12 ms·
New 2MW electric vehicle chargers could revolutionise mining industry
- satanspastaroll 7y agoInteresting; it seems that the dust in mines is actually conductive, and makes for a challenge with high-powered appliances.
- LeonM 7y agoAny foreign material in high-powered electronics (conductive or not) can cause problems, so these electronics must always be sealed properly. But I foresee no big problems with this, because this is something that manufacturers of such equipment have plenty of experience with.
- scrumper 7y agoI saw that too. I wondered whether it might be simpler to have removable batteries (I know they'd be big) and set the charger up on the surface, away from the conductive dust. Vehicle downtime that way may be shorter (remove expended batteries and replace them with a fresh set from the charging station) than charging the vehicle. Maybe that means you need fewer vehicles? Not a fan of the class of comment where people from outside the field propose dumb obvious solutions that make no sense to any actual practitioner, so this is more of a question.
- duckymcduckface 7y agoThe problem with that is getting the batteries to surface. Underground mines operate in either of two access methods: shaft to surface or ramp to surface. In shaft to surface you use an elevator to move all the ore and waste out of the mine for processing, in ramp to surface you'll either use a conveyor belt or use trucks like these to run from where they're loaded to surface. Trucks are also used in shaft access to move ore internally but generally not to surface. In the truck to surface the swap would work but in a shaft access scenario you'd have to throw the batteries into the elevator which has an impact on the proportion of the time you use the shaft for ore. Also usually those trucks are left near where they're needed the operators get picked up at the end of their shift and the next guy gets dropped back at the equipment at the start of his shift. So positioning of these chargers would be tricky. The payoff in terms of savings in ventilation though are where the benefits come for these though. Price of electricity can be very high depending on where the mine is since it's very common to operate off grid in remote locations.
- scrumper 7y agoThanks, I understand that. Of course access-to-surface is another constrained resource which is no doubt already optimized for existing operations.
- baybal2 7y agoSounds too ambitious. There are people working at 900kw chargers at BYD, and they say that cabling for it is already so stiff and heavy that it's bordering on the limit of what is humanly possible to handle. Under spec electronic components are exploding in split second. Imagine a bank of DC-DC converters operating at 600A, and where few stages go out of sync. 10% of 600A is still 60A that turns into heat, in addition to heat already generated by normal operation.
- tw04 7y agoIn a mining situation, why would you think they’d be handled by humans? I would expect it to be a machine driven coupler. Completely unrealistic in a consumer situation due to potential damage and liability. But in a mine? Nobody is going to care about a scratched body panel.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoThey might care about horrific electrical accidents. With High voltage/high Amperage acidents - your lucky if you die on the spot otherwise you last a few days in intensive care with limbs blown off and your internal organs destroyed
- criddell 7y agoMines are such dangerous places that horrific electrical accidents may happen occasionally and it's still an improvement from the current situation.
- ivankolev 7y agoI think the end goal is to not have humans on the field unless something untoward happens.
- donkeyd 7y agoYou can couple mechanically, but get a human to check before actually supplying power. Seems like a simple thing to fix.
- kuu 7y agoIt's promising to see some other areas more than the cars trying to use electric vehicles. I hope we can reach a 100% electric (and clean generation) before it's too late...
- epistasis 7y agoIt's already "too late" in the sense that stopping carbon emissions won't be enough to prevent catastrophic change. It's just now that in addiction to stopping, we need to go negative and start sequestering carbon. This is a far more expensive path than if we had decarbonized sooner. For detailed info from real scientists rather than an internet rando, see IPCC SR 1.5, in particular figure 2.5: https://www.ipcc.ch/sr15/graphics/#cid_457 https://www.ipcc.ch/sr15/graphics/#cid_457 And if you have kids or care about fairness to future generations, this paper should spur you into action: Young people's burden: requirement of negative CO2 emissions https://www.earth-syst-dynam.net/8/577/2017/ https://www.earth-syst-dynam.net/8/577/2017/
- bryanlarsen 7y agoWhy not just run multiple chargers in parallel?
- Klathmon 7y agoThat's kinda what they are underneath, but things are never that simple. For example, getting all that power across a single "cable" (or bundle of cables, or connector of some kind) introduces interesting engineering issues. Heat is a big problem, and watercooled cables are more and more common even in regular EVs. The article also talks about how conductive dust can be a massive issue and how they need to work around that.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoBut why bother bundling the parallel cables? It's probably faster / easier to hook up six separate flexible cables than a single bundle that's incredibly stiff and heavy.
- Klathmon 7y agoI'm assuming since even 250kw EV chargers require liquid cooling and are already difficult to work with (limited length, extremely stiff and a lot of hardware to safely connect), that it becomes a bit cumbersome to work with 8 of those cables. And even if you are reusing the same connectors and cables, I'm assuming it would need some kind of orchestration to have all the chargers work in unison. And at that point designing a single connector sounds like a logical next step. Especially if they are going to design it to work in the harsh environments they expect. But I'm also just a layperson, so I absolutely don't know for sure.
- Reason077 7y agoHigher voltages and liquid cooled cables permit higher power levels without making the cables and connectors unreasonably large and heavy. You can see this in Tesla's "V3" supercharger, where they increased the power to 250 kW, but actually made the cables thinner by adding liquid cooling. Of course, high voltages do brings other issues, like risk of arcing, that need to be mitigated.
- jillesvangurp 7y agoMining is not the only place where this is starting to happen. Fully charged recently did an episode on an electric digger: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cumZxYjzx6M https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cumZxYjzx6M Fuel cost is a great incentive of course but other advantages include a lot less noise and pollution; which is great for indoor operation. Also, these things only use power when you use them (as opposed to idling and slurping lots of diesel). I could see batteries get common for a lot of equipment that is currently diesel powered, in the agricultural, construction, and other sectors. If all you need is a lot of torque/power, electric & hydrolic can do the job.
- codeduck 7y agoElectrical is also a lot simpler and cheaper to maintain.
- abakker 7y agoit is also upgradeable - i.e. an improvement in efficiency for a motor of the same format, or improvements of the battery in the same format can both be "drop in" upgrades. Not necessarily trivial, but much easier than with ICEs.
- johnatwork 7y agoNot only is it much cheaper to maintain, but also a lot safer for the work site and workers to maintain as well. Used motor oil is some nasty stuff, and spilt coolant is quite toxic (but attracts animals).
- proee 7y agoWith all the electronics driving these machines, I don't think they are simpler. There are certainly less moving parts, but if something fails in an electric version you will only be able to debug down to the modular level, which could be VERY expensive to replace. Also, if the manufacture goes bust, you may never be able to get a replacement module so the vehicle is now worthless.
- 7y ago
- Reason077 7y agoThe charging system being referred to is called HPCCV (High Power Charging for Commercial Vehicles), and is being defined by the CharIN group, the same industry organisation responsible for the CCS standard. Incidentally, Tesla is also involved in this effort, as part of the specification of the charging connector for the Tesla Semi. CharIN Steering Committee paves the way for the development of a CCS compliant plug for commercial vehicles with >2MW https://www.charinev.org/news/news-detail-2018/news/charin-steering-committee-paves-the-way-for-the-development-of-a-ccs-compliant-plug-for-commercial-v/ https://www.charinev.org/news/news-detail-2018/news/charin-s...
- wlesieutre 7y agoI don't know who the big players are in electric busses, but I bet this is useful for that too.
- Reason077 7y agoYes! Several electric bus makers like BYD, Proterra, and New Flyer are also members of CharIN.
- p1mrx 7y agoIt's nice to hear that Tesla is working on a real standard for once. I bought an EV recently, but didn't consider the Model 3 because it doesn't have a J1772 port (nor a proper dashboard, but I digress.)
- m463 7y agoFor the model 3 - you need a small dongle for J1772 (provided). On the other hand Europe pushed back on Tesla and its proprietary charging standard and cars there have SAE charging ports instead of tesla ports. (SAE ports are dual J1772 + fast charge) I wholeheartedly agree with your dashboard complaint. Used Model S? Autopilot + big battery + dashboard.
- zaroth 7y agoTesla comes with a J1772 adapter. Isn’t J1772 limited to 20kW? Why would a built-in 20kW max charging connector be a must-have specification for an EV? And the lack of the “real dashboard” is obviously one of the best things going for the Model 3. Makes night time driving in particular almost surreal. The car is extremely forward thinking and futuristic. Definitely not for everyone.
- cascom 7y agoFor what it’s worth I know the three highest costs in most mines are: Diesel, explosives, and tires. Anything you can do to address those issues are big $ savings
- londons_explore 7y agoTires? Really? Most work vehicles rarely go above 10 mph, and could probably get away with non-air-filled tyres made of steel if necessary. They'd last forever then.
- ceejayoz 7y agohttps://www.mining.com/kal-tire-at-minexpo/ https://www.mining.com/kal-tire-at-minexpo/ seems to back that assertion up.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoPneumatic tires have far superior performance characteristics. They have steel wheels. They are called sheep foot wheels or compaction wheels. They are much harder on the equipment running them.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- duckymcduckface 7y agoThey're 50-80k a tire on a cat797 and the truck has 6. Mine roads aren't the same as normal people roads, top layer can vary between what you see on a gravel road to basically really crap with chunks bigger than your fist. Add on to that you're carrying anywhere between 60 to 400 tons.
- qiqitori 7y agoAre there any mines where machines/vehicles are powered by e.g. overhead cables? Seems like that might in some cases be cheaper to pull off than equipping huge vehicles that go up and down the same path over and over again with huge batteries.
- lallysingh 7y agoDepends on what you're moving, I suppose. Some materials may have gasses that don't like sparks.
- Reason077 7y agoUnless your vehicles are operating a very consistent route that rarely or never changes, it's likely to be cheaper to go with batteries than to build and maintain a network of overhead wires.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoThe article mentions that pantographs are unusable due to the number of exposed moving parts and the existence of conductive dust.
- londons_explore 7y agoConductive dust is evil. Even your phone will likley stop working if you get conductive dust into it. It's as bad as water, except gravity doesn't keep it pooled on the floor.
- qiqitori 7y agoI searched a bit and found that "Trolley Assist" apparently refers to a system where large diesel-electric mining trucks use overhead lines for part of their journey. (You can do an image search for "trolley assist" and find examples.) I guess this is the kind of thing I was looking for.
- ajpgrealish 7y agoThere is an example of this at the Lumawan Copper Mine in Zambia. It's trucks are powered by overhead cables and electric motors whilst driving up the fixed ramps, It then switches to diesel when moving around away from the ramp. What is really interesting is that this not only reduces fuel use but allows them to move up the ramps much more quickly and improves productivity of the mine.
- SigmundA 7y agoJust to put in perspective if my math's right based on 139k btu per gallon and say 40% diesel engine efficiency and 60 gallons per minute truck stop diesel pump flow, the diesel pump is equivalent to about a 60 megawatt charger. Which is why a diesel semi can refill in a few minutes and go for 1000+ miles while an electric semi will take half hour to charge for 500 miles at 2MW. Obviously though for mining operations where its short range goes up and then back down electrification is perfect, its also great for urban buses with regular short routes.
- sunstone 7y agoApparently the largest electric mining trucks on earth never have to charge. They go up the hill empty, load up with tons of rock, and regen all the way back down which is more than enough to recharge. This makes my engineer's heart smile.
- SigmundA 7y agoYes that is a beautiful application of regenerative braking I have to say.
- alkonaut 7y agoHere I was thinking stuff was loaded down in the mine and then driven UP out of the mine. I realize there are differnt kinds of mines, but assuming it's a hole in the ground, the truck takes the material up, and the hole isn't situated on a hill... why and where is it going down with material? Really interested to read about this.
- anonymousDan 7y agoIs it realistic to remove ventilation with all that conductive dust floating around?
- remus 7y agoPresumably the ventilation and filtration requirements will be significantly reduced rather than completely eliminated.
- Roark66 7y agoI always thought mining equipment intentionally runs on hydraulic power (and pneumatic back in the day) to avoid sparks that could set off possible gas or dust particle explosion. With brushless motors etc I can imagine how electric can match the safety of hydraulic power, but lithium-ion batteries in a mine? That is a horrible accident waiting to happen. What if the battery is pierced by something? What if it shorts internally when due to an accident? I wouldn't want to be anywhere near it when that happens. We limit the size of lithium-ion batteries we can fly with precisely for the same reason.
- bdamm 7y agoFlight limits on lithium are because the TSA and NTSB can't control the quality of products shipped in luggage holds on passenger jets, not because lithium batteries can't be made safely. Also piercing a battery is a secondary concern to the primary hazard of an object piercing protected machinery. The heat from the lance could spark a fire, and you don't need a battery for that.
- pixl97 7y agoNo. Unless its specialized underground mining may take precautions, but a huge portion of above ground mining equipment is already electric. Most of the biggest shovels on the planet are hooked to a power cable.
- londons_explore 7y agoA quick thought experiment... If you wanted to transfer 2MW, you could do it at 200 amps and 10,000 volts. Two 200 amp conductors, 3 meters long, and 10 mm^2 cross sectional area will come out at half a kilogram. 400 watts of heating will happen in the wire, which could be cooled by a 1mm^2 water/steam return cooling pipe in each conductor running at 1 ml/sec. That weighs another 12 grams. Insulating a 10,000 volt supply sounds a lot, but if the wire was insulated with PTFE, with a 10x safety margin, you would only need a thickness of 1mm on each conductor. Total weight 140 grams. So - the total weight of a 2 Megawatt human-safe cable could, with the right engineering, be under a kilogram (2 lbs) for 3 meters of cable, plenty to hook up your car or truck.
- mdorazio 7y agoYou're not wrong, but what is an EV going to do with 10,000 volts? You'd have to convert that into something useful to the battery system, so all you've done is shove the efficiency drop and heating issues into the vehicle's on-board transformer systems (which would add more weight) instead of the charger.
- timerol 7y ago> “If we increase the voltage on the car side then we can reduce the current we need to push through the cable….so we are looking at higher voltage drivetrains,” says Elshout. Presumably connect the batteries in series rather than parallel, so that the voltage is increased and the current is lessened
- londons_explore 7y agoIt isn't unreasonable to have a battery which can reconfigure itself. It could switch from parallel to series just by opening and closing a few relays.
- mdorazio 7y agoI'm thinking this would probably greatly increase the chance of arcing and catastrophic battery failures in the cell packs, but I'm not certain on that. Also, you still need to get that power into something useful for the rest of the car now - usually 12V for electronics and probably 350ish volts AC for the motor, so you're still going to need to deal with the conversions at some point. There's a reason high-voltage lines are nowhere near people and transformers are chunky as hell. Probably those reasons overlap with EV design constraints.
- cellular 7y agoThe headline made me think bitcoin miners were using free charging stations to power their mobile mining PCs.
- ClumsyPilot 7y agohaha, this is actually quite witty ^ ^
- lbriner 7y agoI'm not sure how much these batteries are compared to the rest of the truck but why not just have removable battery packs that can take longer to charge while a fresh one gets clipped on? You might only need a few % spare batteries?
- drcross 7y agoIt's difficult to build an interface for high power draw which is convenient enough that doesn't break down over thousands of uses.
- auiya 7y agoWhy quick charge instead of just doing a battery swap?
- ufo 7y agoElectric car batteries are large. It is hard to remove them without also taking apart a big part of the car at the same time
- auiya 7y agoYou'd do the swap using machinery, not by hand.
- loufe 7y agoYou're right, but can you imagine how many problems could be introduced by changing batteries in an underground mine? A brand new equipment takes a single shift to gain a nice coat of mud from head to toe. I don't think it's impossible but there are a lot of challenges with regards to battery swapping that would need to be addressed before this becomes feasible for this industry.
- auiya 7y agoWhy would you change it underground? You'd schedule the changes in a controlled environment. Or is this naive?
- ehnto 7y agoSome entrepreneurs in Adelaide recently developed a fully electric utility vehicle for use in agribusiness and mining. It's based on a 79 series LandCruiser (which are still made brand new) and it has 350km of range. I saw some people scoff at that, but mining and agribusiness have the ability to introduce infrastructure, and these vehicles are work vehicles for use on site. Well managed vehicle and battery stocks could see these running 24/7 if need be. Have some solar on site or a grid hookup and you'd never have to worry about fuel logistics for the light vehicle section of your fleet. https://thedriven.io/2019/10/24/first-electric-ute-engineered-in-australia-for-use-in-mining-and-agribusiness/ https://thedriven.io/2019/10/24/first-electric-ute-engineere...
- bullen 7y agoElectricity is not a source of energy, you need to burn something else to generate it. Solar, wind and hydro only takes us so far. Batteries can not compete with the energy density of dead trees, it's actually two orders of magnitude off.
- std_throwaway 7y agoTry burning dead trees or their derivatives indoors or underground and suddenly you care about zero emission vehicles. Zero emission here means that they don't emit at the place where they are used e.g. in an underground mine or a city center. Electricity generation in a power plant with proper filters is much cleaner than having many local burners emitting their exhaust right into your breathing air.
- bullen 7y agoWell that doesn't help much when you're down in a hole in the ground risking your life for money that is created out of thin air.
- bullen 7y agoJust to add a law of nature: The carbon based system can drive metal based systems, but no the other way around. So you will never be able to make food/nuclear/mining with electricity, only dead trees can make both metal and organic stuff. This means nuclear is completely retarded.
- zaroth 7y agoAt some point isn’t it simpler and cheaper to have several independent battery packs which each present their own 350kW ports and you can connect multiple charging cables at once — versus inventing entirely new standards and needing a pluggable harness that can carry two freakin’ megawatts?
- greglindahl 7y agoThat's what Tesla showed for the semi, it's 4 car battery packs used in parallel to power 4 motors, and a 4-cable cable for charging.
- leggomylibro 7y agoIt might be hard to independently charge parallel batteries - you'd have to electrically isolate them and re-connect them after charging, right? Or would you have something like one battery per wheel or axle if you had multiple motors?