5 ms·
West Virginia Inmates Will Be Charged by the Minute to Read E-Books on Tablets
- larnmar 7y agoIn my view, prisoners should have access to (more or less) all the books they want, all the movies they want, all the games they want, and all the video calls home they want, all delivered to the comfort of their own private cell. Balancing this, prisoners should have no interaction with other prisoners — your human interaction comes through the video chat or through your appointments with guards, prison therapists, and so forth. Basically, imagine a dull weekend spent entirely inside your hotel room; now imagine it lasts a lot longer. The room is big enough to exercise in, it has natural light, maybe a caged balcony to get fresh air — it’s just like a hotel except everything is bolted down and you’re not allowed to leave. Preventing interaction between prisoners solves most prison problems, and also enables the number of guards to be massively reduced, compensating for the extra cost of the larger cells and all the entertainment stuff.
- CamperBob2 7y agoOne problem with this position is that for some people, it'd be like throwing Brer Rabbit into the proverbial briar patch (if not the carrot patch). If plenty of people choose to live like this voluntarily, is it still punishment?
- schwartzie 7y agoWhile this might have the effect of symptomatically addressing visible prison problems like fights, it would only further exacerbate some of the worst soft problems like the overall inhumanity of incarceration, and its emphasis on punishment instead of rehabilitation.
- hackinthebochs 7y agoIf I were incarcerated, the forced interaction with other prisoners would be the biggest punishment. Include read-only internet access and I could carve out a meaningful existence in the environment described by the parent comment.
- burgerzzz 7y agoWhat's the humane response to an individual that continually commits serious/violent crimes?
- Cougher 7y agoThe loss of the most basic of human rights: liberty. But your chosen goalpost is noted.
- imtringued 7y agoThe real problem is that they are losing more than just their liberty.
- imtringued 7y agoYeah just have a partnership with Skill Share and Science Journals and other companies to host only content that has been approved specifically for prisons. I can't wait to see the future wave of hermit-like self taught scientists who spent 20 years doing nothing but theoretical physics.
- deogeo 7y ago> provided by private contractors like GTL and JPay. How convenient the parasites involved can present themselves with discreet pseudonyms such as GTL, instead of using their legal names and addresses.
- wolfgke 7y agoThen let us fill up the internet with their legal names and addresses.
- mc32 7y agoUnless they have alternative access to paper books, I don’t see how this does not violate their 1A right to books.
- jmpman 7y agoPrisoners have the right against cruel and unusual punishment. They certainly aren’t protected by the 4th amendment. Do they have 1st amendment rights?
- mc32 7y agoCruel and unusual is a thing that gets interpreted and re interpreted. The 1A is pretty unambiguous. I believe they enjoy a subset of 1A rights, though not all as felons lose some rights.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> I don’t see how this does not violate their 1A right to books There’s a First Amendment right to books in prison? (Genuine question.)
- mc32 7y agoYyyyy-es? I mean they have the right to read books and other materials[1, 2] (whether the prison is required to furnish them is a different question). But generally, I believe yes, prisoners have a limited right to the 1A in prison. There are some restrictions for security purposes as well as they lose some rights (like right to vote) if they are felons. [1]https://ncac.org/news/books-behind-bars-the-right-to-read-in-prison https://ncac.org/news/books-behind-bars-the-right-to-read-in... [2]https://jailhouselaw.org/your-first-amendment-right-to-freedom-of-speech-and-association/ https://jailhouselaw.org/your-first-amendment-right-to-freed...
- Scoundreller 7y agoMeanwhile in Canada, you can still vote while you’re in prison.
- crb002 7y agoThey do this at the Polk County Iowa jail.
- nahtan 7y agoThe US truly has not spent enough effort growing out of its slave economy that has defined so much of its existence.
- RenRav 7y agoThese are private prisons right? They just exist to make money anyway so this isn't surprising.
- anm89 7y ago> In a statement to Reason, a WVDCR spokesperson noted that no inmates are being forced to use the tablets. Yeah but they are locking them in a room for extended periods with nothing else to do. They are only not being forced to do it by a technicality.
- smabie 7y agoI don’t think that providing these things is problematic in itself (though the crony capitalism is worrying). The problem is that many prisons no longer allow book donations or free access to book. In my opinion, categorically, providing more chance cannot be wrong. The problem is when choice is removed (in this case, reading paper books). The problem is that the state isn’t willing to invest money in making prisons better. This stems from the unclear nature of what prisons are for: a debt paid to society, justice, rehabilitation, or maybe to prevent further crimes? If your answer is justice or debt, then you can make good arguments why prisons shouldn’t be nice. If you think they’re for rehabilitation or prevention of crime, then tablets, TVs, etc are probably a good idea. Since we don’t all agree on the moral justification for inprisonment, the state just provides the most basic services. This means that only companies are going to provide these services, which are arguably predatory. Prison is a hard thing to get right, no matter what you do some people are going to get upset. Regardless, I think most of us can agree that these contracts handed out by states to these companies are problematic and stink of cronyism. Probably the only reason these contracts got signed was that the prisons were netting a percentage of the sales, allowing them to increase salaries and stuff: in essence, an indirect bribe for state employees. In return, the state probably agreed to ban books.
- Wh1skey 7y agoThe story of Rome’s fall is both complicated and relatively straightforward yet it eerily resembles America: The state became too big and chaotic; the influence of money and private interests corrupted public institutions; and social and economic inequalities became so large that citizens lost faith in the system altogether and gradually fell into the arms of tyrants and demagogues. If all of that sounds familiar, well, that’s because the parallels to our current political moment are striking. Edward Watts, a historian at the University of California San Diego, has just published a new book titled Mortal Republic that carefully lays out what went wrong in ancient Rome — and how the lessons of its decline might help save fledgling republics like the United States today.