6 ms·
Recently there has been some talk about banning air miles programs and actually flipping the incentives. Because you have to fly under your government ID it wou
by criddell 7y ago
Recently there has been some talk about banning air miles programs and actually flipping the incentives. Because you have to fly under your government ID it wouldn't be out of the question for people who fly a lot to pay more per mile in taxes.
I've been thinking about this a lot trying to root out the unintended consequences of such a plan, but I can't think of any.
- OrangeMango 7y ago> I've been thinking about this a lot trying to root out the unintended consequences of such a plan, but I can't think of any. Record keeping, administration, etc. You could replace it all with simple calculations: Landing Tax: (tax rate) * (landing weight) * (distance traveled within US airspace) Takeoff Tax: (tax rate) * (takeoff weight)
- criddell 7y agoRecord keeping is already in place for the air miles programs. It's a solved problem. The two taxes you listed do nothing to make people who travel more pay more per mile than somebody doing their one flight a year to Disney.
- jungturk 7y agoWhat's the motivation behind making it a progressive scale per mile? Is there a reason the Nth mile should be taxed more than the 1st when the environmental impact of the Nth mile and the 1st are the same?
- blankley 7y agoIn fact the impact of the 1st is substantially greater, because of the energy required for takeoff.
- ElFitz 7y agoAnd since takeoff weight is linked to both passenger count & traveled distance (amount of fuel), it too accounts for distance!
- t34543 7y agoThis is a terrible idea. Some people have no choice but to fly. Say what you want but air travel is efficient.
- MauranKilom 7y agoPretty sure it doesn't take a literal ton of fuel to move me across Europe in a train. In an airplane, it does.
- t34543 7y agoTime is more valuable.
- esotericn 7y agoIndeed it is. There'll be time after us.
- criddell 7y agoYou aren't against pricing in more of the externalities though, right? For example, a round trip flight between NY and London is said to melt 3 cubic meters of arctic ice per passenger. So it wouldn't be unreasonable for airlines to be required to offset that in some way? If so, then we just disagree on how to structure the tax but mostly agree on the need to reduce damaging flights.
- hodgesrm 7y agoDepends on the plane and the load factor. Assuming a conservative 80 mpg per seat a flight from Moscow to London would consume the following to move your tail between locations: 1554 miles / (80 miles/gallon) * 6.8 lbs/gallon = 132 lbs I was actually a bit surprised how little it is. It gets better in newer aircraft assuming all seats are taken. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jet_fuel https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jet_fuel [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_economy_in_aircraft#Medium-haul_flights https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_economy_in_aircraft#Mediu...
- tonyedgecombe 7y ago
- dashundchen 7y agoWouldn't a carbon tax on the source, when fossil fuels are extracted, be more effective? You'd still be paying more for longer and more frequent flying, but you'd also be hitting personal jets harder than full flights, less fuel efficient planes and flight paths against better ones - and it would be reduced even further if an airline managed to electrify. Although that still ignores the additional warming effect of radiative forcing caused by flight. https://curiosity.com/topics/airplane-contrails-are-contributing-to-global-warming-curiosity/ https://curiosity.com/topics/airplane-contrails-are-contribu...
- twic 7y agoThe proposals i've seen are nonlinear. Each person gets, say, one flight a year with no Frequent Flyer Tax. Your second flight is taxed at 100 dollars. Your third, 200 dollars, Your fourth, 300 dollars, etc. The trick is to pitch it so that you don't have much impact on the 85% of the population who do 30% of the flying, but you strongly discourage the 15% of the population who do 70% of the flying [1]. Partly as a practical measure to ensure it's not so unpopular it gets repealed, but partly because those 15% are probably capable of making changes to their lifestyle or way of working that will drastically cut flights, whereas the other 85% are flying where they have to, to see their family at christmas or whatever, or for their one summer holiday. You couldn't do that by taxing fuel, or aeroplanes, or anything other than individual people flying. [1] https://fullfact.org/economy/do-15-people-take-70-flights/ https://fullfact.org/economy/do-15-people-take-70-flights/
- copperx 7y agoThat's a neat idea, but aren't most frequent flyers doing it for business reasons? In which case the business will pay the tab for the tax increase, most likely.
- sokoloff 7y agoBusinesses have a wide latitude to spend on aviation because business travel done right is incredibly lucrative. The wrinkle I see with escalation of taxes per person per year is while my company would happily pick up the tab for work travel, I’d be upset if my Christmas trip home cost me thousands more because I’d done a handful of business trips.
- oh_sigh 7y agoWhy should you pay more the more you fly, and not just a fixed rate per ton of CO2?
- criddell 7y agoI think part of the motivation is to not punish infrequent fliers. I think it's a little like how utilities price water. Water is very inexpensive at first. But if you are filling a pool and watering your lawn a lot, the gallons get more and more expensive.
- 0xffff2 7y agoWhy do you pay more in taxes on the second dollar you earn compared to the first? It's an acknowledgment that flying is a useful activity for many people, but still an incentive to minimize unnecessary flights.
- Nasrudith 7y agoI can see a few with flipping incentives - flight is a subsituable good and a fuzzy one. While not encouraging it for its own sake is fair the alternatives may be worse. I know of one case where a coworker ended a business trip by taking vacation days and a several day cross Atlantic cruise ship home which was likely worse than even a plane trip to an island as it didn't involve hauling essentially an entire luxury hotel thousands of miles. I suspect a better idea for encouragement if anything would be subsidizing efficient clear neccessity/better than current baseline transit. Like say if living closer to work was subsidized along with public transit - both replacing or shortening automobile commutes.
- markkanof 7y agoWhere does this carbon "tax" go? For example if the U.S. federal government imposed this tax it's just gets paid to the government to use on whatever?
- criddell 7y agoI personally would like to see it go to public universities to fund basic research in areas related to climate change.
- mulderc 7y agoSome of it should but since Carbon taxes could be regessive some type of rebate to people on the lower end of the income scale would be good also.
- mulderc 7y agoIn Canada, the carbon tax revenue is given back as a rebate which results in a net tax decrease for most families. In the US there have been proposals to use the revenue to cut payroll taxes, I believe Harvard economist (and notably former republican) Greg Mankiw has been pushing this idea for years now. Where the tax revenue goes isn't the biggest deal since getting a price on carbon alone will result in shifting incentives towards lower carbon behaviors and investments. In my experience watching debates about Carbon Taxes where I live, generally speaking, when people complain about where the money is going they are not arguing in good faith and trying to just spread FUD about the policy to prevent a carbon tax.
- markkanof 7y agoThanks for the first part of your response. Those uses seem potentially interesting. The second part of your response is somewhat frustrating though. It absolutely does matter what the tax is used for. This can’t just be an excuse for the total tax that I pay to be increased with the additional funds being put towards things like war fighting in far off lands. That’s maybe not as much of a problem in Canada as it is in the U.S. It’s unreasonable to dismiss any concerns about how the tax revenue is used as FUD.
- cycrutchfield 7y agoI'm pretty sure that there are certain airlines that are nearly unprofitable from their actual airline operations, but only eke a decent profit due to their airline miles programs (specifically their credit card rewards programs). So it seems like you are suggesting that we should remove a huge profit center from airlines.
- buboard 7y agoWouldn’t they raise prices to compensate?
- throwawayhhakdl 7y agoI think that’s thats brilliant. Many people fly far more than necessary. A carbon tax is important, but this could simply punish the frivolity of most air travel.
- sokoloff 7y agoYou might actually see a huge lift in private aviation as I don’t have to show government ID or otherwise check in with the government for those flights (provided they take off and land in the US). You can’t even necessarily track the tail numbers of the airplane if it operates from non-towered airports away from our largest 150 or so airports and under 10K feet (so piston airplanes). You would also displace a lot of travel to private autos, with a decrease in safety/increase in fatalities and typically an increase in fuel consumption when comparing a single occupancy car to a fairly full flight. Plus, if I’m going to be driving a car 500 miles pretty regularly, I’m going to splurge for a nice, big, comfy car and it’s not going to be an electric. Since I currently fly rather than drive on road trips, today I can drive a small electric as my daily driver.