12 ms·
If Facebook decides which political ads are truthful, then either they reject all political ads (because when was the last time someone ran a political ad that
by AnimalMuppet 7y ago
If Facebook decides which political ads are truthful, then either they reject all political ads (because when was the last time someone ran a political ad that was wholly truthful?), or else they have do decide where to draw the line. Wherever they draw the line, they're going to reject someone's ad, and be exposed to screams of how they're biased for the other side. That's not going to end well for them.
I mean, just running them all is also getting Zuckerberg raked over the coals[1], but I think picking and choosing which ads are "truthful enough" is going to be worse.
And that's if Facebook is actually completely unbiased. If this becomes a vehicle for the biases of those at FB charged with judging the ads, that's even worse.
[1] Zuck was getting raked over the coals in the name of truth, but I suspect it was at least partly because those who did so thought they would benefit politically if FB censored their opponents' ads.
- eranima 7y agoNot all ads necessarily contain statements that would force Facebook to take a side on any issue or become an arbiter of truth. They could simply restrict political ads to essentially just "Vote for [candidate]", or something similar.
- dmix 7y agoYou mean ads paid for by (American?) registered campaigns or anyone who buys an advertisement deemed 'political'? It's easy to define an ideal ad or ideal bad-guy scenario, the problem is in the grey areas of categorizing such a chaotic, broad, and unpredictable group of content. That's always what ends up making this sort of thing a bad idea. They're always at massive risk for false positives, selective enforcement, moral panics, etc. It's also a giant distraction from real problems in the world and provides little long-term ROI compared to all the work that will go into it. It should be either all ads are okay with some obvious-tier moderation (ie, no ads promoting violence) OR no political ads at all. Let's not give FB et al even more power to choose what ads are okay, please.
- vkou 7y agoWhat about ads that promote war? That obviously seems to be promoting violence to me, but unfortunately, that doesn't seem to be a popular opinion.
- rocqua 7y agoPromote it in the abstract, or promote a very specific war. The first seems inside the line to me (stuff like 'support our troops' or 'Join the army, take the fight to our enemy'). The second is past the line (stuff like 'we need boots on the ground in Syria, write your senator!'). I guess legally there is a difference between 'promoting violence between citizens' and 'promoting violence in war'. Since the first is usually illegal, and the second is not.
- ivalm 7y agoIn general, government has a monopoly on legal violence. As such ads that promote war are promoting legal violence. Rules against promoting violence are (implicitly) targeting illegal violence. At the same time, if FB reduced political adds (including any war/military related ones), I would be supportive.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- j-c-hewitt 7y agoIt's really a question of whether or not Facebook should submit to FEC regulation or not. Other media outlets that run political ads need to submit to FEC regulation. Why does Facebook get an exemption? Newspapers literally have to run political ads by their editorial board and TV has to do something similar. It's one of the reasons why political ads are so bland and content-free: they don't want to make any claims that could be evaluated as true or false.
- wheelie_boy 7y agoYes, it's not like this is a problem that hasn't been dealt with in other media. I think one of the things that makes it more difficult in the case of facebook is that the ad targeting makes it possible to serve specific ads only to very specific groups. This means that if the ads say untrue or damaging things, most people will never know, as opposed to newspaper or TV ads. In my mind this argues for at least as strict controls, if not more stringent.
- pm90 7y agoWhat this ignores is that there is a finite amount of ads one can run. It would be easy enough for Facebook to classify ads as political/non-political and for political ads have more scrutiny over what they decide to air. And have strict penalties against those who choose to mis-classify their ads. Or make political ads visibile publicly for anyone to search for details as to who created them, how much they paid, how many people were targeted. All these are valid solutions to the problem, but Facebook doesn't want to do it, because if they can get away with what they're doing right now, they can make a ton of ad money.
- grandmczeb 7y ago> Or make political ads visibile publicly for anyone to search for details as to who created them, how much they paid, how many people were targeted. Isn't that already the case? You can already search all political ads and see who ran them, how much was paid, and the number of people who saw the ad.
- geggam 7y agoFB is either a service provider or a content moderator. One brings liability the other provides an exemption. I know what I would choose. Let the people ads lie about sue the ad purchaser
- outside1234 7y agoThey are clearly a content moderator. You can tell that by trying to post a nude picture.
- tzs 7y agoContent moderation does not reduce or remove the liability protection of section 230 of the Communications Decency Act.
- geggam 7y agoNot real sure how you can put political campaign ads in the same bucket as child pornography and still claim "good faith" ?
- tzs 7y agoWhere did I say anything about child pornography?! Are you perhaps confused because I mentioned the Communications Decency Act? It's true that one of the purposes of the CDA was to regulate pornography on the internet (although I don't think it was about child pornography--the pornography concern was about children seeing pornography on the net), but those parts of the CDA were struck by the Supreme Court in Reno v. American Civil Liberties Union, 521 U.S. 844 (1997). The CDA also, in section 230, said that providers and users of interactive computer services are not to be treated as the publisher or speaker of any information provided by another information content provider. Section 230 was not struct down in Reno v. ACLU, and remains in force.
- geggam 7y agoIntent. The law always uses intent. To compare political ads to the list below is facetious at best and I was calling out one example of content that could be moderated with protection and comparing it to a political ad. You seemed bothered by the comparison. As would most rational folks be. Not sure why this is difficult to understand. (2)Civil liability No provider or user of an interactive computer service shall be held liable on account of— (A)any action voluntarily taken in good faith to restrict access to or availability of material that the provider or user considers to be obscene, lewd, lascivious, filthy, excessively violent, harassing, or otherwise objectionable, whether or not such material is constitutionally protected; or
- jimbokun 7y agoHow much money would Facebook actually lose by banning all political ads? Seems like the amount of revenue their getting from political ads might not be worth the headaches and distraction they are causing the company.
- dageshi 7y agoYou might be right, but I think banning political ads would probably lead to people doing even more massive political astroturfing campaigns within facebook using the funds they would've spent on facebook ads. So facebook goes from having a political ad problem where at least they get paid, to having a political manipulation/content problem (well a bigger problem than they already have) that they still have to solve but don't get paid for.
- dillondoyle 7y agoI think it's less about revenue and more about common carrier status. Though FB has recently put out confusing signals [1], it seems that if they start to editorialize what content is delivered, even just a fraction, they are liable to editorialize it all - at HUGE cost. 1 https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/jul/02/facebook-mark-zuckerberg-platform-publisher-lawsuit https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/jul/02/facebook-...
- mandevil 7y agoThey currently do all sorts of blocking on what content is delivered. Try and run an ad with nudity. The sorts of nudity that is routine in a European advertising context is blocked on Facebook, because they choose not to. They could easily do the same for political ads, but they don't because they choose not to.
- manfredo 7y agoThis article erroneously claims that if Facebook is a publisher it loses section 230 protections. This is not the case. See https://www.eff.org/issues/bloggers/legal/liability/230 https://www.eff.org/issues/bloggers/legal/liability/230 for more details.
- 7y ago
- jonbronson 7y agoIt's a fallacy to believe that the ability to determine the truthfulness of the content of an ad is binary. 100% or 0%. It's a spectrum. There are obvious truths, shades of gray, blatant misinformation, and everything in between. At the very least, they should clearly disallow verifiably false information. An advertisement aimed at Black voters with the wrong day for voting? That's clearly voter disinformation aimed at voter suppression. How close Facebook gets to the gray areas is by no means an easy problem, but it's patently false to pretend they can do nothing.
- makomk 7y agoFacebook do disallow clear voter suppression ads like that one, though. They have a specific rule banning voter suppression which applies to all advertisers including politicians, and they definitely enforce it. One of the articles going after their hands-off approach to political ads (I think in the Guardian) even specifically attacked them for banning this whilst leaving other lies alone.
- humanrebar 7y agoDisinformation about voting dates or choices seems out of bounds. But any negative ad is at a basic level voter suppression.
- paulddraper 7y ago> It's a spectrum The parent comment agrees very strongly with that. > verifiably false information Look at Snopes for an example. Relatively few assertions are "pants on fire" false.
- DiogenesKynikos 7y agoEmpowering Snopes to effectively censor Facebook by deciding what is true and false seems incredibly dangerous to me.
- outside1234 7y agoThere are some things that are just provably false ("Donald Trump voted for the green new deal") - these ads should not be run.
- jerf 7y agoYet, that one is right next door to a very frequently deployed political lie: $POLITICIAN voted against $VOTER_DESIRED_POLICY, when in fact what they did was vote against some massive bill primarily about some other topic entirely that contained some head nod towards $VOTER_DESIRED_POLICY that may or may not even have done anything, or voted against a bill that did indeed have $VOTER_DESIRED_POLICY but had so much other crap in it they couldn't vote for it for some unrelated reason. Teasing that sort of thing out is above the pay grade of anyone Facebook is going to hire to resolve it.
- yters 7y agoThey should have a 'truth' button to accompany the 'like' button, and so people can see who thinks something is 'true', and if they identify with that group. Then there is no censorship, and people also get some sort of crowdsourced 'truth' value that allows them to see the source of bias.
- baq 7y agoBots and troll farms would be popping champagne the day it was introduced.
- knzhou 7y agoSorry, that just sounds naive. It’s all well and good until the echo chamber you live in meets a different echo chamber, which has a different idea of what’s true. The resulting conflict would instantly devolve into furious tribal warfare with people using the ‘like’ and ‘truth’ buttons as synonyms. Except with the worse feature that a popular post would seem to be additionally endorsed by Facebook as true.
- yters 7y agoGood point. 'like' and 'true' are not really different. Maybe allow people to 'like' political ads (or ads in general) will have the same effect.
- malandrew 7y agoThey should just categorize all political ads as "likely untruthful and misleading" and label them as such. If you're a politician and you're advertising on Facebook, your ad should be label "This ad is political and is likely untruthful or misleading. Viewer discretion advised."
- empath75 7y agoI’d be okay with facebook just not running political ads, tbh.
- cptskippy 7y agoImagine if Facebook required all Ads to be truthful and anyone found to have posted a false Ad would have all their Ads taken down for 2 weeks. It's not like the Ads are going to go away.
- chillacy 7y agoAds can be both truthful and misleading.
- remotecool 7y agoThe problem is who decides the truth? Children in cages Abortion is murder Both phrases are true or false depending on who you ask and the end result will be no ads for any politician because they all use questionable language that could be considered false.
- Vadoff 7y agoI don't get it, how come there's no outrage over political ads shown on TV? If it's a legal ad, why should Facebook police it?
- CydeWeys 7y agoPolitical ads on TV are regulated.
- bryan_w 7y agoNot in the way you're thinking: https://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2019/oct/15/elizabeth-warren/phony-facebook-ad-warren-said-most-tv-networks-wil/ https://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2019/oct...
- jpadkins 7y agohow so? I didn't see any mention of the content of TV or radio being regulated (other than the disclaimer of who paid for it) in my quick search. This article appears to say that the content is unregulated. https://www.thebalancecareers.com/should-tv-stations-ban-false-political-ads-3956480 https://www.thebalancecareers.com/should-tv-stations-ban-fal...
- chillacy 7y agoBut the ads in question were aired on TV, this letter is asking FB to go above and beyond what most TV networks are doing (CNN being the only one who did not air the trump ad, objecting because it called them "fake news")
- justapassenger 7y agoBecause lying TV ads are old news. FB is an easy target, by all the parties.
- badrequest 7y agoWould anybody besides Facebook's shareholders be upset if they just deemed political advertisements verboten on the platform?
- jkingsbery 7y agoFrom what I've read on the subject, it seems like limitations like this generally serve the incumbent (who benefits from default name recognition that challengers lack). This is perhaps reasonable approach (many people in this thread are suggesting this!), but it seems like this a thorny problem because there is no "neutral" position.
- dmitrygr 7y ago"Put them all up against the wall" is pretty neutral. Just saying.
- sjg007 7y agoHow do TV stations do it? How does the radio do it? Use those same rules. I feel like ads should have equal time provisions too.
- vkou 7y agoGiving two wolves equal time to discuss their bid for the county shepard is, in itself, not going to produce better governance. (And will happen to entrench the false dichotomy of 'there are two, and only two, valid choices.)
- erik_seaberg 7y agoIf 60 voters want X offered by two candidates but 40 want not-X from one candidate, not-X wins 40-30-30. It's not a false dichotomy, it's the flawed outcome of plurality voting.
- landryraccoon 7y agoIn this analogy, if the people are truly sheep, there is nothing to be done. Democracy is finished. The entire premise of Democracy is that voters can be trusted on average to make correct decisions on who should lead. If that premise is false, the wolves win in any scenario no matter what.
- partiallypro 7y agoThere was an ad that had Paul Ryan pushing a grand mother off of a cliff that ran on TV. So Facebook is free to run that, right? Swiftboating, GWB draft dodge charges (later rebuffed after CBS reported it,) the famous "Daisy" ad that was run against Goldwater, etc. I'd love to see where people draw the line.
- asdf333 7y agoagreed. i think the only right answer here is to just ban them all especially if its not a significant source of revenue. ruining the brand for pennies on the dollar is not smart.
- manquer 7y agoPolitical ad spends is expected to be 6 billion USD. It is by no means a small market. Not to mention influence that gives in lobbying
- joering2 7y ago> That's not going to end well for them. Define what you mean? Like users will stop using it or advertisers stop advertising? Facebook IS already banning some categories of ads that could normally upset you - for example you cannot advertise a Gun Store - even tho owning firearm is rooted in being an American. But I don't see Americans leaving in hoards to some other venue. Same with sex ads, viagra, etc, etc. Facebook has their own reasons to block them and it only "ends for them" with higher stock price.
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoIt's going to end badly for in the form of more Congressional oversight, not less; more politicians yelling at them, not less; and more people angry at them, not less.
- jammygit 7y agoIn the recent Canadian election, the conservatives used Facebook to target Asian Canadians with ads falsely claiming that the liberals wanted to legalize hard drugs. It shouldn’t be facebooks job to police that though, we should have legal recourse when that happens
- FussyZeus 7y ago> (because when was the last time someone ran a political ad that was wholly truthful?) Perhaps this is a good time then, to revisit this norm itself? Why is this allowed? Sure, politicians lie, it is known, but we've reached a point where the lies on one side (and it is one side, the Republican side) have diverged so far from reality than the base of that side can no longer engage in any meaningful debate on any issue. It's not even a question of bias, most Republican talking points and positions literally do not make logical sense. They scream and rant about problems that don't exist, and refuse to acknowledge the ones that do that are inconvenient. So much of the right is based on such hard misinformation as to be ridiculous. And of course Democrats fudge the truth a little here and there too, and that should stop as well. To be frank I think the benefits of "Free Speech" are vastly overvalued. You shouldn't have the right to say whatever you want, at least not in the context of politics. You should be held to account for factual inaccuracies, perhaps not penalized but it should be noted, and you should be penalized for what can be demonstrably proven as outright lies and misinformation.
- bluejekyll 7y ago> To be frank I think the benefits of "Free Speech" are vastly overvalued. Free Speech really only applies to the government, not private companies, so FB can impose whatever rules they want (though that might depend on if the FEC decides to try and enforce some regulation). Also, even Free Speech has its limits, for example, yelling "fire!" into a crowd to cause a mass panic when there is no fire is not protected speech. Other examples include slander, this wiki page has a nice discussion on Supreme Court decisions as it relates to the First Amendment: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_free_speech_exceptions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_free_speech_exce...
- FussyZeus 7y ago> so FB can impose whatever rules they want Except, as evident, they don't. And they don't really have a financial motive to police speech, in fact they have financial motives to turn a blind eye to it. And moreover, Facebook not making more money does not affect society at large, but the continued distribution of misinformation has direct repercussions for society at large.
- starpilot 7y ago> Wherever they draw the line, they're going to reject someone's ad, and be exposed to screams of how they're biased for the other side Today it's not about being "unbiased" and objective, it's about receiving equal amounts of bias allegations from both sides. That's what the NYTimes has done, liberals are saying it's not harsh enough on Trump.
- austincheney 7y agoThey could ignore truth all together and simply focus on factual accuracy.
- kpU8efre7r 7y ago"I plan to do X, vote for me" truthful. "Don't vote for Y, they want to kill babies" not truthful. It's pretty clear to me which ads are in bad faith. I really just wish Americans were bright enough to see through the bullshit themselves but alas, here we are.
- sp527 7y agoIt’s this type of subtle, rational-sounding pacifism that paves the way for evil to erode societies. Regulatory institutions have to actively and vigorously prohibit brainwashing of the masses. Even if it’s unpalatable, it’s the only real way to preserve democracy.
- pell 7y agoThere is regulation for political ads in almost any medium. I don't see why Facebook is exempt from that. The anger towards Facebook is easy to understand as they categorize Breitbart News as "trusted" in their News section.