8 ms·
> Authorities say the suspect stole two belts and a shirt from a Walmart. After he left the store, police say, he broke into Lech's house for protection and was
by epistasis 7y ago
> Authorities say the suspect stole two belts and a shirt from a Walmart. After he left the store, police say, he broke into Lech's house for protection and was firing at officers with a handgun. Eventually, SWAT officers entered the home and apprehended him.
...
> The court noted that if police officers "willfully or wantonly" destroy property, they can be sued in a civil tort case. Lech tried to pursue that legal argument in Colorado state court, but he was not successful.
Here is the real problem. Eminent domain is clearly not the right strategy.
But when a police department is so out of control that they damage a home enough to get it condemned, over a single armed man, and they are not considered to have acted to wantonly destroy property, our society is seriously screwed up.
Every day, these sort of toxic over reactions and abuse of power are making people think less and less of police power. Even those that the police do not abuse are starting to believe the "ACAB" line.
Police need to start admitting to being able to make mistakes, because when they refuse to admit to any error when they have made obvious errors, they look morally weak and we stop thinking they deserve any of the massive amount of power we see them abuse.
- smcl 7y agoPrecisely. The Police are keen to do little "viral" stunts like shooting hoops with kids or buying shoes for homeless guys (ok, fine things to do) ... but when it really comes down to stuff that actually matters - the countless killings and general misery they cause to minorities - they close ranks and put on a united front, and often have the audacity to play the victim. This is why "ACAB" takes hold. They 100% get behind their shittiest members, effectively taking collective responsibility for them. I am really not sure what else they expect, really.
- koolba 7y agoWhat’s ACAB?
- smcl 7y agoIt stands for "All Cops Are Bastards"
- appleflaxen 7y agoIt stands for "All Cops Are Bastards", and is a common graffiti tag. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A.C.A.B https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A.C.A.B.
- eden_h 7y ago"All Cops Are Bastards" - It's to do with all individual police officers, who could be perfectly moral upstanding citizens, being complicit with an institution that has done terrible things. It's more of a reaction to the idea of changing an institution from the inside.
- concordDance 7y ago> general misery they cause to minorities And also non-minorities. According to Scott Alexander the rate of killings per police encounter in the USA is similar for both black and white people.
- eevilspock 7y ago> On any given day, in any police department in the nation, 15 percent of officers will do the right thing no matter what is happening. Fifteen percent of officers will abuse their authority at every opportunity. The remaining 70 percent could go either way depending on whom they are working with. From I'm a black ex-cop, and this is the real truth about race and policing http://www.vox.com/2015/5/28/8661977/race-police-officer http://www.vox.com/2015/5/28/8661977/race-police-officer
- Keverw 7y agoI think it's a little strange they'd even chase someone over two belts and a shirt... I wonder if they knew he was armed, since it was shoplifting and not like a bank robbery, but escalated though from there anyways. Just really surprised they'd prioritise such low value items. I know I've heard in some cities like San Francisco, the police are so busy with everything else even cars being broken into or stolen isn't even a high priority. So the police are pretty much useless and only good for just to get it documented for the insurance company. Then, of course, you have to pay for a copy of the police report, and some or maybe even most places won't even accept credit, debit or even checks. Exact change only. Ideally, though no one should steal at all and in the ideal world, everyone who stolen would be caught. My first iPod Touch was stolen in high school, and the police took a report. I even thought I knew who did it... The officer even asked me if I'm sure I didn't misplace it or lose it, trying to blame me I guess. I kinda feel like corporations are more protected than everyday citizens sadly. Maybe a Walmart in a city will bring more income than a single person though is the logic.
- LorenPechtel 7y agoThe police aren't interested in investigating low-value cases. However, with a suspect in sight they'll go after them even if it's low-value.
- dls2016 7y agoThen why don't they investigate wage theft? Googling around suggests that the cost to the US economy is about the same as shoplifting (and I'm guessing individual cases could be much higher value than shoplifting). When was the last time a battering ram was used in pursuit of a wage thief? Or when was one even arrested? To answer my own questions, police do not care so much about the "value" of the target. Their behavior is much easier to explain once you realize that their job is to protect capital.
- LorenPechtel 7y agoHow much wage theft is treated as a criminal matter vs a civil matter? Furthermore, cops aren't exactly skilled at digging out such things. Wage theft is something for the department of labor, not the cops.
- golergka 7y ago> over a single armed man Who's firing at the police officers and is in the same building as an innocent bystander, 9 year old boy. Seriously, this situation could've easily gone much uglier than property damage really fast.
- tolien 7y ago> The boy, who was home alone when the gunman entered, was able to get out of the house safely. Not to mention the safety issues of firing tear gas into the building, blowing out the windows and driving an APC into it if he wasn’t already out…
- gldalmaso 7y agoIs it common for the police to resort to explosives and military vehicles to handle a single armed person? Or maybe they have just too much leftover military toys and are eager to play with them?
- afarrell 7y agoIf your employer had an option available which could significantly reduce your risk of dying on the job, what would you prefer that they prioritise above taking that option? A) The lives of bystanders B) The property of bystanders C) The cost of equipment D) The aesthetics of equipment Personally, say: - Definitely A. - B & C at some point if the cost/risk is above a certain amount...but what is that number? - Never D.
- squarefoot 7y agoI agree with the use of force since the robber was armed, but in the end refusing any compensation is an awful choice that also sends the wrong message: next time make an attempt to trade with the robber but don't call the police.
- mannykannot 7y agoIt is preposterous to suggest that every other option would have created more risk for the police. The issue here is not one of giving the police protection, it is one of misuse (to put it mildly) of the equipment intended for that purpose.
- oefrha 7y ago> the suspect stole two belts and a shirt from a Walmart. A petty thief who stole $50 worth of merchandise was armed with a gun. That's your problem and that's what led to the overreactions.
- merpnderp 7y agoThe new rules people seem to be advocating for is you can commit low level crimes and the police won’t follow you, as long as you carry a gun. Which is crazy. The cops did nothing wrong blowing up that house as long as they were willing to pay for it. If they can’t pay for it they should have stationed some cops to wait him out. But armed fugitives need to handled lest they murder someone.
- oefrha 7y agoNot sure it’s my writing or your reading comprehension lacking. Elsewhere with sane firearms control (most countries?), petty thieves don’t tend to carry guns. Americans like to beat around the bush when the single worst catalyst for tension is lying right there in plain sight.
- merpnderp 7y agoMexico just called, they said they made carrying a single bullet worth years in jail. Rumor has it they have a serious armed petty (and not so petty) crime problem.
- oefrha 7y agoTo refute my point on U.S. gun control, you point me to a country whose gun violence is almost exclusively fueled by guns trafficked from the U.S. Really strong argument.
- merpnderp 7y agoCitation needed, because I'm calling BS. The Mexican government used to send serial numbers of weapons suspected of originating in the US to the ATF, but stopped after nearly all of those weapons were determined to have been sales to the Mexican military. Cartels are billion dollar enterprises with shipping connections all around the world, to believe they're getting their LAW's and M249's from Billy Bob's Country Emporium is beyond ridiculous.
- krageon 7y ago> starting to believe When it is founded on hard evidence I think belief is not the right term to use.
- Dumblydorr 7y agoWhy do they deserve massive power? That was not constitutionally mandated, it is local, state, and national politics related to drugs and motor traffic that seems to have given cops now more violence and also more ubiquity. What if police didn't have outsized reactions to recreational drug use or minor non violent offenses? What if they weren't getting their revenue from seizing assets and catching motorists for arbitrary speed tickets?
- nvahalik 7y ago> Why do they deserve massive power? They don't. We've given it to them willingly. It has been granted to them by every person who has chosen to "outsource" dealing with their problems to the police. Loud neighbor? Call the cops. Something doesn't look right at the house down the street? Call the cops. Someone breaking into your home? Call the cops. As a society, many, many of us have forgotten how (or even why) we ought to fight, defend ourselves, or interact with society. So we call the cops and go back to our Netflix or whatever it is we are doing that we don't want to be bothered with.
- BubRoss 7y agoIf you have a loud neighbor you personally fight them? The problem here is not that police are carrying out violence that should be enacted by citizens. I think you have misunderstood the need for accountability, not self reliance when it comes to using force.
- nvahalik 7y agoNo, my point here is that a lot of people don't interact with their neighbors at all. I've had loud neighbors in the past and when I've had a problem gone directly to them and asked them to rectify said issue. They have generally complied. The point is that if we were all better in "public relations" and de-escalation, we wouldn't need the cops at all. But if the default answer is just simply "call the cops" then people do feel attacked and they tend to get defensive.
- eloff 7y agoThat doesn't seem out of control. This man was firing at police. That warrants a SWAT response. You've got a very high risk of officers getting killed. What is fucked up is that there's no law that requires the government to compensate the homeowner.
- claudeganon 7y agoMaybe just let the guy run off with the clothes in the first place? The idea that we have to defend a corporation’s property rights at the level of a SWAT team having a street battle with a shoplifter is the height of militarized insanity.
- eloff 7y agoUsually police don't even respond to shoplifting on that level. I'm not sure what happened here.
- thomascgalvin 7y ago> This man was firing at police. That warrants a SWAT response. Absolutely. And there is no reason they couldn't have cut utilities to the property, set up a perimeter, and waited him out. One of the biggest problems with SWAT teams today is that they seem to feel that they have failed if they don't go in all-a-Rambo. Protocol should be just the opposite: the most successful missions are the ones where a cop never has to fire a gun.
- eloff 7y agoYeah, that would have been better, at least given what we know of the situation.