7 ms·
Bipolar-Zener Combo Takes On CMOS
- fouric 7y agoThe static power dissipation might be a problem, depending on its magnitude, and would only be exacerbated by the increased density. On the other hand, the increased density allows for lower latency relative to CMOS, and latency improvements are hard to come by.
- adammunich 7y agoThese are insulated gate transistors so you don't need base current. It might not be too bad actually.
- markrages 7y agoIf it is Zener-ing, there is some base current, no? The article says there is "some" static power requirement... that sounds like base current to me.
- adammunich 7y agoThis is absolutely incredible, I can't wait to see what foundries adopt the process.
- zw123456 7y agoInteresting, here is another link with some additional interesting points: https://www.electronicsweekly.com/news/design/tunnelling-transistor-offers-logic-power-easy-make-ic-2019-10/ https://www.electronicsweekly.com/news/design/tunnelling-tra... What caught my eye was this tidbit.... "Analogue computing The last trick up SFN’s sleeve is Bizen analogue blocks – op-amps and comparators (in the PDK), and even analogue computing blocks such as a divider – the analogue computing blocks avoiding using logic – and thus the associated ADC and DAC – in certain applications. Using a coarse-fine architecture, Summerland is predicting 1μW 1μs analogue division instead of ~20 instructions and ~100 instruction cycles if logic was employed. This analogue processing capability is being branded IPU for ‘instantaneous processing unit’." Analog computers making a comeback ? you never know.
- ajuc 7y agoI wonder if using this for low-precision floating point math in graphic cards would make sense. Maybe it's a way to do realtime raytracing? Who cares if the results have a little noise? It can be even argued it gives it a special "look".
- breck 7y ago> Analog computers making a comeback ? you never know. For dataflow paradigms like deep neural nets it makes sense. If it's significantly faster and significantly more power efficient, and the intermediate states are largely arbitrary weights anyway, what's the point of digital precision.
- regularfry 7y agoIt's not the precision, it's avoiding O(n^2) physical connections per layer.
- breck 7y agoThat's my point. Swapping digital for analog gives up the ability to know the precise bits of a register but in return you gain a lot in efficiency.
- regularfry 7y agoThat's not what I'm getting at. It's not the nodes you need to worry about, it's the edges. If you've got two fully connected 100-neuron layers in a physical circuit, that's 10,000 wires you need to route, and they all want to cross each other. That's why nobody builds physical neural networks.
- colechristensen 7y agoI guess all you would have to do is to make sure the precision was a few dB/bits more accurate than 16/32/64 bit floating point for a certain sigma probability and a lot of people would be perfectly happy with it.
- hthtegr 7y agoDoes the quantum tunneling have a lower limit on node size? This is being developed it seems to keep a 1um fab competitive, but does it also apply to smaller nodes?
- m0xte 7y agoIt’s got a terrible reputation on repeatability on a process. One reason tunnel diodes never went anywhere. They were expensive, tetchy and unreliable!
- dfox 7y agoThere was one big application for tunnel diodes: fast comparators. IIRC many classic Tek scopes use tunnel diode based comparator in their trigger circuitry. On the other hand doing the same thing in some modern bipolar process is significantly cheaper and more reliable. Another thing is that in such designs the tunnel diode looks like it does nothing. And that may have something to do with most engineers not using it.
- m0xte 7y agoExactly. I actually have few ex Tektronix trigger tunnel diodes here[1]. Repairing the infernal scopes was a hobby of mine until I got fed up of it. By the mid-80s we had cheap ECL comparators which were much faster, required no bias calibration and lasted a lot longer. [1] https://imgur.com/5ijmSh8 https://imgur.com/5ijmSh8
- magnat 7y agoWhat's the likelyhood that Intel, TSMC or some other fab company already stumbled upon the process in r&d and binned (hehe) it due to some unforeseen difficulties making it not worth investing?
- zwieback 7y agoIs there a problem with charge, like in MOSFETs?
- mannykannot 7y agoIs this what you are thinking of? "Bizen also does not suffer from CMOS’ electrostatic discharge (ESD) susceptibility and latch-up problems."
- m0xte 7y agoI bet it does suffer ESD issues. Even “SWR proof” RF BJTs are fragile. Anyway not that it matters really here even for CMOS as the ESD protection is just on the die lands. Most of the devices on the thing don’t have ESD protection on CMOS.
- tawm 7y agoI think the question is about gate charge.
- amelius 7y agoAnd I guess gate capacitance may cause signal-delays.
- magicalhippo 7y agoNot just delays. Being able to drive a transistor fast can be important for reducing power dissipation. That is, for switching one wants the transistor to spend the least amount of time in the non-saturated (linear) region where it acts as a resistor.
- Ballas 7y agoJudging by the process size quoted in the article, they won't be chasing speed, but rather low-cost devices.
- 7y ago
- ChuckMcM 7y agoPretty cool, I think the rub will be how well they can control the PN boundary and hence the switching thresholds. The simpler NOR gate was pretty cool too, so their next step should be to build a RAM chip (either a 2 gate equivalent dynamic cell or 4 gate equivalent static cells) If they can do that, then they can show that the process can be controlled well enough for reliable gate fabrication. Then the step after that might be mixed mode analog/digital circuit paths. Process control gets even harder when you're doing analog as non-linearity propagates and you can't ever get rid of it. A typical zener[1] has a variance of >100mV for its breakdown voltage. The "easy" analog circuits in my radio need better than 40 dB of dynamic range which is more like 1 mV so 100 times better than a zener. I'll have to read up more on the device physics to see if getting that level of precision or better is really practical. [1] http://www.vishay.com/docs/84830/plzseries.pdf http://www.vishay.com/docs/84830/plzseries.pdf
- magicalhippo 7y ago> A typical zener[1] has a variance of >100mV for its breakdown voltage. My interpretation was that that was the point of the substrate biasing: "A second tunnelling junction, represented by two horizontal lines in the device diagram, biases the device so that it is ‘on’ (but not saturated) when the tunnel terminal is open-circuit. While this represents a continuous current flow to ground during operation, tunnel current is typically only 2-5nA [...]"
- robocat 7y agoWhat is "plasma metal edge" and "wet edge metal"? The article is a unique usage of these words in that order... Edit: generally the article feels a bit like word salad for April fools (however, I only have an undergraduate EE knowledge of transistor design, so there's a lot I don't understand in there). Edit 2: if it were a good chance to become a breakthrough tech, why is it missing deep VC level funding to get it to market? I know it's not software, but neither is it limited by FDA regulations!
- baybal2 7y agoIt is how you etch the metal-device contact. Using liquid or plasma. Plasma etch is more expensive and slower, but is easier to control. > Edit 2: Electronics is not in vogue with those people. Just like in computer science, the few breakthroughs that matter in last few decades went by nearly completely anonymous despite their enormous utility, but every cat video website gets... you know.
- campfireveteran 7y agoEEVblog (Dave) entered the chat hope he makes a video about this development.
- satya71 7y agoThis looks interesting, but it's very early days. No mention of reliability, variation, interconnect (modern CMOS processes have 8-10 layers of interconnect). Certainly not taking on CMOS anytime soon.