5 ms·
While I can see the argument for decriminalisation of most drugs, I can't believe something like fentanyl should ever be. Just like you can't legally buy cyanid
by gambiting 7y ago
While I can see the argument for decriminalisation of most drugs, I can't believe something like fentanyl should ever be. Just like you can't legally buy cyanide without a permit - it's just too dangerous to allow free market distribution.
- jdc 7y agoThe rise of fentanyl trafficking is largely a result of prohibition. Imagine you are a drug smuggler. Now would you rather have truck load worth $100k or a briefcase worth $100k?
- jariel 7y agoLegal drugs would create vast incentives for R&D and fentanyl would have likely happened sooner - but it doesn't matter. Fenatnyl largely ends the debate on 'full legalisation' - there are just far too many things that are 'fun close to death' beyond even that. Everything will have to be taken case by case: micro dots I can see happening. Maybe coca leaves - unprocessed. But beyond that it's just too hard to regulate reasonably - it's one of those interesting and undeniable cases of community vs. individual freedoms: just as there are super conscientious folks who can 'handle there stuff' there are far, far too many who cannot. I live in a mixed neighbourhood across fro a social clinic and this experience has been enlightening. To me, the freedom opportunity is simply not worth the extensive social cost. Decriminalise, change how we think about it surely, but there's no avoiding the general 'war' on controlled substances at scale. Just look at Juul and vaping, it's absolutely rocked in popularity, spreading through youth culture to the point where it's really a fundamental behaviour, and therefore concern. And that's just nicotine. I'd be nice to find a way to sort out the reasonable folks from the rest ... but I'm not sure this is going to happen in our lifetimes.
- remotecool 7y agoIt works so well with guns.
- XorNot 7y agoDrugs are a thing which destroys the user. Guns destroy everybody else.
- Finch2192 7y agoWell, to be fair, and we're on course to veer right off topic -- a large majority of gun deaths are suicides.
- baby 7y agoNot sure why you’re being downvoted.
- tasty_freeze 7y agoFollowing up Finch's reply, which said: "a large majority of gun deaths are suicides." Specifically, in the US, 60% are suicides. https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/08/16/what-the-data-says-about-gun-deaths-in-the-u-s/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/08/16/what-the-da...
- empath75 7y agoAs a gun owner you’re far more likely to commit suicide than murder.
- rkoten 7y agoDoesn't the same logic apply if you're a legitimate provider?
- kerridge0 7y agoNo because of the increased risk of death means you might get a worse reputation if people OD.
- duncan-donuts 7y agoProbably? Hospitals use fentanyl all the time and I’d imagine they have no problem with dosing. It’s probably pretty great to have enough pain killers on hand for an entire hospital and not needing 100x the space (or whatever the scale is)
- Scoundreller 7y agoFunny how you say that. Fentanyl solution for injection that hospitals get is a lot less potent than the hydromorphone solutions for injection that they can stock. (50mcg/mL vs 10, 20, 50 or 100mg/mL). As for the actual dosing... fentanyl is a lot more forgiving than morphine or hydromorphone, as measured by therapeutic index.
- refurb 7y agoThis is very true! Fentanyl tends to cause less respiratory depression at higher doses than opioids like morphine. The ODs are mainly because people don’t know what they are buying.
- DuskStar 7y agoSort of, but the calculus changes. In a regulated market, costs are likely to be dominated by the cost of the product, cost of service, regulations and taxes - shipping a truckload of product legally isn't going to come close to that. But with illegal drugs, cost of transport is one of the biggest contributors to cost, and so taking steps to minimize that is worthwhile. For instance, cocaine costs ~2k/kg in backcountry Columbia, but ~20k/kg in US cities [0] (at least at the time the article was researched). And when your transport costs dominate that much, almost every way to reduce volume and weight is justified. 0: https://www.businessinsider.com/from-colombia-to-new-york-city-the-economics-of-cocaine-2015-7 https://www.businessinsider.com/from-colombia-to-new-york-ci...
- Daishiman 7y agoIt's much easier to criminalize something like fentanyl when less harmful opiates (and alternatives to opiates) are around.
- Consultant32452 7y agoThe language I like to use is systemic risk. Legalize or decriminalize everything that's not a systemic risk. Overuse of antibiotics presents a systemic risk. Grandma's heart medication does not. Fentanyl is a borderline wmd.
- stickfigure 7y agoWhat makes you think there would be a market for fentanyl if alternatives were legal?
- gambiting 7y agoI don't know. It is my understanding that with opiates you build up resistance to a point where eventually you just need something of fentanyl strength - and in that case surely it doesn't matter whether it's actually fentanyl or something else, any opiate of this strength is too dangerous to be out there, no?
- senorjazz 7y agothen tough. If someone is to the stage where however much pure heroin they inject is not enough, then the the medical care on offer at such places is put into place way before this becomes a problem. As a recreational drug, heroin is much more desirable than fentanyl. The problem with street heroin it is cut to nothing and expensive (relative). Fentaynl is pure strength, shorter lasting and less enjoyable.
- Lazare 7y ago> in that case surely it doesn't matter whether it's actually fentanyl or something else, any opiate of this strength is too dangerous to be out there, no? I don't see why. The primary issue with fentanyl today is not that the people who need/want it are taking it, it's that it's being used to adulterate other drugs. Many people die from fentanyl having no desire to take it, nor any knowledge they are taking it. Others die because of incorrect labelling or unexpected purity. Regulate the market as we regulate other markets, and these problems go away. My local supermarket sells a lot of things which would kill me if swallowed in relatively small amounts (acetaminophen and caffeine tablets, for example), but there's no crisis of people dying from taking a box of No-Doz because, well, why would you want to? Fentanyl overdose is a pretty baroque method of suicide in a hypothetical world where all drugs are legal and safe. (I'm not especially against the idea that, even if heroine is legal, fentanyl should still be prescription only or whatever for some reason! I just don't see any obvious reasons why it would be uniquely dangerous. Most things will kill you at a sufficient dose; they're problematic only if you're at risk of accidentally taking that dose. And the obvious problems with fentanyl today would not apply so...)
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- swiley 7y agoIf by cyanide you mean hydrogen cyanide that sounds to me like something trivially easy to manufacture on your own. The permit thing must be to protect people from hurting themselves. EDIT: yeah it is, if I’m reading Wikipedia right (and it’s accurate, I’ve seen bad chemistry on it before) a teenager could make it with ammonia and charcoal from Walmart.
- airbreather 7y agoCarbon in pulp gold miners/producers buy it by the hundreds of tonnes, key part of extracting mineralised gold. While toxicity is very high and thousands of people handle it daily, number deaths at Gold mines is very low - I don't know last time Western Australia had an accidental cyanide death and there are hundreds of mines with 7% of global production from the state.
- namirez 7y agoDecriminalization /= Legalization Decriminalization means an activity is no longer criminal, but it can still be punishable as a civil infraction, like crossing a red traffic light. When it comes to hard drugs, some people advocate for decriminalization but not legalization. So in your example, fentanyl will still be illegal.
- shermozle 7y agoI doubt there'd be much demand for fentanyl if other opiates were available but the problems with it are caused by unknown quantity and quality. Solve that and overdoses get a lot rarer. "This amount is what you need to get high. More than that is dangerous."
- refurb 7y agoThe other thing to keep in mind is some of what drives IV drug use is efficiency. You get way more for your buck injecting heroin than smoking a much bigger dose. If opioids were legal, I wonder how many would just be popping cheap OxyContin instead of shooting fentanyl laced heroin.
- colonwqbang 7y agoThe article states that Dream Market did not allow the sale of fentanyl. Most of the time when you hear about fentanyl it's because an unscrupulous distributor added it where it shouldn't be. I strongly suspect that the main thing keeping fentanyl popular is government policy.
- zelly 7y agoAgreed. Morphine/heroin would be a dirt cheap commodity without government prohibition. Morphine is a natural product. It is harvested and extracted industrially not unlike stevia, cacao, or coffee. There is nothing uniquely capital-intensive about the process except the smuggling. Murdering cartels and private prison owners became billionaires off of enormous human suffering because someone wrote a law.
- Scoundreller 7y ago> Morphine/heroin would be a dirt cheap commodity without government prohibition. Morphine is a natural product. It is harvested and extracted industrially not unlike stevia, cacao, or coffee. There is nothing uniquely capital-intensive about the process except the smuggling. It would become a lot more efficient without prohibition. A lot of heroin is derived from laborious manual processing of opium from poppies. The agricultural-industrial complex would plant a field of a potent strain, fertilize it, let it grow, chop it all down, crush it up, extract out the goods and probably 5x+ crop yields with a team of 2 or 3 operating thousands of acres. That's not happening in Myanmar or Afghanistan!
- zelly 7y agoIn the Golden Triangle or cocaine-exporting countries, the drug lords are often using slave labor (another reason prohibition is disgusting). Slaves are still more expensive than agribusiness automation though.
- PeterisP 7y agoIDK - I've seen what a heroin addict can do not only to themselves but their family and community; and a natural product can easily be evil that needs to be restricted. It's wishful thinking to expect that all people are capable of full responsibility for their actions and deserve the ill consequences of their choices given unrestricted access to everything. Our free will, motivation, goals and core values can be chemically altered - probably even more so in future. There's a tradeoff, there's an optimal amount of restrictions which results in best outcomes for most people, and while I'm not certain where exactly that optimum lies, I'm absolutely certain that zero restrictions is not that optimum.
- zelly 7y agoFentanyl, cyanide, heroin, and meth should all be legal and over-the-counter. I don't think the government should tell a woman what to do with her body, and I don't think the government has a right to tell you what to do with yours. When you advocate for drug legalization from the perspective of safety, then you get into doublethink territory. Some people simultaneously want cannabis and hallucinogens to be legalized yet want the tobacco age increased to 21. Cannabis is not exactly safe. Methamphetamine has been prescribed for decades for legitimate medical use, and hallucinogens have caused permanent schizophrenia. If cannabis were suddenly proven to be extremely dangerous, would you reverse your position and become a prohibitionist? Do you really want to prioritize safety over freedom? Basically the only substances that the government has grounds to prohibit are things like weapons-grade plutonium which actually (not rhetorically) could harm more than just one being.
- fittslickare 7y agoWhat, so cyanide can not harm more than one being? And fentanyl neither?
- gambiting 7y ago>>Basically the only substances that the government has grounds to prohibit are things like weapons-grade plutonium which actually (not rhetorically) could harm more than just one being. You do realise that fentanyl is even deadlier than cyanidie, right? Few hundred grams dropped into a water supply would kill a stupid number of people. What else do you think should be available over the counter? Industrial-strength acid? Organic mercury compounds? It's not about "I will do what I want with my body" - it's just that dangerous materials and poisons shouldn't be available to everyone, just like automatic rifles aren't. Can criminals still get them if they want them? Sure, but that's not an argument for making them available to general population.
- refurb 7y agoWhy not? Just mandate it can’t be solid unless diluted. Can’t sell pure powder. Properly diluted, it’s no more dangerous than other opioids.