4 ms·
Google did this to themselves when they invited and fostered this culture. It had its naive merits. But like many such attempts, what happens is these groups
by mc32 7y ago
Google did this to themselves when they invited and fostered this culture. It had its naive merits.
But like many such attempts, what happens is these groups with good intentions get coöpted and controlled by others with bigger agendas-agendas which often are not in alignment with leadership.
When the PLA got too strong Mao devised the Red Guards. He didn’t want another Menshevik - Bolshevik-like episode.
Nor do companies.
It’s one thing to let people “have a say” in constructing their workplace atmosphere; to make it coöperative, inclusive etc., things which align with productivity— it’s another to interfere with the economics of the company.
- crb002 7y agoI bet several Google employees object to working on military/govt force projects. Enough jobs to go around.
- mc32 7y agoThere probably are. They tend to be idealists who if it ever came time for them to set rules in their newly formed society would lean on the same instincts to keep people who disagree with them out when realpolitik emerges.
- Daishiman 7y agoYou can't have it both ways by using "don't be evil" as your mantra for a decade and then disregarding everything when it is no longer convenient.
- mc32 7y agoI think they really meant it. It was the antithesis to the Microsoft of the early aughts. But now they have other, broader goals to work for. Arguably they have become more borg-ish than MS of the 00's. But they’ve come to realize that at a certain point in size idealism doesn’t scale (coöperatives, hippie communes, etc) and others will eat your lunch if you encumber yourself with idealism (which can also go in the negative direction (when idealists find conflict amongst themselves and a loser is defined).
- taurath 7y ago> others will eat your lunch Thats not what would happen to Google. What it would mean is Google has a slightly slower path to being a trillion dollar company.
- Apocryphon 7y agoSort of like how Jobs founded Apple as the antithesis is IBM, at least that’s how the origin story goes, and now they’re arguably closer to the latter than their original incarnation.
- the_biot 7y agoNo, Jobs didn't "found Apple as the antithesis of IBM". Woz and Jobs started Apple because Woz wouldn't/couldn't be bothered with all the sales/admin etc involved in running a company. All the rest is Jobs BS.
- tristram_shandy 7y ago>It’s one thing to let people “have a say” in constructing their workplace atmosphere; to make it coöperative, inclusive etc., things which align with productivity— it’s another to interfere with the economics of the company. At one time, an activist employee insisted that blacks could work a lathe just as well as the white employees. An activist employee insisted that children should not be shovelling coal. An activist employee might insist that a woman could manage an engineering team. All of the hard-won victories of labor were controversial, and yes, they all absolutely interfered with "productivity" and the economics of the company, itself a term so vague it encompasses everything. Perhaps what you mean to say is that any further social progress beyond the milieu of 2011 is 'unproductive'; which appears to expose your conflation of 'productivity' with morality. So, to subscribers of this worldview diversity is good because it increases productivity, inclusivity is good because it increases productivity, and so forth. Absolutely nothing to do with equality, human rights, dignity, or other idealisms. Of course these same people would have argued against diversity and inclusion in previous eras and claimed that it would be unproductive, but let's pretend your fascism isn't on your sleeve and visible to everyone. Are you only treating people well because you think it increases productivity? What would you do to people if it would increase productivity and the bottom line? It's rhetorical, of course. These activist employees were trying to prevent Google from helping the government stick Hispanic children in cages. That's apparently too radical for modern 'liberal' capitalists of 2019, eh?
- zaksoup 7y agoYour points are great and valid but isn't it even simpler to point out the flaw in OPs argument: if the end-all and be-all is the economics of the company then they should surely be fine going in to work tomorrow and offering their boss a 20% pay cut to help contribute to the economics of the company...
- takeda 7y agoGoogle is where it is now, because they started as good guys. Everyone loved them because they were fixing problems, but they started to change since they became pubic and quarterly earnings became important.
- PeterStuer 7y agoActually Google is where it is now because they were the first to build a search engine that did not trust the webmaster and therefore succeeding where competitors were sucombing to the first scirmishes in the eternal SEO war.
- lggdn 7y agoI don't think google was naive. They did this intentionally and while it worked, they were willing to go with it. Now it doesn't work, so they are stamping it down. I wouldn't use the term "naive" when describing Page, Brin and especially Schmidt or google in general. Also, whether Google's motto was "Don't be evil" or "Be evil", "agenda" was going to affect their company from within/internal or without/external. Also, anyone else find it strange that every post that has nothing to do with china has a comment that somehow tries to tie the story to china? I get that a lot of propaganda vis a vis china is being pushed due to the trade war, but being so obvious doesn't help anything.
- 0x262d 7y agolol this is absurd, they're fighting against rampant sexual harassment and a variety of other real workplace problems, not being mind controlled by nefarious bolsheviks
- 0x262d 7y agoalso, the core problem is that treating workers well is not in "alignment with leadership"
- 0x262d 7y agohonestly using diaeresis (things that look like umlauts) while typing stuff out about how people who don't want to work for an evil company are being controlled by other forces just gives off the biggest wannabe top hat monopoly capitalist vibe imaginable.
- casefields 7y agoMore like just following the New Yorker style guide, which are decidedly not top hat monopoly capitalists: https://www.newyorker.com/culture/culture-desk/the-curse-of-the-diaeresis https://www.newyorker.com/culture/culture-desk/the-curse-of-...
- 0x262d 7y agothe new yorker is the most prominent top hat aesthetic organization in the world. just look at their icon. andwhile they are often nominally opposed to monopoly they're a thoroughly capitalist news organization that is privately owned by a selection of the superwealthy.
- aaron695 7y ago> rampant sexual harassment Sounds like something straight from the Bolsheviks in an attempt to take down a larger entity purely for control. The concept Google is worse than general society is out there. Try looking at the real world, of transport or construction or the service industry or cleaning or food harvesting. Pretty much anywhere but the industry of IT of which Google is exemplary.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]