5 ms·
There are 1,3 billion people in China so the overtaking of the GDP would be expected if they reach a certain developmental level. If often hear the economic gr
by raxxorrax 7y ago
There are 1,3 billion people in China so the overtaking of the GDP would be expected if they reach a certain developmental level.
If often hear the economic growth must be due to surveillance and an autocratic regime, a laughable suggestion, although often shared by my unimaginitive government (Europe).
The third reich also had a booming economy. War creates massive economic opportunity. Slavery too. But somehow increased governmental control is the key for economic success? Doubtful at least.
The success of China is pretty straight forward. They had very cheap workers and hungry foreign consumers. I don't see how you wouldn't get any profit out of that situation. But no, it certainly must be due to complete systemic differences instead of economical ones.
- friendlybus 7y agoThe Chinese gov did play a big part in keeping the economic boom going. They continually propped up the housing bubble even though it was generating new construction well over demand and could have crashed multiple times. They did a bunch of currency manipulation to keep exports going. Whatever that was keeping shipping costs in and out of China so low worked very well. I don't think you can rule out the government as a factor, there's plenty of cheap workers in the world that want money.
- raxxorrax 7y agoTrue, but I doubt that creating bubbles will create long time economic growth. And that there are indeed are cheaper workers elsewhere has already become a problem for China. Still, you cannot say they didn't grab the opportunities and have indeed build up significant industrial infrastructure. Maybe a strong central government is currently required to keep the peace for so many different people, but the tendency to see Chinas governmental system as some form of panacea for all problems is a bit off in my opinion. Given more time to develop, I believe the authority will decrease and that this process actually gives more room for even more opportunities.
- eru 7y agoA reasonable monetary policy will avoid recessions, yes. Currency manipulation is not really a useful concept.
- ClumsyPilot 7y agoIt's a bit rich to criticise China's approach to currency after 2008. Their government should be given credit for basic competence, which our leaders don't seem to have. Their government has consistently put major support behind key industrial sectors and built out infrastructure that enabled industrial growth. Just as an example, China now has more high-speed rail than the rest of the world combined. They are the world's leading manufacturer of solar panels, electric vehicles, etc. There are several countries with equal or better starting positions, yet no achieving equivalent economic growth. Meanwhile holders of the highest office in US/UK are busy with Brexit, building a wall, and denying climate change exists.
- friendlybus 7y agoI fail to see the lack of basic competence once you look outside of hot button issues, or even inside those issues. It is trivial to make both China and the west look good or bad with a selective view. I was not seeking to criticize China (though I will if it makes sense to) but to make the observation for parent's sake that the Chinese gov does in fact play it's hand in the economy.
- eru 7y agoIndeed. Private consumption per capita wasn't so great in the Third Reich. The Great Depression in the US was only great because of some really stupid policy decisions. So some other countries avoiding the worst of that Depression doesn't mean they had Great policy, just that they were slightly less stupid in that regard.
- krageon 7y agoThe thought that economic success is solely due to simple factors that you understand and not the complex interaction of systems that are large and practically unknowable seems to me to be very close to hubris.