV last year and I (joe shmoe average user) didn't see any that weren't smart.
- chime 7y agoBuy the best TV that fits your needs. Do not configure the Smart TV features at all. If it requires Internet access for initial configuration, setup your phone as a hotspot with a temporary password. Once configured, change your phone hotspot password and disable it. I have many Smart TVs, all working great as dumb monitors for my AppleTVs. I wouldn’t change a thing.
- r3vrse 7y agoAnecdotal: was setting up some Hisense TVs at work the other day and the unit came up with a message that "all Network features" would be disabled if you declined the EULA. Immediately thought "works for me". I wonder if any other manufacturer offers that choice. Edit: commercial signage panels are about as close as you get to dumb TVs these days. Rarely include any smart features, can get in quite large sizes. Not OLED or anything but if you just want a decent display...
- SmellyGeekBoy 7y agoFWIW - I discovered recently that Hisense is actually owned by the Chinese state government, if that kind of thing matters to you.
- swader999 7y ago
- bubblethink 7y ago>I have about 400% more trust of Microsoft and Sony than I do of random smart tv manufacturers This is a really weak trust based argument. Sony put rootkits on cds (different division of sony, but still). MS has been fighting their users forever now. Ultimately, none of these trust based arguments work. If you care about privacy, use kodi, new pipe etc. Don't try to pick overlords. That's a losing battle.
- gbear605 7y agoI trust them to keep their products relatively secure from hackers, not to not use my data.
- notatoad 7y ago>PS4, Xbox One which are almost certainly also tracking everything. In general i agree with your advice, and would rather keep smart TVs off my network. but if your goal is to not be tracked, plugging in an additional piece of hardware from another big tech co isn't going to accomplish that goal.
- mackal 7y agoLG and Samsung both use Linux for their Smart OS and there are a few Android TVs. Also, fun fact, my cable boxes from Verizon also run Linux :P
- rraghur 7y agoI have a cheap, Chinese make 'smart' TV... (Le Eco).. e the company has gone under quite some time ago... It runs in it's own vlan with only access to the DNS (pihole). It's consistently the top blocked client on my home network! Ott. Nielsenccdata.tv
- friendlybus 7y agoWhy do you trust Microsoft more? They have the most egregious and base level of data collection compared to any other company. Their collection from the OS is pervasive and deep. The inability to truly disable Cortana is evidence that we don't own our purchased software anymore, merely borrow it from the big tech companies. In terms of undermining user ownership, MS has done more than most with help from Apple. I can get a different webmail provider and use a different search engine. Changing operating systems to Linux from one that actively fights you to run your computer for you is something else entirely.
- walrus01 7y agoI should clarify that I do not trust Microsoft more in terms of data collection, rather that security patches will be automatically pushed to an Xbox one. And that it has a relatively low likelihood of becoming part of a botnet, or compromised by a persistent form of Trojan. Good luck getting a software update for a four-year-old smart TV running some obsolete version of Android. Or WebOS. Xbox 360s are 12+ years old now and are still generally considered something that is safe to have on your home network, and not vulnerable to any known in the wild remote code execution. Xbox one or PlayStation 4 has considerably lower chances of becoming a malicious, virus-infected device on my home network.
- friendlybus 7y agoYeah I can agree with that. Samsung's apps on the older tvs need updating and in my experience they do not deliver the firmware updates they promise might happen at sale.
- nizmow 7y agoI trust them in the sense that they're going to _mostly_ keep the data they steal to themselves and are capable of doing so.
- Abishek_Muthian 7y agoI concur on leveraging console's(Xbox One/PS4) for smart TV functions due to better security and hardware; But the power consumption in using console as smartTV equivalent should be higher. Xbox One X has excellent power efficiency, it is my preferred way to gaming as I'm extremely conscious about the power consumption of my devices; but Smart TVs do consume lesser power for what they do.
- Diesel555 7y agoRoku scares me when I'm watching movies on my Rapsberry Pi. They are .mp4 files. I'm not using their software at all... and about 2 minutes in I get a pop-up "You can view this move elsewhere at XYZ." How do they know what movie I'm watching? They are analyzing the feed. Scary.
- ojosilva 7y agoBy recording and matching soundbites on their servers, similar to what the app Shazam does.
- hakfoo 7y agoI can't fathom what possible conversion rate that ad would have. Even assuming the underlying premise is something like "we suspect this is pirated and here's a legitimate option", you're suggesting I leave a task I'm in the middle of... to perform the same task elsewhere? I could see if they had the set turn on to a Wii-style menu and they had a box that said "Since you enjoyed watching Show XYZ, you may enjoy Service EFG, featuring XYZ and more", that could possibly convert, but the timing there is completely tone-deaf.
- adreamingsoul 7y agoSome will still try to connect to any open wifi and phone home. I’ve seen that behavior only on the one model that I was analyzing. Still, I assume it’s industry wide and even applicable to every/any IOT device.
- krageon 7y ago> I have [...] trust of Microsoft and Sony Stop trusting companies. That's what got us in today's horror show of privacy invasion. Verify what you get and buy accordingly. Trust in corporations is something that's not required and is actively detrimental to society as a whole.
- giancarlostoro 7y agoI have an LG smart TV I got when I got an LG G5. I do exactly this. I dont connect it to the internet. I did at first but then I changed the wifi password / reset the damn thing. It is just a dumb TV for my MiBox (Android TV) which I prefer since if that component dies I can replace it. Though I am likely going to buy an Apple TV instead in the future if I see any decent offers on one.
- deogeo 7y ago> Microsoft and Sony have teams of lawyers who've drafted the data collection/data sharing/opt-out policies for what their current generation game consoles track and phone home about. Those lawyers are looking out for MS and Sony, not you. Their job is to make sure everything is legal, not ethical.
- neop1x 7y agoI would also never connect smart TV to the internet. Years ago we purchased dumb plasma TV and set up a Linux box on older PC. The main part is Kodi (XBMC) which has addons for various online services + we have Tvheadend on another box for satelite and DVB-T2 recording. All two DVB-T2 muxes we are receiving are also sent multicast on the LAN using dvblast. Kodi can be controlled via an app on the smartphone or it's web interface. This has been working for years, some maintenance was needed but I am happy with it and don't plan changing it. This TV box is also a Kubernetes worker node for light workloads :D but that's another story.