8 ms·
> Come on, none of us are really "human" anymore since the advent of cell phones. We all use our cyborg-capabilities to search the internet and fact-check ourse
by jimbokun 7y ago
> Come on, none of us are really "human" anymore since the advent of cell phones. We all use our cyborg-capabilities to search the internet and fact-check ourselves every day. Programmers use stack-overflow to teach themselves programming and remember obscure details (using our cyborg capabilities to tag, search, and sift through information ever faster and faster).
Sure and any of us could jump on a motorcycle and fly past Usain Bolt in the 100m, but that kind of misses the whole point of the competition.
> Give the world-champions each a copy of AlphaGo on equal computers. Have them play Go against each other WITH computer assistance.
Won't the winner be the one who just takes AlphaGo's recommended move every time without changing anything?
- AllanHoustonSt 7y ago> Won't the winner be the one who just takes AlphaGo's recommended move every time without changing anything? That's only true if AlphaGo never makes a mistake or if AlphaGo will 100% always make the better or equal decision than a human + computer at any given state of the board. I know the former certainly isn't true and I assume the latter isn't true either, but I don't know enough about Go to say for sure.
- sukilot 7y agoLike self-driving cars, it's not enough to outsmart AI on one move, it's necessary to outsmart on AI with positive expected value over all the moves you are confident enough to weight in on.
- joosters 7y agoSelf-driving cars is a terrible comparison, especially since the state of the art right now is that the best human drivers far outpace the best AI driving, in both skills and flexibility. Plus, you only have to outsmart the car AI once to 'win' - e.g. just override one 'drive into the highway barrier' or 'run over that pedestrian' AI mistake.
- gizmo686 7y agoAlphaGo (and, presuably, any AI system with a remotely simmilar means of operation) can output a score for each move. Actually, AG can output 2 scores: win percentage and branches explored. You can use the relative scores to decide when to overrule the AI. Eg, if move A has a 50.1% win chance with 2k branches explored, and B has a 50.2% chance with 1.9k branches explored, I would go with the opinion of an expert human, as AG thinks the moves are essentially equal.
- summerdown2 7y ago> That's only true if AlphaGo never makes a mistake or if AlphaGo will 100% always make the better or equal decision than a human + computer at any given state of the board. Even if AlphaGo makes mistakes, and somewhere on the board a better move can be found, you would also need the human to reliably spot it. Eg: AlphaGo makes a move. Let's say that at least 20% of AlphaGo moves can be bettered. Is this one of them? How can you tell? Most of the time, you'll mistakenly think a move can be improved and end up playing a worse one. But, let's make AlphaGo even more fallible. Let's say that at least 50% of AlphaGo moves can be bettered. Again, is this one of those? How can you tell? And more to the point, on the times you are wrong, are you more wrong than AlphaGo is with its mistakes? Because even if you imagine you can spot a better move than AlphaGo and pick the actual better move 50% of the time, you also need your mistaken moves to be better than AlphaGo's mistaken moves or you'll still lose. Worst of all, you can rule out a really good ability to spot AlphaGo's mistakes already. Let's say 99% of AlphaGo's moves have a better option. If you could spot them all, you'd be beating AlphaGo regularly on your own. As no human can now beat AlphaGo, this plainly isn't true. So it's likely that: a) No human can reliably pick a better move than AlphaGo and/or b) No human can reliably spot a move from AlphaGo can be improved, and/or c) Human mistakes are worse than AlphaGo mistakes, so even if you could fight it up to parity you'd still lose.
- dragontamer 7y ago> Won't the winner be the one who just takes AlphaGo's recommended move every time without changing anything? No. Consider this scheme. I take my copy of AlphaGo and for a full year, I'll build a database of all opening positions AlphaGo is willing to explore. I'll rank these opening positions from "best" (Black-wins with most consistency) to "worst" (White-wins with most consistency). I'll put all of this information into a 16TB database on a singular, $400 16TB Hard drive, and load it into my computer during the contest. https://www.newegg.com/p/1Z4-002P-015K6 https://www.newegg.com/p/1Z4-002P-015K6 If you dare to pick AlphaGo's best move, you will lose. Because I already know which moves AlphaGo will take, and I already checked to find all of the positions AlphaGo wants to play (but loses anyway). The only way you can equalize the field is if you yourself ALSO build a 16TB database to consult and override AlphaGo's instincts during the game. If you see AlphaGo wanting to play "losing position #6234115", you'll tell AlphaGo to "search harder" and find another move instead. Good luck.
- dmurray 7y agoSo your tool of choice will be AlphaGo plus an algorithmically generated opening book? That's not meaningfully different from "everyone will bring the best available computer program" and again, it's a task for computer programmers, not Go grandmasters. Human + computer might still beat computer in Go - this was true for a few years in chess, and even now to some extent in correspondence chess - but what you describe isn't really that.
- btilly 7y agoThis comment sounds reasonable, but shows that you don't understand the challenge of Go on computers very well. Go does not have openings. It has reasonable choices to make, with an insane branching factor, with few moves making much of a difference by themselves. Therefore your database will only extend a few moves, and all of the positions that it winds up with will still be very close to even. So your database confers very little advantage. If you have alpha-go play itself a thousand times, it is unlikely that by move 10 you will wind up with the same board position twice. This is exactly the problem that made Go so hard for computers in the first place. Alpha-beta search is useless within practical limitations of computer hardware. That said in a different game, such as chess, your strategy would work very well indeed. (Which is why all decent computer programs have an opening book.)
- jacobwilliamroy 7y agoI'm actually not sure if we have motorcycles that can accelerate faster than usain bolt. I know the blue fin tuna has more acceleration than any vehicle ever devised by humankind.
- usefulcat 7y agoMaybe not over a distance of less than 1m, but over 100m?
- hyko 7y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sprint_(missile) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sprint_(missile)
- planteen 7y agoWow! 100g acceleration, Mach 10 in 5 seconds. I can't imagine the level of noise from that.
- jacobwilliamroy 7y agoHuh. I suppose that is more powerful than a bluefin tuna. Not as efficient though.
- tooop 7y agoA top sprint bicyclist can beat Usain Bolt in 100m. A modern or even a few not so modern liter bikes would have no problem in beating Bolt either.
- fossuser 7y agoAnd yet Usain Bolt still runs. The impression I got from Lee Se-dol in the Netflix documentary was that he had a lot of his identity tied up in this (particularly being the best Go player in the world). Not a huge surprise given the time and effort required to do it, but there's probably a healthier mental framing (I think Kasparov has a healthier one). If people give up on learning or doing something every time someone or something else can do it better then there's going to be a lot of disappointment as things continue to move forward.
- forgot-my-pw 7y agoLee Sedol has been on the decline, even before AlphaGo. He was top 5 back then, but now down to 50+: https://www.goratings.org/en/players/5.html https://www.goratings.org/en/players/5.html Maybe he's lost motivation, but this retirement is not a surprise.
- scottlegrand2 7y agoUsain Bolt chose his core competency wisely. Although it does imply hilarity would ensue from an all robot Olympics team (from the nation of 0 1 obviously), no?
- correct_horse 7y agoI think Usain Bolt no longer runs - he retired - but point taken.
- meesles 7y agoI appreciate the sentiment. If you look at sports records over time, everything gets continuously improves. Whether this is because of genetics or technology is up for debate, but I'm reminded of a funny (probably false) quote from an ex-Commissioner of US patent office: "everything that can be invented has been invented". The point is we don't really know what limits exist beyond our small pinhole of perception. During industrialization I'm sure people said the same thing: "What's the point of hand-made clothing if machines can do it?". Today both hand-made and factory-made clothing have their place in the market. Throughout history, tools have disrupted humanity and we've adjusted and expanded our horizons. To me this feels like another wave, and If I could bet and could collect winnings centuries in the future, I'd say this isn't even the last one.
- mastax 7y ago> Sure and any of us could jump on a motorcycle and fly past Usain Bolt in the 100m, but that kind of misses the whole point of the competition. An accurate metaphor would be a person on a motorcycle competing against another person on a motorcycle.
- sixstringtheory 7y agoOr rather, two people showing up to a footrace with motorcycles. It sounds a bit silly to call it a footrace at that point. Nothing wrong with motorcycle racing, but gotta be honest about it.
- CrazyStat 7y ago> Won't the winner be the one who just takes AlphaGo's recommended move every time without changing anything? Based on what we've seen in a couple decades of computer-aided chess, no. A good chess player using a top-rated engine to help them can pretty consistently beat the engine by itself. There are tournaments and even a world championship in computer-aided (correspondence) chess and you don't come close to winning by just taking the program's recommended move every time.