16 ms·
Science papers are getting harder to read (2017)
- mwyah 7y agoThat's because of the influx of papers written by the Chinese who can't write proper English.
- Zedronar 7y agoCan you write proper Chinese? The whole world is trying to adapt to a single universal language and for some cultures with completely different roots is probably much more difficult than for others.
- mwyah 7y ago...and? I'm just offering an explanation, I didn't say they should "git gud".
- jefft255 7y agoMost papers written by Chinese in good conferences or journals are either written by someone with decent enough English or some university-hired translator (which is totally fine). Not everyone has the privilege of being born in a area which happens to speak the language the world chose as “universal”.
- 68c12c16 7y agoAwesome! We now identified someone, other than our own politicians, as an alternative who can be blamed for all the problems that have undesirable effects...
- martindbp 7y agoI find it a better strategy to first read blog posts explaining a paper more casually in order to get the intuition for the thing, before reading the actual paper. I think this is closer to how the researchers were talking about it while doing the actual research, rather than the formal description used in the final paper.
- chadcmulligan 7y agoI find this for a lot of maths - I have often wondered why they don't include the intuition and the process that led them to the result.
- grenoire 7y agoIt is taken granted that if you are reading a high level maths paper, you are capable of deriving the authors' working intuitively. Papers would be excessively bloated without that assumption; besides, how far in detail do you go with the process and intuition?
- JadeNB 7y ago> It is taken granted that if you are reading a high level maths paper, you are capable of deriving the authors' working intuitively. I don't think that many research mathematicians expect that the readers of their papers will be able to derive their work intuitively. I know that I don't expect this, and my papers are no works of high-flown genius, just highly specialised and domain-specific so that even the people most interested in using the results probably won't be as interested in the techniques.
- JadeNB 7y ago> I find this for a lot of maths - I have often wondered why they don't include the intuition and the process that led them to the result. On the most basic levels, because journals don't want it and many referees want it taken out. (There's still the mindset that physical space on paper is a bottleneck, since most of the big journals also have printed versions.) On a less cynical level, intuition is highly non-transferrable. What gives me the intuitive understanding of my result probably won't help you (https://byorgey.wordpress.com/2009/01/12/abstraction-intuition-and-the-monad-tutorial-fallacy https://byorgey.wordpress.com/2009/01/12/abstraction-intuiti...). I think that the established school of thought is therefore that, rather than my giving you my useless esoteric intuition, better to give you the results of crystallising that intuition into a transferrable formalism, and then allow you to decode that formalism into your own custom-built intuition.
- unicornmama 7y agoThat title is so provincial. Rewrite as “We found an increase in the slope of comprehension impediments in publications within the field of systematic study of the structure and behaviour of the physical and natural world through observation and experiment.”
- jefft255 7y agoI find it funny that Nature is writing this as their journal require such short papers (usually three pages) that you basically can’t explain anything in real depth. Every AI paper that ends up in Nature, I have to go read something else to get it (usually a paper by the same author elsewhere).
- xamuel 7y agoI find your comment really interesting because I see things the opposite: the shorter the paper the better, in my view. This is grounded on the general principle that in 99% of cases, any particular paper will only have one really important key new insight (if even that much). I suppose I'm biased because I primarily read theory papers, maybe it's a different story when it comes to experimental stuff.
- jefft255 7y agoExactly; I come from robotics which is highly experimental and it is very easy to design a robotics experiment where there will be no way to fit a description of the experiments plus the theory in three pages.
- sideshowb 7y agoNature lets you put as many details as you like into supplementary material. That said, the one nature paper I've properly studied was to me so obviously making unwarranted claims that I'd never have let it through review. (And I'm usually a very supportive reviewer! ) One of the authors admitted as much in another paper a year later. But hey, it had all the wow factor that nature selects for.
- Merrill 7y agoGrammatical and structural complexity is a problem that should be corrected. However, the use of specialist terms and abbreviations is not a problem so long as they are understood by the audience for the paper. The example given is OK if understood by interested biochemists.
- tomkat0789 7y agoFor generally improving writing, I'm a big fan of "The Art of Scientific Storytelling" by Rafael Luna. It's a short, focused book that walks you through writing an easy (well... easier) to read scientific manuscript.
- pintxo 7y ago> So how could the readability of scientific papers be improved? First, by recognizing that good writing doesn’t happen by magic. It can be taught — but rarely is. Douglas suspects that many first drafts of papers are written by junior members of a research team who, lacking any model for what good writing looks like, take their lead from what is already in the journals. And there “they see the jargon and complexity as markers of what passes as scientific writing”, she adds. Such self-reinforcing mimicry could certainly account for the trends highlighted by Thompson and his colleagues. This is pretty much my experience with scientific writing. No one told me how to do it, so I started copying the style from the papers and books I had at hand.
- CuriouslyC 7y agoIn my time in academia, I actually saw the opposite. Advisors were actually teaching students to write passive voice jargon laden drivel. A lot of academics have been trained to think that difficult to understand is an indicator of profundity, and there's a toxic culture of trying to look smarter and more sophisticated than your peers.
- xamuel 7y agoAlso, a lot of peer reviewers have been trained this way, so even if DO make a paper more readable, you might be endangering it from getting published at all.
- HenryKissinger 7y agoCould the increased unaccessiblity of the scientific literature be partly responsible for the distrust of the general public for scientists and scientific theories?
- CuriouslyC 7y agoA lot of the intelligent people I know who distrust scientists became that way after seeing repeated patterns of poor science and incomplete knowledge being held up as absolute truth, and that "absolute truth" being used as a weapon to bludgeon dissenters. The most familiar example is nutritional science, and the whole fat vs carbs debate. There are a lot of easy examples in medical science and economics as well. The scary thing is the more scientific articles you read the more you see this pattern everywhere. Scientists have greatly oversold the degree of their knowledge in most fields.
- hatmatrix 7y agoDidn't English only become the lingua franca of science since WWII? Before then, French and German was more the norm. So the increasing number of non-native English speakers contributing to this pool of literature analyzed could have something to do with it. Technical English is much more restricted in its vocabulary (within each field) and conforms to predictable patterns that are markedly different from colloquial English, which was used as a reference for readability. It is this technical English that foreign language scientists pick up and publish in, so perhaps the conclusions are not surprising.
- imvetri 7y agoDon't laugh at this suggestion. Gif / visual representation of the paper should also be published.
- _Wintermute 7y agoIf you haven't you should check out https://distill.pub/ https://distill.pub/ it's mainly machine learning focussed but I really like the idea.
- throwaway77749 7y agoA fun thing I've noticed among HN and HN-adjacent crowds (e.g. the rationalist movement) is - and I'm sorry to be disparaging here - this fetishizing of some of the worst and most boring aspects of science: opaque, always serious and long-winded writing, an obsession with citations and links ("do you have evidence to back this up?"), mindless statistics even if they don't make sense, trudging through bibliography and literature, and so on. I get that the intentions are noble (of course assertions need to be backed up, of course statistics are essential, and so on) but the end result is that arguing on HN feels like passive-aggressively LARPing as scientists, but not with any of the good stuff. Actual discussions between scientists are much more lively: either both participants know the literature so no one bothers with citations and we try to directly jump to the key insights using our and other people's intuitions; one side knows the relevant literature and one does not (happens often in collaborations) and blindly trusts the former; both sides don't now anything (happens often in bars and conference cocktails) and just speculate wildly without any seriousness or defensiveness. The writing part (with all the seriousness, opaqueness and citation overload) is utterly boring and mindless drudgery: I know very few people who actually take pleasure reading or writing papers, and the few ones that do are considered weird.
- throwawaylolx 7y agoI may sound like those which you criticize, but isn't this a critique of empiricism rather than of rationalism?
- throwaway77749 7y agoI'm not criticizing any philosophy, just describing how people in some communities write. It's a matter of form and conventions, not content.
- solveit 7y ago> Actual discussions between scientists are much more lively This only works because the people are vetted. Almost everyone on HN is a rando and randos had better be able to back their assertions up. Otherwise you just end up spending all your time humouring crazy people.
- dawg- 7y agoI don't really see the problem here, to be honest. Thoreau wrote that real reading is that which we have to "stand on our tiptoes", and "devote our most wakeful hours" to grasp. The French philosopher Gilles Deleuze believed that we aren't really thinking if we don't struggle with the content. He maybe took it to an overly extreme level in his writing, but I like his general point. The article cites the increased presence of words such as 'robust’, ‘significant’, ‘furthermore’ and ‘underlying’ as examples of how papers are getting harder to read. They go on to say, >The words aren’t inherently opaque, but their accumulation adds to the mental effort involved in reading the text. The article doesn't sufficiently explain why mental effort is something to be avoided. Or why multisyllabic words are actually bad. Perhaps if one read more texts with lots of multisyllabic words it would get easier over time? They give a scary example sentence from an abstract (completely taken out of context anyhow): >Here we show that in mice DND1 binds a UU(A/U) trinucleotide motif predominantly in the 3' untranslated regions of mRNA, and destabilizes target mRNAs through direct recruitment of the CCR4-NOT deadenylase complex. Well a good reader knows that when you don't know a word, you look it up. If i was reading this paper I would have to look up just about everything in that sentence: What is DND1? What is a "UU(A/U) trinucleotide motif?? What is "the 3' untranslated regions of mRNA", what is translation of mRNA for that matter? What does mRNA even do? What is a target mRNA and what does it mean for one to be destabilized? What is the CCR4-NOT deadenylase complex? Would it take me hours to read this paper and gain an incomplete, novice-level understanding of it? Yes. But just in that one sentence I would learn like 1000% more about biology than I currently know. You do not need researchers to waste time writing a basic biology textbook in every single one of their papers. You need them to communicate their research and get to the point. If the reader wants to understand it they need to put in the work, science will never be easy and devoid of mental effort. I realize this will not be a popular post as many people value accessibility in science and more widespread science literacy. But I argue that accessibility is not the same thing as easy reading, and a literacy built on purposefully watered down texts is a cheap knockoff of true understanding won through dedicated effort.
- _Wintermute 7y agoThe issue isn't the use of technical words or trying to make the papers accessible to a general audience, it's that more and more publications are writing in an awful style and using unnecessary language to try and sound more scientific. Often trying to cover up the fact their paper isn't very interesting or novel, but if it sounds really complicated it must be good, right?
- zarro 7y agoYou would expect that as the topic of conversation becomes more esoteric, that they would get harder for the general audience to understand. But what I think sometimes happens is even the target audience doesn't understand what the papers are saying. Goethe said something about this in his autobiography about health/chemistry books that were popular in his day where imposters would write some "Scientific" book which is full of esoteric terminology that would look appealing to the lay reader, but once you started analyzing and reading that work "the book still remained dark and unintelligible; except that at last one become at home in a certain terminology, and, by using it according to one's own fancy, felt that one was at any rate saying, if not understanding, something".
- hinkley 7y agoTen, fifteen years ago I told a coworker I’d been an ACM member for a while and that I enjoyed reading the SIGPLAN proceedings in particular. He stopped, stared, and asked, “you can read those?” I was taken aback but realized I knew exactly what he meant. I told him, “about half” and this somehow relieved him a bit. We need a lot more abstract thought in plain English in this world. The problem with smart people is that they have the faculties to create elaborate protections against easily bruised egos. If only we could figure out those faculties can also be used to get over yourself and try to be helpful to the world instead of a trumped-up windbag.
- rdlecler1 7y agoThere is selection for obfuscation. Sound smart and technical and the reviewers will give it a pass because they are too embarrassed not to call out what they don’t understand. Make it easy to read and it’s easy to see the problems.
- thelazydogsback 7y agoOn a related note, can someone tell me why scientific/technical papers do not have the publication date listed prominently in the title area? -- usually this info is nowhere to do found in the paper. When I find a PDF of a paper I want to look at the date along with the abstract as a first-pass heuristic as the whether the paper is relevant to me.