8 ms·
If they removed US access to Chinese supply chains, it'd be a pretty big deal for the US... that might even start a war.
by nicoburns 7y ago
If they removed US access to Chinese supply chains, it'd be a pretty big deal for the US... that might even start a war.
- redisman 7y agoEconomic Mutually Assured Destruction?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- patagurbon 7y agoHardly. Mutually Assured Damage, with the US clearly coming out on top. There are plenty of other places to make cheap goods, even disregarding increasing automation. There are not as many places to sell cheap goods by the trillions.
- semiotagonal 7y agoIn the long term, it isn't even necessarily damage. Chinese manufacturing won't be cheap forever; wages are already too high there for them to continue sorting through and recycling the US's plastic. Rebooting US manufacturing earlier rather than later will make the transition to "expensive China" less of a jolt.
- shkkmo 7y agoMoving manufacturing out of China is not synonymous with moving manufacturing into the US. A great deal of that manufacturing would move to other countries with cheap labor and burgeoning supply chains.
- TaylorAlexander 7y agoI wouldn't underestimate the quality of the supply chains in China. They've had decades of development and experience, and starting elsewhere could not be done without significant setbacks.
- gamblor956 7y agoChina's a great place to make something cheap that doesn't last very long. It's not a great place to make something that needs to last. It's an even worse place to make something that needs to meet quality standards, since you spend as much or more on QA than you saved by moving manufacturing to China.
- lonelappde 7y agoChina makes things as good or bad as the client wants. My 12 yr old laptop was made in China.
- patagurbon 7y agoOh certainly. That’s what I meant by mutually assured damage. It wouldn’t be painless for either side. But I’d make the argument that it’s far more harmful to China. The US was in a much better position when they ceased to be the industrial center of the world. Then again, we’ve never seen a nation like China.
- patfla 7y agoSome low-end production had already been moving to places like Vietnam, based on labor costs where Chinese labor costs are now > places like Vietnam (and have been for a while). Trump's trade war has accelerated the trend. Arguing the other way is that you have suppliers for, say in electronics, literally everything in places like Guangdong. So that's a disincentive to move.
- mmsimanga 7y agoIn Africa we have started to speak of China as the modern age colonizers. They are appearing everywhere, building roads, airports, dams and coal fired power stations. They bring all their equipment. We have challenges with governance (understatement). In my home country we have severe power shortages, daily power cuts lasting up 18 hours. Chinese are building a power station. So picture the day we try assert some right and China just switches off the power. This kind of scenario is playing itself out in Africa and I fear by the time we wake up China will own the continent. I exaggerate but I think you get my point.
- pinkfoot 7y agos/we have/some of us, actually just a small minority on Twitter, have/
- mmsimanga 7y agoTwitter doesn't build power stations. Its pretty hard to miss the ground being cleared as the power station is being built.
- pinkfoot 7y agoWhere I live, Hitachi build the power stations. So we all now also believe the Japanese are colonising Africa? Outside of Twitter 'building complex machines for a fee != colonisation'.
- mmsimanga 7y agoYou missed the part where I said in Africa we have governance challenges. 99 year lease of Sri Lanka Hambantota port is modern day colonization.
- pinkfoot 7y agoJust to be clear, Ski Lanka is not Africa. All debts have collateral. Don't sign up to loans you cannot afford. Any don't vote in governments that do. [And don't stuff up the maintenance of your infrastructure to the point you don't have electricity for 18 hours. It wasn't like that when it was commissioned.] Then you won't need to take deals on onerous conditions. The Swiss don't.
- pinkfoot 7y agoIf I was a Chinese strategist, I would announce a root and branch re-certification of the 737-MAX (in Chinese of course) as a completely new type. Especially have just buttered up Airbus with 300 A320 orders in March. And even more so if I was convinced the C919 will certify in 2021. There also aren't many places to sell aircraft by the hundreds.
- derision 7y agoMany companies have already moved or are moving to India, Malaysia, etc. Apple is already manufacturing some models of iPhones in India.
- perseusprime11 7y agoThe India move is a strategic move probably to see if they can get the same quality from their assembly lines. The key is still access to supply chains for important semi conductor metals.
- r00fus 7y agoFor Apple, that's only due to requirements / tariff impositions by India making it cheaper to manufacture locally.
- jerf 7y agoYou have to analyze the costs & benefits to all relevant parties when thinking about that sort of thing. I think you've only analyzed the costs to one party in that analysis. "Cutting off all US supply chain in China" is on the table, but definitely way down the list of what China wants to do. The US decoupling from their economy isn't their big winning play, it's a nightmare scenario for them. If it was a big winning play right now for them, they'd already have done it.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoBringing (automated) manufacturing back to the US and ensuring the security of our supply chains while also doing economic harm to an authoritarian government while they're in a precariously unstable economic situation? As a US citizen, I'm fully onboard. Call China's bluff. Monetary policy (cheap money) is in a phenomenal place to support the necessary infrastructure investments (roads, rail, energy, etc), and that spending will keep the US economy humming while further decoupling us from China's. What good are values as a nation if we're willing to trade them for profits and cheap goods from China?
- rayiner 7y agoWell said.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoThank you, I appreciate it.
- FruityFarm 7y agoSays the nation that slaughtered and took the land of the native population. The hypocrisy is unreal.
- colechristensen 7y agoIsn't that every nation? And that "native" population to populations before it? Either you live in a place so inhospitable that nobody is interested in taking your land, or the land you live on has been stolen again and again and again by different populations.
- luckydata 7y agoit would be bad for a while but the consequences in the long term would be all positive for the US. Hope that happens.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- gamblor956 7y agoRemoving US access to Chinese supply chains would just accelerate the transition to non-Chinese suppliers...for US and non-US companies. It would also effectively damn China to being a permanent outsider with respect to manufacturing for the next several decades.
- 29athrowaway 7y agoThe first priority for China is keeping unemployment low to avoid internal conflict.
- jdhn 7y agoIronically, this could potentially help Trump due to the fact that some manufacturers might say "Screw this noise", and attempt to use more US based sources in order to avoid more trade uncertainty.
- sdinsn 7y agoIt would be a lot worse for China.
- godelski 7y agoSeems like an empty threat to me. How much of China's economy depends on the US? The US is China's number 1 trading partner and accounts for about 20% of their exports. It would also be a hit to the US, but finding cheap labor isn't that hard and there's existing momentum of labor markets moving out of China. As far as I can tell, this hurts China more than it hurts the US (though clearly it hurts the US). It is just a matter of who's going to backdown first. Who calls the bluff? Who is more risk adverse?
- celticninja 7y agoAll that would achieve is the acceleration of moving away from Chinese supply chains.
- dekhn 7y agoit would be the best thing for the US if China made it hard to obtain their supplies (wth the exception of anything China has an exclusive source of). Look at oil. The US was the first country to pump oil at scale. but over time it invested in other countries to develop their oil fields (few countries have the capital to bootstrap their own fields) and extracted strong pricing concessions through joint ownership of the fields and the processing facilities (The Prize, Daniel Yergin). Eventually, it was just cheaper to buy oil from other countries while sitting on our own reserves (which will be worth more in the future if supplies start to dwindle). However, eventually the oil market got complicated with multiple new players and the US rediscovered how profitable oil exports could be. When we wanted to, we had the capital and the expertise and the will to exploit US oil again (I am explicitly leaving all environmental concerns, short and long, out of this argument, although they are important both for oil and chip production). once the US was an oil exporter again it forced all other players to adjust their game. It gave the US a lot more global negotiating power, it gave US more domestic supplies, it provided lots of very high paying jobs to oil workers (again, ignoring environmental externalities here). Let's say china makes it hard for people to buy chips made in china. And the US decides in response to take all the free capital and tax incentives it has and turn large swaths of unused land into fabs and manufactories for high tech equipment. Remember, like oil, chips are something the US invented and it has a very deep bench when it comes to fab tech. And China is terrified of this. They know we intentionally outsourced fab production for environmental and cost reasons and they know we can bring it back. They are already seeing how some large consumer electronics companies can pick up major components of their production pipelines and move them to other countries. personally I think it would probably be a net negative for the US because (like oil) fabs have massive environmental externalities and we happily exported those problems to other countries. but it's an entirely plausible scenario that would just take a bit of changes from the current situation.