11 ms·
We’re Rewarding the Question Askers
- andrewstuart 7y agoThe biggest problem is downvoting. Downvoting is toxic. A better change would have been to make any downvote COST 10 points. Or at least 1 point or 2.
- CharlesColeman 7y ago> The biggest problem is downvoting. > Downvoting is toxic. I disagree. Ignoring SO's dubious classifications of what's on/off-topic. The last couple questions I've posted have been shit-shows of off-topic comments and answers. If you ask a hard question, a lot of people seem to only want to uselessly question what you're doing then answer a different, easier question. Those are totally worthless, and force me to waste a lot of time writing really defensive questions that try to nip the derails in the bud. Honestly, SO should have some feature where the asker can just delete responses as off-topic. > A better change would have been to make any downvote COST 10 points. Or at least 1 point or 2. IIRC, it already costs 1 karma point to downvote an answer. I would guess it's the same for a question.
- james-skemp 7y agoIt did cost points to downvote questions, but they rolled that back (seemingly 2011): - https://stackoverflow.com/help/privileges/vote-down https://stackoverflow.com/help/privileges/vote-down - https://stackoverflow.blog/2011/06/13/optimizing-for-pearls-not-sand/ https://stackoverflow.blog/2011/06/13/optimizing-for-pearls-...
- KKPMW 7y agoI would urge you, or anyone who thinks that downvoting is toxic for this matter, to volunteer in moderating questions written by new users for a day or two. Once you see a constant flood of "I made app, here my 1000 lines of code (screenshot), I get error, where bug?" that the moderators have to defend the site against - you might just change your opinion about the value of downvotes.
- andrewstuart 7y agoI'm not saying there should not be a mechanism for regulating that sort of stuff. BUT on StackOverflow it is entirely normal, even expected, that you post a well thought out and reasoned question and its instantly downvoted because, well, who knows why? Drive-by downvoting is simply negative. A different mechanism could be used for the sorts of issues you identify.
- jasode 7y ago>A different mechanism could be used for the sorts of issues you identify. Would the new proposed mechanism require more volunteer work or the same effort as now? Btw, many people forget that back in 2011, Jeff Atwood was concerned that there was too much crap and the community was not downvoting enough. Therefore, he removed the points penalty to encourage the community to aggressively downvote more: https://stackoverflow.blog/2011/06/13/optimizing-for-pearls-not-sand/ https://stackoverflow.blog/2011/06/13/optimizing-for-pearls-...
- thrower123 7y agoIs this really the common behavior? I feel like I live in a different world... Maybe I do; I don't ask a ton of questions, and when I do they are usually on pretty small niche tags, but the last several times I've asked something, I've wound up with a friendly soul suggest something within an hour or two that's gotten me pointed in the right direction.
- triceratops 7y agoWhat if downvoting required leaving an anonymized comment?
- Ajedi32 7y agoCan you point to an example of a "well thought out and reasoned question" on SO that's at a negative score? In my experience, that just doesn't happen. Most questions sit at a score of 0, and those which do receive votes are almost always upvoted. (The data supports this[1].) Questions rarely end up with a negative score, and when they do it's usually because there are obvious problems with their formatting or content. (Usually low effort, off topic, or an obvious duplicate.) [1]: https://data.stackexchange.com/stackoverflow/query/1096887/question-score-frequency-whole-site#resultSets https://data.stackexchange.com/stackoverflow/query/1096887/q...
- jerrac 7y agoAgreed. Down voting is toxic. Though, rather than costing points, I'd prefer to see the voter required to explain why they are down voting. As small as it is, a down vote is a public action saying that the person posting what you are voting on has less value. At least that what they said has less value. That is never a fun experience, even if you have very thick skin.
- gwbas1c 7y agoI always explain why I downvote, unless there already is a clear explanation. Why do I downvote? I downvote when an answer is wrong or outdated. That's the point of downvotes, to push incorrect or outdated answers to the bottom.
- jerrac 7y agoGood. I'm glad you explain. That doesn't make it any less of a public reprimand. In polite society, when you reprimand someone publicly, you only do so when private discussions have failed. I'd also argue using down votes for outdated information is very inefficient. Wouldn't it make sense to just have a "this is out dated" flag, and list how many people have used it? Then, the author of the answer could update their post and ask that the flag be cleared. For wrong answers, I'd say a comment "this is wrong because" first, then something other than down voting.
- dkersten 7y ago> I'd say a comment "this is wrong because" first, then something other than down voting. I guess its just as much a signal to people looking for an answer as it is for the person who wrote the answer. At least with a downvoted answer, its easy to see "ok, maybe not this one" and you can check the comments to see why. Not that I'm a fan of downvoting, I think a flagging system would achieve the same thing while being more helpful to all involved than an opaque downvote.
- papln 7y agoSO is a crowd-sourced FAQ, not a conversation forum.
- WatchDog 7y agoIt already does cost a point. SO heavily encourages leaving constructive feedback rather than simply downvoting.
- leepowers 7y agoIt's hard to be the recipient of downvotes. At the same time it's a great tool for assessing the quality of posts. It's the same reason HN allows downvotes. However the dynamic of SO is different. Users are coming to the site to get help and solve problems, not to have open-ended discussions. SO should have a grace period for new questions. No downvotes during the first 1-2 hours. Aside from being less discouraging for new users it would also mitigate cases of incorrect downvoting. A negative score is a signal to other users that a question is not worth consideration, and dissuades possible answerers from providing a solution.
- papln 7y agoA simple solution is to count downvotes but truncate the UI to 0. That way you don't get the ego sting of a negative score.
- the_jeremy 7y agoThe problem is that people have different ideas of what a downvote means. To someone who has spent a ton of time answering questions, it means "this is not a well-written question and I do not have the time to explain to the poster why that is; I would rather spend my time on answering well-written questions, which is what I came to this site to do." To a question asker, it means "you suck and I hate your question, and I'm not going to tell you why." The problem is that there are a couple of mechanisms for getting rid of questions - downvoting, or flagging / voting to close. Some questions are clearly on the wrong site - just close them. Some questions are not good questions (screenshots of code, no explanation of desired behavior, no research done into error message) but they are not closeable according to the options provided. The downvote is just to send a message. Answerers who downvote are people who genuinely want to help - they are spending their free time answering questions on the internet for no gain other than extremely localized imaginary internet points. The solution is providing one method of feedback to the question poster, and couching it in a less negative way. Maybe all methods have the asker's feedback get hit, maybe none of them. Maybe the asker should be protected from feedback until they learn the site. Asking technical questions properly is hard. I got downvoted and closed and duplicate questions on my first 5 attempts, and even my recent questions have 0-1 upvotes (my answers fare better, for whatever reason).
- BeetleB 7y ago> Answerers who downvote are people who genuinely want to help - they are spending their free time answering questions on the internet for no gain other than extremely localized imaginary internet points. I think it's more accurate to say that answerers who downvote want to give answers (vs genuinely want to help). Because explaining to someone why their question is problematic is part of helping.
- KKPMW 7y agoThis is more nuanced. And StackOverflow as a website themselves are part to blame. They cannot seem to make up their mind if they are there to help the people who ask questions, or if their task is to construct a database of problem-answer pairs for future reference, like a type of programming encyclopedia. For the longest time everyone on the site believed it to be the "database" model. And helping individual users with their questions is not part of it. Under this framework answerers who downvote are simply doing what they are expected to do - weeding out poor entries from the encyclopedia. And the person who asks a question has no right to expect an answer, as stated in their 2011 blog entry: > We believe asking questions on our site is a privilege, not a right. [1] However recently they seem to be moving away from that model and only time will tell what it morphs in to. [1] https://stackoverflow.blog/2011/06/13/optimizing-for-pearls-not-sand/ https://stackoverflow.blog/2011/06/13/optimizing-for-pearls-...
- LanceH 7y agoI find this is true on questions with the Go tag. They can't seem to let a question languish at zero. Or just downvote it once to -1, they have to hammer it. Upvotes are rare, so on balance the entire page of go questions frequently has a negative balance. For a great many tags, it seems like there is a sport to show that a question doesn't apply to a specific tag, that it is a duplicate, or that the user should be doing something a different way than what they are asking for. There seems to be so much effort put into deliberately not answering the question that trying to participate is truly deflating.
- chapium 7y agoAs an experiment downvoting is disabled on some smaller reddit subs. The effect in the gaming /hobbiest communities is they get overrun with memes and content designed to get a reaction. Theres an overwhelming number of readers who never participate in discussions but will upvote the most mindless stuff. You can see consensus in a forum that few enjoy the content, yet it gets strongly upvoted if unchecked.
- FooHentai 7y ago>Downvoting is toxic Can you elaborate? It's difficult to agree or disagree since I can't tell what you have in mind. What does 'Toxic' mean to you in this context?
- james-skemp 7y agoAs meta visibility on SO is hit-or-miss, the thread on meta is at https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/391250/upvotes-on-questions-will-now-be-worth-the-same-as-upvotes-on-answers https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/391250/upvotes-on-q...
- ebg13 7y agoI predict that this will have zero effect on anything. The people who care strongly about accumulating SO e-points are the ones answering the questions, not the ones asking them.
- variaga 7y agoSO has always been hostile to questioners by design. It's a natural consequence of requiring "high-quality" questions. Since most questions will not be "high-quality" (for any reasonable definition of "high-quality"), most new participants' experience will be of asking a question and being told "that's a bad question" either explicitly (downvotes) or implicitly (editing their question to "improve" it). It gets worse as time goes on because of the "no duplicates" policy; the more questions that are in the system, the harder it is to come up with a question that isn't marked (correctly or incorrectly) as a dupe. Banning all politeness words (hello/goodbye/please/thank you/you're welcome) from questions/answers because they're "noise" is just the cherry on top that makes people who aren't already immersed in SO culture think that everybody there is rude/mean, no matter how many times they put "be nice" in the CoC. Not saying these are _bad_ policies per se - SO has a stated goal of being a "curated resource of high quality questions and answers", and they need to separate the wheat from the chaff somehow, but the policies _will_ be perceived as hostile by most new users. Giving the questioners an extra +5 fake internet points will not fix any of that.
- Bnshsysjab 7y agoYou just summarised how I feel whenever I ask a stackoverflow question. I wasn’t aware that politeness was banned but I avoid asking questions there even if it means joining free node channels and waiting hours in hopes that someone answers my question. S/O has some very high quality responses but I actively avoid asking questions there because it feels over policed.
- a3n 7y ago> It gets worse as time goes on because of the "no duplicates" policy; the more questions that are in the system, the harder it is to come up with a question that isn't marked (correctly or incorrectly) as a dupe. I'm curious why they don't have a no duplicate answers policy.
- SnarkAsh 7y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20191105161629/https://meta.stackexchange.com/questions/337604/stack-exchange-is-planning-to-retroactively-change-the-vote-value-on-questio https://web.archive.org/web/20191105161629/https://meta.stac... > We know that people who contribute by asking have a harder time earning privileges than people who focus on answering. Independent research suggests this disproportionately affects women: > > We also see that women contribute differently to building the community’s knowledge base: they are asking more questions. Stack Overflow’s current system strongly incentivize answering by rewarding upvotes on answers twice as much upvotes on questions.
- the_jeremy 7y agoThis is a waste. Few people upvote questions because they are well-written; by and large it is that they had the same question and you asked it before they had to do so themselves. This heavily biases upvotes on extremely novice questions from 8 years ago (before they were all asked), and gives new question askers a bad example of what a good question is ("I just did the same thing this person did, and they got 200 upvotes, and my question was closed in 2 minutes!"). Question askers get the reward of having their question answered. I think votes on questions should be done away with entirely. Questions that should be exemplified can have some other metric (stars for "this is well written and generalizes easily for other users"), and low-quality questions should be flagged or closed, which at least gives some sort of reason. Downvotes aren't useful to askers because they have no idea what they're doing wrong when they receive them.
- tenebrisalietum 7y agoKeeping the participation friction as low as possible ensures the maximum number participate, which ensures questions have maximum visibility. Changing the simple vote up/down process with something requiring to specify a reason can reduce the number views a question gets. Also nothing is stopping a downvoter from leaving a comment explaining why the question needs improvement, other than lack of reputation (you need a minimum reputation for your downvotes to be visible anyway). People who care to explain their downvotes can already use the existing process. Since comments can be upvoted (but not downvoted), there is already an incentive in place for that as well.
- yabadabadoes 7y agoMany people mention they avoid commenting on downvoted questions for fear of the wrath of the asker. People seem to feel differently about close voting, perhaps since they are collected and presented as a group. I don't really get the point of the vigilance toward bad but not intentionally spam questions. The question # has been used, derank it and call it a day until someone sees a reason to revive it.or the asker ASKS for help improving their question.
- 7y ago
- seph-reed 7y agoI've tried saying it on Meta, but that place is not great for discussion: Newbies should help newbies. There are lots of ways to incentivize this, but the basic gist is that users who are just growing out of the newbie phase are in the best position to be indoctrinating new arrivals. They'll have the most patience and understanding, and it's an easy job that shouldn't be done by super experienced users. Most of this could easily be isolated to a newbie pre-stage too. Basically, a tutorial area in which new users work together to make their questions better so they can move on to the non-tutorial experience. Personally, I'd filter these posts out by default, but on days where I was feeling nice I might go in and help out. Worst case scenario: it takes some extra work from a newbie to get their first bits of rep.
- dsr_ 7y agoRewarding the question askers... like Monica Cellio, who asked a clarifying question about the not-yet-implemented pronoun policy, and you canned her for it? That sort of reward?
- EpicEng 7y agoWow did that send me down a rabbit hole. I had no idea. I used to be pretty active on SO, but not for a few years now. This would have done it for me.
- chowells 7y agoWhy do you think she's telling the truth? Have you talked to any mods who think stackoverflow made the right choice, but way too late? I have. They say her behavior from start to finish was incredibly rude and explicit in stating her plans to ignore the policy.
- gjm11 7y agoIf they say that, in that way, then they are being misleading. Months ago, well before the current Stack Exchange pronoun policy was a thing, she said (yes, explicitly) that she wasn't willing to use singular "they" because it feels so wrong and confusing to her. This wasn't a "plan to ignore the policy" because at that time there was no policy. (It also doesn't appear to have been motivated by sexism, transphobia, etc., although people who say such things sometimes are; she is explicitly willing to use neopronouns -- "xe" and the like -- for people who find that "he" and "she" don't fit them.) Then, much more recently, the upcoming change to the Code of Conduct was announced in the moderators' chatroom. M.C. asked some questions about that, very definitely did not state any plan to ignore the policy, and promptly got de-moderator-ated. It's possible that she isn't telling the truth about what has happened in private, away from the view of other moderators. Maybe she sent an email to SE management saying "I'm not going to abide by this; fire me if you dare" or something. But as far as externally-visible things are concerned, her account of things matches up better with reality than SE's statements do. There are, indeed, moderators who think M.C. should have been canned long ago, but my impression is that there's something close to unanimity that SE should not have canned her the way they did, and that the majority of those with any opinion on the matter think that they shouldn't have canned her at all. (Source: am a moderator on a Stack Exchange site, have read all the relevant transcripts from said chatroom. Note that discussions there are confidential, so the above is about as specific as I am prepared to be about who said what.)
- ddingus 7y agoQuora did this and the outcome was awesome, click bait type questions. And a ton of them. Net value loss.
- unionpivo 7y agoBut I bet their traffic increased. I see quora often in searches. I might be pessimists but I think they knew exactly what they were doing and are happy with results. And I am guessing new SO leadership wants the same.
- ddingus 7y agoI am sure they are quite happy. Users? Not so much. Getting at great contributions is now much harder. I use Quora much less now. Churn 'n burn for traffic dollars is a strategy. Suppose it opens a door somewhere too. Do that enough, and there is clearly room for a less noise filled source. IMHO, the difference here is Quora has a plausible, casual user case that makes sense. The people who helped to build Quora content won't give two shits and will move on, but Quora itself may do just fine. Meh. Degrading the value to current users of SO to attract more in general, leads where for SO?
- whoisterencelee 7y agoIt might be better to allow the market to decide how the reward mechanism should work. People who see a question as relevant and interesting to them, would add points or monetary incentives. Thereby increasing the speed and quality of the answers. This mechanism has already been tested out and actually works only with crypto currency due to low transaction costs. Better explained 2 mins video: https://youtu.be/lcsgx_5c7D0 https://youtu.be/lcsgx_5c7D0 Here is an example: What makes you nostalgic? Answer with #Obyte Know-it-all and earn up to 410,172,272 Bytes : https://t.co/EaVFrscFC7 https://t.co/EaVFrscFC7 (enough Bytes to make > 700,000 transactions whenever you want in the future thanks to obytes' tiny predictable fees)
- ilaksh 7y agoThat's awesome and its a step in the right direction. And I notice a lot of female employees or managers being mentioned which might be a coincidence but it also might be deliberate and somehow be related to the idea that females might have more empathy? Which could just be my own prejudice and not true but I dunno. But anyway, if they are going for nicer/more empathetic employees and policies, that's great, but its not going to stop all of the (mostly male) super-critical narcissistic arrogant shaming-happy vote-whores who are eagerly waiting to get in another passive-aggressive veiled hint that I am an idiot while they downvote my question. Not planning to ask another question on Stack Overflow anytime soon, thanks though.
- JohnFen 7y agoInteresting. I've never asked or answered a question on SO (I wouldn't dare!) because I can plainly see the horrorshow that is likely to come with doing that by reading other questions. Over time, I've come to simply ignoring SO for the most part. I think I may check in from time to time to see if the place actually improves.
- ShteiLoups 7y agoIt is funny that we have the "techies" (programmers, engineers, etc) designing and managing these social media platforms when the techies are stereotyped as awkward and antisocial. Who decided that software developers should have the final say over how people interact? I feel like there's probably a field or two of experts on that that should be being consulted.
- fenomas 7y agoWhen one considers that the median experience of asking a question on stackoverflow is "immediately closed as a duplicate of a vaguely similar question from six years ago", this seems like a pretty superfluous change. A far more meaningful way to reward askers would be to simply change how dupes are handled. Instead of closing questions with a link to a related question, give users a mechanism to answer questions with a link to a related answer. Then if the link really does solve the problem the asker can accept that answer, and if not the original question can stay open. I get why SO chose their current aggressive stance on dupes, but it's probably time to try something else.
- eitland 7y ago> I get why SO chose their current aggressive stance on dupes, but it's probably time to try something else. Work is under way here and elsewhere: https://forum.codidact.org/ https://forum.codidact.org/ Based on my past actions I guess I would be happy to donate a few dollars to anyone who makes a better q/a site and makes me aware of it. By better I mean: - important current database (allowed with current licensing) - rewrites the meta game to make helping (answering) more valuable than administering (deleting). - raises bar to asking questions (stack overflow seems to always be crying over all the stupid questions they get yet the thought of raising the bar for asking questions never seen to get any traction) - have a karma tax or something on questions and contributors: just because someone was the most valuable contributor or something was the best question two years ago doesn't mean they still are. - don't split into many subsites for every topic, if people want to ask it and other people want to answer it and it isn't illegal or scary or anything, bust leave it alone. Karma tax will take care of it in the long run.
- killface 7y agowow, what a great way to completely avoid the massive controversy they've been trying to sweep under the rug for a couple months now.
- monksy 7y agoI'm still going to complain and not use the service. (I wrote the article a while ago: https://theexceptioncatcher.com/blog/2012/09/stackoverflow-is-a-difficult-community-to-participate-in/ https://theexceptioncatcher.com/blog/2012/09/stackoverflow-i... ) [Which was after the first recalc] It took them 7 years to change their minds on it. Sigh. --- Side rant: This whole piss people off/break things and expect people to stick around is a dumb idea. Company does stupid things, I'm going to find an alternative company and not return.
- reportgunner 7y agoThis makes me feel like it's a beginning of the end. It is beyond me why they would want to award spammers for creating more spam.