8 ms·
Atom editor still phones home prior to consent dialog
- blakesterz 7y agoThe answer given is, in part: "Atom is designed to run in an internet connected environment, doing things such as checking for updates (your first dialog) without prompting the user." The problem with that, as I see it at least is, "doing things such as..." If it said "It's ONLY checking for updates", that seems fine, but "doing things such as..." could be literally anything, and maybe some of those things are things that many people don't want done without consent.
- sneak 7y agoChecking for updates sends a packet out of your computer that contains your IP address, happens at a given point in time (timestamp), contains 'atom.io' in the TLS SNI, and is accessible to your ISP, their network providers, the national intelligence agencies that monitor those connections, Amazon network administrators, Microsoft systems administrators, and GitHub systems administrators. It's telemetry because it happens whenever you open your editor, and it includes your IP, which in the hands of some of those recipients (i.e. intel agencies, your ISP, and Amazon) means your exact physical location (because you ordered paper towels to your street address using that IP two hours ago). It can never be anonymous because it has to have a source IP on it, and even if the TLS connection is zero data, the fact that it has "atom.io" in the SNI field means that it's a data leak of the "person at 123 main street opened their text editor (Atom) at 1:23PM", and it leaks that information to a lot of people. "only checking for updates" is, unfortunately, a form of telemetry, and must be gated on a user's explicit consent to telemetry, otherwise it (no hyperbole) sends an activity event that becomes available to thousands of people against the wishes of the user. Remember when librarians got all up in arms about warrantless collection of what books you've taken out of the library? That was per-user. This is bulk collection, and is way more invasive: it has second-granularity timestamps. PS: Thank you, Edward Snowden.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mobjack 7y agoAlmost any other network request puts you at more risk than this. If that is your concern, then you are better off turning off your Internet. If they were really trying to track you, there would also be an unique ID with the request as that makes it much easier to identify you. IP addresses alone are not as useful for those purposes.
- sneak 7y agoThat's fine; however opening my text editor (Atom), or running a static site generator (Gatsby), or burning an iso file to a USB drive (Etcher) is not a network request, and should not put me at risk.
- fortran77 7y agoI don't understand why Microsoft / Github doesn't get rid of Atom. It serves no purpose with Visual Studio Code around.
- ryanolsonx 7y agoYou can't just "get rid" of FOSS software. It'll live on. :)
- jonny383 7y agohttps://thenextweb.com/dd/2018/06/08/githubs-new-ceo-promises-to-save-atom-post-microsoft-acquisition/ https://thenextweb.com/dd/2018/06/08/githubs-new-ceo-promise...
- ansonhoyt 7y agoI'm still nervous that Atom fades away, despite the promises and good intentions of continuing to develop it. I'm nervous because... Commits have dropped since mid-year: https://github.com/atom/atom/graphs/commit-activity https://github.com/atom/atom/graphs/commit-activity No blog posts since mid-year: https://blog.atom.io/ https://blog.atom.io/ I love Atom, so am hoping it gets rolling again soon.
- kiaulen 7y agoFrom the community manager, on the atom slack: > Lee Dohm: @aviatesk This is a temporary status. Atom’s pace of development has always fluctuated over time as developers join and leave the project, take parental leave, have vacations, etc. Reference: https://atomio.slack.com/archives/C044E54H0/p1570033670104600 https://atomio.slack.com/archives/C044E54H0/p157003367010460...
- kiaulen 7y agoStrongly disagree. To implement something simple in VS Code, you have to write an entire package, or put out a PR to one. To implement something simple in atom, you open up your init script. To change a bit of css in code, you have to write an entirely new UI theme. To change a bit of css in atom, you open up your stylesheet. Vim mode plus is significantly better than VSCodeVim, both performance and feature wise. I will freely admit that VS Code has better IDE features (especially out of the box) than atom does (built in terminal, better autocomplete, better LSP support). But to say that VS Code somehow obsoletes Atom is misguided. Atom is exactly what it bills itself as: A hackable editor built by github.
- urthen 7y agoIt performs an auto-update check. You know it's just performing an auto-update check. While there's not no argument to be made here, it's not like it's secretly collecting a bunch of data and reporting it before letting you opt out. The paranoid, accusatory tone in the issue does nothing to help your argument, and I believe makes it harder for maintainers to take you seriously. Your argument is well thought out, and I don't necessarily disagree with it in principle, but you're making mountains out of molehills here. If you'd simply pointed out the issue and asked that the auto-update check be performed after the consent check - especially if it came with a PR implementing that - you'd go a lot further.
- sneak 7y ago> You know it's just performing an auto-update check Actually, I don't. I didn't agree to let it phone home. It does it before it tells me anything at all. It's also connecting to the telemetry service endpoint immediately on launch, despite not having selected a telemetry consent setting yet. How about this one? It phones home when you click "don't phone home". https://github.com/atom/atom/issues/20185 https://github.com/atom/atom/issues/20185
- urthen 7y agoDon't use Atom then? Seems pretty obvious if you care that much. I respect your privacy views and even share many/most of them (if not so strictly), and appreciate that you are probably just trying to bring this to people's attention. However, you are not the king of open source, and you cannot dictate how other authors must write their projects. It's an open source product written by a for-profit company. There's always going to be trade-offs.
- sneak 7y ago> However, you are not the king of open source, and you cannot dictate how other authors must write their projects No, but I can convince other people who don't like their computers being used a spying tools against them to put social pressure on maintainers so that they stop doing this nonsense. Atom's telemetry used to be on by default; spying silently caused them such a shitstorm that they added a consent dialog. They're almost there! Now they just have to make it functional. https://github.com/atom/atom/pull/12281 https://github.com/atom/atom/pull/12281 There are precedents. We can push back, especially against open source projects. > There's always going to be trade-offs. I don't think that's how software works. I certainly don't take that to mean that I should just accept that it's going to spy on me. I don't want that, and I don't accept that, and I will yell, loudly, at anyone who says I should accept that without a fight.
- McTossOut 7y agoIn other news atom editor sucks and people who use it are hacks.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- robomartin 7y agoWhat a number of comments in this thread miss is that in certain business environments you cannot use software that calls home, regardless of the reasons for the call. Before someone says "it's open source, you can modify it", please understand that very few users of FOSS have the time and necessary knowledge to audit every single piece of code they install on their machines for compliance with company security and privacy requirements. It is my personal belief that the correct stance in these cases is one that places privacy and security at the top of the stack. In other words, nothing calls home unless the user enables it. You are not entitled to initiate any such communications without user approval just because you wrote software people decide to use. That's intrusive and entitled. It's wrong. Disclose it and obtain their permission, and then it's OK. Atom is cool, I like it.
- kelnos 7y agoIn those restrictive business environments, the IT admins have a couple options: they can whitelist outgoing connections they've allowed and block everything else, and they can disallow users from installing anything but approved apps. A business that says "you can't use software that calls" home is going to completely fail at enforcing that unless they implement technical restrictions that preclude it from happening in the first place.
- tschellenbach 7y agoIf you feel strongly about a feature request on an open source project.... you know maybe actually do the work and not just wine about it? This is why people stop doing open source, these type of people with their weird feeling of entitlement reporting issues.
- dane-pgp 7y agoPlease excuse the format of this reply, but this analogy is the best way I can think of to offer a different perspective to the one you are expressing: "If you feel strongly about human rights violations in a democratic country.... you know maybe actually run for elected office and not just wine about it? This is why people stop becoming political candidates, these type of people with their weird feeling of entitlement exercising their right to free speech." To be clear, my point isn't that we should solve all data collection problems with legislation (although that might be beneficial in some cases) or that automatically checking for software updates is necessarily a human rights violation. My point is that it's unreasonable to expect everyone who cares about any feature request to write software to satisfy their needs, especially if the upstream developers would refuse their patches. It's even more unreasonable to demand that people who care about certain issues never try to raise awareness of those issues with other people who might be affected or might be able to do something about the problem.
- sneak 7y agoRemember also that I'm asking for tracking code to be removed, not added.
- blub 7y agoYou seem to be confused. Atom is developed by a for-profit company which is owned by the for-profit megacorp Microsoft. For them open source is a PR move and an employee retention measure, they just don't give a fuck if anyone is helping them out... at most they want to have contributors to help with PR and retention.
- undecisive 7y agoYou are asking for open source developers to make the business decision on Microsoft's behalf? Also, someone HAS already worked on it, and marked it as done. They have failed that ticket's stated goals, either because it did not align with business objectives, or because of an oversight. Nobody (afaik) has asked this person to take over and do the job properly, or even consult on a better flow. The response has been "You are wrong. It doesn't matter. Don't worry about it. Trust us. Stop using atom" You can argue that if you aren't paying for the product, then you are the product... and therefore have no entitlement. That's a viewpoint I guess - but one very much at odds with the perceived values of the open source community.
- m3kw9 7y agoCould be some 3rd party libs doing that behind its back
- damm 7y agoAtom messes up my graphics driver on Linux; so it isn't installed any more. Example: When i launch atom everything else in KDE disappears I can't see any other apps until I tab over to them. Moving the window in focus fixes it so the screen is back to normal until I launch a new application. Quitting X and restarting it is the only thing that fixes it. I liked Atom but like textmate it got forgotten and it will get harder to use over time
- SahAssar 7y agoThat sounds like a bug in either XWayland/X or chromium rather than atom directly. Does the same happen with other electron/chromium apps?
- jmull 7y agoIt’s a little baffling the Atom team can’t seem to understand this is a bug. I get that the tone of the report is a little off-putting, but a bug is a bug. Fix it and move on.
- sneak 7y agoThey don't want to understand it, because understanding it would mean that a big chunk of their userbase could download and use the software, see the opt-out panel, opt out (because really, who wants to be spied on?), and they would receive no information whatsoever about it. That's what they're trying to avoid. It's not about the user convenience benefits of autoupdate, it's about their metrics panel and the "success" it implies going dark/trending down.
- BurnGpuBurn 7y agoWhich raises the question: Is Atom a true open source project or a Microsoft business venture masquerading as an open source project? I've had similar discussions about Mono.
- sneak 7y agoYou don’t get to gatekeep “open source project” on business venture or not. If it has a free software license and the code is provided, it is a true open source project. Simply being an “open source project”, however, unfortunately, does not mean that the maintainers are going to act ethically or not produce software that abuses people’s human rights.
- awinter-py 7y agoI love this thread. Every important question for privacy-conscious power users is raised in here: are automatic updates safe, how should software obtain consent to act on your behalf, how can power users keep up with the arms race of privacy settings, is phone-home inherently sleazy. This user is running a firewall / connection observer (little snitch) -- as more people adopt tools like that + ad blockers, and as businesses figure out whether and how to serve those users, the norms for this stuff will get worked out. For now, businesses benefit tremendously from surveillance for both sleazy and non-sleazy reasons and are totally incentivized to understate the potential harms and the ways in which they use what they collect.
- f0ez 7y agoEveryone should just stop using atom, I found the way they responded to the issue very condescending. "You are certainly free to block the network access and Atom will work in an offline mode if that is your preference, if that is not what you desire though there are plenty of other editors out there that may fit your needs better." No one asked them if they are free to block network access or if they are free to use other editors.
- jve 7y agoCan autoupdate be considered as telemetry? Secondly. Atom download page (https://atom.io/ https://atom.io/) contains text (well, someone may not even notice it, that's another issue): > By downloading, you agree to the Terms and Conditions. It says: > Auto-Update Services > The Software may include an auto-update service ("Service"). If you choose to use the Service or you download Software that automatically enables the Service, GitHub will automatically update the Software when a new version is available Moreover: > Privacy > The Software may collect personal information. You may control what information the Software collects in the settings panel. If the Software does collect personal information on GitHub's behalf, GitHub will process that information in accordance with the GitHub Privacy Statement. People don't read the TOS and complain.
- chownie 7y agoI'm not sure it's reasonable to expect users to read the ToS to find out whether their text editor will phone home. This also doesn't excuse the editor sending analytics for users who opt out of analytics.
- jve 7y agoThis is EXACTLY what I expect to find out in TOS. Along with how they use and with whom they share the data (privacy policy). TOS actually is stronger than preferences. If TOS doesn't state that I can opt out, I don't expect that I'm opted out of everything, even when I set such preferences in software. And that they can introduce some phoning home at will, as long as they comply with their TOS.
- chownie 7y agoThat answers a different question, whether you expect that content to be in the ToS or not isn't relevant. I asked whether it's reasonable to expect users to search the ToS to understand the behaviour of their editor. I don't think it is reasonable, the language complexity expressed in a ToS is vastly different to anything written that's really intended for users to read. People with chronic illnesses experience brain fog and may not find it easy to read a document like a ToS, the elderly, young and those who use english as a second language are also more likely to have issues parsing one. Even despite that point the software is currently in violation of its own terms of service. If it sends telemetry before you can open the settings panel then clearly you cannot "control what information the Software collects in the settings panel", as the preceding telemetry message can't be prevented.
- nielsbot 7y agoI don't see why they can't just show an "Allow Atom to check for updates?" on startup, just like so many other apps I've used.
- owaislone 7y agoSomewhat unrelated but why dos Atom even exist anymore? MS should just fold the Atom team into VSCode and go full in on VSCode. From Microsoft's perspective, I don' see any reason for Atom to exist. It's not like Chromium vs Chrome where Google wants to ship an open-source project with some important proprietary bits and pieces.
- kiaulen 7y agoWhy does vim exist anymore? Neovim exists and has more and newer features. We should just get rid of vim, and have Bram focus all his efforts on nvim instead. Some of us don't like VS Code (for lots of reasons) but do like Atom. From Microsoft's perspective, they just bought a golden goose (GitHub) that can bring them a lot of developer goodwill. If they kill off that golden goose, they lose all the goodwill they just bought. Atom is a part of what GitHub stands for. It's a hackable editor for the 21st century. And when you're one of the richest companies on earth, you can afford to pay a few developers' salaries for a lot of goodwill.