6 ms·
None of these are the actual hard problems in cryptocurrency and the fact this is the focus speaks volumes. The real hard problems are: 1. How do we stop using
by arcticbull 7y ago
None of these are the actual hard problems in cryptocurrency and the fact this is the focus speaks volumes. The real hard problems are:
1. How do we stop using more power than Switzerland to process 4 transactions per second (lol)
2. How do we stop payments to international terrorists and rogue states.
3. How do we stop money laundering.
4. How do we stop price manipulation by fraudulent actors.
5. How do we allow people who lost access to their money by negligence, fraud, theft, act of god or otherwise, access to their money again.
[bonus] how do we generate the right quantity of new cryptocurrency so that the pace of money growth matches that of economic and population growth so as not to disproportionately reward early comers just for “being early”?
You know, the “currency” problems and not the “crypto” problems. These are the actual hard problems of cryptocurrency and until solved it will never, and I mean never, reach mass adoption, making the questions from the article totally irrelevant.
- ralfd 7y ago> How do we stop money laundering If that would be stopped, crypto would be pointless. We already have real (regulated) money. But with crypto you can online pay your drug dealer.
- arcticbull 7y agoFunny you can online pay your drug dealer in countries where drugs are legal, like pot in Canada. It’s almost like social solutions are the right way to solve social problems.
- mhluongo 7y agoYou don't think cryptocurrency is a social solution? To your implication- what's legal and what's right are orthogonal concerns. Individuals decide which to follow based on their own principles.
- arcticbull 7y agoNo, it’s a technological problem. The social solution is to make what you’re trying to do legal. And yeah you’re free to do whatever you want so long as you’re willing to pay the consequences such as fines and jail time.
- mhluongo 7y agoWriting code collaboratively and convincing thousands of people to run nodes replicating your slow database is a social act -- I'd even call it a political act. Not sure why you think technology is outside the context of our society. This stuff isn't built by elves.
- arcticbull 7y agoI mean sure, to an extent everything involves society. However, what I'm suggesting is that instead of tackling the problem at hand (that you want drugs to be legal) you're suggesting creating tools that make funding anything impossible to stop. You're not solving the actual problem by going out and convincing society you're right (and you are, the Portuguese model shows that full decriminalization and even legalization lead to much better outcomes and no material increase in usage). You're convincing people to deploy magic bean producing power wasters that just happen to let you buy drugs. It doesn't help mitigate or undo the harm foisted upon the millions in US prisons who got there because they wanted drugs. It doesn't help bring about the downfall of the cartels. If anything, it props those things up. > Writing code collaboratively and convincing thousands of people to run nodes replicating your slow database is a social act -- I'd even call it a political act. Yes, in and of itself it is. The social act is deploying a slow database, which in turn provides technological workarounds to the actual social issues (like drug policy) that should be tackled head-on.
- shawnz 7y agoSo then should we forget about easily accessible encryption, since it's a social problem if your government spies on your data and not a technological one? That's not a very "defense in depth" approach. Our democracy is purposely designed to allow such checks and balances through mechanisms like the fifth amendment. It is an important part of what makes our democracy strong and prevents lawmakers from throwing people in prison at their whim.
- arcticbull 7y agoCryptography is a tool that enables applications. Cryptocurrency is an application of cryptography. While I don't believe this myself, I could see a logically consistent case for supporting the development of ciphers and banning something like TrueCrypt. It's not about the technology, it's about how you choose to use it.
- emsimot 7y ago1. I don't know if it will work, but the idea is Proof of Stake (ETH2 in Ethereum-land) 2. You can't -- this is a cultural problem, not a technological one 3. There's no such thing as money laundering 4. Peer-to-peer, transparent finance infrastructure 5. User-money as a layer on top of cryptocurrency
- arcticbull 7y ago> 1. Proof of stake. This has yet to be proven, and as you say, there’s reasons why it has yet to land. I give this one vitaliks sideways smiley face. > 2. You can't -- this is a cultural problem, not a technological one Uh, one that doesn’t exist in the current financial system. I’m sure y’all will find a way. As I said, it’s a prerequisite. > 3. There’s no such thing as money laundering. Hilarious. I see someone never took compliance training at work. With that attitude I’d love to see you explain your position to a judge. Money laundering is literally financial transactions arranged in such a way as to conceal the original source of funds. > 4. Buzzword soup. > 5. More buzzword soup. More buzzword soup that immediately falls down as once you use crypto as only a bulk transport instrument you’ve lost out on all its ostensible benefits. No transparency, no security, it’s no better than just using a wire transfer.
- realusername 7y ago> Uh, one that doesn’t exist in the current financial system. I’m sure y’all will find a way. As I said, it’s a prerequisite. Is that sarcasm? How do you think criminal groups get funded? They use the financial system like anybody else. You should have a look into the history of HSBC, money laundering and financing drug cartels is one of their main specialty.
- weego 7y agoHilarious. I see someone never took compliance training at work. With that attitude I’d love to see you explain your position to a judge. Money laundering is literally financial transactions arranged in such a way as to conceal the original source of funds. I though anonymity and legal safeharbour were founding principles of cryptocurrency? The original comment is correct that what we call money laundering is an artificial construct of power.
- mhluongo 7y ago> How do we stop money laundering. Hm, so the dollar won't reach wide adoption until we close Wells Fargo, HSBC, and other major banks that have been party to large-scale money laundering?
- arcticbull 7y agoLuckily there are efforts being made to stop it, and fines paid and systems put in place. Are they perfect yet? No. It is still orders of magnitude better than pretending the problem doesnt exist or outwardly encouraging and abetting it.
- mhluongo 7y agoThose banks are all still in business after billions in proven conspiracies to launder money. You might want to consider why that is.
- afiori 7y agoThose banks have such a bad record in a system with strict regulations to stop money laundering. I can only imagine that with less controls and regulations they would behave even worse.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- hannasanarion 7y agoBecause once those conspiracies are discovered, the people involved are banned from banking. Can you ban people from bitcoin?
- wolco 7y agoWe are very lucky indeed
- DirkNowitzki 7y agoI work in banking. AML is always a fine line. Don’t do your job well, you get hit for enabling laundering. Do your job too well and you kill millions/billions in deposits. AML at its core is asking a bank to purposefully reduce their profit. Other than fines and morals, there’s no real incentive for them to give their all, and those don’t seem to bother most of the industry.
- qqii 7y agoOraces and a reputation system can attempt to solve these "currency" problems, in the same way that they are solved with real currency.
- Hendrikto 7y ago> 2. How do we stop payments to international terrorists and rogue states. > 3. How do we stop money laundering. No currency ever achieved that.
- wolco 7y agoThese aren't problems but one of the many reasons why people use cryto. You are looking for some power to control cryto but still offer everything it currently does. It can't.. "How do we stop payments to international terrorists and rogue states".. Most of their wealth comes from cash/diamonds/oil/grain.. why would cryto be any different?
- rmtech 7y ago> 2. How do we stop payments to international terrorists and rogue states. We should definitely build a technical system that stops payments to terrorists but allows payments to freedom fighters; that stops payments to rogue states but allows payments to states that stand up to bullying by tyrannical regional powers. /s Seriously I think these kinds of questions need un-asking rather than answering.
- vogre 7y agoThe one's freedom fighter is somebody else's terrorist, so it's not an answer.
- williamdclt 7y agoThat was exactly the point
- acdha 7y ago> Seriously I think these kinds of questions need un-asking rather than answering. That’s equivalent to conceding that the concept cannot work and giving up. No matter your personal views on a particular issue, this is really just asking how to comply with legal obligations: governments don’t care if your system is broken by design and makes compliance hard, and that’ll deter most legitimate users.
- rmtech 7y agoBy pretty much the same argument strong encryption cannot work because governments would prefer it not to exist; terrorists and rogue states can use encryption, and it is not technically possible to build encryption that "only works for the good guys". In reality there is an ongoing battle over encryption where various governments try to ban it, people fight back, etc. I suspect that we will see the same thing play out over cryptocurrency. In any case I don't see anyone on hacker news asking how we can design an encryption algorithm that prevents all and only the bad uses of encryption. It is generally understood to be a dumb question because good and bad are complicated enough that we cannot hope to formalize them right now, and ad-hoc attempts to make a technology only work for the good guys have been repeatedly shown to help the bad guys (e.g. backdoors etc)
- rmtech 7y ago> You know, the “currency” problems and not the “crypto” problems. You seem to be looking for fiat currency, that already exists. The point of cryptocurrency is that not everyone wants fiat, some people place more of a priority on certain things and less on certain other things.
- hannasanarion 7y agoI don't think you know what the word "fiat" means. Crypto is fiat currency. It's backed by nothing but wasted electricity and a lucky guess. You can't trade it in for anything of value.
- rmtech 7y agoI do know what fiat means, and my meaning in this context is government-issued fiat such as dollars, pounds, euros, etc, though I think that was pretty clear to everyone else!
- hanniabu 7y agoGold is backed by nothing but scarcity, high energy costs to mine it, and utility. That's no different than ethereum.
- arcticbull 7y agoExcept the scarcity of digital assets is all pretend, since you can just fork Ethereum and make your own. You can't fork gold.
- jki275 7y agoThese are arguably features not bugs. Except for your 1. which has already been solved by multiple POS cryptocurrencies.
- golergka 7y agoThose are features, not bugs.
- jstanley 7y agoPoints 2, 3, and 5 are essentially "how do we give the government the authority to block or reverse payments even when the sender possesses the relevant private key, or send payments even without the relevant private key". I'm not saying that's not a fine thing to want, but if that is what you want, then you don't want cryptocurrency. Cryptocurrency is purposefully antithetical to that goal.
- Nursie 7y agoAnd as a result will stay irrelevant :/
- jstanley 7y agoThat's like arguing that TLS will stay irrelevant unless it comes with government backdoors. The fact that authority figures can't break it is a feature, for the kind of people who would want to use it in the first place (which should be all of us, but sadly is not yet).
- Nursie 7y ago> The fact that authority figures can't break it is a feature, for the kind of people who would want to use it Like I said, this is why it will stay irrelevant. Most people don't want to perform those actions, nor support those actions by using the systems that do. We're never, as a society, going to want to support money-laundering, terrorist-funding or price manipulation.
- hannasanarion 7y agoChargebacks? Reversing accidental payments? Theft? Fraud? These are all pretty important parts of the currency system, and people aren't going to give them up just for the sake of some nebulous idea of decentralization for decentralization's sake. Do you always log into every machine as root? Do you want everyone to have admin powers on HN and every other social media/chat/forum you use? Authorities exist for a reason.
- 7y ago
- metacritic12 7y agoSerious question, is this list specifically designed to troll crypto? It literally lists the exact items the technology is designed against, with little good faith to recognize the problems crypto is actually solving. An analogous for "Hard Problems for PC Work Processors [vs Pen and Paper]" would be: 1. How to record a single essay without the price a hundred reams of paper? 2. How to function when there is no electrical power whatsoever? And not contribute to rising technological inequality in developing countries. 3. How to allow governments to still do handwriting analysis on printed word docs to thwart bad actors, ransom note writers, etc? 4. How to stop international terrorists and rogue states from printing multiple pieces of propaganda to recruit? 5. How do we allow people a closer sense of connection to the writer of a word processed doc when handwriting is missing. [bonus] how do we ensure jobs are not destroyed in the lumber industry? how do we ensure manufacturing of these so-called PCs to not contribute to environmental destruction / leeching of toxic chemicals if/when they become popular?
- Terretta 7y ago> These are the actual hard problems of cryptocurrency and until solved it will never, and I mean never, reach mass adoption... Let's look at these for cash, which has some level of mass adoption. > 2. How do we stop payments to international terrorists and rogue states. Both of these are amply funded today, so between cash and banking system, this isn't really a thing. Whatever form does work, isn't hampering adoption. > 3. How do we stop money laundering. (a) This is an invented problem. Just because it's propagandized in compliance training doesn't make it real, and it's unfortunate banks are having to spend time and money obliging local governments so politicians can pretend they're having an effect. (b) Neither cash nor banking system succeed at stopping it today, yet both enjoy mass adoption. > 4. How do we stop price manipulation by fraudulent actors. Mass adoption? See pink sheets versus mainstream stocks. Chicken and egg problem, granted. > 5. How do we allow people who lost access to their money by negligence, fraud, theft, act of god or otherwise, access to their money again. A friend once tossed a $100 bill from her birthday into the wood stove with birthday wrapping paper. There was no expectation this form of currency could recover access by negligence, fraud, theft, acts of god, or otherwise, yet she was thrilled to mass-adopt that $100 until it turned into ash. > You know, the “currency” problems and not the “crypto” problems. It doesn't seem as though these are real problems for the adopters of currency. It seems as though they're problems for authorities who wish their jobs were easier.
- zaphar 7y agoA friend once tossed a $100 bill from her birthday into the wood stove with birthday wrapping paper. There was no expectation this form of currency could recover access by negligence, fraud, theft, acts of god, or otherwise, yet she was thrilled to mass-adopt that $100 until it turned into ash. Remove the negligence item and fraud and theft are still there. Banks and other regular institutions have remedies for these and they are an "improvement" for most users in this area. Put that together with the fact that it is far and away easier to lose your cryptocoin holdings than it is to lose cash or money in your bank account and a cryptocoin is in most ways a step backward for consumers. They benefits they tout (Easier to send money to someone else, Proof against government meddling) sound good but the second is why it's a step backward for most people and the first is hampered by the combination long transaction times and the volatility of the coins value. Is it possible that these will all get remedied? Sure. But until you remedy them most people shouldn't be using a cryptocoin unless they can afford to lose what they put in there.
- dblank9 7y ago1. Bitcoin isn't meant to be fast, it's meant to be reliable, and that's what you're paying for. Other chains are a different question. 2. We don't. One man's terrorist is another's freedom fighter. 3. We don't. The system is broken, Bitcoin is a new system. We need to figure out a new way to transact. 4. Maturity of the system will achieve this, just like it did with Wall Street. Or did it? :P 5. Many many solutions. Threshold signatures, regular multisig, mintable cryptos, etc... [bonus] Life is not fair. Early birds always get the worm.
- leppr 7y agoPoints number 7, 8, and 9 in Vitalik's article are about your 1, if you cared to read it. The rest of your points are as you say "currency" and usability problems, problems that a layer above will decide to solve or not. There is a lot of work being done on these points too, but Vitalik and the Ethereum 2.0 research teams are tackling a more low level set of issues. Think of it like Visa, SWIFT, or the internet: those are also technical platforms that need to be engineered and thought about, often in abstraction of other issues like monetary policy and local regulations. Many systems are built that way, where the underlying platform is kept "dumb", and requirements that need highly flexible enforcement (like the selective censorship/cancelation in your examples) are applied a level above, where humans are kept in the loop. There aren't any protocol-level rules in TCP/IP that says network packets containing information about the Tiananmen square protests can't go from US to China, those rules are implemented in Chinese routers. Maybe if you had your say in the design of TCP/IP things would've been different, but this approach has so far proven wildly successful.
- api 7y ago2. The problem is that there are so many terrorists and such. I've become very skeptical of the idea that technology can solve social problems, and unfortunately decades of futility propaganda by the existing order has convinced us that the political order we have now cannot be improved upon. On the flip side this principle also makes me skeptical of cryptocurrency, which seems like a very expensive attempt to use technology to solve social problems. Existing simple money systems work and are highly efficient. Corruption in those systems is a social problem.
- stoops 7y ago2, 3, and 5 are features.