13 ms·
The US nuclear forces’ messaging system finally got rid of its floppy disks
- mdorazio 7y agoI was kind of hoping they were replacing the floppy disks with CDs or something else equally old school and hard to hack.
- oyashirochama 7y agoMost likely that would be what they use due to its security. It's what most of the air force has transitioned to for backups and transferring data in classified and unclassified environments alike.
- killjoywashere 7y agoThey explicitly said solid state. I suspect they are trying to future-proof their tech stack somewhat to ensure reliable sourcing.
- dsamarin 7y agoAs far as I know, we don't even know the length of time CDs will last because they haven't been around long enough. I would love someone to correct me if I'm wrong.
- madengr 7y agoCD-R are maybe 10 years. Floppies are more reliable. I have plenty of C64 and Apple II floppies that work fine.
- einr 7y agoFloppies are more reliable. I have plenty of C64 and Apple II floppies that work fine. 5,25" floppies (especially lower density variants like the ones you mention) are quite reliable indeed, but the most recently common 1.44 MB 3,5" floppy is terrible.
- magduf 7y agoNope, when I was using 1.44MB floppies, they were extremely reliable. However, after most people had moved on, when I did use more recently-manufactured ones, they were indeed terrible. My theory is that, when Zip disks and CD-Rs took over and people stopped using 1.44MB floppies, the manufacturing of them changed, and both the disks and the drives became much crappier than they used to be. The drive manufacturing moved from Japan to Thailand, for instance, for some of the drives I looked at, and the components were noticeably crappier (drive motors much smaller, for instance). These were the days when every PC had a 1.44MB drive just for Windows XP drivers, and no one ever used the drive for anything else because it was just too small, so the OEMs really cut back on the quality since the drives weren't expected to be used much. But back in the early 90s, it wasn't like that; those disks were totally bulletproof, just like all the other floppies.
- madengr 7y agoI'm having the same issue with CD drives. The quality now is garbage, compared to the days of caddy loading. Recently bought 4 at $18 each, and will just through them out when they break. Even the Windows support of CDs has gone to shit. Windows 10 usually can't figure out if the burned CD was already ejected and inserted with a fresh one, and randomly retains files from the previous burn. Ripping audio CDs is slower than it used to be as the drives seem to become unbalanced.
- einr 7y agoHere's me replying to a 12 day old comment, but... You are right that at some point they started making (much) worse quality 1.44MB floppies (and drives, probably, though I have had nothing but good experiences with mid-2000's floppy drives so far), but I still say they're much less reliable overall than most 5,25" formats. I say this partly because I have a retro-computing hobby and when acquiring random floppies from various places my experience is that 360K floppies from the mid-80's almost invariably still work fine while DD and HD 3,5" floppies from the late 80's to mid 90's are about 50-75% unreadable garbage at this point. They just don't survive. I also remember having to throw out a lot of 3,5" floppies (name-brand, too; Sony, Verbatim, etc...) due to them becoming unreadable in just a few years in the late 90's. I mean, it's not surprising. Each bit is simply much physically larger on a 5,25" floppy.
- whoopdedo 7y agoThere are CD-R and DVD-R made for archival. MAM-A/Mitsui has tested their Gold reflective layer CD-Rs with their Mitsui dye, to withstand the full spectrum of light, same as the sun, for 100 continuous hours without damage. Using data from tests like these, industry standard guidelines predict that MAM Gold CD-R will last greater than 100 years! (In fact, if you extend the data, MAM-A predicts a lifetime of up to 300 years before failing at the Orange Book limit of 220 CPS)
- eatbitseveryday 7y agoPlease avoid using code blocks for quotation. It creates side-scrolling windows. Just a sideways carrot > or italics is sufficient.
- eru 7y agoPressed CDs should last much longer than CD-R.
- robdachshund 7y agoThis is true, but tape lasts much much longer. I know people have issues with floppies, but I wonder if that is more to do with dirty floppy drives that need to be cleaned, and the fact that it's harder to use tape for digital storage vs analog as you have to read encoded signals and convert to digital values vs having a few small dropouts on a cassette recording or a vhs. Floppies are really just tape in a disc format, and use heads to read high and low signals and deduce the 1s and 0s. It stands to reason they should last quite a long time considering audio/video/data tapes can last over 50 years.
- madengr 7y agoOne of my bucket list projects is to use an SDR to forward error correct and modulate raw data into something that is compatible with NTSC VHS recorders. I wonder what the capacity of VHS tape is, given the restrictions of the NTSC modulation? I believe, back in the 80’s, someone made a ISA card for PC backup to VHS.
- mrguyorama 7y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TUS0Zv2APjU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TUS0Zv2APjU NTSC video signals offer a lot of bandwidth but very very few promises about the quality of the reproduction of the stored waveform
- mburns 7y agoM-DISC claims a much, much longer lifespan for writable DVD/Bluray discs. Readable by normal drives. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M-DISC https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/M-DISC
- Zenst 7y agoPunched cards are for me one of the most reliable mediums ever, in terms of proven to last without media decline (though keep away from snails). So be thankful they didn't reinvent those, only using plastic instead of paper based card. Though plastic punched cards would last a very long time and also be imune to EMP, water...many things that other forms of media fall foul of. Just don't get the storage capaicty there and if they are using systems that fit data on a floppy. Well, a CD based media would perhaps be overkill. As for CD quality, that can vary a lot with some lasting since day one, others - rusting away (literally I have old CD's from the early days, some fine, others have rust holes due to impurities in manufacture). But like most things, you don't appreciate the quality of the product until time has past and it still just works.
- kalleboo 7y agoFloppies from the last decade of their reign were absolute garbage. I had many that didn't last more than a week before they started throwing errors. That's when I switched to FTPing schoolwork to my free 10 MB ISP spacr despite still being on 56k
- robdachshund 7y agoCDs already get disc rot, sometimes just after a few years if they are cheap. Don't forget, CDs have been out since 82, and they were not the first optical disc format around, either. Tapes however, can last 50+ years. It's a much better medium than most think it is, for analog or digital storage. Heck, a reel to reel tape unit offers the best analog sound quality you can get.
- jacquesm 7y agoBut the optical discs from before the CD era used gold as the base material, CDs use Aluminum.
- Zenst 7y agoI have CD's from that period - some fine as, others disc rot most evident. Even had rot in gold layered ones (few VCD's I had). Gets down to manufacturing quality and in just the same way silicon chips are made, not all chips are equal and work perfect forever. Same with media. Tape has done well, however when you look at how it was used and how it is used today. The density of data is much tighter today than the 80's era. So tolerance of errors was greater and more forgiving as data would be stored in a larger area, so a few atoms going adrift won't stand out, when you get into density when a few atoms is your data, errors are statistically more prone to happen.
- willis936 7y agoOld school tech is ridiculously easy to hack. New tech is much more hardened. The only advantage old tech has is that it doesn’t have peripherals that connect to the internet. At the end of the day the most secure computer is a new one, that isn’t on the internet, and is physically secure.
- onlingyding 7y agoOld computers don't have whole computers built into the motherboards running inaccessible operating systems that can't be switched off.
- namibj 7y agoPOWER9 doesn't either. I'd buy a laptop with that for 3~4k next summer if it existed...
- pimmen 7y agoOnly for people who know what they’re doing. If a hacker faces hardware they’ve never seen before it will take some time to read up on it, especially if datasheets and such is not available online. I fully concede it’s security by obscurity, though. A technician possessing any experience with that hardware is probably going to make short work of its security measures.
- aussieguy1234 7y agoUnless its been tampered with in the factory or in transit for delivery, the NSA has been known to modify hardware in transit for spying purposes.
- willis936 7y agoSo its either have an old system that is trivially compromised or have a new system that has the potential of having an unknown backdoor.
- aj7 7y agoBut no more. At long last, that system, the Strategic Automated Command and Control System or SACCS, has dumped the floppy disk, moving to a “highly-secure solid state digital storage solution” Did SuperMicro make the board?
- mises 7y agoThat story made a big splash but was never proven. Bloomberg claimed sources it conveniently couldn't reveal. I'm just as suspicious of China as the next guy, and they've probably got something in the supply chain, but probably not that. Besides, a ME or BMC 0day does the job just as well with very little risk.
- mikestew 7y agoDid SuperMicro make the board? Suppose for the moment that they did. Surely you're not going to stake your reputation on an unconfirmed rumor from Bloomberg for which no single shred of hard evidence (or evidence at all, frankly) was ever offered, because that would just be silly. So what's your point?
- greggman2 7y agoI don't know what the right solution is but I recently watched this documentary about a serious accident at a missile silo in Arkansas https://www.pbs.org/video/american-experience-command-and-control-first-chapter/ https://www.pbs.org/video/american-experience-command-and-co...
- User23 7y agoLong term reliability metrics can only be gathered for technologies that have already been deployed in the long term. That’s why many mission critical applications like this one use “obsolete” technologies.
- anonymfus 7y agoWell may be it would be a good reason, but do we have an evidence that it was intentional?
- metaphor 7y ago> That’s why many mission critical applications like this one use “obsolete” technologies. ...or perhaps it's a much more simple risk probability v. consequence severity decision?
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 7y ago> While SACC’s hardware is decades old, its software is constantly refreshed by young Air Force programmers who learn software development skills at Offutt’s Rapid Agile Development Lab. I am not so sure I want “Rapid Agile” development for something that literally controls nuclear missiles.
- misterdoubt 7y agoActually launching? YAGNI. We can easily implement that if it ever comes up.
- anoncake 7y agoAs long as the potential enemies believe it is implemented, that would be ideal.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- noonespecial 7y agoIndeed. "Move fast and break things" might not be the best idea in this particular case.
- pintxo 7y agoIsn‘t this the very definition of an ICBM?
- TheSpiceIsLife 7y agoInterestingly move fast and break things is the last thing an ICBM should be sneaking off and doing. Yet it definitely is designed for that. I wonder if they ever feels frustrated.
- pintxo 7y agoThe value proposition is to be a deterrent, I’d say they have performed really well in that regard, no need for frustration.
- Thorentis 7y agoWhile SACC’s hardware is decades old, its software is constantly refreshed by young Air Force programmers Well that sounds like a disaster waiting to happen.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gamblor956 7y agoUnlike Silicon Valley, the armed forces spent a lot of time training their programmers. After a tour any one of them could be a VP of Engineering at a FAANG or Unicorn, and they generally choose to remain in the public sector because money isn't the most important thing in their lives.
- andy_ppp 7y agoI can’t wait for them to get Internet access!
- Scoundreller 7y agoI understand the 747 still gets nav updates via monthly diskettes. Most have replaced the unit with a floppy simulator that takes an SD card (or USB key?). The load takes just as long. But it doesn’t fail (forcing you to get an undamaged disk and start over). I wonder if that’s why they say they got rid of the floppy disk. Maybe they maintained the underlying tech.
- eternalny1 7y agoCan confirm, that's how it works (for the 747).
- apostacy 7y agoSo when we upgrade the hardware, how much of it will be sourced from China? Is it even possible to fully secure the supply chain? Introducing any outside code or hardware is a liability. Unless there is a really urgent problem, I think they should just freeze their entire computer platform, that way they can eliminate any chance of any new threats. I can not possibly imagine any cost justification for doing so. I have no problem with taxpayer money being spent to keep ancient computers running forever. Keeping our nuclear missiles secure is priceless. What new features do they even need that they don't have now? The thought of some ux monkey using npm anywhere near our ICBMs makes my physically ill.
- benj111 7y ago"What new features do they even need that they don't have now?" That's not the question you should be asking. The question you should be asking is, what features would the Commander in Chief want?
- nobatron 7y agoTwitter integration probably.
- otaviokz 7y ago"The thought of some ux monkey using npm anywhere near our ICBMs makes my physically ill." Almost spilled my coffee reading this one.
- SEJeff 7y agoSorry Sir, we can't launch because that jerk removed left-pad from the npm registry!
- metaphor 7y ago> So when we upgrade the hardware, how much of it will be sourced from China? FYSA[1], would it surprise you if that figure was precisely zero? [1] https://www.dmea.osd.mil/trustedic.html https://www.dmea.osd.mil/trustedic.html
- benj111 7y ago" Air Force software development hubs like Boston-based Kessel Run or Los Angeles-based Kobayashi Maru" Is this article a troll, or is the Air Force just trying to be 'cool'.
- goatinaboat 7y agois the Air Force just trying to be 'cool'. Why wouldn’t the Air Force be full of geeks?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- C1sc0cat 7y agoI Know some one in our DnD group who when working for the MOD in the UK, got into trouble for naming a set of servers after the kings of Rohan.
- NoGravitas 7y agoSurely Kobayashi Maru should be a Navy development hub.
- benj111 7y agoI think an unwinnable scenario works quite well with the nuclear weapons theme.
- taborj 7y agoYou might be interested to know that they also nicknamed Rainbow Canyon as "Star Wars Canyon", and the various branches fly their jets through at high speed for training purposes.[0] In other words, the Air Force (and other branches) can, indeed, be "cool." [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W0NHXiB-R58 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W0NHXiB-R58
- bArray 7y agoI know of several military systems that still use floppy disks, that comforts me for a few reason: * Their maintenance is well understood - every fault that is likely to happen has happened and has been recovered/repaired from. It's very unlikely there will be new surprised down the road. * Their degradation is well understood - it's been around long enough that parts have failed and have been repaired. * Isn't easily communicated with through modern tech - no USB ports, no network access - people aren't picking up floppy disks in the car park and plugging them in. * Robustness to electromagnetic interference - the bits are so big that a few electrons being knocked out of the way won't cause an issue. * Software well understood and tested over time - the only way to _really_ trust software is by having it work without failure. * Simple implementation - because there's no computational space or power, it only does the minimal it needs to. It's not rendering a GUI, it's not running some complicated neural network. Old hardware isn't sexy, but it does work. I still use an oscilloscope with a phosphor display and a programmable power supply with instructions on a floppy disk. Floppy disks occasionally fail, but there's no substitute for making good backups over several mediums/locations.
- dmos62 7y agoThis could be a sign that a new generation of technologies are reaching a similar level of reliability.
- BostonFern 7y agoThis could be wishful thinking.
- dmos62 7y agoI'm asking myself what does it look like when the baseline tech is superseded, though I'm not arguing one way or another. I think that this kind of trend switch would be a gradual movement with ups and downs, where people would often be asking themselves "is this a serious trend", "is this wishful thinking", etc. None of these things prove that a meaningful long-term transition is happening, but I think that they're there when it does. Actually, I'm not even thinking about floppy disks vs X. Rather about qualitative changes as a whole.
- edejong 7y ago> You can't hack something that doesn't have an IP address. That's a very risky assumption to make. There are many attack vectors besides TCP/IP: social engineering, side-channel attacks, EM pulse, backdoors in ICs...
- rightbyte 7y agoRemote sabotage from anywhere and spies roaming the cooridors are quite different things.
- edejong 7y agoWell, that's the funny thing. The claim is: "No IP address == unhackable." So, for a second stop assuming we are in a nuclear bunker. There are many unconnected systems that are still hackable. For example, the Stuxnet worm was able to infiltrate an unconnected SCADA system using USB exploits. Many systems radiate data in EM and ultrasonic (side-channel). And obviously, there are known and unknown backdoors in PCBs, ECs, and ICs. All of these do not require an IP address. I would even argue that having an IP address can improve security by increasing monitoring, improving continuous security updates and decreasing a false sense of security. This was the original goal of DARPA all along.
- danmg 7y agoThis guy needs to go back and watch/rewatch wargames.
- mark-r 7y agoAmazing what you can do with just a telephone and a modem.
- xen2xen1 7y agoJust read up on Stuxnet to see a real world case. No network connection did not stop them.
- cameronbrown 7y agoTo be perfectly honest, I'd rather they used floppy disks than the latest trendy JavaScript frameworks.
- drmpeg 7y agoIn the 80's, I was the project engineer for the Air Force DSP satellite ground communications network upgrade. This system used a 20 MB Bernoulli Box to store the early warning messages. It was replaced in 2005. This was the system used to pass early warning to the Patriot anti-missile (Scud) batteries during the first Gulf War. Internetworking the Air Force system to an Army system was considered revolutionary in 1991. Today, it would be equivalent to "stone knives and bearskins".
- metaphor 7y agoIf your team had Link 16 integration requirements, I extend my deepest sympathies.
- drmpeg 7y agoNothing that complex. The link between Buckley and the Patriots was over AUTODIN.
- Shivetya 7y agoalso in the 80s, when I served in the secure communications group we had a Burroughs computer that was the first generation to have not used tubes, it was the main computer for this application. Could boot by switches or paper tape. not that the base computer for personnel and other records was much more modern, cards were still used till 89 for many applications; this was on a Sperry 1100/70 ? I remember my first turbo pascal program was used to replace a Sperry program used to upload card images to the system; we still had paper cards for some departments.
- drmpeg 7y agoThe system we replaced consisted of an IBM Series/1 and some unknown Xerox computer the size of a refrigerator. The Xerox box was being kept alive by cannibalizing other boxes that had been taken out of service elsewhere.
- excalibur 7y ago> “highly-secure solid state digital storage solution” So not just any thumb drive, an expensive thumb drive.
- AnnoyingSwede 7y agoJust getting my amiga/commodore 64 500 3.5/5.25 setups back up and running, 75% of data is demagnetized away. Looking around sourcing any of these formats is more or less impossible today. HOW did they ever managed to keep 8 inch disks in a read and writable stage, without exhausting possible read/re-writes? Secondly, how does one replace a 8 inch drive (most likely MFM interfaces) with a solid state disk?
- taborj 7y agoYou know how you can buy an SD2IEC device[0] for your C64? Probably something like that. [0] https://www.c64-wiki.com/wiki/SD2IEC https://www.c64-wiki.com/wiki/SD2IEC
- seamyb88 7y agoDoesn't matter which tech they use, when the most ignorant in society are in charge.
- ycombonator 7y agoReliability over sexiness. There is reason space craft launched when most of the people here on this board weren't even born still work. https://voyager.jpl.nasa.gov/mission/status/#where_are_they_now https://voyager.jpl.nasa.gov/mission/status/#where_are_they_...
- HNLurker3 7y agoWe need to fire whoever decided to make this decision, and then fire whoever decided to hire that person, and then reevaluate the entire existence of the agency that managed this entire process. Nuclear weapons are not a joke. These are the kinds of things that actually threaten our immediate existence. This whole thing makes me seriously sad, anxious, and scared. I don't know what else to say. From what I understand, military personnel generally "operate" equipment and technologies that are built and designed by private industry. I can only imagine the idiotic buzz-word sales pitch that some whiz-kid fast-talking slime-ball in a suit from a fancy looking tech company made to some meat-head, decorated military general with no understanding of what a digital threat model is and barley knows how to check his email on a windows 7 machine on IE, all for quick federal contract. I hate it.