13 ms·
I have to say, this is really the only way to respond to China when it comes to their no-humor censors: just come out and mock them. They don't really have any
by dekhn 7y ago
I have to say, this is really the only way to respond to China when it comes to their no-humor censors: just come out and mock them. They don't really have any way to reply.
One wonders if there is an entire revolutionary class within China sharing South Park videos for freedom.
- throwaway_bad 7y agoSometimes we forget that getting disappeared in china is not just a meme. Police will show up to arrest you just for posting comments online: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cCOAbkTs_a4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cCOAbkTs_a4
- dekhn 7y agoi certainly don't forget. I've been watching Russia and China from a very safe position of privilege in the US for many years. The last time I really worried was when I used to post dumb stuff on usenet in college, but in retrospect, I was never really at risk.
- StaticRedux 7y agoIt's not privilege. It's a right the country has fought and died for for over 200 years. It's a principle the country was founded on. "Privilege" has lost all meaning in today's world. It's just a word to throw around to slow how "woke" you are. Calling our rights "privilege" is throwing out the struggle and sacrifice of everyone that fought for those rights. You may have been Lucky to have been born in the US, but not Privileged
- dekhn 7y agoI understand where you're coming from and I thought twice about using that word. I certainly appreciate the work done to give me freedoms, and I agree luck had a big part of it. But the reality is that as a white middle class male in the US, I do have the privilege to say things and do things in public that people who aren't white or middle class can't. The freedoms we have aren't equally distributed due to systemic racism and sexism. I'm pretty anti-woke, actually, I hate the term.
- Konnstann 7y agoCan you give me an example of something a non-white, non-middle class person can't say or do in public? Maybe it's my limited world-view, but I can't think of anything specific.
- dekhn 7y agoSure, if you (10 years ago) smoked a joint on the street, and you were black, you carried a far far higher risk of being imprisoned.
- Konnstann 7y agoWhere's the parallel between doing something illegal (10 years ago) and being able to comment on the political climate without fearing for your life/livelihood?
- cblades 7y agoThe unequal application of the law based on race. Equal treatment under the law is just as much a fundamental right as freedom of expression is and, arguably, equal treatment prevents the subtle and slow erosion of other rights.
- munk-a 7y agoThe fact that African Americans are the most likely people by race to be stripped of their right to representation and political expression by a wide margin. To clarify - this is via them losing access to representation by being deemed a felon, and a lot more African Americans are sentenced with drug possession or intent to distribute than any other racial group proportionally.
- laheyBro 7y agolol What an awful example.
- notduncansmith 7y agoDepending on where you are, simply leaving the house. Black people are more likely to be "randomly" stopped, more likely to be searched at a stop, and more likely to be arrested at a stop. Other statistics highlight similar issues faced by other minorities. https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/black-people-more-likely-be-stopped-cops-study-finds-n616546 https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/black-people-more...
- grievances 7y agoMany brave people have fought and died for their countries and rights. Its easy to forget that minorities and “unlucky” people fight too; knowing that you’re safe expressing your points of view is something that many have earned, not all have received. That very much sounds like privilege to me.
- gonational 7y agoWe fight to make this country what it is so that we can all stand together as one people, not so we can whine like little babies about who’s more privileged or marginalized than everyone else.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- danharaj 7y agoyou specifically didn't fight shit, buddy
- cblades 7y agoAcknowledging that rights are more readily and equally given to some people than others is not whining.
- danso 7y agoWhich marginalized group, when fighting "to make this country what it is", hasn't been opposed and mocked (e.g. "whiny little babies) by the status quo at the time of their fight?
- joelx 7y agoWe need to avoid getting lost in minor internal debates. I agree some classes of people in America have had more difficulty exercising their rights, but they always had those rights and the courts enforced them usually. What we are talking about with China and Russia is totalitarian dictatorships that come and take you from your home and beat you and murder you for making a comment on the internet they didn't like or even sharing a Winnie the Poo meme. We need to all band together to fight this or we will lose all of our privileges and rights.
- azangru 7y ago> Calling our rights "privilege" is throwing out the struggle and sacrifice of everyone that fought for those rights. But isn't it the very definition of privilege, when through no effort of your own you get to enjoy the benefits for which others have "fought", "struggled", and "sacrificed"? How is it different from the privilege of being born into a rich (or just functional) family? > You may have been Lucky to have been born in the US, but not Privileged It looks like the word "privileged", through all these fights on social media, has got a bad rep :-) How is being privileged different than being lucky?
- IllogicalLogic 7y ago> Calling our rights "privilege" is throwing out the struggle and sacrifice of everyone that fought for those rights. Next South Park should do an episode that shows how greedy western leaders running opium/heroin for the better part of now two centuries, turned the most populous country into a paranoid dictatorial hellhole for the Chinese people. US introspection would be too on the nose? You ever ask yourself what percentage of the heroin/opium supply would be pulled off the market if China could extradite people from HK? More than 50%... and who gets hurt by that?
- AnthonyMouse 7y ago> But isn't it the very definition of privilege, when through no effort of your own you get to enjoy the benefits for which others have "fought", "struggled", and "sacrificed"? How is it different from the privilege of being born into a rich (or just functional) family? The reason this framing is despicable is that rights and privileges are not the same. Being able to afford a Lexus is a privilege. Not everyone has it and that's OK. Having access to clean water is a right. Not everyone has it and that's not OK. Free speech is a right. Everyone should have it even if some people currently don't.
- tdb7893 7y agoI think that this distinction isn't widely understood as the definition of privilege. If you look it up in a dictionary privileges you'll see a lot of definitions where privileges are defined as a special case of rights so they are most definitely not mutually exclusive https://www.dictionary.com/browse/privilege https://www.dictionary.com/browse/privilege
- davidw 7y ago> "Privilege" has lost all meaning in today's world. It's just a word to throw around to slow how "woke" you are. It gets thrown around a lot, but it absolutely has a meaning. Ever know anyone who says that "they ignore politics"? In many cases, those people come from a place that they can do that because it doesn't affect them that much, and certainly not as much as other people. For instance: today the supreme court in the US is deciding whether it's ok to fire people for merely being gay. To not have to worry about that is 'privilege'.
- corodra 7y agoWell, lets not forget their detention camps for ethnic minorities they don't like: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/sep/23/china-footage-reveals-hundreds-of-blindfolded-and-shackled-prisoners-uighur https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/sep/23/china-footage-... I mean at this rate, I seriously think in a decade or two, we're going to find a Holocaust level event has been going on in China that's going to make the Nazis look like amateurs. But instead, we're focused on stupid left/right political differences and figuring out whether gender binary bathrooms cause anxiety.
- elliekelly 7y agoI don’t think it’s even a find out a decade or two from now thing. Despite our best effort to shield our eyes from the evidence we can say with reasonable certainty that China is currently committing all of the same atrocities as the Nazis.
- corodra 7y agoMy speculation, the problem is the huge dependency the USA has on Chinese manufacturing and now on investments (Hollywood, Silicon Valley, etc). Like, as much as these tariffs are going to hurt us in the short term, I'm not fully against them. It's just like an business, you cannot have a large portion of your income come from one client or rely on just one supplier. You become far too dependent on them and are not willing to cross them, even if their demands don't align with you or really isn't advantageous for you in the long term. But you'll always move that goal post a little for short term happiness until you did it so much, you realize your goal post is in a whole different country. I'd personally like to see far more diversification in USA imports and exports. A 21.5% dependency on Chinese imports... when I did freelance years ago I panicked over the fact I had a customer that made up 12% of my yearly income. I quickly did a reach out to obtain new customers so I could drop that to roughly 6%. While I understand geopolitics is a different ball game... it's really, really dangerous to have a 20%+ reliance on a supplier. Being shut off that easy on that much of goods and materials, that easily, is pretty scary.
- ddrdrck_ 7y agoBrainwashing millions of people is a terrible thing to do, but I don't believe it is on the same level of atrocity than genocide and mass murdering. Nazis did not try to "assimilate" Jews by forcing them to reject their religion and traditions, and by forcing weddings between aryan and jews (could you imagine that ?).
- dabei 7y agoThought Police caught in action.
- a0zU 7y agoNobody's forgotten that it isn't a meme.
- jimclegg 7y agoLooks similar to what happens in the UK - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DF_rvhsGjBM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DF_rvhsGjBM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z1Xr4nfKsWk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z1Xr4nfKsWk Wonder what she typed.
- jdm2212 7y agoOne is a country with rule of law enforcing its laws. The other is an autocracy enforcing the whims of the current ruler.
- threwawasy1228 7y agoThis is such a ridiculous framing, so in your opinion by this logic, if Xi was democratically elected by a free and fair election, and then proceeded to ban memes via a legislative branch that would be perfectly fine? I think what the UK is doing is equally shameful. This kind of "its ok when the west does it" type of narrative is why when I talk to Chinese students about censorship issues they can consistently point to Western censorship of topics with smugness. "Oh but those things we ban here are anti-PC, so we are offended by them", sounds eerily similar to, "Oh but those things we ban here are anti-CCP, so we are offended by them".
- jdm2212 7y agoThere are two separate issues with China banning memes: 1. it's symptomatic of Xi's government being able to do anything it wants to (including killing people to harvest their organs) without any checks and balances 2. it violates our ideal of freedom of speech One of those is a far more serious problem than the other. A democratic society can fix laws that don't live up to its ideals. A lawless, autocratic society cannot.
- jimclegg 7y ago>A democratic society can fix laws that don't live up to its ideals. A lawless, autocratic society cannot. China has mechanisms to change laws but they have to be routed through the proper channels. From what I understand, individuals can complain all they want, as long as they don't organize outside of these designated channels. This definitely pisses off the % of western governments that use "grassroots" movements as an attack vector to undermine unfavorable foreign governments.
- SomeOldThrow 7y agoThis is true of all countries. Try posting threats about federal employees and you will also get arrested.
- goatlover 7y agoThreatening someone's life is a bit different from a cartoon, and it should get anyone arrested in any country, with some consideration of context, of course.
- greedo 7y agoI was under the understanding that words generally don't rise to the legal definition of assault (at least in the US).
- munmaek 7y ago"words" doesn't mean anything. Making a death threat isn't just "words". [0] https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution-conan/amendment-1/threats-of-violence-against-individuals https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution-conan/amendment-1/t...
- munk-a 7y agoAnd so taking a stand like this is a privilege for those with status - a dude working in a newspaper stand wouldn't get away with this - but Trey Stone & Matt Parker have survived the worst the Scientologists could throw at them... they'll weather this one or, if China decides to throw pressure at ComedyCentral or whoever their corporate overloads are, then they can be ready to greet the Streisand effect. I applaud them for doing this even though it'll mean nothing but trouble for them, any positive PR they're getting this will be drowned out by pressures coming out of China and the loss of a giant market - still, good on ya mates.
- sgt101 7y agoI expect that they need their self respect a lot more than they need the Chinese market. What will they do with another $10m each? or $100m... they don't strike me as G5 and coke fellas... Maybe more divorces?
- stebann 7y agoOh and in Argentina Pro-US-"Freedom" Party make disappear protesters or poor people claiming for their rights, and I don't see that in CNN or in Twitter. If you post something in Twitter against the actual administration they ban you from using some services or even finding a job.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- bluntfang 7y ago>One wonders if there is an entire revolutionary class within China sharing South Park videos for freedom. I've noticed a trend on this site in particular where we collectively wonder if our western media is a part of Chinese counter-culture. Is this hubris uniquely American?
- olalonde 7y agoThat and the idea that Chinese citizens see themselves as oppressed. As crazy as it may seem to us, they're overwhelmingly supportive of their government.
- dTal 7y agoIf they weren't, how on Earth would you know? Being anything other than publicly "overwhelmingly supportive of the government" gets you killed. I believe many Chinese citizens are aware that their situation is not ideal ("oppressed" is probably not quite the right word), because I believe at least some subset of Chinese citizens are not brainwashed morons and any idiot can see what's going on. If they really had overwhelming support, they wouldn't need to censor so hard. Banning images of Winnie the Pooh demonstrates weakness.
- jaynetics 7y ago> any idiot can see what's going on Yes? Would you want to try circumventing the great firewall without getting caught? I fear the Chinese are mostly supportive. Most Germans also supported Hitler before things went awry, and his election results were superb even before massive manipulation began. There was still a substantial minority that didn't support him and resisted at great personal cost, much like some educated Chinese citizens are resisting at great personal cost now, knowing that many share their sentiments, but assuming that most people will find a way to look beyond the propaganda seems overly optimistic to me.
- dekhn 7y agoDon't large numbers of professional chinese who work on the internet use VPNs to get around the firewall? My insight into this comes mainly from professional Chinese scientists who were previously trained in the US but returned to China because there were better scientific opportunities. Many of them have told me (in person, while visitng the US) that they have to use VPNs to get their work done, and as long as they are relatively cautious, circumspect, and don't repeat what they see to others, they are tolerated.
- throwaway_law 7y ago>One wonders if there is an entire revolutionary class within China sharing South Park videos for freedom. There certainly is an entire generation who is ready for reforms if not an outright democratic revolution, but no I don't believe their end goal is freedom to pirate South Park video clips.
- ozzyman700 7y agoThe revolutionary class in china is the Party itself, working to liberate the world.
- eli_gottlieb 7y agoPlease tell us that tankie sloganeering was sarcastic.
- ozzyman700 7y agoNo I believe MLM is the path towards achieving common goals of superabundance and unleashing human ability.
- eli_gottlieb 7y agoCool, I'm gonna flag all your propagandistic bullshit comments.
- ozzyman700 7y agoYour choice! Workers of the world unite!
- eli_gottlieb 7y agoThe workers of the world should unite... for actual democratic socialism and not just doing whatever the fuck Xi Jinping says at the point of a gun.
- fiter 7y agoThe need for a revolutionary vanguard makes it clear who is really uniting: the revolutionary vanguard. Whether that unity helps workers is secondary. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vanguardism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vanguardism
- dang 7y agoPlease don't troll on HN.
- catacombs 7y ago> One wonders if there is an entire revolutionary class within China sharing South Park videos for freedom. Oh, there certainly is, especially among the richest of the rich. The whole point of censorship is for control.
- everdev 7y ago> “Like the NBA, we welcome the Chinese censors into our homes and into our hearts.” It's interesting that we used to think the more connected we were the more other countries would see and appreciate our democracy and start to adapt it. This is the first time I can remember communism and censorship flowing the other way. > “It’s not worth living in a world where China controls my country’s art,” says one character in the episode. About sums it up.
- vharuck 7y agoThe hope may be, in the long run, a free society will eventually reject the burdens of a non-free society once it notices the cost. But the non-free society will catch and spread the idea of individual human rights like a virus. A good virus, of course, in my opinion.
- blago 7y agoI think middle-class Americans tend to overestimate human appreciation for freedom. In my experience, most people in the world, including US, will trade freedom for prosperity in a heartbeat. Communist regimes collapsed not because they deprived people of their freedom but because their economies failed. Autocrats like Putin and Xi are popular at home because their economies are growing and people's lives are improving, even though individual freedoms are slowly but surely eroding. Trump was elected and is still in office because he gave hope for prosperity to people who had long lost it, and they will support him no matter how damaging he is for the rest of the country, the world, or their own freedom.
- onemoresoop 7y ago> Autocrats like Putin and Xi are popular at home because their economies are growing and people's lives are improving, even though individual freedoms are slowly but surely eroding. Neither Russia nor China have free elections. The Russian economy is shrinking fast and Putin's popularity is disingenuous. That may not be true for Xi. The Chinese are riding a humongous economic growth, they don't question their party much because they like the results and don't want to rock the boat.
- brodouevencode 7y agoAgreed - daylight is one helluva sanitizer.
- unqueued 7y agoBack in I think 2011, Pakistan threw up their hands and gave up censoring the Internet, because trolls has so inundated popular websites with banned memes. This was during a conference where the prime minister was trying to lure investors and show how modern Pakistan was, while all of YouTube and Twitter had just been blocked. Censorship is an up hill battle. It is way easier to defy them than it is for them to block us.
- ASalazarMX 7y agoI wish I knew Mandarin. Just watched the episode, and although it's not needed to appreciate it, the Mandarin probably is another layer of humor. I got that impression because I watched "Mexican Joker" after that, and when the immigrant kids arrive at the detention center, and the welcome is being translated for them, the mangled Spanish, while brief, was brilliant in its mangling. I appreciate that care to detail.