5 ms·
Because other people here are throwing in their frustrations, I will at least add that on the flip side I have been frustrated by sites that attempt to disable
by jchw 7y ago
Because other people here are throwing in their frustrations, I will at least add that on the flip side I have been frustrated by sites that attempt to disable autofill for illegitimate reasons, like attempting to disallow password managers. I think I understand where this is coming from.
On the other hand, I, too, have been bit by this at least once, in the past. I think it was easier to just disable it at that time, but IIRC, the solution we landed on was to not use form controls at all but switch said text controls over to use content-editable elements. In our case it made sense, since it was not a form at all. My memory could be a bit hazy here, though.
(I do not work on Chrome or use Chrome at home, but as disclosure I do currently work at Google.)
- doctorpangloss 7y agoDisabling autocomplete is so incredibly frustrating that I ran an extension in Safari to remove the off tag from sites. Of course I want to use KeyChain, the whole point is that touch based ID is more secure.
- Nitramp 7y agoI have my own extension for Chrome that yanks the autocomplete attribute. I much rather deal with over eager completion than websites disabling it for silly reasons and pseudo security.
- httpsterio 7y agoTouch based are not better. Your fingerprint is not a password, it's just an identifier and shouldn't be treated as a secret.
- dustinmoris 7y ago> Your fingerprint is not a password Correct, because a fingerprint makes a password to some extent redundant. > it's just an identifier and shouldn't be treated as a secret Correct, identifiers are not secrets. Your face is not a secret and your fingerprint either. The problem is that we use secrets to identfy someone, when we potentially already have tech which can identify someone without having to remember a secret and store it in a dictionary of secrets on someone else's computer in the cloud. The sole purpose of a password is to identify someone with a certain degree of confidence. If a fingerprint taken from a handheld device, which has already been proven to belong to a person, can provide the same if not even a higher level of certainty about someone's identy, then a password or as you say "secret" is not required at all anymore.
- Santosh83 7y agoAnonymity is weakened if we tie authentication to biometrics. Something you know (as in password) is always theoretically more secure than something you are (your physical characteristics).
- dustinmoris 7y agoAnonymity is of course weakened, but that is a different debate. Currently there is no anonymity at all if your account is linked to your email address, which you've also used to register your online banking account, your credit card verification, your PayPal account, etc. and when you have your mobile phone number confirmed, etc. A password gives you 0 extra anonymity in this case. All it is used if for "identifycation" and in this regard it sucks in comparison to true biologial identification.
- cuu508 7y agoYou are mixing up terminology. When logging in a website, your username identifies you, and your password authenticates you.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- scient 7y agoI think the statement you make about "something you know" always being more secure is not nearly as clear cut as you present it. A combination of "something you know" and "something you have" is always going to be a very strong authentication scenario, and making "something you have" a non-hackable thing that truly only you can have (i.e not a USB key or a TOTP seed etc.) is a good choice. The catch here is that when you mention biometrics, you make the assumption of static biometrics (rightfully so, as most methods like Touch ID and Face ID are static), but if you combine lets say face biometrics with liveness checks, you are getting into a territory where faking them becomes much much more difficult (there are various mechanisms out there, the good ones rely on completely random interactions and light-bouncing detection methods as an example). The real challenge is how do you make these very strong biometric methods frictionless and cheap? Or how do you introduce similar controls - like liveness - for easier methods like fingerprints? And using any of these (ideally) has absolutely nothing to do with anonymity. You are not anonymous online regardless of what you use for authentication - and you are frankly not smart if you assume thats the case. A company offering a service with biometrics is no different from a company doing the same based on email/username and a password, if they do privacy and security right. I could actually get into a much longer rant about this last part, as it blows my mind how many netizens are all about privacy and whatnot, yet are willing to expose every single detail about them when its convenient from them...
- geofft 7y agoYour fingerprint is an additional factor (something you are) for the actual better-than-passwords thing here, the isolates processor/storage in your laptop that handles Touch ID (something you have). Without physical possession of the laptop, the fingerprint is useless.
- anoncake 7y agoI think we need a way to disable features only for those developers that abuse them. Like uMatrix but built-in and with rules being supplied automatically as ad blocking lists are. You autocomplete=off a password field? That attribute won't have an effect on your site anymore. You auto-play videos when the user doesn't expect it? What videos? The web doesn't support videos – as far as you are concerned. Scroll hijacking? I hope you used progressive enhancement because you just lost your Javascript privileges.
- Roritharr 7y agoThis is actually a reasonable proposal. A moderate list could be an in-built feature, with some config options.
- anoncake 7y agoIt would only work if a strict list is the default in browsers that developers are not willing not to support. The point is not to hack around user-hostile patterns. That frequently means entering an arms race you cannot win. Even in the best case, you're doing that site developers' job. Badly: You have to remove the bad stuff while avoiding overblocking. That's a lot harder than not adding it to start with. I'm proposing to take away tools from developers that abuse them no matter how much that breaks. If you mine bitcoins or annoy the user using pop-ups we shouldn't spend time finding out what scripts are good and which are bad but just disable all of them, till you remove the user-hostile stuff. We just broke your SPA? That's your problem. Better start working then.
- msclrhd 7y agoCan we have a reliable cross-browser way to say "this is a change password field, so don't autocomplete it" and "this is an email address field not a username field, so don't autocomplete it with the login username"?
- edoceo 7y agoI've seen/used autocomplete="new-password"
- gnud 7y agoChrome explains in their security FAQ [0] why they don't adhere to autocomplete=off for password fields. They could still follow it for other fields. 0: https://chromium.googlesource.com/chromium/src/+/master/docs/security/faq.md#why-does-the-password-manager-ignore-for-password-fields https://chromium.googlesource.com/chromium/src/+/master/docs...
- kevincox 7y agoOf course then websites will just stop using password fields and that is awful for security and convinced.
- kerng 7y agoShouldn't the work on changing the spec, rather then confusing majority of developers and causing even financial loss and embarrassment for many? This thread is filled with cases where this caused issues. Google should spend their cycles to work on a standard for password managers. The current design of those is flawed anyway.
- cdubzzz 7y agoWe recently had to go through a website project and disable autocomplete on all password fields after a security scan as part of a PCI compliance process. For autofill password it didn’t seem to have any effect in _any_ browser I tested in. How can it be used to thwart password managers?
- driverdan 7y agoWhy would you need to disable autocomplete passwords for PCI compliance?
- toast0 7y agoBecause either the PCI standard says so, or the PCI consultant says so. PCI compliance is about checking boxes, not weighing the options and making good choices.
- cdubzzz 7y agoExactly this. Some of the checks _are_ valuable. We found a couple of real issues and made good security improvements. But we also ticked off more than a few boxes that made no damn real sense.