20 ms·
Interpol plans to condemn encryption spread, citing predators
- noobermin 7y agoThis is such a tired argument but is becoming more and more widespread. It's time for IT professionals beyond just the activists like the EFF to stand up and explain how encryption is good and necessary.
- carapace 7y agoIt's not like this BS is new BS. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crypto_wars https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crypto_wars Everyone who wants to know knows or is a newbie. However, if newbies come into the discussion faster than they can be brought up to speed there's a risk of an "Eternal September" effect diluting common sense, so you're basically right about how we should all be explaining it to our friends and family and whatnot. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eternal_September
- mirimir 7y agoI bet that Interpol uses VPNs without backdoors.
- newguy1234 7y agoThey probably use TOR.
- deogeo 7y agoDupe of https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21559957 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21559957
- tomhoward 7y agoIt's only a dupe if another submission of the same article/topic already had solid upvoting and discussion: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20significant%20attention&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- etaioinshrdlu 7y agoImagine for a moment that ssh became illegal. Is it even possible for the tech economy to continue? What would that look like? My head hurts. Actually, think of what Attorney General Barr said: Corporations should have access to strong encryption, just not little people. In that horrifying sort of world, there would be encryption licenses perhaps. And general purpose computing would be under a large threat. It is so absurd that it would only work under a totalitarian system. Maybe that's what we'll eventually get.
- m0dest 7y agoIt’d probably be some new PKI on top of SSH where your private key would be held in escrow by an identity provider. e.g. Your username is your email address, and your email provider retains your key pair. It’d probably be portrayed as an improved key management solution that allows more frequent key rotations and revocations. Might even start with being required for government projects, resulting in supported implementations by cloud providers that want lucrative government contracts. Then they just wait for a crisis opportunity like a cyberattack to force ISPs to block non-PKI-based SSH traffic in the name of national security. And the largest and most paranoid companies that host their own mail and authentication services on-perm would probably be allowed to use those. But most everyone else is left doing key escrow with Google and O365 for their work and personal accounts...
- alfiedotwtf 7y agoGiven the trade wars, would the US be ok if China were to hold onto American company private keys so they can "monitor for lawful activity" of Chinese users? Let that sink in and show that the government arguments are not workable in the slightest.
- etaioinshrdlu 7y agoIt could happen that the US blocks services from China the same way China blocks services from the US. Oh well, the Internet was cool I guess.
- deleted 7y ago
- RHSeeger 7y ago> The international police organization Interpol plans to condemn the spread of strong encryption in a statement Monday saying it protects child sex predators, three people briefed on the matter told Reuters. Let me fix that for you > it protects nearly every single person on the planet.
- noobermin 7y agoThis is close to saying child rapists rape children behind closed doors so you shouldn't have locks, ignoring that well locked doors benefit everyone who has a house. It's disingenuous.
- goblin89 7y agoWhile I support the sentiment that privacy is important, comparing encryption to locks in this ghastly context is self-defeating. Recall that there were more than one instance where critical evidence against a wealthy person, required for the prosecution to make a compelling case in court, was obtained by force with a police raid. At least one such instance happened in the US in 2019 and was well-publicized. Now imagine a real-life security system that is absolutely, one hundred percent immune to unauthorized entry, even if it is attempted as a part of law enforcement raid. It is possible to identify with the argument that everyone should have access to such an impenetrable lock. However, it’d be really hard to argue that widespread access to it wouldn’t create a radically new situation.
- notelonmusk 7y agoAn invisibility cloak makes a much better analogy for encryption.
- jdc 7y agoYou know one way the situation would be way different? We'd less need for the police.
- GoblinSlayer 7y agoEncryption doesn't prevent police raids.
- nayuki 7y agoLook at the government repression on the Hong Kong protesters, who are fighting for freedom and accountability. That's a good reason to support encryption technology.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 7y agoI wish these people who say privacy is dangerous would commit to having all their communications and movements published for all to see. Or something similar like that. At least then they wouldn't be such hypocrites. For example, there was an interpol bribery scandal a year ago. Maybe it could have been prevented if that person had to communicate fully in the open.
- snowwrestler 7y agoThis is a good time to remember that police forces work for governments and not the other way around. Of course it would be easier for the police to catch bad guys if they had full-text search access to all conversations and content, worldwide. That doesn’t mean it is a good idea. They’re asking for something to make their job easier... can’t blame them for trying, and of course who doesn’t want to catch people who harm children? But it’s not their responsibility to account for negative side effects. That’s our responsibility, as citizens who are in charge of our governments. And we have to remember that governments and police can hurt children too. Look at what the border police in the U.S. are doing right now. And when it comes to fighting that sort of thing, encrypted comms are essential for political organizing. This is on top of the obvious and many benefits of encryption in protecting us all from crime.
- newguy1234 7y agoCouldn't have said it better myself.
- tfha 7y agoI'm pretty sure part of the job of a bodyguard is to ensure the well being of their client. If they ask for something that improves safety but makes the client miserable, they are not doing their job.
- tqi 7y agoI also this is a good time to remember that not every citizen has to have the same values on this. Some people might think the tradeoff in terms of freedoms vs security is worth it. It seems everyone is so eager to paint the other side as objectively wrong / motivated by bad intentions, when in reality I don't believe this is an objectively right answer. As a society we have to decide how much freedom and security we want at this moment in time.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- killjoywashere 7y ago
- andai 7y agoLet Interpol set a good example then and voluntarily give up all their privacy.
- Razengan 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sousveillance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sousveillance
- paulmooreparks 7y ago“Tech companies should include mechanisms in the design of their encrypted products and services whereby governments, acting with appropriate legal authority, can obtain access to data in a readable and useable format.” Yes, because governments always act with appropriate legal authority, by definition, right?
- GoblinSlayer 7y agoAs soon as it's legally allowed, it's not illegal anymore.
- microcolonel 7y agoCriminals lock their doors, you're not a criminal, are you?
- protomyth 7y agoEncryption is math, and not even hard math at that. You have as much chance of stopping evil people from using encryption as you have of stopping them from doing multiplication. Make every politician who opposes encryption feel like an idiot for thinking they can stop people from adding and multiplying.
- emptybits 7y agoIndeed. It would appear all the necessary components for encryption are impossible to ban, by simple common sense if not by guarantees of very basic constitutional or charter rights. 1. public and private keys (criminalize the possession of large integers?) 2. transmission and reception (criminalize freedom to speak or write or read or hear large numbers or random-appearing text?) 3. encryption and decryption (criminalize, as you say, some relatively simple math operations?) Anti-encryption governments and law enforcement don't want this simple breakdown understood by voters. They'll emphasize fear (<insert_threat>) and shame/virtue ("what do innocent people have to hide?") Weak arguments but they seem to press stronger emotional buttons than the more principled (IMO) philosophical math and speech arguments that should guarantee freedom to encrypt forever.
- wruza 7y agoSadly, courts will laugh and proceed. The same argument could be done for firearms – it’s just physics, and not even space/quantum physics. Really, a device pushing a small body to some direction via expansion of another body. It’s all bodies, you can’t stop people from surrounding them with these. If adopted, a law will state “the piece of information for which format and representation cannot be detected in a considerable amount of time” and then a judge to decide. Send some random bytes and you’re in trouble.
- ars 7y agoI had an idea that a decent compromise is to limit keystrength, but not have any kind of backdoor. This way the vast majority of communication is protected, and the government can't just spy en mass. But, if there was some specific target they could throw a lot of computing resources at it. But they would need to know in advance who to target, they couldn't just have a wide dragnet. Thoughts?
- BLKNSLVR 7y agoThrowing computing resources at it can be fairly accessible to small groups or even individuals as a result of 'cloud' computing. There are examples of people coordinating a large number of cloud instances for a short amount of time to crack hashes, and it was surprisingly cheap. I don't have a reference on hand though. This also makes it trivial for nation states and larger groups to decrypt whatever data they're able to sniff. It would actually encourage more groups to get into more places where they can sniff more data.
- emptybits 7y ago> if there was some specific target they could throw a lot of computing resources at it 1. Yes, for many (too many) values of they. "Your" government, all governments, so essentially any corporation, or any private individual that can afford time or computing resources and is interested in a target. 2. This scheme doesn't age well. Targets' mandatory low-grade encrypted communications today could be saved as blackmail time capsules, much more easily decrypted with cheap resources in the too-near future.
- ffe44 7y agoIf a cipher can be broken by the government, it can also be broken by narco cartels or mafia states. The targets will be key decision makers, not regular citizens, but their decisions, coerced by those mafia states, will harm regular citizens. Unlike physical locks, breaking encrypted data doesn't need physical presence. This means that not just local authorities under an elected Sheriff can break into one's house, but also completely random people from say China or KSA can teleport in, break in and kidnap the data. In the near future we'll have a brain-to-computer-to-internet interface. This will be a big leap forward or backwards as it can be used for rapid collaboration or total undisputable survelliance for a greedy dictator. The crypthography case today will set the precedent for tomorrow. Btw, even the 24/7 thoughts monitoring can be used for good: someone really advanced, a saint-like person, could be giving advice on what's wrong with your thoughts. But we understand that the humanity is far from this level of maturity.
- cmdshiftf4 7y agoSigh. What we can basically tell from this is that the Five Eyes crew have joint legislation ready to go on this and are now going to insert an easy-to-digest and appealing narrative into the mainstream ahead of the release of that legislation. The combination of "But the children! You don't support child predators, do you?!", low general technical understanding and overall apathy to the removal of our rights (in the name of "progress") means that this is basically destined to succeed. Might be time to really re-evaluate our personal relationship with technology and make the appropriate moves to isolate it in our lives. If/when this goes through, technology will essentially have us under surveillance in every aspect of our daily lives.
- ddtaylor 7y agoI would say that time has already passed since many social media companies have such a grip already.
- blaser-waffle 7y agoYeah but I don't have to opt into social media. And I can run my own OpenVPN tunnel on Digital Ocean or Linode or whatever. Outlaw crypto and I can't, the choice has been removed. Prepare to be watched, citizen.
- coldcode 7y agoI for one are ready to give up my encryption when the politicians do it first and we see how well that works.
- DarkWiiPlayer 7y agoNext time someone tells me "Why would you need encryption if you have nothing to hide?" I'mma just answer with "Why do you need clothes then?"
- Koshkin 7y agoOriginally, only to keep oneself warm.
- Gatsky 7y agoLots of criticism here, fair enough, it’s very worrying to give non-transparent institutions this kind of power, not to mention the technical feasibility. But... what should be done about child pornography, then? The ability to disseminate it with impunity is a problem we can’t just pretend doesn’t exist. Using online platforms pedophiles can monetize and go full time professional in countries where children are easily exploited. Nobody is coming to save those kids.
- pixelpoet 7y agoIf we're going to throw out anything and everything to win that unwinnable battle, first goes encryption, then cameras, then computers, and then finally all humans after puberty. Obviously there must be some reasonable limit, and making all encryption illegal (or just for civilians, and then shady stuff will start happening under govt and corporate encryption) is truly throwing the baby out with the bathwater, in that digital society can no longer function. We don't stop selling knives because some people get stabbed with them, they still sell AR-15s in America despite ridiculously frequent mass shootings, so I can't see where the logic is coming from for making encryption illegal.
- Gatsky 7y agoYes I agree with you. But at the same time, I don’t feel comfortable knowing what is going on and just accepting that it is a cost of liberty. We are talking about the worst, most harmful most exploitative human behaviour that destroys lives. If we can’t introduce some nuance and proportionality here then well I think we are doomed. Guns aren’t a good example... I mean guns are regulated? There isn’t total liberty there.
- soraminazuki 7y agoWell, encryption doesn't cause child exploitation, very much like how the air we (and criminals alike) breathe doesn't either. Limitations of police powers are there for a very good reason, and it's not like there wasn't much crime when they were introduced. I think it's short-sighted to give up our civil liberties because of crime.
- andy_ppp 7y agoThe weirdest part of this argument is that law abiding people get no encryption while people who break the law will still have access to encryption, so how does it help you catch pedophiles? I don’t really understand how this will work in reality for things like SSL or ssh.
- newguy1234 7y agoThe truth is the law won't be used to catch pedophiles. It will just be used to prosecute anyone who uses encryption for legal or illegal means.
- scotty79 7y agoI think that's how it should be argued. Strong encryption software exists. It's on the internet. You can't make it disappear. If you outlaw it, law observing people won't use it. But how would you force a criminal not to use it if you can't force him not to abuse children?
- sdfsafsawe 7y agoSimple. First assume that a random-looking message is sent only by criminals. Second, ignore the theoretical problems with measuring kolgomorov complexity of a message. That's just academic mumbo jumbo - "can I zip the message?" is good enough. Third, buy $80 car battery at HD with $20 booster cables.
- scotty79 7y agoAnd how do you plan to detect steganography in funny cat pictures? Or zip files that just seem corrupted? Will you try to unpack everything?
- cesarb 7y ago> law abiding people get no encryption while people who break the law will still have access to encryption, so how does it help you catch pedophiles? If only people who break the law use encryption, then everyone who uses encryption must be breaking some law (that is, "(~lawbreaker => ~encryption) => (encryption => lawbreaker)"). That is, instead of having to do all the work to find out if the guy is really a pedophile or something else, they can simply arrest the guy for using encryption. It's a lazy approach. > I don’t really understand how this will work in reality for things like SSL or ssh. It wouldn't, these protocols (and many others) would have to be basically rewritten, or we'd have to go back to plain HTTP and telnet.
- peterwwillis 7y agoThere must be an algorithm that we can apply to show what such a change will have for society. If the probability is that the change is negligible, we should consider allowing it. But if the probability is that the change is overwhelmingly "bad", we should not allow it. Let's not argue from ignorance. What are the numbers? What are the ethics? For example: Say if we listened in on all connections, we would catch an extra 200 predators. But we also know that several hundred million people's private conversations would be scrutinized by government(s). We know from historical precedent that letting child predators go unnoticed means more children get abused. But we also know from historical precedent that governments scrutinizing otherwise private information about citizens leads to abuses of government's powers, and of citizens' rights. An algorithm could show estimates, such as "for this given change in the US, 1,750,000 people's rights may be potentially violated for every 1 new predator arrested". But if the value was actually 5,000 additional predators caught, this would become "70,000 people's rights potentially violated for every 1 predator caught". This is of course a very wacky over-generalization based on some ballparked numbers, which is why an algorithm with more data could give more realistic probabilities. But also from the other side of the algorithm, you could look at our historical access to privacy. Telephones and mail have been monitored in the past by law enforcement. Now that we have privacy, we don't want to give it up. But would it actually benefit society more to have less privacy? Again, you tune the algorithm to take data about when we had privacy and when we didn't, what the outcomes were, and what the potential new outcomes are from a change. It could be that as a society, we actually don't significantly benefit from, or could do without, total privacy of remote communications. But then again, our transactions weren't all remote. All of these considerations (and more) if compiled in some way that could be easily analyzed, may lead to a conclusion that is easier to reason about.
- raxxorrax 7y ago> Telephones and mail have been monitored in the past by law enforcement But is that in any way comparable with automated surveillance? I think a fitting analogue would be having every mail scanned and archived. Different circumstances... I doubt the numbers game you are proposing would net any insights, since it has a hidden premise that child trafficking can only be prevented with restricting encryption.
- tanto 7y agoAre they not aware that could equally condemn walls as having 4 off them at night protects predators equally? /s
- rebuilder 7y agoHave any of these proposals to require companies to provide access to law enforcement included any concrete suggestion of how, exactly it should be done without also providing access to bad actors? It sounds like Interpol et al. are just saying "make 1 + 1 = 3" and expecting the nerds to figure it out.
- self_awareness 7y agoNext step: "Is he using encryption? If yes, he might be a child predator!"
- AndrewBissell 7y ago"citing predators" So, where is Ghislaine Maxwell? Shouldn't the all-seeing panopticon we've already constructed be able to pinpoint her location at a moment's notice? I'll believe all this surveillance is really about "predators" the day I see her taken into custody.
- sgjohnson 7y agoThey could have simultaneously wrapped it in "protect the children" and "national security"
- LatteLazy 7y agoPredator complains other predators "making life inconvenient".
- skokage 7y agoAny time these topics around weakening privacy or removing encryption comes up, it's nearly always presented with a save the children type of argument. I mean, who doesn't want to protect children from child abuse and predators? The problem however, is that most children that are abused are done so by family members or people already close to them (like maybe their priests), so with that in mind I don't really understand how weakening encryption will help protect children from predators.
- newguy1234 7y agoThat's because there is a deeper agenda than just "protecting children". If you read the Edward Snowden book (permanent record) then you'll note that he talks about what the NSA/CIA is actually doing with their signals intelligence programs. It isn't about national security, it is about espionage on a global scale. They want information on what foreign governments, journalists, domestic organizations (not just terrorist groups as they claim) and corporations are doing. For domestic citizens, they want to know if you are a threat to the United States or violating laws. The second strong end-to-end encryption is implemented, the whole system simply fails to operate. Instead of having a massive data collection system, you now have to go back to more traditional methods that require much more effort to implement - like hacking a target's computer directly. If that happens then the USA will lose its edge in terms of obtaining critical information and that will be a treat to their global dominance....hence the reason they mention national security. Of course, you can't just come out and say this is the reason so they mask it in "fighting sexual exploitation" etc. The truth is end-to-end encryption and fighting sexual exploitation are not mutually exclusive. We can have both.
- x220 7y ago>hence the reason they mention national security. Of course, you can't just come out and say this is the reason so they mask it in "fighting sexual exploitation" And then all the intelligence employees come on HNews after 5 PM and bitch and moan about how we don't trust their agency's reports about its own conduct and activities...
- ffe44 7y ago
- roenxi 7y agoThe issue here is that you can't stop people from using encryption; they'll just start using a combination of encryption and steganography for example. It isn't like we are dealing with people who are afraid to break the law.
- lolc 7y agoI don't follow this argument. Compromising commonly used encryption means less people will use hard encryption. That goes for criminals too. They won't all just switch to a hardened scheme. Some will switch, some will go with the compromised version, and some might even stop the criminal things they are doing for fear of detection. The question is whether this means it's worth compromising encryption.
- hellotomyrars 7y agoI can’t imagine that a significant number of criminals who are involved in sexual exploitation of children would suddenly be unmasked due to any government imposed rules about encryption. At best you’d have a small wave of folks caught off guard. The "question” is a false premise. You can’t stop people form using encryption. The people who are strongly motivated to use it to cover their criminal activity (the more heinous the more motivated they’re likely to be) are still going to. The knock-on effect is that you give the police and governments the keys to the kingdom against people who are probably not committing heinous crimes. The abuse potential increases with little to nothing gained for the rule of law and the common person. People have been committing crime and hiding them (the key component to not getting caught it turns out) since humans decided to implement laws. Weakening encryption isn’t going to stop that and it’s a hollow argument.
- lolc 7y ago> You can’t stop people form using encryption. This is repeated often but that doesn't make it any truer. Legislation can make people use ineffective encryption, or prevent the use of it. Remember when SSL certificates had 48 bits effective key length? It was legislation that caused this. People used bad encryption because of the legislation. Remember when PGP was the only end-to-end messaging scheme widely available? Only very few people used it. Its reach was hampered by legislation. (In part; let's not forget bad usability.) Most people are unaware how the services they use are protecting them from eavesdropping. Sure some are careful and research the failure modes in the security of their communications. And some would go to any length to keep their communications encrypted. But the less mainstream it is, the easier it is for them to fuck it up. Suppose due to legislation no apps in the Google Play store can do reliable end-to-end: Suddenly you have these "privacy conscious" people downloading an App binary from some random site because they heard it was "good". Yeah right we know how that story goes. By all means, argue that ubiquitous encryption increases security for all of us. And I'm your friend. But don't go claiming that compromising mainstream encryption wouldn't hamper security for the bad guys. Because it absolutely would. Like for the rest of us!
- neiman 7y agoSo in the same time they should condemn democracy and freedom, as they're having exactly the same effect. It is much easier for police in authoritarian countries to prevent crimes and find perpetrators. But if they don't condemn democracy and freedom, they should also not condemn encryption. The ability to communicate privately, or saying things outside the consensus anonymously, is an important tool for citizens to protect democracy. The Interpol job is to protect the law under the settings of democracy and freedom, not to try to change those settings in order to make their job easier.
- glangdale 7y ago"It is much easier for police in authoritarian countries to prevent crimes and find perpetrators." Is this actually true? This sounds like one of those bits of received wisdom (like the trains supposedly running on time under Mussolini) that turns out to be bogus. I'm not sure that the expansion of police powers under authoritarian regimes has anything to do with making them more efficient at preventing or solving crimes that are crimes in all regimes (e.g. murder, rape, etc). I would at least need to see some evidence that clearance rates are better in authoritarian countries.
- danielrpa 7y agoAuthoritarian states tend to be not as advanced technologically (one consequence of authoritarianism!), thus their police forces should be less efficient in general despite the increased powers. But controlling for other factors, why wouldn't enhanced surveillance help catch criminals? It's a pretty logical claim. Perhaps you should look for the evidence and bring back to us. For now, it is reasonable to accept the common sense statement.
- Nasrudith 7y agoGiven the needle in a haystack effect? Common sense has proven itself wrong repeatedly It was "common sense" that merchants had to be frauds because the value of goods was universal and they had transport labor. Besides just because they can doesn't mean they will. Authoritarians are also infamous for both corruption and finding rooting out dissidents a higher priority than what most would call actual crime. All other things /aren't/ equal.
- journalctl 7y agoYou can do encryption with a pen, paper, and a calculator. The genie is out of the bottle at this point.
- Iv 7y agoFight against pedophilia has always been one of the common excuses (the other being terrorism) used to install spying devices everywhere, even despite very few actual organizations that fight the problem actually asking for such things. I would be sad to hear that it would indeed be a useful tool, because the behavior of western government in the last 20 years at least makes it impossible to trust them on that one.
- AdrianB1 7y agoThere is a huge part of the public that does not understand the implications of encryption, but they are moved by any mention of fighting against evil (and pedophilia is a scare for most) and these people have the right to vote. With enough propaganda, they would vote happily on anything, so this particular one is an easy one.
- qwerty456127 7y agoEvery time somebody tries to exploit the children protection narrative to justify a privacy/freedom withdrawal it's a huge red flag. E.g. at the time when the government was introducing the websites blocking system in Russia they spoke about blocking underage porn but as soon as the system was deployed they started to block whatever sites they dislike (for political reasons or for money) every day.
- stevefan1999 7y agoSigh. They use child sexual abuse as a scapegoat again.
- juskrey 7y agohttps://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Pedophrasty https://www.urbandictionary.com/define.php?term=Pedophrasty
- boomlinde 7y agoOf course, if a child predator really wants to conceal their communication and it's not built into the chat service, they can do so using, say, PGP and some sort of steganography. On the other hand, that law enforcement agencies can catch criminals today using e.g. Messenger means that there are criminals that are not careful or savvy enough to do so. IMO end-to-end encrypted chat should be regarded as private eye-to-eye conversation. It's understandably convenient for law enforcement if it isn't. In the end, that a criminal can say something incriminating to another in private is not a new problem.
- koheripbal 7y agoI understand that child predators are thrown around a lot as an example of why backdoors are needed - but, in reality, it's the worst example. The crimes that warrant a violation of public privacy would need to be those that create _systemic_ risk. Like on the order of the 9-11 attacks that were so disruptive to the entire country that they merit a (temporary) privacy sacrifice. Child predators are used for their emotional bait, because everyone agrees they are hated, but for all the horror they inflict, they do not cause a systemic problem.
- jonny383 7y agoI hate to say it, but us (citizens of the internet), are fighting a losing battle. Gone are the days of the internet being an open, connected hub for worldwide culture.
- Roark66 7y agoInterpol is a bloody joke. Recently they accepted a submission from Russia to put an international arrest warrant on an activist named Ihor Mazur right before he was going to EU to appear at some conference. The guy, is not a terrorist, nor an extremist, but he was arrested on the Polish border and it took 2 days of effort from Ukrainian and Polish embassies for Interpol to finally accept the Russian claim as bogus and withdraw the warrant. He was eventually freed, but for Interpol to even accept this from Russia on their word alone was insane.
- moomin 7y agoThe link provided, of course, is https.
- growlist 7y agoIf only the police would show as much enthusiasm towards catching low-tech predators.
- danielrpa 7y agoAfter normal citizens stop being able to use "unbreakable" encryption, only criminals will be able to use it. So you will get the same "terrorism" and "child pornography" as you do today, but we won't be able to protect our privacy from state actors (or from tech companies and their employees) who will develop the upcoming wholesome, good-enough-for-you encryption. By the way, is XOR considered "strong encryption"? Is it if an one time pad is used? Just asking :).
- sdfsafsawe 7y agoXOR is very strong encryption, therefore it will be illegal. And easy to detect (random looking signal)
- auslander 7y agoI will continue using strong crypto for all my data even if it will be illegal. Cyberpunks not dead.
- upofadown 7y agoThe "going dark" issue has been known for something like 30 years now. Law enforcement has had a lot of warning. Instead of modifying why way they did things they instead wasted their time by buying various sort of cracking technologies. Any idiot could see that such technologies were a stopgap measure. Now those technologies are not working very well, or at all, and law enforcement is acting all surprised and outraged.
- GhettoMaestro 7y agoThis is nothing more than an extension of technology enabling both good actors and bad actors. I refuse to penalize/water-down technology solutions available to good actors because there are a handful of bad actors that make some of us clutch our pearls.
- DarkWiiPlayer 7y agoYou know what else protects criminals? Walls. Seriously, wouldn't it all be much easier if the police could just look into your home from the outside without those pesky walls around it? This constant war on encryption is getting so absurd lately. The kind of people who are pushing this should just be fired if not thrown into prison. It's just a blatant attack against human rights and the public should finally start viewing it as such.
- schwede 7y agoWhat about warrants? The police can get a warrant to look inside your walls. You can’t do that with encryption.
- vcavallo 7y agodo you think warrant should also extend to the walls of your skull? should police be able to access your thoughts, given the correct warrant? the “walls” analogy is sort of unfortunate because it doesn’t apply evenly.
- SkyBelow 7y agoOnly if they think something is already happening. A world where every room in every house is covered by cameras results in less child abuse than a world where warrants are required to search a house. How many children is privacy worth?
- Faark 7y ago> You can’t do that with encryption. Isn't the most effective way to get around encryption to compromise the endpoint? Obviously not after the fact, but I doubt a highly motivated and well funded police force would find ways to get eg video of a password being entered inside the house of nearly any selected criminal.
- croon 7y agoEncryption backdoors mean they can look at your data without your knowing. This is not equivalent to warrants. What they however can do is have a warrant to access your house, where some of your data might live, or potentially decryption keys. And they could potentially motivate you to reveal your keys. All of this is possible currently without encryption backdoors.
- specialist 7y agoI'm unclear how this could help law enforcement deter or solve crimes. eg Why does the FBI need to unlock a spree shooter's iPhone AFTER the mass killing? What new information could they possibly learn? That the now dead murderer had mac & cheese for dinner beforehand?
- octosphere 7y agoRecycled comment from an article a few weeks back about Former FBI General Counsel Jim Baker Choosing Encryption over Backdoors[0] [0] https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2019/10/former_fbi_gene.html https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2019/10/former_fbi_ge... You can read the discussion on HN here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21377093 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21377093 _________________________ This is why Tor and onionland is a lawless wild west. All so that journalists can report and trade documents, and so that repressive regimes can't easily censor access to news and information. This is the cost of encryption: you get all sorts of scoundrels in the mix in the name of privacy and security for the masses. Some might say this cost is too high: that scoundrels are running rampant and won't stop their criminal actions. But without this we get a broken backdoored Internet where no such privacy/security exists and could actually cause more damage to society since spying would be rampant.
- LeftHandPath 7y agoBanning encryption is like requiring that all your walls be made of glass and that the police can search your home at any time, for any reason, without warrant. A personal electronic device, and the connections made with it, are extensions of the person and their respective home. A literal ban on encryption is probably the single largest step any government could take towards becoming a dystopic, tyrannic, borderline-criminal entity. (I originally posted this comment under my reddit account, /u/lovecars.)
- cr0sh 7y agoNote that the politicians and the law enforcement people (and the government by extension) will have walls built you can't see thru... ...gee, where do you think all the criminality will be occurring then? In a way, they'd be figuratively shooting themselves in the foot. Right now, they can somewhat get away with their criminality, because they are more or less noise in the signal - since everyone has "walls" that can't be seen thru. If they get their way with this kind of legislation, you know there will be an exception for them. Once the people realize that the criminality continues, they will look around and say "well how's that possible? if only criminals use encryption...<lightbulb turns on>" - and then they become the targets of the people. Of course, the people should have realized this NOW - not later...
- shrubble 7y agoLook at the Marc Dutroux case, where evidence clearly suggested that the predators' network was located inside the government itself... gives a new light to Interpol's views.
- danmg 7y agoJeffery Epstein used unencrypted burned CDs/DVDs for his child porn. Also, did Interpol ever ground his plane---the Lolita Express?
- leftyted 7y agoI disagree with the tone of the comments here. Encryption is scary. Of course law enforcement is dismayed by the possibility that certain kinds of crimes could leave behind no trace at all. What these people, who want to regulate encryption, don't seem to understand is that this is the downside of living in a free society. In a free society, people can commit crimes, and sometimes they can get away with them. We've made a deliberate choice to structure our society this way rather than optimizing for preventing crimes or punishing criminals. This is the right choice. At the same time, you have to understand the temptation of structuring your society in a different way, in order to punish the guilty and protect the innocent. That perspective truly has massive appeal. Comments that fail to acknowledge this and boil down to "you can't regulate math" are not good arguments. They're condescending and far too dismissive of a facet of human psychology that is actually admirable (a strong preference for justice). A better argument acknowledges these things but reiterates the liberal arguments that undergird our societies (which have turned out rather well, if you ask me).
- commandlinefan 7y ago> don't seem to understand is that this is the downside of living in a free society No, what they don’t understand is that the cryptography that protects your bank account is the exact same cryptography that (supposedly) makes law enforcement difficult. There’s no way to separate the two, any more than you can separate the arithmetic that is responsible for updating your bank account from the arithmetic that is responsible for updating the bank account of a Colombian drug lord.
- TheSoftwareGuy 7y ago> (supposedly) makes law enforcement difficult You don't need that parenthesized qualifier, and putting it there seems unfair. If we are to have a fair, honest discussion focusing on the merits we need to recognize when the opposing side makes a valid point, and it is pretty obvious that secure & encrypted communications does make law enforcement materially more difficult. Once this point is accepted we can focus the discussion on whether the trade off is worth it.
- 7y ago
- ajb 7y agoIt's so obvious to many of us that 'think of the children' is a disingenuous argument, that it's difficult to articulate a counter-argument which would be emotionally valid to someone for whom this is not obvious. Here is my attempt: Someone whose child has been kidnapped, would sacrifice a great deal to get them back. A lot of the things which we hold dear, our dignity, privacy, democracy, even rule of law - would pale into insignificance to against the loss of a loved one. But for that very reason, we should not look to victims for a standard of how much the police can override our civil rights. The standard of 'what the police can demand from honest citizens' cannot be 'what a mother would sacrifice for her child'.
- vcavallo 7y agoit’s a good attempt, but i think it still won’t appeal to those on which the previous argument didn’t work.
- eternalny1 7y agoHow can they prevent this? What if I secure my messages with a known passphrase inside a picture of a rainbow using steganography? Are they just talking about decrypting the big players like Facebook Messenger and iMessage? Because you can't "prevent" encryption.
- tasubotadas 7y agoThey can't. That's why legitimate users won't be able to use encryption (because it's against the law) and criminals will still continue using it because they can and they don't care.
- CryptoPunk 7y agoI see this as an existential threat to human civilization. It poses a very significant risk of creating power asymmetries between the politically connected elite and the masses that lead to highly unstable social hierarchies where states have total control over their population.
- vcavallo 7y agothroughout history, bad people protected themselves from good people using the same technologies by which good people protected themselves from bad people. if you remove the former, you also lose the latter. there’s nothing more to it. anyone advocating for removing the former must first be clear that they are abdicating the latter. any other framing is a lie.
- danesparza 7y agoThis reminds me of the cypherpunk movement in the early 1990's (more information: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cypherpunk https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cypherpunk ). We have seen this kind of threat before. We need organizations like the EFF and ACLU more than ever.
- commandlinefan 7y ago"It is insufficient to protect ourselves with laws; we need to protect ourselves with mathematics." -- Bruce Schneier
- glitcher 7y agoReminds me of the old saying, if you outlaw guns then only outlaws will have guns. Maybe this would be an analogy politicians could understand better when it comes to encryption! Surely the analogy would break down quickly on closer inspection, but politicians live and die by sound bites, not by thoughtful consideration and debate of all points of view. So to fight fire with fire, when faced with the "protect the children" argument that stifles debate, counter with "a government who takes away everyone's encryption is one step away from taking away everyone's guns". Then see how that plays out with their constituents.
- t0ddbonzalez 7y agoA predictable call to arms - only criminals use encryption, right? The Four Horsemen of the Infocalypse: terrorists, pedophiles, drug dealers and money launderers https://firstmonday.org/ojs/index.php/fm/article/view/1999/1874 https://firstmonday.org/ojs/index.php/fm/article/view/1999/1...
- rootsudo 7y agoIf it wasn't already posted: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Horsemen_of_the_Infocalypse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Four_Horsemen_of_the_Infocalyp...
- turc1656 7y agoI love how governments love to pretend that either none of these crimes happened prior to the digital communication age or that they never caught anyone prior to it (which they definitely did). Let's also take a step back and consider the series of events and how this would play into that. Under normal circumstances, you need a warrant/reason to look at such data and communications. The theory here is that if they could decrypt everything that would make their job much easier. Fair point. But in the world 20-30 years ago these tools never existed so there was no such communication to capture. Which means the evidence was non-existent. Yet, through other means of investigation they were able to identify and gather evidence against these criminals and prosecute them. How did they do that? It's because these are real world crimes (meaning not purely residing in the digital world) so there is real world evidence to be gathered. And all the other methods they have without decrypting data still applies. That can mean tracking credit card charges, phone calls, cell tower pings, etc, etc. As we know, they can build out quite a substantial profile of a criminal network in that manner. They can correlate all sorts of things and gather insights into the data. This is just government pulling a classic fear-mongering bullshit tactic wrapped in a "think about the children!" plea to simply make their lives easier while simultaneously trying to whittle down our privacy rights even further.
- tehjoker 7y agoWe need to solve child porn, but law enforcement always uses this example when talking about encryption to help us forget that the state is the enemy. When people start demanding concessions from the state in the midst of an economic crisis, the state will use its powers to suppress protests and ensure wealth continues to concentrate in the upper strata. We see this in revolutions all over the world at this very moment. The state is dangerous and the police are not to be trusted in this way. The police stand against a democratic and equitable society. We must never forget this.
- aussiegreenie 7y agoI always like to quote the Golden Thread of British Justice, "It is better ten guilty men go free than one innocent man goes to jail"
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- prirun 7y agoIMO, the reason they always use the child abuse excuse for encryption backdoors is evident in this thread discussion. Nearly all people are against child abuse / porn. But if a person says "I'm not willing to give up secure encryption worldwide just because it is used for child abuse / porn", a pile of people will say "It's not acceptable for one child to be abused!" Of course it's not acceptable. But should everyone in the entire world lose their privacy, even if it eliminated all child abuse, which obviously it won't? To me, these encryption backdoor ideas are rarely about law enforcement. They are about people in power wanting to maintain and extend their power. Criminals who want to use unbreakable encryption will always have easy access to it because encryption is an easy technology that anyone can use. Governments can make whatever laws they want, but it will mainly affect law-abiding citizens. The criminals will just ignore them, as always. The people pushing this backdoor encryption agenda are not stupid. They know that criminals will ignore these new backdoor rules, which is why I believe it is really about power, not child porn.
- lunias 7y agoThis ask presupposes a huge amount of trust which simply isn't justified considering the history of governments. I prefer my trust to be guaranteed; with like, y'know, cryptography.
- pacifika 7y agoOn the other land, do you want to live in a lawless society where there is freedom but no personal safety, and why would the internet be any different in that regard? The assumption is to let law enforcement do their job with safeguards in place to prevent overreach. The tech community are in a good position to monitor overreach and provide transparency, right?