15 ms·
Gaggle monitors the work and communications of almost 5M students in the US
- JohnClark1337 7y agoHave to get them ready for the police state
- mindgam3 7y ago> Gaggle is one of the biggest players in today’s new economy of student surveillance, in which student work and behavior are scrutinized for indicators of violence or a mental health crisis, and profanity and sexuality are policed. There has to be a way to reach so-called “troubled” kids without creating a culture of fear around expressing difficult emotions. This is part of a larger trend of parenting surveillance tech (ie Life360) that I find quite disturbing. Schools seem much more willing to pay for newfangled tech rather than more trained counselors, for example. Outsourcing content moderation to low-paid contract workers is what gave us Facebook. I fear that these technologies will put a nice band-aid on the problem of student mental health while actually making it worse.
- AlexandrB 7y agoThis is a combination of CYA (“we did everything we could, we even surveilled all their communications”), and tech “magic” mentality: where new, unproven technologies are sold as an easy fix for complex societal issues. 10 years from now we’ll read about how none of this actually helped any kid in real crisis - but it’ll make a few school administrators feel good and in control for a few years. The bigger problem is that unlike previous similar boondoggles (see D.A.R.E.), this might have lasting consequences by acclimating a generation to constant surveillance.
- phnofive 7y agoI’d not be at all surprised to learn D.A.R.E. went a long way to vilifying drug users.
- lonelappde 7y agoPer the article, this tech is used so counselors can reach out to kids who aren't reaching out to counselors.
- habnds 7y agoHard not to compare this to surveillance in mainland China. > Among the many banned words and phrases on Gaggle’s list are "suicide," "kill myself," "want to die," "hurt me,” "drunk," and "heroin." Children growing up in this sort of environment will come to expect it from their government. I wonder if they have any data at all that shows they can actually prevent catastrophes with this sort of system or if this is just a placebo with dangerous social side effects?
- throwaway_law 7y ago>Children growing up in this sort of environment will come to expect it from their government. Public school systems and employees are the government.
- journalctl 7y agoAlso, have they ever actually seen kids communicate? With the way the world seems to be, my friends and I joked a lot about wanting to die (and still do). We don’t actually mean it, it’s just a really strong way of saying that shit’s messed up and it’s all rather absurd. The joke itself also implies irreverence. It’s usually taboo to joke about dying, so doing so is a bit subversive. It can also be used as pure ironic detachment. For example: [1]. I don’t know if current youths make jokes like this, but my friends and I do. Anyway, yeah, restricting a few key phrases is amateur hour. It doesn’t actually help, and kids will just find ways around it anyway. Wait until they discover Unicode homographs! [1] https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/like-this-image-to-die-instantly https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/like-this-image-to-die-instan...
- amatecha 7y agohahaha! I am laughing so much at these images right now. Genius. It's totally true though - no amount of word filtering is ever going to serve a real, tangible purpose for people who are having a consensual conversation between each other. Further, if AIM or ICQ back in the day had filtered my conversations, my friends and I would have just moved to one of the other many services that _don't_ use such filtering. It was bad enough when they started showing automatic previews of URLs in messages, the last thing I need is something actually modifying or acting on the text content of the messages.
- markdown 7y agoSounds like something out of a Black Mirror episode.
- intolerabletech 7y agoHeh, I came here looking for this comment. That's because it literally is! "Arkangel" follows a very young girl through to young adulthood. When she was very young, she was part of a pilot program that allowed her mom to see what she was seeing at all times, filter visual and auditory content, etc. It went about the way you'd expect. Bark's response to DHH [1] made me fucking literally nauseous. How detached from reality do you have to be to not realize the insular effects that this will have on children? How insulated is one's life that they would be unable to conceive of the obvious and likely immediate effect these tools will have on teenagers who are already struggling with identity and discovery?! Can't wait until Bark announces the feature where they'll mail you weekly to tell you if your kid is likely to be gay (which as any LGBT person on social media will tell you, is incredibly easy. Facebook has been accidentally outting people via association for a decade or more, and I can't imagine how that is amplified with full access to the screen, messages, raw data.) Just disgusting. [1]: https://mobile.twitter.com/brandonhilkert/status/1189217762335432715 https://mobile.twitter.com/brandonhilkert/status/11892177623... EDIT: Also, wow, he's really trying to drop "prevented" statistics in another Twitter thread. IT's not even impressive. You're monitoring 50M students and have only caught 320-some predators despite pervasive constant monitoring? I don't even find that impressive. The testimonies too, HOW IS THIS REAL -- "I only get notifications if there are items of concern (sex, depression, bullying, profanity, etc.) Totally worth it!" -Bark Mom
- intolerabletech 7y agoI can't seem to edit my comment any further (Thanks HN for just returning 200 on the edit and trashing the content of my update! This is the third time I've typed it, thanks a lot!) As a last plea, young adults are human beings with autonomy. Trying to suppress that autonomy has always had the same effect, every generation has tried. Meanwhile, I can confidently say that there is a VERY STRONG chance I would not have made it through high school with pervasive, constant surveillance. An overly anxious boy coming to terms with his sexuality in god damn Kansas is hard enough, to think that I would have to worry about every electronic action being reported to my school or parents probably would've made the thoughts of suicide unsuppressable and I wouldn't have had the VERY small community that I sort of accidentally discovered via Facebook, again because there are so many indicators of someone possibly being LGBT even just from what friends you have in common, etc.
- sdan 7y agoThis made me laugh. I'm currently in High School and we use GSuite (we also used GSuite in elementary/middle school for that matter), but am not 100% if we use Gaggle, but even if we did: Once kids come into HS/Middle School at least now in 2019/2020, most if not all use personal emails and external chatting apps (most likely Messenger if not Instagram Messages or Snapchat). Compounded with psuedonyms, it's hard for any AI to determine who's chatting who... and even if FB/Snap knew who it was, I'm somewhat certain they wouldn't do anything. However, in Elementary school, email and Hangouts was the way to go (experience from siblings and myself around 5 years ago), so I guess Gaggle's "AI" can determine if elementary and some middle school kids are a "threat". Regardless, kids nowadays are really into "self-deprecating jokes": "I want to KMS" or other abusive/harmful messages which a good majority use as jokes (in my experience) although they don't have any wrong intentions. I think any AI or NLP model to determine which is a credible threat and which isn't will be extremely hard to tell, even for humans who aren't teens.
- mmazing 7y agoExcellent! So hopefully this means that it's not desensitizing kids to surveillance, just teaching them how to avoid it since they know it's there. Good times.
- helen___keller 7y agoHaven't been in school for a while but this was my first thought. Kids social lives exist far from the realm of the Official School Account™️
- inetknght 7y ago> Compounded with psuedonyms, it's hard for any AI to determine who's chatting who... and even if FB/Snap knew who it was, I'm somewhat certain they wouldn't do anything. It's hard for a human to determine who's chatting who, but not impossible. It'd just take too much attention away from other more important things like teaching. Getting an AI to determine who's chatting who? It's a lot easier than you think. I recommend you read everything Snowden's released. Or watch Joe Rogan's podcast-interview with him. Your phone goes with you when you go places. That is literally all that is needed to determine who's chatting who, particularly with using Facebook or Snapchat or TikTok or whatever spyware kids mistake for trendy social apps these days. > even if FB/Snap knew who it was, I'm somewhat certain they wouldn't do anything. Maybe, maybe not. You don't know the laws in your country. Even if you did know the laws in your country, people and businesses break laws all the time. You might not yet see the danger is selling an advertisement to you. I highly recommend you pay attention in any psychology or statistics classes you have.
- AlexB138 7y agoI try to have a charitable interpretation of other people's actions, but I can't help but feel like this is the old trick of using "think of the children" to force the leading edge of a wedge on something reprehensible. This is an absolutely disgusting level of surveillance on developing minds, and trains them to think it's normal to live in a virtual panopticon. It's easy to force societal change by poisoning the impressionable minds of children and simply waiting.
- AWildC182 7y agoIt's not even meaningful. I read through the article and it's just scanning word docs and anything else that goes through your school email account. How many kids are dumb enough to threaten harm upon themselves or others, or otherwise share explicit imagery on their school email account... All this does is get kids used to being watched.
- choward 7y agoThis is completely absurd and I'm convinced it solves zero problems. The kids don't know they're being spied on until they do something "wrong". Gaggle (a terrible name btw) claim they prevent suicides and school shootings. This might "work" at first until kids know they are being spied on. Now they know not to send an email saying "I'm going to kill people". All your doing is preventing communication using school provided technology and eroding students trust in the school. You're not actually preventing a shooting. Kids can still do whatever they want and there's nothing you can do to stop it. On top of that they monitor for profanity. WHY? It doesn't harm anyone and let's people express themselves how they want. If I was a parent I wouldn't want some random people at a for profit company spying on my child. That's my job. Do kids still read 1984?
- whydoyoucare 7y agoWell said. As the article states, it is indeed a solution in wait of a problem. Also don't discount the possibility that the school may have a need to be seen doing something (meaningful or not). 1984 it is indeed.
- RealStickman 7y agoIf I were a student and knew about that I'd purposefully put in a variety of words and phrases that might get flagged in every email
- lopmotr 7y agoThen you'd be doing a "violation" and get a warning. Presumably some in-school punishment for repeat violations.
- CWuestefeld 7y agoThere's plenty of space for triggering false positives. "I wonder if I'm gay.", "I read that if you drink bleach it could kill you", or just meta "what happens if I put the phrase XYZ here?".
- Silhouette 7y ago
- Ididntdothis 7y agoThis feels like an extension of how the work world is being run increasingly. More and more process, policies and automated decisions and less common sense. Good to teach children as early as possible to fall in line :(
- UnFleshedOne 7y agoI wonder what can parents do to prepare kids for that -- teach them to never post anything personal where school could be watching (so nowhere), create a fake public persona to avoid closer scrutiny, and so on? Schools will prepare students for accepting global surveillance and to counteract that parents will prepare kids for living in cyberpunk underground. I don't think either of those extremes are good for the kids themselves...
- RealStickman 7y agoHonestly, I'd flood their system with words, phrases and various images from the internet.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- cproctor 7y agoSo much for education for democratic citizenship. Someday I will help lead a school whose software is written by students and whose policies are debated by student government, faculty senate, and the PTA.
- pergadad 7y agoA really sad state of affairs when we are monitoring all our children's communications. Its the same as those parents installing spyware on their kids' devices: an attempt to alleviate the symptoms, rather than the causes: loneliness, lack of attention, lack of parenting skills, poverty, lack of funds for good teachers, ...
- TurkishPoptart 7y agoIt would be great if a hacker could get this system to create a bunch of false positives to the extent that the schools could no longer justify the $60k price tag on this. Also, isn't that enough money to hire an additional school psychologist? This is not a problem software can fix.
- turc1656 7y agoThis is so utterly horrifying I can't even put into words my disgust. Although, I probably should have seen it coming. How do the schools and Gaggle have access to all of this info anyway? I assume they have school accounts that are provided by the school and therefore the legal property of the school since they are the ones paying for the MSFT 365 accounts? But what about Gmail? I don't use it but I thought it was free? I take it there is some corporate version that is paid for?
- jrd259 7y agoNote the politics of funding such surveillance as a justification for not needing to restrict access to weapons.
- llsf 7y agoThis is awful. Privacy should be a fundamental right. But I cannot help thinking of my younger self, toying with that Gaggle AI :) I mean as a teenager (old enough here to have been through the "no-future" 80's) me and my friends would have push that Gaggle AI, where no AI has gone before :) What can they do to the kids who write "inappropriate" stuff ? They cannot prevent the kids to do it again, it is free speech during private conversations. This reminds me and my cousin who created a secret language "fefe" that easy enough to process and speak, but too confusing to understand when listen too. Kids are going to just do that, new words or old ones with new meaning, and challenge Gaggle.
- zucker42 7y agoThey say it's AI but it seems like just a hash map to me.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoMost AI seems to be either that, human workers pretending to be AI, or some half-baked, misapplied and not working deep neural network. I have a huge respect for companies that know about linear regression.
- ACow_Adonis 7y agoAnd what is a neural network but just interconnected weighted functions? If you can call that AI, why not a hashmap? :p
- Silhouette 7y agoOne of these days, someone is going to suggest the radical idea that there might be some connection between (a) a culture of authority and draconian measures where adolescents aren't respected and the very people who are supposed to look after them and set an example are instead their enemies and not to be trusted and (b) a culture where significant numbers of adolescents think it's OK to commit extreme acts that harm themselves or others.
- swasheck 7y agodont tell them that they're the problem, because they (and their investors) are making loads of money on positioning themselves as the "solution."
- toss1 7y ago>>student emails are scanned in real time, and those that violate the rules are blocked from their intended recipients. Aside from the massive overriding issues of such pervasive surveillance, this practice seems additionally stupid and counterproductive. As soon as kids figure out that their language is being monitored for certain phrases -- and this is an instant give-away -- they'll simply avoid using those phrases and develop a new code, rendering the entire system useless (as well as abhorrent). Gaggle's mgt are clearly not the sharpest tools in the shed, making this kind of basic and stupid opsec errors...
- MikeGale 7y agoI find it interesting how this sort of thing is spreading so far. The CCP state, Facebook, Google... now Gaggle. I hope there's some studies of the damage such things do to people. How much do they lose the ability to control their own lives? How does this change their attitude to other people? Respect for authority? Most of all, this ought to be opt-in, opt-in only, and if you opted-in you can get out again. My reading of the articles says it's none of these.
- timlod 7y agoFrom Gaggle's FAQ (https://www.gaggle.net/frequently-asked-questions/ https://www.gaggle.net/frequently-asked-questions/): How much does Gaggle Safety Management cost? Gaggle Safety Management truly is a one-of-kind solution that shouldn’t be mistaken for a less expensive or free alternative. We understand that no two school districts are alike, so our per student pricing is based on your specific requirements as well as the size of your student population. Pricing for other Gaggle solutions also can be customized to the needs of your school or district. Perhaps a better question to ask is "How much will it cost your school or district if you don't use Gaggle Safety Management?" (emphasis mine) A lot of their webpage seems to be riding on fear, as is visible when just visiting their homepage.
- zaptheimpaler 7y agoIts part of a broader pattern of factory-lining everything in the industrialized world. Any solution that is not codified into a law or structure of some kind is "illegible" to those who only see structures. Who needs social structures when you can just outsource every problem to a company and throw the ones that don't fit into some variant of prison or mental ward?
- danharaj 7y agoFoucault was astute in observing that schools mirror the architecture and processes of prisons.
- quadrifoliate 7y agoSomewhat of a tangent, but I can't help thinking about it – since workplace surveillance has now also been normalized in the US, four years of college might be the only place where young American adults will have the ability to be exposed to a place where they can say or do anything on the Internet without Big Brother looking over their shoulder. I'm assuming that most progressive college campuses don't use these ridiculously invasive tools (the college I went to ran a fairly unrestricted internal and guest network), but perhaps that's being too optimistic.
- rdiddly 7y agoProfiting off of fear-mongering. But I suppose there's a certain amount of sales genius (albeit evil) in manipulating faint-hearted administrators to buy your product. They need to add things like going outside, storm, thunder, lightning, raincoat and so forth to the list, since getting struck by lightning is about 600 times more likely nationwide than being shot at school.
- ahaferburg 7y agoLightning doesn't make global news.
- rdiddly 7y agoRight, because, I suppose, it's 600X more commonplace than school shootings! So, we're paying close attention to exotic scenarios we'll likely never experience personally, and getting worked up over them. Meanwhile the various elephants in our rooms, the ones that are likely to be actual problems for us (heart disease, dying in a car crash, cancer, etc.) are drab and gray, so we ignore them. I mean who wants to solve real problems? BORRINGGG! Suddenly just now while typing I realized that 1) an exotic, unlikely scenario 2) that we engage closely with ...is precisely the paradigm of all fiction, fantasy and entertainment. What is a video game other than an exotic scenario you'll probably never experience in real life, that you engage with and try to "get into?" How about in ancient times? Sure - even back in Greece or in Shakespeare's time, "the play was the thing," namely an exotic scenario (the inside of the royal castle perhaps, which most people will never see) and "getting worked up over it" might be more aptly described by your drama teacher as sharing in the tension, drama and catharsis. Even our ideas about the future tend to center around exotic utopias, or exotic apocalypses (the writer John Michael Greer has talked about this) whereas in reality things will probably just continue to slowly get shittier, more annoying, less comfortable, less convenient etc., and ironically it'll probably be that way precisely because we've got our heads up our asses with fantasy (including things like "Hey there was a shooting; let's implement 1984.") and can't seem to reach a basic consensus about what reality is and how to keep our house in order. BORRINGGG!!! Anyway if we're using news of a school shooting as entertainment -- "Riveting tension!" says the New York Times. "So sad!" says the Washington Post -- then suddenly instead of a fictional universe with actors, we're using real people, real victims, for our entertainment. Which feels like a wrong to me. Huge tangent, sorry. Didn't expect to be writing in this direction today.
- swasheck 7y agobut i was just writing a paper on the social impact of Beck's mid-90s hit, "Loser"
- milofeynman 7y ago> Gaggle touts itself as a tantalizingly simple solution to a diverse set of horrors. It claims to have saved hundreds of lives from suicide during the 2018–19 school year. I just read a great newyorker piece on a security company that sold FUD[0]. This seems like another example of FUD for sale very similar to some security companies out there. [0] https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2019/11/04/a-cybersecurity-firms-sharp-rise-and-stunning-collapse https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2019/11/04/a-cybersecurit...
- mixmastamyk 7y agoI was not happy to learn recently our school was using google sites and chromebooks. We weren’t asked or even notified about that. Gaggle is another large step in the wrong direction. All demonstrating that school (and govt) officials are not even aware of the need for privacy.
- annoyingnoob 7y agoThis is completely unnecessary. Has our world really come to a complete dragnet? Anything in the name of safety? Innocent as long as you keep proving yourself innocent. This is no longer the land of the free and the home of the brave. Let the kids be kids.
- iamleppert 7y agoBack when I was in school, they had a software called “Foolproof” installed on all the computers that largely did the same thing. In addition to that it prevented system-level changes to the computers and crippled them in other ways, like preventing installation of applications and hooking into Windows to implement all sorts of restrictions. It also did content monitoring and would regularly take screenshots of whatever you were doing. However, the software was poorly written, full of bugs, would frequently crash, and generally ineffective. It wasn’t long until we (kids) figured out its weaknesses and we had full control of it —- we could force it to crash, uninstall it, and we even took over it’s command and control server. Mind you, this was 20 years ago. Today’s kids are up against more mature software but I tend to feel whoever makes these things is generally bottom of the barrel outsourced devshops, so it’s probably all still very low quality. Couple that with kids being generally more tech savvy and advanced these days with clueless school administrators —- kids are generally smarter than you think and need a lot less protecting. Information spreads at lightning speed in a school. I’m sure they all know all about this software and how to get around it.
- nloladze 7y agoHow is this legal? I'm not doubting the school's intentions but this is a massive breach of privacy, a sort of dystopic 1984 scenario. "Believe happy thoughts! You are happy! Smile please!" I think the solution lies outside the tech world and in face to face solutions; train teachers to spot problems and red flags and possibly have a tally system. Are several teachers reporting issues? A student missing classes, showing up long sleeves, withdrawn, depressed? Grades slipping, unable to focus? Set a counsel meeting and get to the bottom of it. An abstract and mind-you poorly run AI is just a nightmare scenario. I feel sorry for any students going through the system now.
- vageli 7y ago> How is this legal? I'm not doubting the school's intentions but this is a massive breach of privacy, a sort of dystopic 1984 scenario. You might also be surprised to know that your employer can also log everything you do with company property. Not that I agree with it but the legal precedent is there and children in school have far fewer rights than others.
- analog31 7y agoMy school district started giving out a Chromebook to each kid, and has these things locked down pretty tight. Kids are forbidden from installing their own software. (We tried installing Python / Jupyter). They also hired a surveillance company, maybe the one mentioned in the article. They conducted a trial run of the surveillance service at one middle school for a couple months, whereupon they claimed that it prevented two suicides. A suicide per month in a single middle school isn't remotely plausible. Now of course the kids know about the surveillance. It was announced in the newspaper. But already for years, parents have already been teaching our kids about dealing with the internet: Don't write anything that you wouldn't want to see on the front page of the New York Times. Don't admit to being a member of a hated group. Don't criticize governments that are capable of carrying out censorship beyond their borders. Assume that all "private" information will be stolen or sold. My kids have told me that every kid at school has figured out how to install a VPN on their cellphone, so they can bypass the content blockers. They know that the VPNs themselves aren't secure. They don't use the Chromebooks except to look up school assignments (which are themselves surveilled via anti-plagiarism service). Unfortunately the short term desire for entertainment, and to be part of a community, outweighs their long term concerns for security and privacy. But at least from the standpoint of being informed, they're quite well informed.
- DanBC 7y ago> whereupon they claimed that it prevented two suicides. A suicide per month in a single middle school isn't remotely plausible. The software is really worrying, and this is one reason why. Risk prediction for suicide is really hard. Currently the risk prediction tools (created and used by health care professionals) are bad, and there's strong advice that these should not be used to predict future suicide or self harm, and should not be used to determine who to offer treatment to or who to discharge from treatment. And these tools are somewhat more sophisticated than "has the person used the word suicide?" https://www.nice.org.uk/donotdo/do-not-use-risk-assessment-tools-and-scales-to-predict-future-suicide-or-repetition-of-selfharm https://www.nice.org.uk/donotdo/do-not-use-risk-assessment-t... https://www.nice.org.uk/donotdo/do-not-use-risk-assessment-tools-and-scales-to-determine-who-should-and-should-not-be-offered-treatment-or-who-should-be-discharged https://www.nice.org.uk/donotdo/do-not-use-risk-assessment-t...
- dansman805 7y agoI am currently attending a school at which GSuite and Gaggle are both used. I agree that Gaggle is extreme, especially the "three strikes" system. On the other hand, I also try to avoid tying my school online identity to my personal online identity, and leave my school account for school. That also means not doing anything personal on district provided chromebooks. However, I only really know to do this due to knowledge in technology focused areas, not something most students have. My main issue with this sort of tracking is that the students are very loosely told what it is tracked and how; at our school, students were told that the chromebooks used gaggle and not much more than that. Overall, students and parents should definitely be better taught as to what occurs with surveillance, and in my opinion the current level of surveillance is extremely excessive.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- btrettel 7y agoMy high school gave all students Gaggle email addresses 10-15 years ago. The account was used as part of an assignment in a computer class to send some emails, though I think the teachers expected you to continue using the account for personal things. I don't recall being told the account was being watched by anyone. Makes me glad I never used it for anything beyond the assignment. Incidentally, over the past few years I've been doing an audit of my password manager and couldn't log into the Gaggle account any longer, so I suppose the addresses are deleted after a few years. Hopefully that's current policy as well as I think most people would agree that what you write as a teenager may not reflect well on you later.
- throwaheyy 7y agoSeeing this headline reminded me of that Lysol TV ad. All sounds like a noble cause until they briefly mention “and partnering with a smart thermometer company”. And bam, there’s your kids data being sucked up by medical company...
- pbreit 7y agoDHH really laid into Bark” this week: “https://mobile.twitter.com/dhh/status/1189235145192157184 https://mobile.twitter.com/dhh/status/1189235145192157184
- chiefalchemist 7y agoTwo brief thoughts 1) This is no way to treat kids that are already suffering from a dysfunctional society created by adults. 2) Even worse, to these kids, this is only going to normalize the idea of the surveillance state. But maybe that's the point.
- yspeak 7y agoPrivacy here is no different than an employee using his employees computer. These systems save lives and alert parents to harmful activity. All the kids are informed and troubled kids often will send a message with trigger words intentionally as a cry for help.
- decasteve 7y agoWhen I was going through school I was taught that this is the sort of thing that happens in the GDR--the surveillance state. We watched videos/documentaries on this. These are the tools of totalitarian states is what we were taught. The technology has changed but the end result hasn't--it's still chilling. This has come up for my family this past week. When my son came home from school and said he feels uncomfortable with all of the video cameras in the hallways I was shocked that this was a thing. He said he even felt uncomfortable going to the washrooms as he couldn't be sure there weren't cameras. The measures of surveillance employed without notifying the parents was shocking to me--with no option to give feedback or opt out? I haven't even looked into other forms of monitoring like what's shared in the article. But I'm going to find out.
- norgate 7y agoEthics and privacy rights notwithstanding, how can we help to educate schools that software like Gaggle are more fraudulent than they are helpful? It's quite clear to me all this product is doing is maintaining a blacklist controversial words and flagging any content that is passed through it that contains them, and is calling this AI to make it sound more advanced than it is. False advertisement to a community that is generally not very tech savvy. Are parents and schoolboards really comfortable with $10/hour contract employees looking through their children's content to decide its obscenity? With the money these school districts spend on scammy software, they could be spending it on recruiting health experts. I'm confident this company justifies its product's existence by taking a secondary school kid's joke about killing himself or herself out of context, flagging it, and claiming they prevented a suicide to boost their metrics.
- jrochkind1 7y agooh my god what a world. Basically, this is a scam where a company gets rich by convincing school districts to abusively surveil their students with no real benefit.
- bensonn 7y agoI am a childless tin-foil hatter so I am asking out of ignorant curiosity- is there any way to avoid tracking on your child? Does refusing to agree to Google/Gaggles/MS/Etc's ToS, EULA or Privacy policy mean the public schools can refuse your child education? Is there some different ToS and privacy policy for minors forced into using these services? I also feel like this CYA policy may backfire. Before they could rightfully say they weren't the responsible party. Now that they are using tax payer funds to "prevent" these things I feel like they put themselves in a position to be responsible if it fails. I am sure there is some legal doctrine term for what I am trying to say.
- vageli 7y ago> I am a childless tin-foil hatter so I am asking out of ignorant curiosity- is there any way to avoid tracking on your child? Does refusing to agree to Google/Gaggles/MS/Etc's ToS, EULA or Privacy policy mean the public schools can refuse your child education? Is there some different ToS and privacy policy for minors forced into using these services? > I also feel like this CYA policy may backfire. Before they could rightfully say they weren't the responsible party. Now that they are using tax payer funds to "prevent" these things I feel like they put themselves in a position to be responsible if it fails. I am sure there is some legal doctrine term for what I am trying to say. This is a really interesting perspective and I'm curious if someone knowledgeable on the subject would comment. If public education is a right, can my child be denied that right if I refuse to consent to a license? If the child consents, is that not an invalid contract?
- amursft 7y agoCreepy. Who's working on homeschooling?
- consentfactory 7y agoWhile Gaggle is indeed crazy intrusive, they're not really alone in this world of K12 monitoring. GoGuardian and Lightspeed Systems are doing the same thing, perhaps to a lesser degree, but maybe not. For example, administrators using GoGuardian can get 'Smart Alerts' for 'self-harm' and other objectionable material. They'll receive an email that includes a screenshot of the material in question, and for G Suite, it spans Google search, Docs, and effectively any Google service. However, that said, I just tried to pull up a link for GoGuardian and noticed they have this disclaimer: "Please note: Smart Alerts for the "Self-Harm" category is no longer available for new customers. For more information, please reach out to your sales representative."
- tapatio 7y agopiazzo is doing the same thing.
- meh206 7y agoYou have to wonder about the slimy people who advocated for and approved this crap in the school systems. Only in America
- miki123211 7y ago> “[There’s] a very consistent and long-standing belief that children have fewer rights to their own communications, and to their own inner thoughts and to their own practices,” IMO, that's the biggest problem here. Until we stop treating children the way we treated slaves, people of cololor, women and LGBTQ+ in the past, we will get horrible systems like this. We need to recognize that "it is self-evident that all people are created equal", and that includes children too. I'm a pretty young user by HN standards and I still keep in touch with under18s. I know a few who have been surveilled at every step and prohibited from using most modern technologies like other teenagers do. This created way more problems than it solved. This was particularly prevalent in the U.S. On the other hand, I never had any rules imposed, and I think I'm in tech only because of that. In Poland where I live, monitoring children's use of technology is almost unheard of. I haven't really heard of any problematic situations that monitoring would solve. On the other hand, I know a few horror stories from the U.S. where monitoring was used.
- lonelappde 7y agoSex and violence and curse words have never been allowed at school. Kids can do all these things on their personal Gmail/WhatsApp if they want.