5 ms·
Following the link on airplane mode: >“Every phone has two operating systems,” explains Gary S. Miliefsky, CEO of SnoopWall, “One that connects to cellular net
by Havoc 7y ago
Following the link on airplane mode:
>“Every phone has two operating systems,” explains Gary S. Miliefsky, CEO of SnoopWall, “One that connects to cellular networks, and one that interfaces with the consumer. Airplane mode may only disable features in the consumer facing operating system, such as Android or iOS, but not in the OS used between the phone and the carrier network. A phone may be giving out a ‘ping’ and you’d never know it.”
Surely that defeats the whole idea behind airplane mode. i.e. stop the phone from sending crap that (supposedly) messes with airplanes?
- Romanulus 7y agoYeah, they need to update that setting to "Data Harvesting Mode".
- AshamedCaptain 7y agoPhones affecting airplanes is already not that much of a risk (even if indeed existing), and besides, as the article claims, the phone might still just sent a periodic ping, which is going to be practicable unnoticeable for any equipment.
- coldtea 7y agoIf it's a signal it will be noticeable with a tool that scans the relevant bands. Trivially so. In what sense could it ever be "practicable unnoticeable", much less "for any equipment"?
- iamkroot 7y agoAgree, if the signal is strong enough to reach a cell tower there is no way you could hide it from someone who was looking for it.
- AshamedCaptain 7y agoI mean in the "affect airplanes" sense. Obviously it is distinguishable from noise because it has to be received...
- angry_octet 7y agoUTC 0830 Smart devices mimic what they hear around them so they can blend in. For example, for wifi using the same MAC address and IP info as something transmitting frequently. You'd have to check the sequence numbers or use multi-directional gear to detect it reliably. Conceivably it would use a different waveform with lower energy when transmitting clandestinely, but that would be insanely expensive to achieve, probably need to add a separate chip, and it wouldn't work for people who change phones regularly. I'm reminded that a while back the Shin Bet modified a phone to have a chunk of plastic explosive, used to kill a Hamas bomb maker. It was detonated remotely with a non-phone protocol (as the phone channel was in use by the target).
- Medicalidiot 7y agoFrom a friend that is an amateur radio enthusiest "It's because your phone connects to so many towers (50-100 at a time) at once that it's an issue versus bringing the plane down".
- kawfey 7y agoAs an RF engineer who has tested frequency spectra and radiated powers of various consumer electronics including cell phones, I've never seen a cell phone (specifically an iPhone 5, A Nexus, a Samsung Galaxy S4, and a razr flip phone) transmit with airplane mode turned off. It's not just airplanes that could be susceptable to cell phone emissions, but back in GSM days, the number of handoffs while in flight would effectively jam the cellular network in a 200mi radius. Nowadays cell phones are much smarter and don't do that, and the EMC risk in aircraft is extremely low.
- DoctorOetker 7y agomight phones in some sense be cheating emissions tests?
- iamkroot 7y agoHow? I don't think there's any way a phone could know if someone has a spectrum analyzer looking at it's antennas, so it wouldn't be able to distinguish between a user enabling airplane mode because they want to vs. someone testing it.
- sitkack 7y agoIn those RF cages, the phones are basically in a deep black void, pretty easy to tell you are in a void and not a rolling sunny hill. Or do what VW did and detect the testing station, I am sure the locations of the FCC test facilities are widely known.
- dmix 7y agoIf it was on airplane mode before it entered the room it wouldn't be able to tell, that'd be a useful first step.
- guywhocodes 7y agoWhy? Airplane mode is a software feature right, you just don't enable whatever power transistors you use to amplify your transmission. However a receiver won't give measurable EMF, you could still listen and detect any abnormally low noise floor. You could probably even employ a heuristic like "only call home if the noise floor has been very high for at least one hour". That would still be catastrophic for people trying to avoid tracking in demonstrations for example. Or what am I missing?
- drclau 7y agoJFYI, at least on iOS 13, airplane mode disables only the mobile connection, while WiFi and Bluetooth remain on. This is not hidden in any way, the buttons remain active in Control Center. I assume that only mobile signal has enough power to be considered dangerous. Maybe someone can explain what's the reasoning behind this choice.
- dwaite 7y agoI believe iPadOS/iOS 13 by default will leave Bluetooth on while in airplane mode (likely for watches and headphones). If you turn bluetooth off while in airplane mode, it remembers that as a preference.
- coldtea 7y agoThe reasoning was so that WF on flight, and BT/WF peripherals like AirPods, Apple Watch, and (for the iPad) the pencil, connected keyboards, and so on, can continue to work.
- flanbiscuit 7y agoI feel like this aligns with what "airplane" mode should be. I find it annoying when I turn on airplane mode and it disables my bluetooth and I have to re-enable it (Android X/Api 29 and below)
- ingenium 7y agoYou can set which radios are disabled with Airplane mode with an adb command. It persists and will even transfer to a new phone. The default is: adb settings put global airplane_mode_radios cell,bluetooth,wifi,nfc,wimax I have mine set to: adb settings put global airplane_mode_radios cell,wifi,wimax
- flanbiscuit 7y agoThat is great! Thanks for the tip.
- NowThenGoodBad 7y ago
- godelski 7y agoFrom what I've seen, the phone still collects all the data as normal but just doesn't transmit while in ariplane mode, but will transmit after. edit: Quickest thing I could find was a Tucker Carlson piece, so grain of salt https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0s8ZG6HuLrU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0s8ZG6HuLrU
- masswerk 7y agoNotably, appeals to not having your phone on in an airplane and airplane mode are more due to the extensive reach of an airborne cellphone and the effect this has on cells and hand-over protocols, as the phone connects to a plethora of cell towers in rapid succession, by this seriously harming available capacity. So this is intended more to protect the earthbound infrastructure than the cockpit electronics. I'd guess, subverting any countermeasures by means of the baseband system would be contrary to the interest of those involved and profiting from this.
- PeterStuer 7y ago"stopping the phone from sending crap that (supposedly) messes with airplanes" was never the goal of airplane mode. If phones could bring down an airplane they would have never been allowed on board. The technical problem was always that planes cross cells at speeds for which the gsm handover protocol was not designed. The business problem was phones would eat into the juicy onboard services turnover.
- ahje 7y agoMeta data from regular operation, combined with data from apps, and OS telemetry is probably be such a treasure trove that backdooring the baseband processor is probably overkill in most cases, and while I suspect there are phones backdoored in this manner the real threat will not likely be government agencies for most people; it's the risk that non-government actors discovers it and abuses it for criminal purposes. I suspect various alphabet agencies are perfectly aware of this, and that they're actively avoiding such measures unless they're considered strictly neccesary. After all, imagine the media shit-storm if some North-Korean hacker group managed to start mining bitcoin with 2 billion Android devices and it turns out that NSA put in the back door that allowed it.
- angry_octet 7y agoIt isn't plausible that the baseband is routinely incorporating backdoors. However it is very plausible that nation states do lots of testing of baseband firmware, with an eye towards exploiting it. If baseband protocols were as easy to test as wifi we would probably see more vuln reports about them. It is unlikely that they would be able to remotely update the baseband firmware though, especially on an iPhone. Also, an increasing number of baseband systems use highly verified kernels, such as sel4. As to phones in flight mode routinely pinging, this is incorrect. It would easily be detected by standard tools and counter-surveillance equipment. It isn't plausible that a modern phone would interfere with a modern jet IMO, but I still turn it to flight mode. Doesn't mean a passenger couldn't cause problems if they wanted too though -- turn on a GPS jammer and ADS-B/mode-S spoofer while onboard and watch everything go kooky. A more realistic security problem is that of phones listening to wifi when turned off for geolocation purposes. Just the listening is exposing the stack to some degree.
- beagle3 7y ago> It isn't plausible that the baseband is routinely incorporating backdoors. Intel and AMD effectively incorporate a back door into every processor, one that they refuse to document or give the keys for (but which likely some government agencies have, whether provided willingly or not). Why is it implausible that basebands incorporate something similar?
- angry_octet 7y agoFeatures like Intel ME were actually requested by major IHVs, like Dell/HP etc. VISA is a debug system you need ring 0 access to use. In contrast, Qualcomm/Intel clients like Apple are very concerned to not have magic backdoors (Apple bought Intel's bandband IP and team recently, supposedly to make their own 5G chip). In any case, there are plenty of garden variety vulnerabilities in bandband chips, no need for NSA voodoo.
- beagle3 7y agoYes, some users find them somewhat useful. That does not explain the complete lack of documentation, access keys, and the inability to turn it off under any circumstances. It is possible that this is not and has not been used as a back door. But why is that so implausible?