18 ms·
Why the Government Isn't a Bigger Version of a Startup
- SQueeeeeL 7y agoI don't really understand the argument, most startups explicitly have a goal/off ramp. The government is the exact opposite in terms of goals...
- deadmetheny 7y agoExternally funded by deep pockets and primarily created to make a small group of people extremely rich at the expense of everyone else? Oh, wait.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- mturmon 7y agoThis is a weird article. The author has plenty of background and standing to comment on the topic. But he's leaving out that many of the problems the government seeks to address are bigger than what a "startup" (his word) would ever address. A better comparison might be between governments and very large-scale enterprises -- not startups. A lot of his words have to do with software, when typically the problems governments address have to do with (in increasing order of difficulty) hardware, big infrastructure, or society, or other societies. The startup/government comparison is not parallel for other reasons too -- and it's exhausting to enumerate!
- ianai 7y agoIt’s a weird topic but the claim to run a government like a business is rampant and needs to be corrected.
- godelski 7y agoI mean it almost makes sense if the purpose of the company is to make it's employees richer, happier, and overall have a better life. And if you consider that ROIs that take decades or a century are still profitable. But I'm not sure of any company that operates this way because how can your product be employee well being?
- tlb 7y agoNobody's talking about the whole government being a startup. He's saying that government agencies can't be run like a startup. As far as scale goes, many government agencies are smaller than many successful startups.
- jonawesomegreen 7y ago> The government isn’t a bigger version of a startup and can’t act like a startup does. Innovation activities in government agencies most often result in innovation theater. While these activities shape and build culture, they don’t win wars, and rarely deliver shippable or deployable products. > The very definition of a contractor implies a contract. And a government contract starts with fixed requirements that only change with contract modifications. That makes sense when the problem and solution are known. But when they are unknown the traditional methods of contracting fail. This I think is the biggest failure in public private partnerships. These arrangements were supposed to save the taxpayer money by allowing nimble contractors to come in and do the heavy lifting on projects. However what it really did is: 1) Create an adversarial relationship between between the government and the contracting entity, which is very much filled with even more red tape then it was were trying to replace. 2) Hollow out the talent in the government, causing more reliance on the private sector. I'm not convinced these relationships can exist in a healthy way. If there isn't a lot of red tape and strict contracts then it's likely the government will get robbed blind and that leads to stricter contracts and more red tape: a virtuous cycle of red tape and lack of progress. I think less emphases needs to be put on these partnerships and more on developing talent within the government that can innovate from within. This creates the possibility of empowered leaders within government departments that can run projects like agile mini-startups.
- luckydata 7y agoyou hit the nail in the head. Innovation cannot be contracted, it needs to be nurtured from the inside. I think a better model for that would be a professional, long term version of Code for America.
- sailfast 7y agoFor what it's worth (to the initial quotes posted) there are plenty of options in the FAR and on existing contract vehicles to hire people with particular sets of skills to achieve a general goal / purpose of the organization "and other duties" that will allow you to contract flexible skills that you can direct as needed. To your last point - I agree there is a lot of red tape. This needs to improve but it's also there for protection. At a minimum, updating the GS scale / hiring authorities to ensure that the right expertise can be hired at competitive rates to effectively manage and guide contractual expertise is a MUST. Right now, program officers may not even have the expertise / in-house resources to understand whether the work being done / reported is going to achieve their contract objective, and they might be relying on contractor project managers to translate. (Sometimes from the same company!) so checks are hard to come by and it's all very inefficient. To do this effectively you have to be able to hire folks that know, to create a culture around the effort at the agency so they can bring contractors on as true partners that understand the way the agency does business (norms, engineering standards, reporting, etc) - this goes a long way to ensuring objectives are met and real work is getting done.
- adamnemecek 7y agoSo much of the government (and other things, insurance, driver's license, any sort of interaction between two parties) would be solved with some programmable UUID. Essentially, I want a thing where I issue a new UUID (communication channel) for every party I'm interacting with, I can revoke these, redirect these, renew these at my convenience. So much of clerical work is literally double checking forms. I want to fill out one for, the other parties can then request my info.
- firasd 7y agoThis sounds a bit like the Aadhaar system here in India (I can open a bank account without filling out any new forms, just using a finger print reader).. I would say be careful what you wish for; this lays the grounds for a surveillance state.
- adamnemecek 7y agoNot quite. With aadhaar, you don't see the data the state has access to. I'm very much concerned with the surveillance however as they say, good fences make good neighbors.
- thephyber 7y ago> this lays the grounds for a surveillance state We already have a surveillance state in the USA without the convenience of good digital authentication with tokenized opt-in data-access authentications, as described by GP. I'd rather have the benefits of a more mature authentication system. We in the USA pass around 3-4 strings (Social Security ID, Full Name, Date of Birth, Mother's Maiden Name, sometimes Street Address and/or Zip Code) and that is used as a proxy for Authorization (not even authentication). It's ridiculously easy to get defrauded of your entire life savings (or more) in the US because knowledge of those strings (and sometimes a few more) is enough to someone to get access to a loan, mortgage, a cell phone (possibly porting/transferring from your existing SIM/line) in my name.
- ISL 7y agoAs a physicist who is looking for a job, the primary things preventing me from working on defense projects are twofold: 1. Defense systems are, in general, useful for offense. Unless I can know that the primary utility of an innovation is for good, I cannot work on it. Our only control in the matter is our choice of which innovations to make. I was heartbroken the day I saw a citation of my work in a military application, as it was never the intent of the work. I'll do nuclear non-proliferation work all day, but won't touch a system that can kill another human unless we are at war. Humans are really, really good at killing one another -- we don't need to get better at that. 2. Defense projects are classified, and classification is the antithesis of science.
- kube-system 7y agoOffensive capabilities aren't linearly related with human death and suffering. It's not even clear whether the relationship is positive or negative.[0] Have you considered the possibility that your work could potentially create a net-benefit to humanity by keeping world powers in a state of Nash-equilibrium/MAD? [0]: https://ourworldindata.org/uploads/2018/09/Bubble-and-lines-FINAL-03.png https://ourworldindata.org/uploads/2018/09/Bubble-and-lines-...
- ISL 7y agoYep, sure is possible. But all it takes is one unstable leader, or the failing of governmental structures designed to promote stability, or a few flaky sensors erroneously claiming a nuclear attack, and the meta-stability of MAD can tunnel to the true potential minimum, where nobody can wage war because we're all dead. The modern world is unaware of how terrible major wars and nuclear weapons can be, because we are now generations removed from the experience. I fear that we are poised to re-learn some of those lessons. Circling back: Yep, sure is possible, but I'm not going to work on weapons systems unless we are at war. I'd rather work on the education and science needed to help everyone respect one another and lead healthier lives. I've only got one life and don't want to spend it building systems that might end others' lives more-efficiently.
- adamsea 7y agoI think its more about what do you want to leave behind you ....sure, a given defense technical discovery or innovation may, in the right circumstances, used by the right people, prevent suffering, but, if your goal is to help others it seems a lot more direct to be a teacher, or a doctor, etc.
- joshypants 7y agoctrl-f "profit motive" - 0 results
- tehjoker 7y agoctrl-f "democracy" - 0 results
- Spooky23 7y agoI've worked in government, late startup and corporate roles. There isn't anything fundamentally broken about government. The difference is operate vs. build. Government is usually optimized around operational activity, and it usually does so very well from the perspective of how the organization is designed. Things get weird because priorities are driven by external mandate. DMV issues licenses, taxes are collected, social services are delivered. The downside of scaled operations is that changes are difficult and expensive. The exception is when there is growth -- the government is good at borrowing money and good at building stuff. Large corporations aren't that much different. If anything, the average medium/large corporation has fewer controls and is less competent at a given task that a .gov organization would be, but delivers each marginal task at a lower cost and less red tape. (aka compliance requirements) Startups are different. They are built to build and tend to do the minimum viable activity and are usually a big mess operationally.
- xkde 7y ago> the government is good at borrowing money and good at building stuff MNLARS: “Hold my beer.”
- chongli 7y agoI think where people get frustrated about government is that they expect it to respond to changes in society and technology. They see inertia and think inefficiency. I think that’s missing the point entirely. What governments offer is stability. “Inertia” is a feature. If governments swung around rapidly the way tech trends change then it would cause tremendous damage to people’s lives and to the economy as a whole.
- seph-reed 7y agoWell, it's not a zero sum thing. Backwards compatibility can mean stability without inertia. We can get pretty much all the best features from start-ups, gov, capitalism, and socialism at the same time. Too often we focus on the outsides of a venn diagram, and fail to invest proper effort where the overlap is. IMO, the part in the middle done well is more than enough for a good world, and the bits on the outside are just flavors.
- FooHentai 7y agoI've worked in both the public and private sector, albeit not in the USA. The simplest and biggest difference between public and private sector organisations is their motive: Private sector makes money. Public sector avoids being front page of the news. The behavior of each organisation often maps directly to these motives (albeit also, sometimes, perversely). Secondary to that you have the fact that startups (and other private-sector organisations) fail and disappear all the time. Public-sector organisation's are enduring. If your defense force screws up and waste 100 billion dollars, there will still be a defense force the next day. This explains differing priorities around enduring, consistent activity and focus where in the private sector you might see full-blown pivots. I like some of the stuff in the article's table but some of it is presented as a bit more immutable than is the case in reality. For example, fixed requirements on government projects versus agile/testing/story/feedback based delivery? Not true as a rule, lots of that kind of thing happening in the public sector. But fair as a broad generalization.
- sailfast 7y ago> So, the question is: What’s next? How do leaders in government think about and organize innovation in a way that makes a difference? The answer here for me is to create a culture of experimentation and hypothesis testing whose results can be rapidly incorporated into the operations of the agency. Allow for testing off the critical path. Allow for smaller-scale experimentation to prove a concept that has an on-ramp into your day-to-day operations This works for technology approaches, this works for regulatory approaches - it even works for opt-in citizen services IF you create the framework that supports it. (Director signs paper saying citizens can opt-in to test practices and those that do have X rights in the normal process, get the language cleared by legal, and you've got something that can last for a bunch of use cases) Reduce the burden to get something started at a low level when your staff know it's a better way. Continue to reach out to line employees to ask what they would like to try out / attempt to make the organization better. So much of government stagnation is the sheer burden of getting any sort of experiment approved / blessed, so you miss out on what's already in the building, let alone what can be gotten from outside. Maybe what I'm describing is "lean enterprise" type stuff. As for Why Government Isn't a Startup and the original premise. Well... why isn't IBM a bigger version of a startup? Imagine dealing with all of the cruft ever written by congress since the formation of the country as your basis for operation. :)
- purplezooey 7y agowhy should we listen to this dude... a lot of off-base speculation in there
- empath75 7y agoI was on an agile team for a government project and one of the other people on a team made the observation that agile is about people over process and government is about process over people and I don’t think people would prefer government to work the other way.
- ChrisMarshallNY 7y agoThis is a great article. I've worked for defense contractors, but most of my time has been spent at a very conservative, results-driven, constantly-in-ship-mode commercial corporation. It has taught me to make software that actually works; not software that looks like it works. I don't give pitches; I give demos. I quickly learned to never try selling a pig in a poke. It had better work. The problem with that, is that it takes more work and time to get to that phase, and, possibly, more risk. It taught me to carefully evaluate projects, and plan for the long term. I'm often painted as a "naysayer" because of this. Nothing could be farther from the truth. I plan to succeed. That means shooing the unicorns and pixies out to pasture, and concentrating on the raw materials, and how we will get from here, to there. That often requires resource husbandry, and compromises. I also NEVER assume that the MVP will be a "one-off." It WILL be the seed of the product for the long term, so it can't be rushed, and it must be of the highest quality that can be reasonably achieved. I generally optimize for quality over features for early-stage releases; knowing that we probably will never be given the chance to "go back and fix it later." In that respect, the corporation was very much like the defense department. There's a story about Hyman Rickover, and how he'd deal with tech salesmen, coming to his office with sample kit. I'm not sure if it's true, but it is fun: He is said to have taken the kit, walked over to his second-story Pentagon window, and dropped the device out onto the ground below. "If it still works, I'll consider it." He is reputed to have said.
- tabtab 7y agoStartups are generally taking risks by design. When you are allowed and expected to take risks, your behavior is different than those being risk averse. Most gov't services are infrastructure to a degree. You don't want people gambling with infrastructure.
- stretchwithme 7y agoWhy would anyone think that? A startup can't coerce people to become its customers. A startup has to convince individuals to part with their money voluntarily.
- archgoon 7y ago"But the 2013 Snowden revelations damaged that tenuous relationship yet again. In hindsight the damage wasn’t the result of what the United States was doing, but over the Pentagon’s inability and unwillingness to own up to why it was doing it: After the intelligence failure of 9/11, security agencies overcompensated by widespread, warrantless datamining as well as electronic and telephonic surveillance, including on U.S. persons. Without a clear explanation of why this had been done, startups,..." I don't think that lack of understanding of the reasons for surveillance is the problem. It is quite common for people to understand the desire to fight terrorism and prevent another 9/11, and still understand that the NSA's methods are ripe for abuse. Lying to Congress about the nature of the program (the what, not the why) doesn't inspire confidence that abuse won't happen. I find the idea that the reasons for surveillance was simply not explained very well to be ahistorical. Perhaps that's just the bubble I've been in though.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ngcc_hk 7y agoGovernment 101 It is not just one lens. There are many governments. Unitary, system, process and politics. There is not just one consistent same government even for communist. And there are many startup. Further they serve different process, client, budget among all these group. Solution may be smaller core, affiliated ... but not to abandon the core.
- jeffml84 7y agoThe author of this article needs a lesson in what facts are.
- ngcc_hk 7y agoOne more. Whilst you want success but do you want some government Lue HONG kong and chinese government successful. Hence what government is more important than success for government. We can have a lot of startup and we hope we will so some can fail !!! May be we want some government to fail as well but not most of them.
- jasonhansel 7y agoAnd yet the government gave us the moon landing and the Internet--two massive technological feats that could never have been accomplished by private companies.
- classified 7y ago> the damage wasn’t the result of what the United States was doing, but over the Pentagon’s inability and unwillingness to own up to why it was doing it What? Is violating the Constitution on a massive scale just a casual pastime like pepper-spraying a protester?
- classified 7y ago> ...rally the nation against a common threat. Only that the common threat is now the nation's own citizens if the targets of surveillance are any indication.
- auggierose 7y agoA simple but crucial distinction between government and startup / company: a startup / company can select the people it consists of.
- throwaway936482 7y agoBecause most start ups fail and when government's fail really really bad things happen? Because government's have an utterly different set of priorities than startups which are founded with the aim of making their founders as much money as possible? Because move fast and break things works of you're building Facebook but not if you're providing end of life care?
- gatestone 7y agoI am wondering more like why can't the government be a bigger version of IETF, with the deliberate democracy ideals of Habermas: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=363840 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=363840
- natmaka 7y agoBureaucracy is a major reason. See Pournelle's iron law of bureaucracy ("in any bureaucratic organization there will be two kinds of people: those who work to further the actual goals of the organization, and those who work for the organization itself. Examples in education would be teachers who work and sacrifice to teach children, vs. union representatives who work to protect any teacher including the most incompetent. The Iron law states that in all cases, the second type of person will always gain control of the organization, and will always write the rules under which the organization functions."). A government tend to be less and less efficient, whereas a startup has to be more and more to survive. Technocracy is another one. The Dilbert principle/Putt's law/corollary ("Technology is dominated by two types of people, those who understand what they do not manage and those who manage what they do not understand"/competence inversion) is everywhere at play, however startups are too young and not big enough to really suffer from it. Raw power, coupled to inertia, is also a reason. As J. Ousterhout pointed it out "The most important component of evolution is death. it's easier to create a new organism than to change an existing one. Most organisms are highly resistant to change, but when they die it becomes possible for new and improved organisms to take their place" ( https://web.stanford.edu/~ouster/cgi-bin/sayings.php https://web.stanford.edu/~ouster/cgi-bin/sayings.php ). A government is very powerful and has huge inertia, it won't easily evolve or die.
- solatic 7y agoIf public-sector work actually cared about reducing risks, then SRE would be huge in the public sector. SRE is literally about making rational decisions about engineering reliability in the context of risk-tolerance levels (i.e. availability/error and financial budgets). But it's not. The kind of risk-avoidance that pervades the public sector (really, all sufficiently large organizations) is actually one of political risk avoidance. It's perfectly OK for systems to fail for reasons that were forewarned, because management's ass is covered. If something is working, then don't fix it, because all change is political risk. This happens because ultimately, at the end of the day, public sector organizations are led by politicians. The "deep state" is not genuinely independent from politics - the attitudes of leadership trickle down the chain. No matter which policies are currently favored by the politician serving at the head, the process of advancing your interests is largely identical.
- JohnClark1337 7y agoThe US Government was a startup...in the 1780's
- classified 7y ago> Startups can do anything. They can break the law and apologize later (as Uber, Airbnb, and Tesla did), but a government official taking the same type of risks can go to jail. That doesn't seem right at all. Shouldn't we all be equal before the law? Or has it become the norm that the foundations of democracy are being vanished one after another?