20 ms·
macOS 10.15 Vista
- etchalon 7y agoI understand this is chaos, but it's chaos because it has to be. There's no way to move users from an world of opaque "if it's an application, it can do anything it wants" to a world of "applications should ask me when they want to do something" transparency. The idea that Apple doesn't care about the Mac because it's trying to explicitly improve our privacy and security is … weird.
- ixtli 7y agoYes their recent trend of moving user privacy to the forefront is one of the few really positive trends i've seen out of apple in the past 2-3 years. Ignoring that the questions being asked by the OS are good is very bizarre.
- danieldk 7y agoYes their recent trend of moving user privacy to the forefront is one of the few really positive trends i've seen out of apple in the past 2-3 years. Apple has moved privacy to the forefront for a much longer time. Apple was the first to roll out end-to-end encryption of messages to hundreds of millions of people (iMessage 2011), the first to roll out end-to-end encrypted (video) calls to hundreds of millions of people (Facetime, 2010). They introduced the secure enclave, which was quickly used throughout the OS with iPhone 5s in 2013. Whatever reasons they have (and despite their failings), they have been pushing privacy for almost 10 years now.
- rinchik 7y agoSecond this. It's a major security update that allows you to re-evaluate and more precisely manage access rights that your existing apps have. Not sure what "super user" author is really sad about. No one is keeping him from using windows.
- bsaul 7y agoI don’t think that’s intentional though. Otherwise a proper way would simply be to prompt the user with something like « you’ve just upgraded your system, would you like to take this as an opportunity to reevaluate all your applications access rights ? ».
- Spivak 7y agoAlmost every user clicks no and moves on with their life and then we’re put into a weird situation where apps installed prior to Catalina have a ton of permissions and apps post Catalina have comparably few. You could say this is fine but it does demonstrate that something bad probably happened because we’re they presented the immediate option for existing apps they would have made a different choice. Right now I have iOS 13 and it’s been great to see how many apps want but 1000% have no need for Bluetooth access — it’s nice to not have to comb through settings and revoke them manually.
- mtrower 7y agoErm, preferring the old Apple experience (or even a perceived old Apple experience) to the modern Apple experience does not necessarily mean he would prefer the Microsoft experience to the modern Apple experience...
- agret 7y agoIt really says a lot that he has no provision for comments on his posts.
- berberous 7y agoIt's a bad onboarding though, full stop, and not very Apple like. For example, I imagine there could be a way to present the user a screen with all apps, and ask the user on one screen to check/uncheck any that it would like to receive notifications for. Similarly, for the apps requesting access to various things, if I were Apple, I'd wait a bit and then present the user a list with the apps requesting access, explaining why it's happening, etc. So two simple screens with clear explanations and helpful advice, versus a million baffling popups.
- etchalon 7y agoIf you have one window, with checkboxes, the window would need to start with the boxes all unchecked. And users, being users, would then demand a way to check all of the boxes. And then what would the point of the notifications and requests be? If they didn't, people would complain that they had to click all these checkboxes, and then missed one. Or the window wouldn't have room for applications to explain why they needed that access. Or they would, and users would maybe read the first one, but skip others. There is no "better experience" which doesn't sacrifice the point of the prompts.
- Someone 7y ago”I imagine there could be a way to present the user a screen with all apps, and ask the user on one screen to check/uncheck any that it would like to receive notifications for” All 150+ apps (I don’t know how many are installed by default, but I have 277 on my system), many of which the user won’t even know he has installed? (I just found out I have an “Adobe Air Uninstaller” and two “Abobe Air Application Uninstaller”s, something called “Computer.app”, and 11 different Java 8 updates, for example) And no, I don’t think such a dialog would be useful because users could delete applications they “don’t use” from there. The average user simply doesn’t know which applications he doesn’t use. I certainly don’t. I think they could do a bit better, but I don’t think this problem has an easy answer. For example, they could exclude all Apple apps from these questions, but I suspect that would (rightfully) give us “Apple gives its own applications preferential treatment” complaints.
- dpkonofa 7y agoI disagree but only for one major reason: the entire reason this is coming up is because the OP is using an old version of Alfred that wasn't prepped for the new permission settings of Catalina even though there's a fully compatible version that's been released since. The vast majority of users will never, ever get something this obnoxious so it's not a bad on-boarding experience as much as it's a side effect of running old software.
- js2 7y agoApple could have figured out a way to coalesce all the individual pop-ups into a single window. I'm sure they considered it and deemed it not worth the effort since this is a one-time pain... of course it's one-time pain shared by millions of users. :-(
- etchalon 7y agoAn individual window would have completely destroyed the point. The point was to make you aware of what permissions the applications you use require access to. And to get explicit permission from the user.
- toomim 7y agoYou could do that within a single window.
- burk96 7y agoYou certainly could, however I guarantee a huge majority of users wouldn't read a lick of what they were agreeing to. Individual popups don't completely solve this, but it makes more obvious that a specific application is requesting a large amount of permissions. They're a bit more digestible to the crowd that won't bother to read an alert longer than one line.
- 72deluxe 7y agoHow? It shows it at the point of access request. If 2 programs request access 5 minutes apart, how would you show that in a single window? Do you suspend the first program and wait until another application makes an access request? What happens if another doesn't make a request in a given time period? Will the user wonder why the first application has stopped doing anything useful for 5 minutes? Honestly, how would you show this in a single window?
- inferiorhuman 7y agoAn individual window would have completely destroyed the point. Hardly. Apple could have used the OSX installer to scan two or three common locations for applications and do a bit of static analysis. Apple could have put the permissions notifications in the notification center with an annoying nag screen every hour or two for the first ~30 days turning into an immediate prompt after that (or after all detected programs have been processed).
- bsaul 7y agoI don’t think you read the post properly : all those popups appeared after an OS migration. I don’t see why upgrading the OS would need you to reauthorize apps, and even parts of the OS like icloud shouldn’t require you to relog (unless the security mechanism of icloud itself has been upgraded to a new system with no migration possible of the credentials).
- draw_down 7y agoI disagree. The solution to this situation where there are a bunch of dialogs popping all over the screen, asking for some permission, is not to throw up your hands and say "best we could do".
- mathemagics 7y agoAgree that it is overall an improved experience. After upgrading, I discovered that a VPN app wanted access to my Documents folder. No reason it would need that, so I simply denied it. Lo and behold, the app continues to work just fine as expected. IMO, this alone is a big reason to upgrade to Catalina.
- cactus2093 7y agoI wonder if maybe it just stores a settings file in there or something? I've seen similar things with apps that request access to Dropbox or Google Drive just not being scoped granularly enough, so they just ask for access to your entire account to control a single file or folder. Which leads to a shitty situation, either you give up functionality like being able to declaratively override settings and sync them between machines, or you compromise your security and allow access. There's no way the PM for the product actually cares about granular permission scoping, so of course nobody actually implements in a safer way where you don't have to make this choice. I haven't looked closely at the new MacOS permissions and how granular they can be, but I'm kind of curious how this will turn out. I suspect the average person will just get used to clicking allow on everything, so developers won't actually care about only asking for what they need, and not much will actually improve about security. But I hope to be proven wrong.
- mathemagics 7y agoApple provides APIs for saving app settings in the app's sandbox. They require no additional permissions. You're probably right that it's not nefarious in this app's case, but rather just developer ignorance. But even so, this is the right path to nudge developers towards better security practices. Also, the permissions are contextual. I didn't see this dialog until I launched the app. Similarly, the first time an app wants to show a notification, the system prompts you to allow / deny it. I'm sure Apple can polish this more over time. But I will take this over the "nearly full-system access by default" paradigms that dominate desktop OS's.
- 72deluxe 7y agoSettings should be under ~/Library somewhere (perhaps ~/Library/Preferences?) and not in the Documents directory.
- Wowfunhappy 7y agoI expect applications to have access to my desktop. I do not need to be asked. It would be like asking permission to access my clipboard, or use my speakers, or read my keyboard. If you bombard users with dialogues for every little thing, all you will do is train them to habitually click yes. Now you have lowered security, because users will ignore the more serious warnings too. And you've wasted everyone's time in the process. This was exactly why UAC dialogues were largely a failure. And to think that UAC appears only once per app...
- dpkonofa 7y agoYou expect applications to have access to your desktop? You should only ever expect the user to have access to the desktop and, even then, the only apps that would ever prompt for access to the desktop are those that aren't updated for High Sierra and above. On the latest versions of macOS, the Desktop folder is shared by iCloud. This is definitely not an instance where security has been lowered nor is this the standard behavior of the new OS.
- Wowfunhappy 7y ago> You expect applications to have access to your desktop? Yes! That's what applications do, they read and write files. Most other software is, more likely than not, either a game or a web page. Does every app need to access my desktop specifically? No. But if we're trying to protect "normal users", I don't think most of them have the wherewithal to think through "what exact locations does and doesn't app X need to access?"
- CDSlice 7y agoBut they should only read and write files that you give it permission to. E.g, Word should only be reading and writing whatever files you open to edit, it shouldn't be able to access all the files in your Applications folder. If it needs temp files it can write those to it's designated section of the file system.
- 7y ago
- DevKoala 7y agoVery well said. It is a rough upgrade, but a step forward in security and privacy.
- api 7y agoIt's just change = bad without looking at what is being changed and why.
- fbelzile 7y agoThe "privacy" dialog popups are just marketing. Sure, there may have been an issue with a few bad apps, but Apple found a way to continuously remind you that they are the only ones that 'care about your privacy'TM. Meanwhile, they still happily take Google's money to make it the default search engine in Safari.
- etchalon 7y ago… how is an actual functional limitation imposed on applications through an operating system's APIs "just marketing"? If you click deny, BEHOLD, the application is denied that permission.
- microcolonel 7y agoI don't know about this somehow being proof that "Apple doesn't care about the Mac" or something, but I remember distinctly when Apple themselves, and the fanboys, were ragging on Microsoft for UAC (which really only asks you to confirm occasional administrative operations). As for the general quality of Catalina, there seems to be a deluge of amateur-hour flaws that affect real workflows for real users.
- GeekyBear 7y agoNot being asked to grant all permissions that an application wants up front (before you even get a chance to use the app) has a positive impact on the user experience. If the application asks for permission to access my contacts only after I select an option to share information with others, for instance, I can feel more confident about granting that permission. Asking for all permissions up front is the permissions model that Google just abandoned.
- charredbacon 7y agoI disagree that there's no transition. This looks like a pretty good alternative: https://www.andrew.cmu.edu/user/bparno/papers/user-driven.pdf https://www.andrew.cmu.edu/user/bparno/papers/user-driven.pd... Instead of the OS displaying an annoying prompt when the application tries to use a privilege, the application embeds an OS-drawn access control gadget inside its UI, such that the user interacting with the UI grants the privilege.
- comex 7y agomacOS does something similar already for file open/save dialogs: they’re drawn by a trusted OS component instead of directly by the app, and the user’s act of selecting a file grants the app permission to access that file without an additional dialog.
- misterdata 7y agoActually not far from how it works on macOS. Usage of a system "open file" dialog automatically creates a permission for the application to access that file from inside its container. https://developer.apple.com/library/archive/documentation/Security/Conceptual/AppSandboxDesignGuide/AppSandboxInDepth/AppSandboxInDepth.html https://developer.apple.com/library/archive/documentation/Se... (search for "Powerbox")
- celadevra_ 7y ago> a world of "applications should ask me when they want to do something" transparency. Why not make the user know what applications do: which files, ports, devices it has to access, and what data it emits, to begin with?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- webwielder2 7y agoComplaints without suggestions are really the worst.
- farisjarrah 7y agoWhy? Sometimes pointing out a flaw, even if you don't necessarily have an answer can open the channel for someone else to contribute something that may help you.
- FPGAhacker 7y agoThat’s hilarious. Kudos if you meant to do that.
- yowlingcat 7y agoVery sad to agree with this entire post. I hate to essentialize it to an already checked and problematic mythology of Jobs-Ives, but it seems like all of the air left the sails after Jobs passed. The OS versions are getting unreservedly worse, likewise with the hardware -- it's active regression rather than stagnation. When it comes to having a quality laptop and OS to get work done, I would at least be happy with stagnation if the stagnation point occurred around the era of the best MBPs -- late model MBPr 15s, ~2012 to 2015-2016. I'm typing this one one right now. It's a little long in the tooth, but I'm horrified to update to a newer one and have to get the whole bottom panel replaced, yet again. I'm hoping to defer this decision by a year or two, but I'm sure I'll have to bite the bullet eventually, and every year, I hope that it's not going to be worse, so that it'll at least be good enough. Sadly, it looks like that hope may yet be naive.
- wil421 7y agoWhy do you think the hardware and software versions are getting worse? My late 2017 15 inch rMBP is a lot better than my 2011 MBP. I also like the recent releases of MacOS. Dark mode, stacks on desktop, seeing Meta data in preview, and the new screenshot tool are a few Mojave features I like. Memory compression in Mavericks was also something I feel is great. Although I never dealt with it directly as a programmer, only a user.
- yowlingcat 7y agoOn the hardware side: keyboard, touchbar, touchpad to keyboard ratio. On the software side: slowness but more importantly a general decrease of opinionated cohesion, and an increase in odd UX decisions. Facetime calls to my iPhone trigger alerts on all of my devices, even if I'd prefer it to just be my phone (I rarely use Facetime on my machine). Beyond that, there are too many useless popups that interrupt me in what I'm doing that I have to X out of that I end up with a screen that looks like the topic post -- hence the pejorative "10.15 Vista" which is how a lot of folks about Windows Vista when it was released after the relatively sleek and polished UX of Windows 2000 and XP.
- 7y ago
- FPGAhacker 7y agoYeah, this was basically my experience. Not a good first impression, but I’m assuming I won’t be asked this stuff again for the same apps. So, oh well.
- geerlingguy 7y agoThis is kind of the same as the first time you enable Little Snitch. IMO it’s good to reveal that you’re running dozens of applications with basically full access to all your files. I’d rather give additive permissions to applications, since I’ve seen evidence time and again that security is one of the lowest priorities for most development shops. It’s annoying the first time after upgrading (I haven’t done it yet), but it is infrequent after that. Except for the Safari 13 download authorization prompt for every domain. That is a little more annoying to me.
- ashton314 7y agoLS is probably my favorite app after iTerm2. The hardest part is definitely the first few months of CONSTANT dialogues. So worth it though. Maybe it’s just me, but I feel a certain sense of comfort in seeing explicit privacy dialogues that make sense, coupled with a deep feeling of control when I press that “Deny” button.
- ilumanty 7y agoUsing Little Snitch is an explicit choice. It would be weird of Apple to assume that users want to see all those messages and peek into the clockwork at the first occasion.
- bobbylarrybobby 7y agoYou can change the default download permission from "ask" to "allow" in Safari's websites preferences.
- psychometry 7y agoWait, Bartender 3 can record my screen?
- justintoon 7y agoThey provide a detailed explanation why at this page: https://www.macbartender.com/Screen-Recording-Permission/ https://www.macbartender.com/Screen-Recording-Permission/
- bobbylarrybobby 7y agoFascinating, I had no idea it worked that way...
- psychometry 7y agoWell, I decided that none of that was worth the risk and uninstalled it. They need to find a better way.
- someonehere 7y agoLiterally this was me this morning after I upgraded last night and went to bed. I get Apple wants to make people feel their in control of their privacy, but literally every app I use for work prompts me for every permission imaginable. “Oh the command you’re running in Terminal, it wants permissions to your Downloads folder, is that ok?” ::click yes:: “Guess what? That same command you’re running in Terminal now wants to access you Library folder. Is That cool?” ::click yes:: “hey it’s me again, that Terminal command. It now wants to access your Documents folder. Is that cool?” I’m a Sys admin prepping all the hoops to make my clients avoid this fiasco. It’s somewhat documented what we should expect, but it’s a lot of prep work and real world testing we need to go through to ensure our users don’t ask, “why am I always being prompted with these pop up questions?” Also, TV, Podcasts, and FindMy are being disabled in Catalina. Disabling FindMy and logging everyone out of iCloud turns off the risk of the new Tile like features Apple is about to release on the world. I don’t want my users turning their work machines turn into Bluetooth beacons for Apple.
- andrekandre 7y ago> I get Apple wants to make people feel their in control of their privacy, but literally every app I use for work prompts me for every permission imaginable. i would guess this has the side-effect of making devs think hard about what really needs access or not, and tightening up where data is stored (say in the app container, not copying files willy nilly over the hd, using entitlements etc) > Oh the command you’re running in Terminal, it wants permissions to your Downloads folder, is that ok?” ::click yes:: “Guess what? That same command you’re running in Terminal now wants to access you Library folder. Is That cool?” ::click yes:: “hey it’s me again, that Terminal command. It now wants to access your Documents folder. Is that cool?” yes, that is annoying, but i’m pretty sure that only happens the first time it tries to access those folders... is that correct? personally, i think that’s good that it checks those, because some scripts can do damage to your data (say. by accident), and you might want to know if it’s trying to say, read your keychain or not
- pfranz 7y ago> yes, that is annoying, but i’m pretty sure that only happens the first time it tries to access those folders... is that correct? I haven't updated to Catalina, but some recent macOS (Mojave?) I didn't get those prompts in Terminal until I ran `find .` So I think you're right.
- sys_64738 7y agoIs this not a slight on Windows Vista? By SP1 they had pretty much resolved all the UAC hiccups.
- dpkonofa 7y agoYes, but that took nearly 2 years (1.5 if you're only counting from individual public sales) and the launch was terrible. I'm glad that Vista happened because it very much needed to but they really shit the bed on its release.
- Rebelgecko 7y agoAt least for me, there's really no good reason to upgrade to Catalina. Most of the new "features" are things that I can't or won't use (e.g. desktop Siri). However Catalina causes a lot of problems with things that I do care about (32 bit apps, hardware drivers)
- scarlac 7y agoI won't pretend you have the same interests as me but one of the reasons I personally look(ed) forward to Catalina was the ability to essentially "run iOS apps" (recompiled for macOS). I can't wait to get rid of some of my Electron apps in favor of proper native ones. That feature alone would be worth the upgrade in my opinion. But that's not to say I agree with how they've implemented the permissions dialogs. As a developer who had to deal with them I found several glaring bugs in Mojave, not to mention a sub-par UX. I'm sad if they haven't improved on that.
- bobbylarrybobby 7y agoHow can you just "run iOS apps"?
- lawik 7y agoDevelopers can use Catalyst to build their iPad/iOS apps for Mac. New thing with the new OS version. And sort of a path forward towards the idea of Swift UI and one UItoolkit to rule them all I guess. https://developer.apple.com/mac-catalyst/ https://developer.apple.com/mac-catalyst/
- rewgs 7y agoThe day before Catalina was released, I found myself looking for the Podcasts app on macOS. I've become a big fan of it on iOS and couldn't remember if it was one those early iOS-to-macOS apps, like News. It wasn't. Bummer. Upgraded to Catalina without a second thought after seeing that Podcasts was included. It's tiny, but it's things like that that make this feature cool. Just a little less friction between the platforms.
- 7y ago
- Gaelan 7y agoYou know, this is a pretty apt analogy. Vista (apparently) was considered terrible primarily because it ripped off the band-aid and made a bunch of inconvenient but important-for-security-in-the-long-term changes. [0] [0]: https://twitter.com/swiftonsecurity/status/851857404891471872 https://twitter.com/swiftonsecurity/status/85185740489147187...
- Yetanfou 7y agoWell, that, plus the fact that it was resource-heavy. This was compounded by the fact that a lot of hardware was sold as being 'Vista-ready' while in reality being incapable of running the overly-fancy graphics-heavy 'glass' shell. It also had a number of performance problems (e.g. slow file copy) which only got sorted out in Windows 7. Oh, let's not forget the fact that Vista was supposed to be Longhorn, the OS of the future with a database file system and all sorts of fancy stuff which was either dropped due to performance problems or never left the lab in the first place.
- kbenson 7y ago> Oh, let's not forget the fact that Vista was supposed to be Longhorn, the OS of the future with a database file system This sounded interesting when I first heard about it, long before Vista came out. Now when I see it I wonder what they were trying to do. A file system is a database, with a well understood user API. So what were they going to add? Tagging? Application level views of the system? None of t hat seems like something that would require anything more than an extension that handled additional metadata.
- kayfox 7y agoLots of file systems at the time were hierarchical databases, but the file-system Microsoft was working on was to be more a hybrid with the ability to find files based on specific criteria right away, rather than having a search process walk the tree looking for something.
- bobbylarrybobby 7y ago
- wayneftw 7y agoI’m surprised they didn’t ask for a password too, after clicking OK on each dialog. I’m not surprised at the UX though, Apple has always done a pretty terrible job of that for power users.
- olliej 7y agoThe problem with "power users" is fairly simple: defining what a power user is, isn't trivial, and different people have different ideas as to what is good. Then you have being a "power user" does not mean "I want any app on my system to be able to do anything". As for not asking for their password: This actually makes a lot of sense. Users already hit "ok" fairly quickly (I assume the inclusion of the readable name + icon in the dialog is to make noticing what is being asked more immediately obvious). Requiring a password would have the effect of making every new app ask for a password, so you are training a user to (effectively) grant root access for any software they install. Compare the outcome: user auto clicks "give this app access to your contacts", app can access and/or encrypt the user's contacts. User auto-enters their account password: app can access and/or encrypt everything. Note that even power users run into malware - they're not magically immune - and if you download "vscode" and it asks for access to your contacts, email, etc you might go "huh" and re-examine it.
- wilg 7y agoThis isn't ideal, but it also looks to be because there's a ton of power user stuff installed, which is going to require lots of permissions. And you really do need to ask the user individually.
- r00fus 7y agoThis. My parents would never deal with this because they don't run Hazel, Alfred, Bartender, etc. I run some of them, but I'm fine with hard transitions.
- crooked-v 7y agoThe biggest annoyance I've had here is that it makes some apps just plain not work if they're using something symlinked from ~/Library to ~/Documents (for Mackup or other syncing solutions), though some work fine, so it may just be exposing apps that are doing something weird with file access in the first place.
- moreorless 7y agoThis reminds me of WindowsRG. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YbEYOaO9kp4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YbEYOaO9kp4
- proverbialbunny 7y agoSince I was quite young I'd play pranks using a computer. I switched the Mac Classic bootup picture with a bomb, causing my father to freak out. I gave my grandparents a free cupholder out of their cd rom drive they used for years. A decade later they were still thanking me for the upgrade. I then once pulled up winrg.swf and fullscreened it. I told my grandmother I had upgraded her computer for her. She took a look at it for about 15 seconds then started crying. Since then I've been a bit more cautious. Windows Really Good edition is still pretty great though.
- widowlark 7y agoIt's crazy to me that when Microsoft does this kind of thing (via Vista), it's considered terrible but when Apple does it, the thread fills with people saying it's the best way forward.
- pram 7y agoHN didn't even exist when Vista was released.
- dragonwriter 7y agoHN was called Slashdot then.
- Zenw 7y agoI just wanna tell you guys a wonderful feature for 10.15 - I use `OmniDiskSweeper` to moving a hidden file to the Trash than I can't either empty or access the Trash with Terminal. Yes, this hidden file lay in my Trash as a zombie. I like zombie stuff including zombie gaming zombie film and now I got a zombie OS, it's cooooool.
- dmix 7y agoFine grained privacy control is not the same as being notified 14 times about the same thing by Windows, even though you said you didn't want notifications already.
- aianus 7y agoIs there any way to turn this feature off?
- cwilby 7y agoI recently tried again at setting up Ubuntu on my 2013 Macbook, after multiple attempts over the years that didn't pan out due to Wifi issues, battery life, graphics drivers, touchpad etc. As of 2019, it's flippin' fantastic. Most issues above are gone and Docker development experience in particular is vastly improved over Docker for Mac. With the direction Apple is going, I don't see a road back soon. Disclaimer - everyone's mileage varies, just sharing my odometer.
- melvinroest 7y agoHuh, that's quite the contrary to my Mac Mini 2012 experience. My Raspberry Pi wasn't here yet and I wanted a web server. Yea, Wifi didn't immediately work, but with some Googling you figure out how to find the right driver and use modprobe (or whatever it was) to load it in. Though, I do have my fair share of Ubuntu install horror stories, so I guess I'm simply lucky when it comes to Mac and Ubuntu.
- greggman2 7y agoI for one am super happy for these permission dialogs. They help me know which apps are doing what and tell them, no, you can't do that! Going from the old model, a native app can do almost anything to the new model, a native app has to ask permission means that yes, there is a one time issue of having to give all apps the permissions you want them to have. That happens just once though on this transition. Normally it would happen once or twice a month as you install new apps.
- dawnerd 7y agoI'm all for them as well. Forced me to reconsider some of the apps I have installed having not previously known what they were doing. Example, bartender needs screen recording. While Im sure it's 100% safe, I still don't trust giving an app that permission if its going to be running all the time. Just seems like an unnecessary attack vector. Seeing some people say 'if you were fine with it before...' - well that's the thing, I wouldn't have been fine with it before if I had known.
- iamleppert 7y agoThis isn’t a “step forward in user privacy” or whatever the others here are saying. It’s a mess and very poorly executed UX. Users will tend to feel overwhelmed and just click through modals when they are presented in this way. Displaying stacks of modals is an anti-pattern. The right thing to do would have been to create a migration UX that allows quick review and audit of application permissions, presented in a table, sorted by applications that are requesting the most permissions. With a clear explanation of what’s happening and why a review is now needed. That would be a step forward in user privacy and informed consent. Anyone defending such an abomination of UX should have their software designing license revoked.
- hkai 7y agoBut that's a one time thing. When you're doing an OS upgrade, I guess you're expecting some extra work. Your also have to reinstall xcode, update other apps etc.
- daveFNbuck 7y agoI still don't know why I always have to reinstall xcode. It's very annoying.
- w0utert 7y agoFor one, it needs to install the SDK's for the new deployment target you just installed (be it macOS or iOS), and update the toolchain so it can build for it. It's mildly annoying, but the alternative would be to let you continue using the old version pegged to an older deployment target, and let you figure out all the incompatibilities at once when you decide you want release your app to the app store. IMO this would be much more annoying than just getting a coffee once while you wait for the upgrade.
- vetinari 7y agoHe said reinstall, not upgrade. For example, Xcode 11, which has 10.15 SDK target, can be installed on Mojave. This has been the case for years, the new Xcode can run on the n-1 OS release. So why reinstall it, after the system is updated?
- auslander 7y agoAlfred 3 app is busted.
- 013a 7y agoI'm astounded with some of the user security dialogs that Macs display. I got one today: "VSCode wants to make some changes. Deny or Allow." That was the exact wording. Seriously? THIS. BENEFITS. NO. ONE. The only thing I can figure is that, somehow, Mac has required applications to display something to the user to get their permission to make some substantial system-level changes. But the application is, I guess?, allowed to fill in the message dialog. I can't believe that wording came from Apple; I assume it was Microsoft, who I do trust as much as anyone, so I'll approve it, but this leaves a lingering question: Either Apple actually did write that, or they allow applications published by "whoever" to fill in "whatever" messaging they want to get the user to click Yes. It's absolutely unacceptable behavior. I'd say I'm done with Apple, but there isn't a personal computing platform who gets this right. Every Apple employee reading this article should be ashamed. Every Microsoft employee should be ashamed. Everyone just Needs To Do Better. What is Better? I don't know, off-hand. It's not easy, but I'd imagine why that's why these companies are paid billions of dollars. For starters: If I install around your centralized certificate signing authority to install something, I Trust That Application. It doesn't need to alert me every time it makes a change. And if I install it through your store, then I also trust it, because you trust it. So why do I get so many damn "Approve This Change" notifications? I should get ZERO after the install. I get that most users aren't as savvy as me, but that's why you're making it so hard to bypass that central certificate signing authority, and I'm fine with that. It's the lingering notifications that make zero sense. Fix your shit, Apple, because I haven't encountered anyone that's ecstatic with anything you've released in the past 18 months.
- blobster 7y agoSo you want all your apps to have root-level system access?
- zamfi 7y agoI think the poster above is arguing that dialogs like "this app needs permissions, deny or allow" are effectively giving root-level system access for all intents and purposes, for almost all users -- exactly because users have no basis on which to make that decision and saying "deny" probably prevents the app from doing what it was the user wanted it to do. So users almost always click "allow". What's the point of the dialog then? Really, the dialog should be explicit about what's needed and why it's needed and what click "allow" does (i.e., always allow this action, for this purpose? Or always allow any root-level action from this app? Or something else?) Only then will users actually be able to make a decision beyond "do I trust Microsoft and do I want to do this thing I just asked Word to do?"
- vikingcaffiene 7y agoI've lost faith in Apple leadership. After 10 years of being a diehard, I recently jumped ship. Got myself a System 76 Oryx Pro and an Pixel 3a phone. Still working out the kinks but so far so good. The apple tax was only worth it when was the clearly superior choice. It ain't anymore.
- cjohansson 7y agoI’m at the same position now. If macOS converges to Windows then Windows is a better alternative, the reason I started with Apple was that Windows was a mess, now Linux feels like the most sane alternative for power-users
- makecheck 7y agoIt seems to me that for the sake of user experience they should really, really try to automatically coalesce multiple system messages and notifications that appear while others have not yet been dismissed. For example, automatically grow the first alert into a list with checkboxes or something if another alert shows up, so that the user can reply to all of them in a sane way.
- dwaite 7y agoThe dialogs are meant to be presented in context so that the user understands _why_ they are being asked for a privacy-impacting decision. Applications rely on this so that they may ask for permission within context. E.g., a retail company app that asks to track location permissions on start will often get denied. That same app asking for location permissions when the user says 'find nearest stores' will have decent success. Promoting it up to a system-level coalesced set of notifications both eliminates the benefits of asking for permissions in contexts and the motivation to stop asking for permissions out of context. It also creates a problem in some apps where the prompt is modal, because the API is blocked until the question is answered.
- makecheck 7y agoApple does require apps to provide context in a lot of cases, and the app’s provided reason appears alongside the message. There is nothing about a combined window that requires context to be lost. For example, add a column that includes trigger conditions and reasons for each one, e.g. “while launching startup item”, “when opening AppName”, “to authorize task performed by AppName”, “downloaded from xyz.com”, etc. If that information really isn’t enough, the user still has the option to deselect one and try it again in isolation. An API can be held in a modal state without requiring each app to have its own dialog; the system can decide what action allows the API to return to resume the app. Similarly, an app can fire off an async notification without caring if that notification window is separate from others. This is entirely a presentation issue.
- Razengan 7y agoApple seems to be forgetting their own credo against nag-based security: https://i.imgur.com/qbUy5aH.png https://i.imgur.com/qbUy5aH.png (from an ancient WWDC slide mocking the Windows approach.) They may have overdone it in a few cases, and not done anything where it's really needed (like a unified list of all third-party startup items, such as Google’s sneaky Keystone malware, or seeing all outgoing data and connection attempts like Little Snitch shows), but as other commenters have mentioned, it lets me catch various apps overreaching into my computer for things they just don't need to function, and I definitely appreciate that. Another thing I wish they would do is provide an infallible way to verify system password request dialogs. Not long ago DropBox used to show you a fake dialog that then stole your administrator password. There should be a list inside System Preferences where you can go and see all the authentic password request dialogs that are currently being shown. In short, they should move away from nagging to better monitoring and reporting.
- dtech 7y agoThe "nagging" approach seems to work well on mobile, at least with targeted permissions. I don't know how it is on iOS, but this seems very similar.
- trymas 7y ago> Not long ago DropBox used to show you a fake dialog that then stole your administrator password. Wow. What the hell? Can you provide any sources to read about this more?
- JustFinishedBSG 7y agohttps://applehelpwriter.com/2016/07/28/revealing-dropboxs-dirty-little-security-hack/ https://applehelpwriter.com/2016/07/28/revealing-dropboxs-di... Dropbox imitated a system dialog box in order to get your password to give itself system level permissions without asking you.
- trymas 7y agoThank you. I am speechless on the behaviour from DropBox. I wonder why I have never heard of this and I do not remember any major security scandal regarding DropBox stealing your admin passwords, but maybe that information just went around me for some reason.. :) EDIT: I wonder how this was implemented, I imagine that any app, can recreate a pixel perfect dialog imitating system dialog asking for password and steal your sensitive information, though how can app add itself to accessibility list programatically? I am not knowledgable of MacOS API and somehow I think apps should be prevented to be able to do this on their own. Was it a MacOS security bug? What else DropBox did "under the hood" with admin password that we do not know of yet?
- ohazi 7y agoMaybe we should be angry? Apple has been neglecting OS X since Snow Leopard, thinking that iOS is the only thing worth investing in. Microsoft apparently agrees -- they chopped up the Windows team last year, pushing out the Windows chief and dumping the remaining re-orged husk under Azure. Just for security reasons alone, it should be terrifying that there isn't a standalone Windows group anymore. Windows hasn't been usable since 7; the current version literally requires you to let it reboot itself on a 9-5 schedule. And now this with Apple, again. Can we move on already? Most of us spend at least half of our waking hours interacting with a desktop operating system, most of us use either OS X or Windows, and yet both of these companies have made it clear that their desktop OSes are no longer a priority! Why are so many of us still putting up with this? I know people like to knock Linux-on-the-desktop, but you know what? I can go buy a Thinkpad, spend 20 minutes putting Debian or Ubuntu on it, and it'll just work, and I'll get software updates forever. I used to care about flashy widgets back when Gnome was cloning old OS X features, but now I just use XFCE because it looks reasonable, it works, and it stays the fuck out of my way. And when there are bugs, people make a little noise, and then they get fixed. Remind me again what version of bash Apple ships? I don't have the time or the energy to work around that crap anymore.
- Beefpro9 7y agoAs of Catalina, Apple has switched the default shell to zsh and nags you when you launch bash. That said... I agree. Between this, the abysmal keyboard failure rate, and some of the user-hostile choices they've made, I've switched to a Razer laptop. Windows 10 Pro lets you avoid most of the jank, by the way. But, I'm only on it as an eventual migration path to something running XFCE (my favorite wm due to its out of box usability).
- elSidCampeador 7y agoWait what? Why/when did they do this?
- dijit 7y agoWhat are you asking? Why/When MacOS transitioned to zsh? Why; because bash became GPLv3 at some point in history and MacOS couldn’t update their version of bash. (The last GPLv2 version). When; was catalina (just released)
- lovelyviking 7y agov
- jzl 7y agoIn case anyone needs a history lesson, here's a good refresher: https://www.networkworld.com/article/2277550/microsoft-to-improve-vista-s-problematic-uac-in-windows-7.html https://www.networkworld.com/article/2277550/microsoft-to-im... "UAC was created with the intention of putting you in control of your system, reducing cost of ownership over time and improving the software ecosystem," according to the post, which is attributed to Ben Fathi, corporate vice president of development for Microsoft's Windows Core Operating System Division. "What we've learned is that we only got part of the way there in Vista and some folks think we accomplished the opposite."
- enzoaguado 7y agoWhat I find personally funny is the amount of bashing Microsoft gets for being hostile to privacy, yet when Apple or some other company tries to make a push forward, they get bad comments because of a side effect of it Yes, this could probably be better, but practically no security improvement can be achieve without a tradeoff. As mentionned in the blog post, this user is a power user, with many programs installed and these popups appears only one time. Spending at most 10 minutes accepting/denying permission prompts (which, let's be honest, are pretty concise and clearly worded) is a good tradeoff for more control on what applications are doing on my system.
- ptah 7y agoI don't see any compelling reason to upgrade to catalina. at least macOS upgrades are a painless process, but the risk of breaking existeng applications is becoming increasingly likely over the years
- NiekvdMaas 7y agoAnyone remember this Apple ad from 12+ years ago? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VuqZ8AqmLPY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VuqZ8AqmLPY That didn't age well...
- 72deluxe 7y agoWell remembered! I used to work with a guy who was a spitting image of the PC character
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- coldtea 7y agoThe reason for so many messages at once -- in case it's not obvious to someone not using macOS -- is that this user had a lot of apps set to autostart at login... So several apps started at the same time (upon reboot and login) and now needed explicit user permissions under Catalina, so they prompted for those. What I don't understand is, why can't Apple have an app/panel where all standalone such nags are placed? So, instead of 20 mini-windows all over the place, you get a single window, with the name of each requesting app and the nag, and even options like "deny all", "allow all", or some quick way to select some and not others (e.g. nags grouped by app). And an additional idea: I'd have a physical led or similar mechanism on the computer, that only when a dialog is official and uses standard system UI lights up (similar to how a led lights up when the camera is on). I'd use secure enclave and make sure that only system APIs can set this on -- no userland code, except when it calls the specific legit dialogs, which should also not be hidable and have the highest z-index.
- JustFinishedBSG 7y agoIn this thread and every other threads like it: people complaining about Windows/MacOS hostile path, yet refusing to use Linux. You know, "vote with your wallet" also means "vote by changing the products you use".
- littlecranky67 7y agoI didn't come close the provided screenshot in the article, but I was also alienated by the number of popups & permission requests I got after upgrading to Catalina. I really see what Apple is trying to do here - I do not want a system as in Windows, where my Game Launcher X scans my hard drive for other game launchers, and extracts contacts & game list just to send it to Game Launcher X manufacturers servers for "analytics" or "enhancing my user experience". (this is just an unconfirmed rumour but nonetheless, see [0]) Apps have become far more than just programs and tools we use to solve a problem, they have become marketing channels and data-gatherer for the companys creating them. The time we can install a program from a trustworthy source and give it full access to OS APIs and the Filesystem are gone. I do not have a better technical solution as what Apple shipped, but I really am glad that I can prevent Applications from scanning through my Downloads folder or settings folders of other applications. [0]: https://www.pcgamer.com/epic-steam-data-reddit/ https://www.pcgamer.com/epic-steam-data-reddit/
- lovelyviking 7y agoSince SL I feel that Apple gets more and more control over Apps, rather then me over my own system. Being for years able to advocate that apple approach, with all problems, was at least superior in user interface feel and experience. Now I have more and more trouble finding real arguments. I can't stand popups, they appear in the middle of what you do. They interrupt your flow. If you ask me they should not exist in a good software.Certainly I was not missing a lot of dialogs for security. I need one list in one place with permissions/apps where I can tune what is allowed and what is not for each app, including(!) Apple Apps and where they connect. It's getting worse and worse in many aspects. I feel less and less in control about what system does. I can't track what connects, where, why and which information is sent, for instance by Calendar, when I turned off all related to iCloud, I do not expect it to connect anywhere, yet it does. Also some "geod" deamon connects every time I go online even though I disabled everything possible through GUI related to iCloud and even time sync ... So why it connects I have no idea, but if I forbid it in a router, then guess what? Internet doesn't work completely. Safari won't load anything. We talk about privacy and security? How about fixing those behaviours and giving me control back? How is catalina with that? So we have many dialogs, distracting us from what are real privacy concerns?
- cotelletta 7y agoEveryone should be spamming the hell out of Apple's feedback form if they: - have 32-bit apps or games that won't be updated - don't think there is anything worthwhile to upgrade for - don't need mismatched marzipan iOS toys on their desktop - don't have an iPhone or iPad and just want a computer that's a computer etc. This reeks of "we checked our stats and the normies don't care", a huge mistake for a platform once loved by developers.
- alimbada 7y agoApple's reality distortion field still at work. Praise Apple engineers for this... nagfest[?] but if it were Microsoft everyone was and would be up in arms about it.
- vkoskiv 7y agoIt's really infuriating. I've been using the 10.15 betas since june. Every single time I build&run my binary in Xcode, macOS asks if it should have access to my Documents folder. I click `yes` every time, but it never remembers. It's just become an annoying extra step to my development cycle.