3 ms·
Farms grow crops that you can't eat, to feed to animals that you can. Name the protein and fat sources that will replace meat. Tofu? We already grow soy for an
by cmrdporcupine 7y ago
Farms grow crops that you can't eat, to feed to animals that you can.
Name the protein and fat sources that will replace meat. Tofu? We already grow soy for animal feed as a cash crop and it's pesticide and fertilizer intensive, and if people eat it directly instead of as an animal feed additive its production will grow at the expense of forests and soil health.
Nuts? I'm all for perennial woody agriculture, but the calorie/acre ratio is not great, and they are labour intensive for picking, netting, processing. I say this as a person who has an orchard of my own with hazelnuts and chestnuts in it.
The reality is that should meat be gone, we'd have to replace it with other foods, grown on a mass scale on agricultural lands. Animals can graze on products (grass, hay, soy, dent corn) that are marginal or useless for human consumption, and turn it into high protein, high fat calorie rich food.
There are populations that eat primarily vegetarian, but mostly they are also heavy on the dairy. But the moment you bring dairy into the equation you're also bringing in non-productive male calves -- in other words, veal. Similar story for eggs.
What we need to be doing -- along with reducing meat consumption some -- is coming up with more ecological ways to raise meats, and diversifying our meat products. Raising insects as feed stock for chickens, for example. Increasing perennial woody agriculture instead of cash crops, with small scale grazing of meat and dairy animals inbetween rows.
Cutting animals out entirely actually leads to a nutrient deficiency. The classic pre-green revolution family farm forms a kind of nutritive circle with manure, grazing, and rooting being an important part of soil health and maintenance. That didn't scale out in the last 100 years, but it's a model we need to look at.
EDIT: wow, the downvotes. Go vegans go!
- Someone 7y ago”We already grow soy for animal feed as a cash crop and it's pesticide and fertilizer intensive, and if people eat it directly instead of as an animal feed additive its production will grow” Only if farmers keep feeding soy to cows that nobody will buy anymore.
- jetpackjoe 7y agoAs long as you are eating a variety of plants and getting enough calories it is practically impossible to be protein deficient.
- wtmt 7y agoTechnically, it is possible to be low or deficient in certain amino acids, but having legumes (including foods such as soy and chickpeas) and lentils regularly will cover that.
- mikestew 7y agoThis vegan was almost to the end and ready to hit the upvote button...and you just had to do the EDIT, didn't you? Have a NULL value instead, and try to quit worrying about imaginary internet points. (No, you can't turn them in for prizes, I found out.)
- baxtr 7y agoHow much protein do you think a normal person needs? Valter Longo recommends ".31 to 0.36 grams per pound of body weight). That comes to 40 to 47 grams of proteins per day for a person weighing 130 pounds, and 60 to 70 grams of protein per day for someone weighing 200 to 220 pounds." Why would you really need meat at all if those numbers are correct? https://valterlongo.com/daily-longevity-diet-for-adults/ https://valterlongo.com/daily-longevity-diet-for-adults/
- mancerayder 7y agoNormal person? What about abnormal athletes, or people who do weight training? How many peas are required if you want both a calorie surplus and 1 to 1.5 grams of protein per lb of body weight?
- mantoto 7y agoAnd do you think this is a real problem because a relevant amount of people are doing weighttrainig? I don't think so. I would even bet that the amount is way below 1%
- mancerayder 7y ago"Normal people" are dying not just because of their poor diets, but because of their lack of activity. The "normal person needs X protein" comment above doesn't consider this, because "normal people" are doing it wrong. They're statistically sitting at desks in in cars, so it doesn't matter what they need. Not to mention that is a pulled-out-of-a-hat cherrypicked statistic. No one agrees on how many grams of protein is needed, anyway.
- sprflyprgrmrguy 7y agoSeems to be 4g of protein per 85g (1/2cup) of peas. I weight ~72 kg (~160lb); recommendation is 1.5-2g of protein per kg, so I'd need 142g of protein per day on the high end, which equates to roughly 3017.5g, 71 cups, of peas daily. Frozen walmart sweet peas are .84c per bag, each bag contain 4 servings, roughly $7.45 in peas per day. For comparison, chicken breast @ 100g (3.5oz or .45 lb) is 31g of protein. I'd need 458g of chicken breast, around 2.25lbs. I can get it for $1.99/lb, but the better quality stuff is $6.99/lb, so $4.48 to $15.72/day. When I'm eating to put on muscle I buy the cheap crap and slow cook it and toss hot sauce on it. Lentils are a better choice than peas, you'd probably need half as much. I'd rather eat chicken than copious amounts of a plant alternative, but I have started eating more lentils b/c they're not at all as bad as I thought they'd be. I hate peas though.
- natethegreatt 7y agoThe only nutrient deficiency that is rather difficult to circumvent with a vegan diet is Vitamin B. Meat is one of the only places humans can obtain it. Everything else is trivial to obtain via plants.
- vfc1 7y agoYou mean B12? This is produced by bacteria in the dust. It gets injected to animals in factory farms, that's why they have it in that environment. We can also take the supplement directly.
- natethegreatt 7y agoCobalt is produced in the dirt. Cobalt is used by animals to produce B12. Pasture-raised meat ideally gets its cobalt from the ground, but most of the time there is a lack of cobalt so the animals need supplementation themselves. Factory-farmed animals, however, are always directly supplemented. Ironic, isn't it? Personally, I have no choice but to supplement my B12s, as meat causes my body to produce kidney stones.
- cmrdporcupine 7y agoThe nutrient deficiency I'm referring to is soil health, not human. Classic pre-industrial agriculture makes heavy use of animal manure as a soil amendment, as well as the use of grazing and rooting animals for soil modification. It's a very effective way of returning NPK to the soil and maintaining long term viability. It just doesn't scale out to large industrial operations.
- vfc1 7y ago> Name the protein and fat sources that will replace meat. All sorts of beans like soybeans and others, legumes, chickpeas, lentils, tempeh and tofu yes are good products. More than enough protein to feed people, much healthier too. Look ,its just not true there is nothing magical about meat. It's highly environmentally impactful and completely optional.
- dahauns 7y ago>if people eat [soy] directly instead of as an animal feed additive its production will grow But will it though? Cutting out the (rather wasteful) bovine middlemen should increase efficiency rather significantly.
- telchar 7y agoIt's like you didn't read the parent post you're replying to. If you can't address the quantity argument, the rest of your post is moot.
- cmrdporcupine 7y agoI absolutely read it. The point is that the land and crops used for animals are disjoint from the land and crops that humans need, and the entire reason why pastoral economies developed in the first place was to take advantage of the fact that we can raise animals as food in conditions that humans couldn't. The key question is quantity of _what_. It's not a one for one trade.
- mantoto 7y agoI'm not a vegan or vegetarian but your statement is utterly wrong. We do not need meat. Eating meat is less efficient in production then plant based. Inform your self properly. And yes we have many countries with people who do not eat meat every day.
- cmrdporcupine 7y ago"Inform your self properly" is a pretty presumptive and arrogant statement. My wife was vegan for several years. A very educated and committed one. She had chronic health problems that went completely away once she started eating modest amounts of meat and fish. Please recognize the diversity of human biology and cultural experience. A few hundred thousand years of omnivorous lifestyle can't be waved away with strident statements.
- mantoto 7y agoIt can. Enough people do it. Nonetheless here in Germay when you are vegetarian or vegan a doctor will recommend regular blood test. And yes you have to be careful or more aware when you live a vegan lifestyle. Also the educate statement was a remark to the comment of efficiency of plants vs. meat. I'm not even advocating a meatless diat. Low meat on the other hand I do.
- basch 7y agopetri dish seeds: nuts, legumes etc. Its probably easier to just grow cereals?
- kick 7y agoPaul Graham: I think it's ok to use the up and down arrows to express agreement. Obviously the uparrows aren't only for applauding politeness, so it seems reasonable that the downarrows aren't only for booing rudeness. It only becomes abuse when people resort to karma bombing: downvoting a lot of comments by one user without reading them in order to subtract maximum karma. Fortunately we now have several levels of software to protect against that. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=117171 News Guidelines: Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- skybrian 7y agoA better way to say it would be that a lot of grazing land isn't useful as farmland.
- vfc1 7y ago> farms grow crops that you can't eat, to feed to animals that you can. You can then grow crops that people can eat instead, and feed those people using much less resources. > Cutting animals out entirely actually leads to a nutrient deficiency. This is scientifically just not true, a proper plant-based diet is adequate to all stages of life - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19562864 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19562864
- cmrdporcupine 7y agoYou didn't read. I was talking about soil nutrient deficiency, not people. Crops need NPK. Manure is a great source.
- e12e 7y ago> Name the protein and fat sources that will replace meat. Insects?
- josefx 7y agovegans don't eat honey, I don't think you will see them eating bees either.