5 ms·
Interesting finding, but the headline doesn’t quite match the study. They didn’t find that chronic adversity dampens dopamine production in general, nor did the
by PragmaticPulp 7y ago
Interesting finding, but the headline doesn’t quite match the study. They didn’t find that chronic adversity dampens dopamine production in general, nor did they find that the stressed individuals had less dopamine than their unstressed peers per se. They only discovered that dopamine production differed between the two groups in response to a specific stressful task.
In other words, the chronically stressed individuals had a different response to stress, which involved less dopamine production than that of their less stressed peers. It’s not clear how much of this is actually a negative adaption, as opposed to just being a different way of responding.
It’s also important to consider the context provided by the researchers in the article:
“This study can’t prove that chronic psychosocial stress
causes mental illness or substance abuse later in life by
lowering dopamine levels,” Dr Bloomfield cautions. “But we
have provided a plausible mechanism for how chronic stress
may increase the risk of mental illnesses by altering the
brain’s dopamine system.”
With studies like this, it’s important to avoid the knee-jerk reaction that you might need “more dopamine”. More is not always better, and we have decades of research demonstrating that dopaminergic drugs are not great antidepressants. When considering your own treatment programs, it’s important to focus on evidence-based medicine and proven, sustainable treatments and therapies.
- c3534l 7y agoMeasuring dopamine is a bit like measuring a person's heart rate. It could indicate fear, or it could indicate sexual arousal, too much coffee, or some other medical condition. People like to say things like "seratonin is the drug that makes you happy," or "oxytocin is the drug that makes you feel love," or "dopamine is the brain's reward mechanism," but those statements are simplified to the point of being wrong. This study is still pretty cool though, because it does point us in a general direction. It can help explain why some mental illnesses like schizophrenia have strong genetic components, yet also environmental factors like childhood abuse. As you said, the reduced dopamine could be a good thing. But maybe in a genetic minority it creates a neuro-chemical downward spiral. Maybe we could prevent the development of schizophrenia by prescribing medication following trauma. Who knows. It opens a lot of doors.
- ianai 7y agoMeds and, you know, talking to them for longer, more often, at earlier stages.
- apatters 7y agoSure. But the issue that needs to be solved with talking therapies is, how do you scale them? Talking to a psychologist starts at $200/hr and the farther you go down the ladder in terms of qualifications the lower the success rate of the therapy. Not everyone can afford this, whereas pills can actually be covered by insurance.
- fsloth 7y agoYeah, you definitely want a qualified therapist. As soon as you are facing individuals who are basing their help merely on intuition and life experience you are statistically on a really thin ice. And even qualified people can be dead wrong. For example it's really hard to find competent help for adult high-functioning asperger spectrum depression patients (I've witnessed this).
- krageon 7y agoIf not everyone can afford proper care, that's a problem that you need to solve in the system that is obviously failing them. Talking therapies already scale just fine, as you say the therapist is paid well and the people that actually need them are a vast minority. If they become the vast majority (where you would actually need to scale), something is systematically wrong somewhere else and that needs to be addressed outside of therapy.
- apatters 7y agoAre they really a vast minority? The statistics here are interesting: https://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/statistics/major-depression.shtml https://www.nimh.nih.gov/health/statistics/major-depression.... About 17M adult Americans have had one or more major depressive episodes. 35% of them received no treatment at all. That's just the numbers for depression, let alone other disorders. The pills can treat symptoms but they don't resolve the root causes of the disorders. I think there are a lot of people out there who would benefit from more or better treatment but the latent demand greatly outweighs the supply.
- duahncjak 7y agoAnother interpretation of this data would be that causality runs in the other direction. You can also make up a plausible-sounding story for the mechanism - a dopamine response to stressful situations helps people solve their problems.
- jotakami 7y agoThis is what I was thinking, since there is probably a strong genetic component to an individual’s dopamine production and response profile. As someone who lived most of my life with undiagnosed ADHD and just recently started taking stimulants for treatment, I can attest that normal life issues which once seemed like arduous mountains to climb are now summarily dispatched before lunchtime when I have a dopamine boost. It’s shocking how effective the medication is, side effects notwithstanding.
- steve_adams_86 7y agoI'm right there with you. 5mg of dextroamphetamine and I'm golden for 5 hours. 10mg of the slow release and it'll last enough of a day that I don't really experience my symptoms throughout the day. I wish I found this 20 years ago. Simple things like keeping my house clean are no longer a planned, forced, prolonged effort. It just happens. I'm happy for you the you made the discovery and found treatment. It's wild how subversive and destructive it can be.
- pitaj 7y agoPlease don't quote with code blocks. Requoted: > “This study can’t prove that chronic psychosocial stress causes mental illness or substance abuse later in life by lowering dopamine levels,” Dr Bloomfield cautions. “But we have provided a plausible mechanism for how chronic stress may increase the risk of mental illnesses by altering the brain’s dopamine system.”
- afpx 7y agoFYI dopamine works well for treating bipolar depression. A google scholar search for “bipolar depression” and amphetamine will show references.
- choppaface 7y agoIt would be interesting if they had studied norepinephrine and seretonin levels too. Could it be that the group with chronic adversity simply were less aroused overall with the stress of the arithmetic challenges? Also, did task performance differ between the two groups? Agree that the connection between adversity and dopamine production isn't so clear in this paper.
- Angostura 7y agoI think the headline's fine actually. It doesn't say there is any general reduction, rather that there is a 'dampening'. That rather implies a change in response to a stimulus .
- _0ffh 7y agoSounds like a habituation result, nothing surprising, but still possibly significant.