12 ms·
Apple pulls all customer reviews from online Apple Store
- mikece 7y agoDarn! Some of those were pretty funny... though when they contradict the prevailing reviews at Amazon it's obvious that allowing comments on Apple.com just invites the trolls.
- LeoPanthera 7y agoI'm not surprised. Most of them were just bitching about Apple, and not reviewing the product. Most of the reviews of the USB-C dongles were just complaining about USB-C, for example. Useless.
- ignoramous 7y ago> Useless. Isn't it on Apple to assign resources to fix the problem instead of going nuclear on it? Surely, not all reviews are useless? > Most of the reviews of the USB-C dongles were just complaining about USB-C, for example. I've seen this problem with PlayStore too, but Google takes forever to delete the reviews: Even the ones that are unrelated. I wonder why AI isn't employed to weed out or help automate the process of flagging such reviews. May be someone should build it?
- chrisseaton 7y ago> Surely, not all reviews are useless? What am I going to do with the review? If I need a new Apple charger then I need a new Apple charger. I’m not going to read a review and decide not to buy it am I? It’s useless noise.
- bdcravens 7y agoThis assumes only one product that meets your needs.
- bdcravens 7y agoI think it would be very difficult/expensive to build a system that wouldn't be called censorship. (I'm not even sure that would ever be successful, even assuming unlimited talent and budget)
- jlarocco 7y agoIs that really useless, though? If I'm about to drop $3-6k on a laptop, I want to know beforehand that it's going to be a PITA connecting things to it. The fact that lots of people think it's difficult, and that Apple responded to their problems, is also useful to see.
- derefr 7y agoProducts are rated relative to one-another, though, not on any absolute scale (because everyone uses a different personal subjective scale, so all a review or recommendation system can hope to do is to normalize each person's ratings against their own learned model of rating criteria such that the person's lowest score becomes a 1 and their highest a 5.) If people don't like USB-C, they're just going to rate everything Apple makes as a 1.0/5, which, as far as a normalization algorithm is concerned, is the same as rating everything a 5.0/5. It carries no signal and gets completely dropped from the algorithm.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoI don't think anyone has a psychological issue with USB C. What they have is a perfectly legitimate issue with not being able to use their existing peripherals with a supposedly top-of-the-line professional laptop/desktop with an unquestionably professional price. Removing the reviews is PR sterilisation. It's appearance management. It's wilfully turning a deaf ear to any feedback that suggests the Emperor may not be fully clothed. It has absolutely nothing to do with raising the SNR in the store.
- derefr 7y agoLet me be clear; I was mostly talking about ratings re: SNR. Ratings, in a very explicit mathematical sense, become literally undefined when you aren't comparing them between things, but just comparing something to itself. You can't have a vote with one candidate; you can't have an auction with one bidder; etc. The results are all undefined. In the exact same sense, you can't have a ratings system in a marketplace with one product in it. Or, for a direct analogy: you can't have Hot or Not where it's just one dude. Is he hot? Is he not? Undefined. Now, freeform text reviews: sure, they might hold some meaning, even in a single-seller marketplace. (For subtle behavioral-economic reasons, I would hypothesize that they probably don't, but let's pretend they do.) I would posit, though, that whatever's in those reviews is already the result of "PR sterilization." What you're seeing is what Apple wants you to see. It's their store. Reviews only "work" (i.e. have guaranteed real signal, rather than "maybe real, maybe fake" signal) when incentives in a marketplace are aligned such that even the marketplace owner has no incentive to tamper with which reviews are or are not visible. That is not true here, and so the reviews are not, and never were, trustworthy. They were noise from the start.
- acomjean 7y agoProbably in prep for the president apple visit. Which included shooting a campaign ad and "opening the new" existing factory for the mac pro factory in Texas.
- briandear 7y agoPretty irrelevant.
- mmanfrin 7y agoI've found the reviews on a brand's own store page to be next to useless. The whole page is meant to sell me on a product, why would I trust "reviews" that are likely curated? Although, if I do find negative reviews on a retailer's site, it does engender some trust.
- generalpass 7y ago> Although, if I do find negative reviews on a retailer's site, it does engender some trust. A marketing friend of mine calls this "verisimilitude."
- trav4225 7y agoHah! It's hilarious, and sad, that this is a concept in marketing.
- kps 7y agoMany ‘accessory’ products had overwhelmingly negative reviews, because Apple's form-over-function philosophy means that they're genuinely hot garbage. … so they fixed the glitch. ¹ e.g. one I'm familiar with http://web.archive.org/web/20191113224149/https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MRW22LL/A/61w-usb-c-power-adapter http://web.archive.org/web/20191113224149/https://www.apple....
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- IAmEveryone 7y agoApple may choose form over function, but the power adaptors are a good example of how they still spent more time thinking of function than any competitor. For the typical "elongated black box" notebook charger, a cumulative sum of exactly zero effort was spent on improving it in either form or function. Meanwhile, Apple had MagSafe (which is nothing but function), the extendable prongs to wrap the cable, or the little clip to fix the cable into place. Both Apple and non-Apple adaptors usually have detachable cables, but for the non-Apple variety it's only purpose was to streamline internal processes to provide country-specific plugs, whereas Apple used the opportunity to allow the adaptor to be used with a long cable or a cable-less plug. Their adaptors are also smaller and lighter, both Watt-for-Watt and even more so considering competitors often choose overpowered adaptors because they happen to be cheap to procure or they already use it and want to keep their inventory simple. And if you search, you'll find that semi-famous deep dive examine the inside of one of their adaptors, and how they are spending at least twice as much on components to safely isolate the high- and low-voltage sides and provide constant quality at any level of power draw. But yeah, the cable fraying sucks.
- rgovostes 7y agoThe only thing remotely surprising here is that they lasted this long. It was frankly idiotic of them to have it there in the first place. No one is happy to spend $80 on a replacement MagSafe charger because the previous one frayed, so of course the listing was marred by 1-star reviews. The community Q&A also tends to be garbage. I understand that the average consumer is not going to have the same level of technical knowledge, and so I don't fault them for asking the questions. But it seems very strange that Apple allows their product page to be polluted by often confused questions, and also allows random people to answer those questions instead of qualified salespeople.
- xhkkffbf 7y agoI understand your point. Still, I think that these reviews were helpful to Apple by collecting the bitching in one central location. It kept the product team on their game. Of course at some point, people stop trusting reviews in general and so maybe it's time to moveon.
- killjoywashere 7y agoI'm pretty sure the product teams have access to Amazon reviews.
- pastor_elm 7y agoMany of Apple accessories are designed to fail. Fewer stars probably gets product higher year end bonuses.
- sockgrant 7y agoYou got a source for that?
- pastor_elm 7y agoYes, the lightning to 3.5mm adaptor. Just look at it.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- oneepic 7y agoGood, more sites should do the same. Customer review systems tend to just get abused and paint a confusing picture. That said, I still wish we could give customers a good way to share feedback at least somewhat publicly...
- theincredulousk 7y agoUnsurprising, given the (now very old) issue of selection/hidden-information bias in voluntary reviews. The people that are happy with the product are exponentially less likely to leave a "review" than the people that are unhappy, including outright trolls. The whole vibe that creates is not very "Apple". In fact I'm not sure the problem has ever been "solved" - raw sample size of reviews is helpful, but nowhere near eliminates these biases. How could it even be improved further in theory? I think you'd at least have to incorporate the number of total products sold into the review rating. If there were 10 terrible reviews on a product with 1,000,000 sold, that means something very different than one with 20 sold. Baseline though, dealing with people, it will probably never be perfect unless the reviewers have "skin in the game". People with positive experiences need some incentive to leave reviews that is as compelling as the negative experience. Lots of Amazon sellers offer some kind of free product or coupon in their follow-up emails - maybe that works?
- adambyrtek 7y agoYou underestimate the tricks online marketers use to source positive reviews. I guess Apple just cannot be bothered to game them since their success is not dependent on their contents. One example is the classic dark (or at least grey) pattern many mobile app use: Showing a popup with a question whether you enjoy the app or not. If you don't then you are asked to send private "feedback" by email. If you do then you are encouraged to leave a public (likely positive) review and redirected straight to the app store.
- LeicaLatte 7y agoDo it for my apps on the App Store too, Apple.
- par 7y agoAgreed. Convenient for Apple to absolve themselves of these things, but when my app gets a bunch of hateful reviews simply because the user doesn't want to pay, or provide an email, Apple lets all that stand.
- saagarjha 7y agoYou can flag irrelevant reviews.
- fdsa_8866 7y agoIf you think that process is fair or efficient I'd say you've never tried it. It's a half-measure meant to appease developers. In practice it's nearly worthless.
- twobat 7y agoOn the other side, as an user, I install some apps on my phone and the ones with bad reviews really deserve it. Poor Android ports, crap interface that didn't improve in 5 years and so on.
- fdsa_8866 7y agoCame here to say that. Unless you're bringing an already popular product into the store or have a large marketing budget, you're really at the mercy of the handful of people who seem to live to give bad reviews. It's even worse for a free product, which suggests that it's a % of people who have nothing better to do. So, you either try to push through it or buy reviews -- and risk getting kicked out of the store entirely. Reviews are 33% of the reason I shut down my app biz. (And then 33% dealing with the college dropouts in the review department and 33% for taking 33% for making my job harder than it would be without their help.) Cutting out reviews would be helpful for probably everyone but the top 1%. It would certainly make it less of a shit show for most developers.
- 8bitsrule 7y agoThis is nothing new for Apple; back around 2007 it removed the complaints of hundreds of iMac owners that regions of their display screens were failing, a year or two after purchase. I was one of those owners (the hard drive had already failed). Last straw for me. GrrrApple.
- salvagedcircuit 7y ago3,2,1... Apple uses COPPA as explanation of why comments removed.
- projektfu 7y agoIt boggles my mind why Apple doesn't have any engagement at all with the community. Their community Q&A is full of questions like "How do I play notifications through the phone speaker instead of bluetooth speaker" and the answers are just community members with the same problem, also wondering how to do it. Zero engagement from Apple.
- Someone1234 7y agoThis is one area where they could learn something from Microsoft. Microsoft use UserVoice for product feedback. Outdated list of UserVoice product sites: https://blogs.technet.microsoft.com/o365guy/2018/01/02/submit-product-feedback-or-feature-requests-to-microsofts-virtual-suggestion-boxes/ https://blogs.technet.microsoft.com/o365guy/2018/01/02/submi... UserVoice allows voting on what issues impact people most and allows the company to provide feedback to those issues/ideas. This isn't to say that a company must do all upvoted ideas, Microsoft certainly don't, but it is a useful outlet for both parties. Microsoft aren't the only major company using UserVoice: https://www.uservoice.com/customers/ https://www.uservoice.com/customers/ and there are competing services offering similar benefits. The concept is maybe more important than that specific product. Apple seems to lack basic communications channels in both directions. This is a problem regardless of company policy.
- musicale 7y agoThere are multiple input channels (feedback.apple.com, support.apple.com, twitter, etc.) but few if any official replies from Apple. Also bug reports are private (due to personal and/or proprietary information as well as potential security issues) so it's hard to gauge whether other people have run into similar issues or if Apple has uncovered the same bug in their own testing. I'd like to see a vetted "parent bug" that would be publicly visible, but Apple would never do this because they don't want third parties to mine their bug reports (which could potentially be exploited maliciously against Apple or its users, or for financial gain.)
- hnick 7y agoEvery time I look up a Macbook problem for my wife it's 16 pages of this.
- jlarocco 7y agoI honestly suspect Apple's completely lost without Steve Jobs and instead of innovating and building quality products they're pivoting into a fashion symbol and trying to push their margins as high as they can and eke out as much money as possible before people realize what's going on and abandon them in favor of better, cheaper alternatives.
- twobat 7y agoTry to read about the features inside their custom chips. Personally I am amazed.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- asdff 7y agoThe most painful part is the overtness of the money grubbing from apple, a trillion dollar company. Dongle tax, mandatory touchbar, base storage and memory stuck in 2012, extortion tier upgrade pricing, and the hardware falls apart if you look at it wrong.
- scarface74 7y agoBy removing the reviews, it's possible that Apple will be seen as less credible to potential buyers. How could anyone disagree with this. Just look at Amazon for a shining example of reviews done correctly. They are always so credible, never gamed, and you never have to worry about fake products especially if you buy products labeled as “Amazon’s Choice”.....
- ratsmack 7y agoSomehow, I must believe you are being sarcastic, or you are terribly misinformed.
- ddoolin 7y ago100% satire.
- otakucode 7y agoI've never understood why online reviews, at least on sites as large as Amazon with a competent technical team behind the company, aren't better. First step, if I review a product, then you should immediately be weighting the visibility of all reviews by reviewers who posted a review which agrees with my own. So if I rate Avengers: Endgame bluray a single star, guess that I have similar opinions to the others that rated it the same, and when I go look at some other Marvel film bluray, if those others have reviewed it, push them to the top. As I review more and more things, the weightings should get better and better. And gaming it would be basically impossible unless you managed to tailor bot posts to match the way I rated dishware, movies, books, videogames, food products, and the dozens of other things I've rated. Fake reviews would get pushed to the bottom with almost instantaneous speed if they would do this. If they cheap out and decide to aggregate and 'bucket' reviewers rather than training a recommender engine per-customer, its performance will fall short and still be gamed, but even that would be better (and seems to be the way big companies handle the computational load per-user systems would incur... personally I'd prefer they push the calculations clientside, but they haven't gone that way).
- asveikau 7y agoI have sometimes had amazing smiles and laughter reading amazon reviews. It tends to remind me that people are pretty diverse in their lifestyles and opinions. When sizing up a product, that gives nothing at all of value: this guy hates it, but seems slightly crazy; this other one loves it but what do they know? So I just have a good laugh at how different these people are from each other, and likely from me, and make gut decisions based on pretty much nothing anyway.
- supernovae 7y agoThis probably has more to do with Google algo changes and de-ranking user-generated content than anything else
- tus88 7y agoWhy any website puts review and rating on their own website has always amazed me. It seemed to start happening during the social media frenzy of the mid-2000s, and really should have gone away by now.
- musicale 7y agoI liked the reviews and am disappointed that they removed them.
- noodlesUK 7y agoI genuinely think that USB-C (the connector) has a huge problem, and I’m pretty sure most of HN knows it. Users everywhere expect that physically compatible plugs in normal consumer devices imply some degree of comparability. Unfortunately because we use USB-C (the connector) for almost every imaginable kind of interconnect these days, most devices have a complicated matrix of things they will and won’t support, and so do cables. I don’t know how users are expected to become educated about this. “Why won’t my display work when I plug it in using x cable, on y single, but will work when I use z cable on q dongle” is such a common question I hear, and I don’t know how to explain it to people other than just to use trial and error. Apple needs to come up with some way of at least commonly labelling things to imply compatibility if they don’t want to confuse and alienate people. I am aware it isn’t just Apple with this problem, but USB-C (the connector) is perceived by most Apple users as an Apple thing.
- classified 7y ago> By removing the reviews, it's possible that Apple will be seen as less credible to potential buyers. That ship has sailed. Who still expects things to work as advertised?
- langaaegeskov 7y agohttps://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2019/11/22/apple-says-its-app-store-is-safe-trusted-place-we-found-reports-unwanted-sexual-behavior-six-apps-some-targeting-minors/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2019/11/22/apple-s... this article used app reviews as its source, maybe apple didnt like that. I dont know if the timing makes sense though...
- doggydogs94 7y agoIt should be clear that this is a USB-C specification issue and not just an Apple issue.