4 ms·
There will always be charismatic snake-oil salesmen, who may even be a little psychopathic. The real problem is the people who follow them, validate them, and
by fortran77 7y ago
There will always be charismatic snake-oil salesmen, who may even be a little psychopathic.
The real problem is the people who follow them, validate them, and throw money at them. Big names who sit on their boards, etc.
At least in Neumann's case, the only thing that happened was some rich people lost their money. There were probably no pension funds, etc, investing in him. And their product didn't hurt anyone.
It's easy to quickly think that "if you're a 6'5" good looking man with great hair you can get away with anything", but people also wanted to believe in Elizabeth Holmes.
To me Elizabeth's Holmes case was even scarier: Investors wanted to believe in a "female Steve Jobs" so much that people were getting bogus medical tests. "Real people" -- not just wealthy investors who should be prepared to lose money -- got hurt.
And unlike the NY Times editors, it doesn't bother me that Adam Neumann walked away with $1 Billion. It doesn't hurt me at all, and it certainly doesn't occur to me that this money should somehow be redistributed to more "worthy" people. It's odd for an uninvolved spectator to feel bitter about this.
Notice that the Times was gushing about Theranos until the Wall Street Journal called them out, but they were skeptical about WeWork from the beginning. One played into their preferred narrative, one didn't.
- throwaway2048 7y agoSo, you have no problem with con artists, its the people they dupe that are the real issue?
- vsareto 7y agoThere's grandma falling for a tech support scam, and then there's heads of billion dollar investment funds falling for business scams and a personality cult. One of these can reasonably be assumed to not be at fault. Masayoshi Son at least had the grace to admit it (indirectly) and try to turn things around.
- fortran77 7y agoExactly. There are some marks and con-men that deserve each other. People who think they're buying stolen merchandise at pennies on the dollar and get a box of bricks for the "street" example. Does either party have clean hands? Then there are Grandma's that get duped. These are real victims, not enablers.
- weberc2 7y agoHow do you arrive at that conclusion in light of his grievances with Holmes/Theranos? Seems pretty obvious that he is distinguishing between the degree of damage between different scams, believing it is worse to harm low or middle class sick people (with their inherent lack of safety nets) than wealthy investors. Whether or not you or I agree with this assessment, we should be able to distinguish between that point and your interpretation.
- fortran77 7y agoBecause this throwaway man, and his downvote brigade, have an agenda.
- buboard 7y agoThey were no artists. The investors money made them artists. I presume both neumann and holmes believed in fake it till you make it, build it and they will come, 10000 hours etc. Holmes turned to a con artist when the thing simply failed to work. Wework didnt get to that stage even.
- GhettoMaestro 7y agoYeah but at least WeWork has an actual product, aside from the financial boondoggle. Holmes was spinning and lying about vapor ware right up to the end.
- lordnacho 7y ago"it doesn't hurt me" is a formula for hurting everyone. You should care that society functions well, even if the parts that don't aren't the parts you are involved in.
- fortran77 7y agoIt wasn't that "it didn't hurt me." It was that it didn't hurt _anyone_! I didn't like Theranos because it hurt people even though it didn't hurt me. And perhaps foolish investors learning a lesson is part of a well-functioning society.
- lordnacho 7y agoDidn't hurt anyone? Misallocation of capital leads to people taking jobs that are unsupportable, and pushes out firms that potentially could have done a better job.
- awinder 7y agoIt’s entirely possible that pensions had some dollars wrapped up in WeWork but I don’t have inside knowledge or anything, they just have a decent backplane of institutional investors. But you can’t take this view that every failed investment “hurt” people. Some investments outperform expectations, some you nail, and some are big dumpster fires. A lot of this seems tied up in the myth that everyone knows what they’re doing: they don’t, grand majority of people are winging it to various degrees most of the time.
- isoskeles 7y agoCan/do pension funds invest in private companies? Seriously asking. Edit: I don't understand why this would get downvoted, and I am endlessly amazed by how weird or sensitive people are on HN. Just to downvote without even answering a simple fucking question in earnest.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoI think "seriously asking" actually ends up making your comment seem ruder rather than nicer. The phrase has taken the same loop as "literally", unfortunately. To answer the question, they do. Many pension funds manage billions of dollars, so they're at the scale where complex investments like that start to make sense. Even when they don't directly do it, very large private companies like WeWork often start getting included in mutual funds.
- isoskeles 7y agoFair enough, might have been better to leave out those words completely. I also thought about writing an entire sentence on it, such as, "I am asking this in earnest, not trying to make some point in a debate with a rhetorical question." But then I thought it would be too much.
- SpicyLemonZest 7y agoIt's definitely a hard balance to strike.
- goatinaboat 7y agoAnd unlike the NY Times editors, it doesn't bother me that Adam Neumann walked away with $1 Billion Remember that the goal of the scam was to offload it to retail investors at a $47Bn valuation knowing it was not worth even a fraction. They were stopped but that doesn’t excuse them of the conspiracy. And they will surely try again.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- unlinked_dll 7y ago>It doesn't hurt me at all, and it certainly doesn't occur to me that this money should somehow be redistributed to more "worthy" people. It's odd for an uninvolved spectator to feel bitter about this. What about the employees he screwed over and are getting laid off without severance?