15 ms·
Some scientists are serious about resurrecting zeppelins for cargo
- emanuensis 7y agoIf they used H2 (vs He) for buoyancy they could make (liquefied) H2 fuel very cost efficient: When you want to come down you are high up and it is cold! Perfect time to liquefy! Making H2 gas is also subsidized on the production end, as Airship travel is cheaper than any other method, so making H2 has that cost advantage. Safety is not an issue for transport. Human travel has that tradeoff though over He.
- JoshTriplett 7y ago> Safety is not an issue for transport. It's less of an issue. You still don't want a burning hydrogen zeppelin crashing down on a populated area, and unless you've fully automated it you'll still have human crew aboard (though they'll be better trained and equipped to deal with problems).
- andechs 7y agoIf it's filled with Hydrogen, it doesn't burn for very long - it would be an explosive burn. The cargo is still aloft in the air though, but that's also a theoretical problem with planes.
- xwdv 7y agoWhy wouldn’t people think this is a serious idea?? We can make far safer zeppelins with current technology even if we use H2 gas. And when you’re using it for something mundane like cargo instead of human recreational activity it’s a no brainer.
- taurath 7y agoIt would seem like it has the same issue as nuclear power, where the problem really is public perception not the science underlying it
- garmaine 7y agoWind shear.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- russfink 7y agoPirates.
- lvturner 7y agoI'd pay good money for an airship cruise, as a premium product - like a direct competitor to a cruise ship on the sea.
- JasonFruit 7y agoWhat I don't see is a discussion of how these airships would avoid the sort of weather-related accidents that destroyed the Shenandoah, the R101, the Akron, and the Macon. The Hindenburg disaster gets all the attention, but the bigger problem with the large rigid airships was their inability to avoid or weather storms. I'd love to see it --- I really would --- but I never see this point addressed.
- weberc2 7y agoI know very little about any of this, but our ability to forecast weather has certainly improved in the intervening century; might that be helpful for avoiding storms?
- em-bee 7y agoaccording to the article, these newer ships could fly high enough to be above all the problematic weather. only take off and landing would be an issue. but at the speed they are flying, a few hours delay won't make much off a difference either.
- nashashmi 7y agoI wonder if it would be easier to just lower the cargo instead of the entire airship
- melling 7y agoAll air travel combined emits 2.5% of our yearly CO2 emissions. That’s hundreds of thousands of flights a day. We could just eliminate all coal electric plants in the world and make a real impact. Then use that cleaner energy to power our electric cars.
- wallace_f 7y agoEliminating the majority of generation does not enable the electric vehicle market.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 7y agoEliminating coal generation overnight would be...impractical, but if it drove up electrical costs, that would send market signals to bring more renewables, utility battery storage, and natural gas generation online. NREL did some research about 5 years ago showing you could move ~75% of the US light vehicle fleet over to electric with no additional generation capacity, so the generation slack is there.
- slimed 7y agoAt peak hours? I somehow doubt that without massive and expensive amounts of new battery infrastructure we wouldn't see blackouts in major cities. Can anyone shed light on this?
- toomuchtodo 7y agoOvernight charging. EVs are a great fit for when demand is low at night (and you’ve got to run the generator regardless), or when there’s excessive production from renewables and you don’t want to curtail and waste that power.
- pojzon 7y agoWe should just introduce a tax for pollutioners. Big enough to make going green an economical adventage. Problem is all of the world politicians are a corrupt scum. And this is the only reason we didnt do that already. We have means to stop polluting. We just choose not to stop.
- teslaberry 7y agoBetter idea ultra high speed megascale nuclear powered cruise ships that never dock. They pull in 1 km from port and use deckside drones to transport tens of thousands of passengers safely on shore in different places all at once or as needed. Speed should reach at least 150mph. And with nuclear power become the domina t coastal form of circuit/belt transport. Not just people but cargo. Nuclear powered merchant marine should have happened. One day it will. Problem with zepllins is the skin will never be robust...because the bigger and faster the zepplins go the thicker the skin must be and the more difficult self healin smart skin systems will be to invent iterate and operate. Forget c02 and global warming. Think about simple economics. Next generation systems must be an order of magnitude more efficient in delivering a passenger to his ultimate goal or to any goal. That doesnt always mean only energy efficiency and operation and fuel price per passenger mile but these are strong factors in the equation.
- nradov 7y agoIt's effectively impossible to run a large surface ship at much over 40kts no matter how much power you have. The drag on a displacement hull is too high, and planing hulls and hydrofoils don't really work for anything large.
- ericd 7y agoThere was a company working on hydrofoils for cargo ships in one of the recent YC batches. No idea how it’s going, but they at least seem to think it’s possible to put foils on something large.
- symplee 7y agoWhat about cargo torpedoes? I imagine you could fit an airplane load into a very large submarine/torpedo and send it at 200 km/h with a nuclear powered propulsion.
- weberc2 7y agoNo idea if this idea is any good or not, but I wouldn’t recommend marketing this solution using the words “nuclear” and “torpedo”.
- randiantech 7y agoSeven days from Dallas to China? How is this considered a serious alternative to current planes?
- zarkov99 7y agoMaybe an alternative to cruise ships is a better option.
- UserIsUnused 7y agoCargo.
- trump2024 7y agoAnybody who eats meat should not preach what to do.
- starpilot 7y agoResurrecting dirigibles comes up every 5 years or so. This attempt looks no more serious than the others.
- danschumann 7y agoWhen I see old pictures with zeppelins in the sky, I am jealous and think they're more futuristic than we are.
- obituary_latte 7y agoAnyone have a non-paywalled version? Frustrating to only be able to read the first paragraph.
- exabrial 7y agoAnd where will they source the helium? Gas wells? We already waste the stuff and it's an incredibly useful substance.
- VonGuard 7y agoThis article doesn't seem to take into account that Helium is becoming scarce, and when used in airships, it's eventually just released and lost forever. NYT Article on the shortage: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/16/science/helium-shortage-party-city.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/16/science/helium-shortage-p... We used to have a strategic Helium reserve in the US for zepplins and so forth, then it was just kept for chemistry and other purposes. I think we started selling it down under GW. Helium seems like it's more valuable as a component in chemistry, super cooling, etc, rather than just using it for lift. Also, we tend to think of Zepplins as rare things, like singular one-off vessels like the Hindenburg. In actuality, the Germans produced 131 of them! Most were used in World War 1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Zeppelins https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Zeppelins
- cforrester 7y agoI wouldn't say that helium is becoming scarce in the sense that we can't get any more, though. I may be wrong, but my understanding is that it's just expensive to store, so nobody wants to do it if it's not worth the money. If air ships started to "take off", there would surely be more money in producing helium.
- teraflop 7y agoHelium is scarce in much the same way that crude oil is scarce: there are plenty of reserves still in the ground, but we are consuming them orders of magnitude faster than they were produced, and as the reserves dwindle the costs of extraction will rise. Helium is a chemical element, and aside from nuclear reactions (which are economically infeasible for non-microscopic quantities) we can't produce more of it.
- jandrese 7y agoIn fact our helium supply is a by-product of the petroleum industry. As we transition to renewable energy our supply of helium will diminish as well.
- colechristensen 7y ago
- crca 7y agoAirships don’t make sense for commercial travel. But they make a lot of sense for transporting cargo, specifically to regions that are difficult to serve by road or rail. LM has had a scalable, deployable system for years but no one has pulled the trigger on actually buying it yet.
- tropo 7y agoAn ordinary suburban location is difficult to serve by road if you'd like to ship a large house.
- scythe 7y agoI hadn't even considered that. You could blimp all sorts of things that won't fit on the road. Houses, windmill blades, HVAC units, pods for modular buildings, extremely large pianos, ...
- ryacko 7y agoNarrow gauge is a good solution for mountainous or rural areas, but infrastructure intensive solutions require government investments.
- sekou 7y agoLike the render on the Lockheed Martin site the first thing that came to my mind was Africa. This could be a solution for heavy-load cheap transport across huge swaths of land where road or rail infrastructure would be inefficient or too expensive to develop. It could help extend commerce beyond coastal regions both on the continent and worldwide.
- crazygringo 7y agoThe article's headline seems misleading: the article is actually about cargo, not traditional travel -- since airships are so slow. But I don't see what needs this would meet -- either you need something to be shipped between continents quick (~overnight) so you use a plane, or you don't so you use a container ship. This seems like it has neither the speed advantage of a plane, nor anything close to the size and scale advantage of a container ship. So aside from the niche use of large deliveries to remote areas inaccessible by ship or rail... I'm not getting it.
- cdolan 7y agoHow do you drive a container ship over land? I Think the point is that you could use this across the USA or other large geographic bodies for similar efficiency that you see with a container ship on water.
- placatedmayhem 7y agoI'm not sure, but I think some standard shipping containers fit on semi truck beds and on special train cars.
- tumanian 7y agoa freight train
- riffic 7y agoWonderful thing called a railroad network.
- usrusr 7y agoRail can only carry objects that can fit inside the cross-section and streets aren't much better. The defunct Cargolifter protect was quite open about not attempting to be competitive for loads that easily fit conventional transport. They saw their market exclusively in loads that are too bulky for ground transport and I don't think that anything has changed. Other than that this hypothetical market could be really huge now that wind turbines have grown into the "untransportable" realm for offshore use where no practical transport restrictions exist. (At least in countries that haven't universally given in to NIMBY and are still expand their land-based wind capacity)
- dr_dshiv 7y agoAirplanes fly high and have tiny porthole windows. You can't appreciate the beauty of the earth. Zeppelins can have huge windows and fly relatively low. The experience of flight would be amazing -- focused on the beauty of the natural world. Zeppelins offer a low-carbon earth-conscious luxury good that the superrich should spend money on -- so that eventually it's affordable to the rest of us.
- perilunar 7y ago> Zeppelins can have huge windows and fly relatively low Also they are constrained by weight, not volume, so there's plenty of legroom. The Hindenburg had private cabins, a lounge, a bar, and a dining room (and a smoking room!). More like a cruise ship than an airliner.
- dr_dshiv 7y agoHere is a picture: https://images.app.goo.gl/7Q7T2DLDjwU3xk367 https://images.app.goo.gl/7Q7T2DLDjwU3xk367
- kaffeemitsahne 7y agoNever realized there was passenger space inside the hull! That makes me slightly less stupefied about the enormous size/capacity ratio of zeppelins.
- xeeeeeeeeeeenu 7y agoWell, if you are willing to pay 15k+ USD for a ticket, airlines like Emirates or Etihad have those things too.
- ryanlol 7y agoI’ve done several long intercontinental trips in F on the emirates A380 and usually paid less than 4k for the tickets. But yeah, depends on the route.
- 7y ago
- etaioinshrdlu 7y agoI got a dumb idea. Permanently stationed blimps around the world that never land. And cable cars for moving between them, on pulleys. Pros: Energy efficient: no need to generate lift. No need for fans to move the cars as you are on pulleys, which are more efficient. Minimal noise! You could go as fast as you want but your efficiency will start to drop due to drag. It can't be any worse an idea than a hyperloop can it?
- galaxyLogic 7y agoWouldn't that be like a train? Maybe cheaper. A long cable would weigh a lot?
- etaioinshrdlu 7y agoYes kind of like a train but without disrupting the land below so much. Maybe much faster to install too.
- anoncake 7y ago> Yes kind of like a train but without disrupting the land below so much. ...or the ocean below. If the blimps can be grounded to ships, the ocean floor or don't need grounding, this could be a realistic way of building bridges across the oceans.
- galaxyLogic 7y agoA movable bridge which hangs in the air :-)
- haspoken 7y agoSounds like they would need to keep the same position. Would that be practical for such a large, light ship that can not avoid the weather?
- etaioinshrdlu 7y ago
- haspoken 7y agoOne problem with airships is the shear size and hence the handling, particularly during the time the airship is in dock.
- growlist 7y agoI suppose it could be possible to leave the airship in the air almost indefinitely, with smaller craft doing the loading/unloading at each end.
- sllabres 7y agoGerman company Cargolifter tried, about 20 years ago. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CargoLifter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CargoLifter
- TN1ck 7y agoMy father worked at the company back then, designing the rudders. After that, he worked at Airbus until retirement. He always said that his coworkers at Cargolifter where really good engineers and much brighter on average than at Airbus, I always wonder where they might be if they didn't run out of funding / if they would have started the company today, where people are much more willing to invest into risky firms like these.
- geocrasher 7y agoThis article reads like Popular Science or Popular Mechanics. From the late 80's. I don't mean to be pessimistic, but this ship has already sailed. Pun intended.
- s_gourichon 7y agoA former neighbor of mine now works at http://flying-whales.com/en http://flying-whales.com/en . Spot on the topic. They plan to specialise on special fret counting in dozens of tons, plus clever engineering to quickly transition between cargo on-the-ground to cargo airborne, and on arrival, airborne to on-the-ground.
- jdfellow 7y agoOff topic but I couldn't help but find it funny that a French airship company is called Flying Whales given that one of the best known songs by French metal band Gojira is called Flying Whales.
- dr_dshiv 7y agoHere is a short slide presentation with great pictures of future zeppelins and an exploration of possible applications: https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1r6CPFJ1AX1ZULacguTf6IyCS1dyiqFz_HsjH-evYiHg/edit?usp=drivesdk https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1r6CPFJ1AX1ZULacguTf6...
- nazgulnarsil 7y agoIf they were serious they would have calculated the max theoretical energetic efficiency of Zeppelin cargo hauling and realized they should stop
- vba 7y agoCan you expand, or give some numbers?
- nazgulnarsil 7y agohttps://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/helium-hokum-why-airships-will-never-be-part-of-our-transportation-infrastructure/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/helium-hokum...
- fhars 7y agoReminds me of https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/CargoLifter https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/CargoLifter
- aaRopi 7y ago"... using almost no energy at all if we used airships to harness the free winds of the jet stream, the narrow band of fast-moving air above the troposphere, where planes fly." But what if the jetstreams are already transporting something useful in nature? Sucking off energy from there will mean messing up with those natural systems that rely on the jetstreams. Oh Consequences!
- pvaldes 7y agoA different way to reduce the fuel bill and contamination without being constricted by scarce non scalable resources could be to design a new generation of (small?) cargo airplanes flying in a zig zag pattern of spending fuel to gain elevation and then gliding with some extra big pliable wings, extensible membranes or something like that...
- m4r35n357 7y agoWhy not sailing ships while we are at it?
- MikeTaylor 7y agoThe article addresses this. Ships are restricted to docking where there are ports, which are expensive and potentially fragile infrastructure (e.g. after a big storm), and can only be situated at the water's edge; while airships can pick up put down essentially anywhere.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoGreat now if we can just stop Bedford council building houses all over Cardington we can get the Sheds back in use.
- dr_dshiv 7y agoThere is huge potential for solar energy production on zeppelins. Back of the napkin: The Graf Zeppelin had a surface area of 27,299 square meters. If the top ⅓ was covered in solar, it could produce 10,800 kWh per day, assuming 1.2 kWh per day per square meter.
- dr_dshiv 7y agoAlso, they could harvest sea water or condensation to generate hydrogen. To produce one kilogram of hydrogen, 12 cubic meters, it takes 9 kg of water and 50 kWh of electricity. The solar Zeppelin described above could generate 2,589 cubic meters of hydrogen a day. At this rate, it would take 77 days to fill the Graf Zeppelin's 200,000 cubic meter capacity
- dr_dshiv 7y agoSo, perhaps we could float giant plastic solar balloons in a lake -- and semi-organically "grow" enormous hydrogen cells for aerostatic lift.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rb808 7y agoIncidental article about Macys Thanksgiving parade baloons are filled with Helium https://www.northjersey.com/story/news/2019/11/27/macys-thanksgiving-parade-balloons-may-not-rise-helium-costs/4318407002/ https://www.northjersey.com/story/news/2019/11/27/macys-than... At the end the gas is released, not recycled.
- nojvek 7y agoI think recreational use of helium ought to be banned. It’s a rare gas that once gone is gone from the atmosphere. It’s likely that our great great grandchildren won’t have it left for other uses. Well it’s also likely that they really won’t have a habitable planet too. But we gotta start somewhere right ?