27 ms·
This being a biology journal, I was kinda expecting an even larger perspective. If you look at how biological ecosystems work, just about every creature reprodu
by lordnacho 7y ago
This being a biology journal, I was kinda expecting an even larger perspective. If you look at how biological ecosystems work, just about every creature reproduces way more than what is sustainable. Someone did a calculation that if the first cell had kept splitting at the rate it had, there'd be a ball the size of the solar system by now or something crazy like that.
The reason it doesn't happen of course is that you run into resource crises. Any species that keeps doubling at their natural rate will run out of food, or it becomes food for others.
Coming back to society, it's as if we just aren't prepared for a shrinking population. It's hard to make preditions against a variable that's always gone one way, but is showing sign of turning. How much of the economy is really just size? What's gonna happen when that reverses?
This will probably be a major political theme that lingers in many advanced nations. Fewer young people to work, but also fewer votes than the people who benefit. Immigration as a potential cure, but for how long, and at what cost? I tend to think it's already a kind of underlying dynamic, just not the one that appears in the headlines so often.
- Felz 7y ago> Someone did a calculation that if the first cell had kept splitting at the rate it had, there'd be a ball the size of the solar system by now or something crazy like that. What? That makes no sense as an exponential process. It'd be at least unfathomably larger than the universe by now, not just solar system sized. Or were they assuming it'd expand constantly only from the surface in all directions?
- Simon_says 7y agoThe grandfather post is probably misremembering something like "it will become a sphere expanding at greater than the speed of light" around the time it is Solar-System-sized. (Pro Physics Tip: This is not allowed.)
- largbae 7y agoDepending on how you measure it could be allowed... the diameter of the sphere could grow faster than the speed of light without any component exceeding c because you can grow at near light speeds in two directions.
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoI think the point was that's the answer given by extrapolation, and its obvoiusly physically impossible. The contradiction with laws of physics is the point. For starters, anything that large wo ui pd collapse into a black hole.
- barrkel 7y agoAs long as the pie is increasing in size, people can tolerate getting a proportionally smaller slice. If the pie stops growing, that becomes untenable. I think the answer is somewhere in wealth taxes, which are much harder to implement effectively than income taxes, but will be necessary for redistribution in a world with static or declining incomes. To put that into context with population pyramids, to support the old people, young people will need to get a bigger slice of the pie. That means less wealth being locked into untaxed distribution schemes that pass down generationally, whether it's trusts or corporations.
- GarrisonPrime 7y agoWealth taxes would only be a band-aid, kicking the can down the road. The wealthy aren’t a magically endless source of loot.
- mdorazio 7y agoWealth taxes might be the only way to avoid complete inequality in market-based systems [1]. Especially if the market is not growing for everyone. The wealthy kind of are an endless source of loot because the definition of wealthy is one relative to a median, so you'll either end up with everyone roughly equal in wealth (is that a bad thing?) or, more likely, over time new people will enter and exit the wealthy class due to various advantages and market dynamics so that there is an endless supply. [1] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/is-inequality-inevitable/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/is-inequality-ine...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Isinlor 7y agoYou should define what you mean by wealth. What does it mean that you will loot wealthy people? Will you eat shares of a company for breakfast? Will you burn cash in stove to warm your house? Wealthy people control resources. You can take control from them, but it will not create more resources. One, fundamental resource is human labor. This resource will decline in proportion to the total human population whether it will be controlled by wealthy people or not. Someone will need to physically do the work that needs to be done around old people. And there will be more old people, than there will be young people.
- ForHackernews 7y agoThere's an unfashionable branch of economics [0] that tries to think about what happens once you can't just assume infinite growth forever. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steady-state_economy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steady-state_economy
- peteradio 7y agoBoooo reality
- zubspace 7y agoIf you want to know more about this, I highly recommend you to read "Change" by "Graeme Maxton" [1]. A short book based on "The Limits of Growth" [2], a study which came out 1972. It's very accessible and shows, what will happen if we don't take action now, based on this graph [3]. [1] https://www.graememaxton.com/gpm/2018/03/30/change/ https://www.graememaxton.com/gpm/2018/03/30/change/ [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Limits_to_Growth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Limits_to_Growth [3] https://imgur.com/a/0aj8tFA https://imgur.com/a/0aj8tFA
- sam0x17 7y agoThe OP does not mention that as healthcare improves, the average retirement age increases. This might not be enough to solve the problem of the collapsing pyramid, but it is certainly a factor. 100 years from now, we could be living in a world where people retire at age 80 or 90.
- rsmckinney 7y agoRetirement itself is a 20th century concept that requires a ponzi scheme to work. Unfortunately the family unit that used to support its elderly members unable to support themselves no longer exists in America. Instead we have nursing homes which amount to concentration camps for our elderly. But that’s okay, most of us are good nazis and deny that reality in trade for an uninterrupted screen viewing experience.
- hos234 7y agoJust because people can live longer, doesn't mean the quality of life they live in old age is any better. Which also means they aren't exactly interested in being treated for cancer or going through major surgery in their 60s and 70s. Ofcourse there are Sanders and Trump type energizer bunnies, but they are extreme outliers compared to everyone at the retirement community. The metrics don't reflect that reality. Most old people (who have dealt with the healthcare system while caring for their parents in old age) know quite well "about the staggering 52% in the last 2 months, and 40% in the last month". Why is anyone paying that cost? For what? I have a Cardiologist buddy who likes to say performing surgery and treating old people is like keeping a Windows 95 system alive and kicking just because its possible. And most of his patients know it and want easy ways to checkout, but either the Doc is obligated by family/incentivized by the hospital to perform some kind of elaborate treatment. Obviously yhis will change for the simple reason a majority of the Docs and the Patients want the change to happen. On top of that there is the ongoing shift of focus from treatment to prevention. My larger point is there are always countervailing forces to any trend that is building up. A good case study is the Population Bomb predictions in the 70s - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Population_Bomb https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Population_Bomb It's good to know why it didnt play out.
- agumonkey 7y agoSimply telling a happy story here: 97yo neighbor had hip locked due to arthritis. Dr was scared of full hip replacement risks so neighbor lived a year without moving much. He and his wife degraded a bit due to this. Last month they insisted in trying. The man survived the operation, just a week later you can see how more lively he is.