6 ms·
I have two high school age sons. They attend the same school. I bought graphing calculators for both. One told me Casio was ok. The other said the school requir
by dboreham 7y ago
I have two high school age sons. They attend the same school. I bought graphing calculators for both. One told me Casio was ok. The other said the school requires TI. Go figure..
Software emulations on smart phone are not permitted due to school rules about mobile device use in class. Also they aren't allowed for tests due to the potential for cheating. Of course you can cheat by storing extra info in a graphing calculator but they don't seem to have thought of that..
- dwohnitmok 7y agoThis is what I meant by a dedicated emulator. That is the hardware is locked down to do absolutely nothing else except emulate a TI. The only reason to use an emulator is to save on dev work. A company providing this would still need to get it certified etc to get schools on board presumably.
- notjesse 7y agoI remember my math teacher used to come around and take everyone’s batteries out at the start of an exam to clear the RAM. Little did she know you can just save the notes in ROM that persists power cutoff.
- StillBored 7y agoWell, I'm pretty sure the teachers don't actually understand 1/2 the functionality of most of these calculators even without the model variations. Even the non CAS models can solve a lot of programs numerically which in my mind creates a lot of confusion about what people gain with simple programs. Particularly as even without a built in root/etc finder, things like newton's method (or any numerical/recursive algo) can be used on the main calculation screen by using the previous result variable in equations and holding down the enter/repeat key until it converges or you get enough precision. Most of them also have a constants list that includes pretty much every constant your going to use in science/engineering/etc school. So I remember seeing some of my classmates programs for various classes and calculators (HP 84s/various other TIs), and I never remember wanting any of them because I knew how to solve the exact same problem with the built in functionality on my TI-85.
- pflats 7y agoMany of us do, but resetting the ROM will also wipe out all of the pre-installed "flash" apps that a colleague might want to use. It's a trade-off. edit: or at least, it used to. Haven't tested in years.
- oefrha 7y agoBack when (and where) I grew up calculators were hardly ever used in math classes and completely forbidden in exams. I later went the IMO route and obtained a degree in mathematics; neither required a calculator. I still fail to understand why the hell graphing calculators are required for some high school math curriculum.
- gtk40 7y agoStatistics is taking a larger and larger part in many math curricula and is quite aided by the use of a graphing calculator. The AP Stats coursework and exam also assumes you will have one.
- oefrha 7y agoTo learn and demonstrate understanding of statistical concepts, no calculator is required. In fact calculating and graphing by hand are great for learning. To bridge the gap to the real world, a computer, however crappy, with Excel installed, however outdated, is infinitely better. (Not that I endorse Excel, it’s just the most common tool among the general public.) I happen to be a physicist too and while I’m not an experimentalist, I’ve been through plenty of experimental training, and have participated in real world data analysis projects. Never once have I seen any physicist doing any statistics with a graphing calculator (I did see a few when I taught undergrads mostly from other departments, so there’s that).
- pietroglyph 7y agoPerhaps you can learn without a calculator, but these timed statistics tests do not function without one. Do you really expect people to do repetitive operations on even n=10 datasets when they only have an hour? You can’t use Excel (because it’s on more capable PC that you can use to cheat). At the end of the day, if you want to remove the calculator from the statistics classroom you probably also have to remove the standardized test.
- pjmlp 7y ago