14 ms·
Iraq blocks Facebook, Twitter, WhatsApp, and Instagram, shuts down internet
- georgeburdell 7y agoStarlink can’t come soon enough. Imagine internet beyond the grasp of control freak governments
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> Imagine internet beyond the grasp of control freak governments Radio jammers. There are very few technological solutions to political problems.
- _bxg1 7y agoAren't some of them planning to use lasers? They'd have a hard time blocking that.
- aaomidi 7y agowat how are lasers working in this scenario
- icebraining 7y agoEach end (satellite and ground station) point a laser at each other, which they modulate according to the data they wish to send. The other end has a sensor (much like in a camera) that captures the light, and processes it to recover the data (demodulate). It's much like fiber optics, except over air instead of a cable.
- abhishekjha 7y agoHow much power would such a laser emitter require? That is a huge distance to cover. Wouldn't it get attenuated over the distance?
- Rebelgecko 7y agoLasers are subject to the same inverse squared law as regular radio waves. However with lasers you're starting with a smaller beam so the attentuation is actually less
- jagger27 7y agoLasers between them in orbit is what I've heard, nothing about ground stations, AFAIK.
- _bxg1 7y agoI could've sworn somebody was planning to use lasers to communicate from the satellite to a ground station, claiming it would improve latency. Maybe I misread.
- jsjohnst 7y agoLasers alone won’t improve latency, but they would certainly impact reliability. Radio waves already travel at essentially the speed of light.
- Rebelgecko 7y agoIt's been done in the past. I think the main benefits are preserving EM spectrum and some theoretical improvement in bits per watt
- m12k 7y agoYeah, probably not much point in making an internet connection that only works without cloud cover.
- yellowapple 7y agoI'd imagine a laser at typical radio wavelengths would be just as susceptible to cloud-cover-induced interference as a non-laser at typical radio wavelengths, no? Not that even lasers would be necessary to mitigate jamming; ordinary beam-forming / directional antennas should be enough (barring some really sophisticated jamming technology of which I'm not aware, or the Iraqi government putting up and maintaining permanent chaff clouds or something similarly outlandish). Jammers (to my knowledge) operate by actively producing an inverted copy of the signals it actually sees. That is: it'd be reliant on non-directional signals. Any directionality / beam-forming would make jamming a lot harder, since it makes it a lot harder for the jammers to actually see the signal in the first place (let alone produce an inverted-waveform copy of it). Jamming also tends to get in the way of other radio communications, so even if it was actually effective against satellite communications, it'd be a last resort and would likely cause all sorts of other issues.
- ceejayoz 7y agoThe lasers are for inter-satellite comms, where there’s no atmosphere to interfere.
- baybal2 7y agoDo you realise that most of satellite jamming is done on uplink, not downlink? This is how Cubans jammed US milcom and few civilian satellites since nineties
- LifeLiverTransp 7y agoYou can make a habbit-routed physical mesh-net, where people smuggle huge encrypted packages from the few "entry points" to the recivers on there phones. That way the urge for total surveilance (everyone has his/her phone on all the time) contradicts the "block all phones all the time". Its also very unrealistic to demand constant phone searchability for the government- and if the app is virus based, gives the users even plausible deniability. Imagine your daily habbits, as a sort of plankton zoo constitued by constellations of cellphones. Shape is specified by agreement on habbit and predictability. The bus driver always knows that the group will behave, shape and dissolve in a predictable fashion. He will be able to predict fixed on-route contacts (home-routers / other entitys). Thus one cellphone with the mesh-net routing virus, can predict and promise a best effort delivery of a package of data to other habbit plankton on route. You could smuggle a whole youtube video in one go out of country, simply by having it passed to other civilian phones, until it reaches a phone on the way to the airport. After its on the web, with some proof, it could decrypt its inner layers and travel by conventional means to the actual adress.
- markovbot 7y agoDeploying and maintaining radio jamming devices is _way_ more difficult and expensive than telling an ISP to shut down service.
- trust07007707 7y agoWay more difficult maybe than running a bash script but in real terms it's very doable.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoDepends on the frequencies and types of antennas used. Doesn't take much to disrupt a radio-based service (people do this by accident, that's why RF regulations exist everywhere). It's not that much of an expense for a government to set up a few antennas and make them put out half a megawatt of noise each.
- markovbot 7y agosure, but they have to have the hardware for that ready to go, and they have to get people deploy each site and prevent it from being vandalized or disabled
- viraptor 7y agoWideband noise generators are cheap and trivial to make. Giving them more power is a bit more tricky. If satellite internet becomes a norm, I'd be surprised if most armies didn't end up with one of them.
- JohnFen 7y ago> Doesn't take much to disrupt a radio-based service Particularly satellite signals, because they're very weak to begin with.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoIndeed. High-gain antennas and some math trickery can compensate a bit (see e.g. GPS and its below thermal noise floor signals), but I don't think a commercial transceiver could in any way win with a 50kW signal on a broadcast antenna turned jammer on a nearby hilltop.
- baybal2 7y agoLEO Ka band jamming is very hard https://www.mitre.org/sites/default/files/pdf/10_2505.pdf https://www.mitre.org/sites/default/files/pdf/10_2505.pdf
- Thlom 7y agoIsn't starlink and most other LEO constellations ku, though?
- baybal2 7y agoYes, C and Ku are dominant now, but not on LEO. LEO is dominated by 400-500Mhz for milcom, L and C. Resurgence of Ku in LEO is mostly due to regulatory regime already being cleared for satellite internet due to previous entrants, and cheaper hardware for consumer market.
- viraptor 7y agoI realised there's more to this article, but with notes like this: "Note this strategy assumes that the link from the ground to the UAV is somehow protected from an electronic attack by the jammer either through waveform design or by narrow beam antennas." you know they're not focusing on consumer level hardware.
- ISL 7y agoAnd prosecuting people with the relevant transceivers.
- lacker 7y agoThen Iraq would have to make it illegal to own this sort of internet connection. A country like North Korea could do that, but not a country like Iraq or Cameroon that has some degree of normal freedom but intermittently shuts off the internet.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoA country willing and easily able to shut down the Internet is also perfectly able to temporarily limit or ban civilian use of a frequency range.
- hanniabu 7y agoYeah, but what about the radio jammer jammers?
- ineedasername 7y agoThere are ways of dealing with jamming [0] though I doubt they are in most (or any) easy consumer available units. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_counter-countermeasure https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_counter-countermeas...
- kungito 7y agoAn interesting social effect could be that currently by default there is no internet. Then you get a device that provides internet and the government takes it a way. If there was starlink lets say there is internet by default. Then the goverment gets a device to jam that internet and the protestors can take it away. It kind of switches the local on ground dynamic I would say and makes it way more interesting for the protestors. They can occupy jammers like they do airports and get internet back
- gouggoug 7y agoIt will still be owned by a private company you have no control over, which isn't necessarily better
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoEspecially since Iraq is leaning on private companies (ISPs) to get them to shut down the internet. The one advantage that Starlink might have is, it might be a company beyond the reach of the Iraqi government, and therefore less likely to give in to their pressure to close off access. But what we really need is several such companies, not just one.
- caleb-allen 7y agoAren't there multiple Starlink competitors in development now?
- hawaiianbrah 7y agoYes, they’re just the furthest along and perhaps most likely to succeed since they own the launching mechanism the others would likely use.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoGiven how satellites don't respect national borders by default, I wonder whether there will be - or maybe already are - international agreements that would make it easier for a nation's government to coerce a foreign operator to deny service over that nation.
- kingo55 7y agoAt least it's a another competing choice.
- DINKDINK 7y ago>It will still be owned by a private company you have no control over I don't have any ethical justification to enslave or coerce or control a person. Why should I have any ethical justification to enslave or coerce or control, if a group of people get together (a company) to do something?
- xeromal 7y agoThe freedom to access information is one of the greatest and most sacred gifts the internet gave us. The longer we can protect that, the further the human race will progress. Bring on starlink!
- JohnFen 7y agoThings like Starlink won't remove a government's ability to cut off internet access. The radio signals aren't hard to jam.
- beamatronic 7y agoWe need one that uses lasers
- joombaga 7y agoWhy? Are lasers hard to "jam" (I'm using quotes because it seems weird to use "jam" with optical media, but maybe that's just me)?
- tonyarkles 7y agoNot to be too cynical, but it’d be pretty straightforward to at least tell where the ground-based terminals are if they’re shooting lasers into the sky. Not sure if laser-based systems use IR or UV or what (presumably whatever has the least amount of atmospheric attenuation), but airborne cameras could likely pick it up pretty quick. And for the most brutal dictators: laser-guided bombs are already a thing...
- DuskStar 7y agoWhy would an airborne camera be able to pick ground-based lasers up easily? Wouldn't you need to fly directly between the satellite and the ground terminal? Same goes for laser-guided bombs - those home in on where the laser pointer is pointing, not the pointer itself.
- sandov 7y agoAlso, imagine it being much harder to verify that your systems are air-gapped.
- vkou 7y agoImagine how difficult it must be to drive through a neighborhood, and mark off anyone with a satellite dish on their roof as a political criminal. Hint: Not very. Also, how exactly do you plan to pay your bills to your ISP, when their service is illegal in your country?
- owl57 7y agoI bet half of houses in my neighborhood has a TV dish. If it will be possible to make Starlink dishes visually indistinguishable from those, the police will have a slightly harder time. Slightly, because detecting radio transmission doesn't seem hard either.
- yellowapple 7y agoTransmissions from ground to orbit tend to be highly directional (it's why satellite TV/internet typically uses dishes instead of ordinary antennae). Detection from the ground would be pretty difficult, given that most (ideally all, but there's probably at least some leakage) of the signal will never reach anything else on the ground (for the same reason you typically can't see the beam of light from a flashlight or laser pointer unless it reflects off dust or fog or some other particulate in the air). The most reliable way to detect ground-to-space transmitters would be with aircraft, since those will have a much easier time crossing paths with the signal (and thus actually being able to see it).
- devmunchies 7y agothe internet, with most content and platforms by freak capitalists
- heavyset_go 7y agoYou'd think a headline like the one we're posting under would stop techno-optimism dead in its tracks.
- journalctl 7y agoWhen all you have is a startup, everything begins to look like a nail.
- seph-reed 7y agoWe got the news within 12 hours. Right now massive amounts of data is being collected, and eventually it will get out. This seems like it'd all be a lot easier to control without technology.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- alistproducer2 7y agoNot to be too cute but by relying on corporations you're trading one dictatorship for another. Im not saying an oppressive government is the same as Comcast. Im just making the point that neither entity is accountabile to the people they 'serve.'
- kevas 7y agoOthers have stated their objections to your comment, but... my belief is that once StarLink becomes operational, the American Gov. will have oversight & control of it, just like our current ISPs.
- JohnFen 7y agoI believe that the only way the US could legally do that is by exerting control over up/downlink stations that are in US jurisdiction. I'm assuming that things like Starlink will have up and downlink stations in places outside of the US as well as inside. Extralegally, though? All bets are off.
- toomuchtodo 7y agoSpaceX is a US corporation, therefore US jurisdiction.
- input_sh 7y agoYou're making an assumption that Starlink will fight a nudge by the US government instead of quietly complying.
- JohnFen 7y agoI'm not, really. That's why I added my "all bets are off" comment.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoI can't see every other nation being too happy about US-controlled global Internet service. They will demand some degree of control over their territories. I can see the space law getting some updates sometime soon.
- buboard 7y agosatellite internet already exists
- journalctl 7y agoAnd instead controlled by one corporation headquartered in a nation that also partially controls Iraq.
- eyegor 7y agoTo anyone else interested, here's a link to a draft paper about starlink: https://mobile.twitter.com/MarkJHandley/status/1044621609120747520 https://mobile.twitter.com/MarkJHandley/status/1044621609120.... Apologies for not posting the direct link, for some reason my copy url gets hijacked on twitter mobile.
- l1n 7y agoFTFY: http://nrg.cs.ucl.ac.uk/mjh/starlink-draft.pdf http://nrg.cs.ucl.ac.uk/mjh/starlink-draft.pdf
- Romanulus 7y agoYet people pine for Net Neutrality.
- api 7y agoA Starlink dish is a transmitter, which is a beacon that says "come arrest me!" or "drop bomb here." Seriously though: as bad as Trump is, I still think Bush II was by far the worst president of the past 100 years. Trump would have to do something much worse than he's already done to match Bush's accomplishments.
- jacobush 7y agoIraq, Syria, yes. Agreed. Though it feels like Trump is one false move from something just as bad or worse.
- 4gotunameagain 7y agoSuggesting that revolted populace protesting about basic life amenities will have the ability to purchase and operate a starlink antenna is uneducated at best
- tomcooks 7y agoYou're forgetting that governments, especially of the control freak type, tend to be the only entities that are entitled to the use of violence and coercion. Good luck using Starlink or any other forbidden technology when your skull is being pushed to the ground by their boot
- rahuldottech 7y agoThis explains why I've been seeing #save_the_iraqi_people and related hashtags all over Instagram. For those not in the know: > demonstrators in Baghdad and elsewhere protest against lack of jobs and poor services. https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2019/10/baghdad-police-open-fire-anti-government-protesters-191001143248615.html https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2019/10/baghdad-police-open-f...
- vkou 7y agoContrast the public and political reaction to these events with the public and political reaction to the protests in Hong Kong.
- kingo55 7y agoWhat are you implying?
- The_rationalist 7y agoThat people have monstruous selective empathy I guess.
- emptyfile 7y agoThat not one of you is sincere. When a protestor in hong kong gets shot "the whole world" is on its feet, when SA and USA starve to death 80 000 children in Yemen no one bats an eye.
- CathedralBorrow 7y agoI'm not going to deny the hypocrisy, but I think it's a very human thing really. Do you respond equally to every unjust death in the world?
- emptyfile 7y agoNot sure what you're asking me. No, I'm not brainwashed enough to think that shooting a violent protestor is the same as intentionally starving to death a whole goddamned country. We don't even have to talk about how american police act... that's a whole other dimension of hypocrisy, unfathomable to me personally.
- webwielder2 7y agoAhh, the smell of freedom!
- aaaaa 7y agodon't think that it is freedom
- normalperson 7y agoglad we spent trillions of dollars bombing them!
- Ahmed90 7y agoIraqi here (But I live in Turkey), protests were raging yesterday and today, first social media was taken down now the whole internet from mid (Baghdad) to the rest of the south of the country Here is a local service monitor for all major ISPs in Iraq: http://akonet.info http://akonet.info This is the usual procedure by the "freedom" government they do this every time, the only issue is this time the protestors are not carrying any flags or any political or religious figures names etc... only the Iraqi flag and burning Iranian flags, so far it's people(sometimes people and the army) vs government... few people got killed already, there is news the Baghdad airport has fallen into the hands of the protestors, and most of the main roads are blocked and crowded with people //UPDATE: All cities are offline except Kurdistan up north
- dastx 7y agoThank you for this. I am Kurdish, living in the UK. I usually follow both Iraqi and Kurdish news but somehow I was completely oblivious to the current uprising. I wish the Iraqi people the best I hope you can either get the government to get their ass into gear or otherwise replace them. I have spoken to plenty of family members in Kurdistan and they're all wishing you all the best. It's a sad state of affairs but I hope it works out for the better.
- AnimalMuppet 7y ago> This is the usual procedure by the freedom government The "freedom" government blocks the internet to censor people? I find that somewhat ironic... (I presume that's the name of the party in power or something. It sure doesn't seem like it's a description of their behavior.)
- Ahmed90 7y agoI put quotation marks around the "freedom" looks better now? xD
- AnimalMuppet 7y agoYes, though I wasn't questioning the way you put it. Why "freedom"? Is it the name of a political party?
- hnspirit 7y agoThis is standard playbook for any govt. who feels threatened. They're just corporations in disguise these days.
- johnpowell 7y agoI have the pi-hole in the house set to block the same stuff.
- mrburton 7y agoPart of me says "Now this is a mentally healthy thing to do!" with regards to Twitter, Facebook and Instagram. I found social media has been becoming emotionally toxic and highly argumentative. it's so refreshing to not go on twitter in 6 months, only look at facebook to check up on remote friends and once in a while check Instagram to see what friends cross the country are actually doing; minus the false "Look at this new fancy thing!" :) Do you avoid social media these days? I enjoy HNs because its informative around technology; not politics etc. So relaxing.
- throwaway66920 7y agoWhy are they burning Iranian flags?
- Ahmed90 7y agoBecause the government is backed by Iran (puppet) and it's fully corrupt?
- yongjik 7y agoWait, didn't America wage a war to install a pro-American government in Iraq? Are they somehow pro-American and pro-Iran at the same time, or did they switch alliances while nobody in the west was paying attention?
- Ahmed90 7y agoHalf these Pro-Americans used to hide in Iran before the war, America got outplayed when it comes to the Iraqi government lol
- GhettoMaestro 7y agoAs an American, I am curious to hear more about how we were "outplayed" re the Iraqi Gov. Thanks in advance.
- Ahmed90 7y agoThey got in, shot down Saddam, got a bunch of anti-Saddam parties and gave them power... most of them were hiding in Iran or worked with Iran during the Iraq/Iran war they didn't understand the powerplay by Iran, they kept struggling with troops in or out whos who etc... withdrawn and left the incompetent government alone, gave Iran, even more, breathing space to take over
- parsimo2010 7y ago1. USA ousts Saddam Hussein, and is obligated to help Iraq transition to a democratic government (because they invasion was done under the pretext of liberating a country from a mad dictator with weapons of mass destruction, instead of the commonly cited argument of securing resources for the American empire). 2. USA backs a candidate and initially gets a government elected that is favorable to the USA. However, these politicians turn out to be kind of scummy and screw up just about everything. 3. Iran realizes that elections can be influenced (they watched the USA influence the first election), and having lots of paramilitary type forces that are trained in information operations, decides to capitalize. They flood across the porous border to spread propaganda (the current scumbags in government make it so the Iranian propaganda doesn't even have to lie, it just has to point out how much the current guys suck). 4. Iraqi citizens, growing sick of the crappy politicians they elected initially, start listening to the propaganda and elect a government friendly to Iran. This is the first time this has happened in a long time, Iraq has not been allies with Iran for several decades. 5. End result- USA invades, eventually loses influence to Iran. The global hegemony USA got outplayed by a regional hegemony because they backed unethical and incompetent sellouts rather than finding a good candidate.
- aminecodes 7y agoThe Iraqi people have been suffering silently for the past years; they are trapped between ISIS, Iranian influence, destruction of the war, and the US-backed corrupt government. People are fed up.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- shopinastore 7y agosocial media can be source of many problems for a country coming back from war, iraq need to be stable to protect people life first then we can talk about network. http://bit.ly/shopinastore http://bit.ly/shopinastore
- savethefuture 7y agoIronically it might be best to stop using those sites anyway :)
- buboard 7y agoThey took the constant complaining in HN too seriously
- yosefzeev 7y agoSo here is a prime example of a government using the power to censor the internet during a revolution...
- djsumdog 7y agoWell mission accomplished .. I guess. A great documentary if you haven't seen it is "Iraq: No End in Sight." It's pretty clear that the completely failed (non-existent) reconstruction efforts of the Bush administration would lead eventually to a failed state. The same thing is happening in Libya after the Obama era bombings. These places weren't democratic paradises before or anything; I'm not saying that. They had corruption and human rights issues -- but they were stable. People who didn't protest against the government and weren't in poverty could usually live in relative peace. You can say the same thing about China to some extent as well.
- quaquaqua1 7y agoAll warfare actions conducted by the United States are excuses for agencies to spend money, and the money goes to corporations that are contolled by politically connected individuals. The dividends from the government consumption of these items enrich the people who are giving the orders to launch the missiles. It is beyond disheartening that innocent people die because of this. I would rather just pay the money, if I must, and let the warheads rust in peace.
- jacobush 7y agoBut the US civilian administrator firing all of the Iraqi military was just stupid. Or sadistic.
- elboru 7y agoI usually hear this kind of statement, is it really that simple? Aren’t there other geopolitical interests from the strongest economy in the world?
- quaquaqua1 7y agoI'm sure we could make the argument that "if the US doesn't invade x country then China/Russia will". But for me, I just focus on the outcomes, not the motives. If Lockheed Martin and Booz Allen Hamilton and Raydeon shareholders are making 100k or 1m or more, and hundreds of thousands of civilians are dying, those are two cold hard facts that can't be ignored. Either the ends justify the means or they don't, in the eyes of the beholder.
- harshreality 7y agoFrom a pragmatic perspective, what is the West and the US in particular supposed to do about this? We shouldn't have gone into Iraq in 2003 in the first place, but we did, so what now? Our government is going to keep its boot on the neck of Iraq and stay involved over there as long as Iraq still has oil, right? If the problem now is more that we have too little influence, so what? Are we supposed to try regime change again because it worked so well last time? The current Iraqi regime may not be good, but neither was Saddam. We still should have left Saddam alone, excepting targeted strikes if we ever got good intelligence about WMD programs.
- nitwit005 7y agoIf they had the ability to make a functional government, they'd have done it already. People seem to be largely kicking the can down the road until someone else is in office.
- lacker 7y agoOur government is going to keep its boot on the neck of Iraq and stay involved over there as long as Iraq still has oil, right? It doesn't seem like it, no. If the US was still controlling Iraq, we wouldn't be permitting their current government, which is more or less controlled by Iran.
- zepearl 7y agoIf somebody leaves a void (US?) then the next strongest force (Iran?) will try to fill it. In the case of Iraq (maybe similar for Syria?) I guess that there aren't probably big motivations/interests nor strong cultural similarities for the West to create something similar to a "Marshall Plan" ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marshall_Plan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marshall_Plan ) to kickstart again the nation and then make it work long-term from both an economic and indirectly social perspective. Therefore, I think that Iraq will just drift more and more towards what will look like the next-best offer(s) (Iran?).
- luckylion 7y ago> We shouldn't have gone into Iraq in 2003 in the first place, but we did, so what now? "Water under the bridge ... what can we fuck up next?" That aside (and no, US/NATO won't learn from that): split Iraq up in three entities (Kurdistan, Sunni and Shia parts), help with the separation, guarantee the agreed upon borders, and then invest lots of money. > The current Iraqi regime may not be good, but neither was Saddam. Compared to post-Saddam Iraq, Saddam was good. Good is relative. Want to lose a finger? Of course not. Want to lose a finger instead of losing both legs? Yeah, losing a finger is okay.
- api 7y agoI see that $1T Iraq war spread freedom and democracy across the Middle East. Great bargain.
- monksy 7y agoWhat I took from this: Earthlink still exists?!
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoAnd Europe has to pick up the pieces in terms of refugees while the US & Five Eyes sit back, popcorn in hand, and watch the mess they've made from a safe distance.
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> And Europe has to pick up the pieces in terms of refugees For us (Europe) this is essentially dress rehearsal for upcoming climate-related migrations, and it turns out we're not handling it well.
- dwoozle 7y agoWhat would handling it “well” mean?
- Faark 7y agoNot having populist demagogs reach significant power would be a nice start. Though I'm not sure if the migrant "crisis" is actually the cause or just a symptom for deeper issues.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoNot dividing population into two sides on the refugee issue, not breeding so high level of internal resentment. Having a bit more united front on the issue. I'm half-convinced that the way the current refugee crisis ended up being handled was much more disruptive to our internal politics than just letting them all in would be to our economies.
- rorykoehler 7y agoHandled it pretty well imo
- TeMPOraL 7y agoWell in the sense that it didn't end up being a comparably large humanitarian crisis on our borders, and that we didn't break the Union into pieces (though the tensions created may well lead to that). Not well in the sense that when the same thing happens again with climate refugees, only 10-100x the size, I don't see us surviving.
- DougPhillips88 7y agoSounds like a utopia. I wish to god the USA would do that.
- reubens 7y agoFrom what I’ve gathered, disenfranchised citizens in Baghdad are protesting, and the government has responded by shutting down the internet. I understand it’s reactionary but what is their logic here?
- whatevertrevor 7y agoYou mean the logic in shutting down the internet? Countries do that these days (see Kashmir) to keep the protests under control by blocking communication and collaboration among the protesters. It increases the barrier to discovery and participation in a protest basically.
- reubens 7y agoThanks. It seemed to me counterintuitive to respond to protests about inadequate services by cutting off another service (fanning the flames)
- ineedasername 7y agoYes, there's another comment here somewhere that points to a study where showing violence tends to increase post-shutdown compared to leaving communications open. I suppose leaving things open lets people organize more, but they tend to be more peaceful in those gatherings. Just supposition though.
- iamsb 7y agoThe shutdown in Kashmir is mostly to stop communications coming in from outside of India, mostly terrorist outfits in countries like Pakistan. There is lot of evidence in last 30 years or so how Kashmir becomes violent and how violent "protests" are organised with funding from state and non state actors from other countries.
- sbmthakur 7y agoSince you have mentioned Kashmir, I must point that protests in Kashmir have been historically violent and have even led to deaths of tourists. https://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/chennai/body-of-thirumani-to-reach-chennai-on-may-8/article23812095.ece https://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/chennai/body-of-thiruma...
- luismmolina 7y agoWhat about using apps like Bridgefy or Firechat?
- pvaldes 7y agoIP over Avian Carriers does not look so bad idea now
- markus_zhang 7y agoIs it a pro or anti-Iran protest? I think it's an anti one but not very sure...
- avocado4 7y agoThey are burning Iranian flags.
- Merrill 7y agoThere will continue to be unrest in Iraq until an all-Shiite government is in control. At the time of Gulf War II under W, the population was about 20% Sunni, 20% Kurdish, and 60% Shiite. So if you disarm the minority ruling Sunni establishment and instead pledge to install a democracy, a Shiite government is the logical conclusion. Since realizing their mistake, the US has attempted to patch together some multi-religious, multi-ethnic government, but these are all destined to failure. The Kurds want to be left to their own devices, the majority Shiites want to rule the south of the country with most of the oil, and they want the Sunnis left out of power in the deserts to the West. George HW, being smarter than George W, pulled his punches, left Saddam in power, and left him with helicopters to kill enough Shiites to prevent a successful rebellion of the "marsh Arabs", as they were called in news reports back then.
- ineedasername 7y agoYou assume 40% of the population won't create a lot of unrest when the 60% come into power and cut them out of having a say in how their lives are run. Which, I guess might happen, but it seems unlikely, especially given the acrimonious history that just keeps getting deeper and deeper.
- alzaeem 7y agoThis "analysis" is so wrong.. power is already dominated entirely by Shiaa governments, except for Kurdistan region, but that has little to no effect outside Kurdistan. The problem is that much of the current government officials are corrupt and have their loyalties to Iran. They are busy enriching themselves. Let alone the fact that they armed a powerful militia group that's completely beholden to Iran.. Much thanks to the US for destabilizing the country and handing it over to their so called "enemy" Iran. There should be no doubts that the government in Basrah is all Shiite, yet people IN Basrah have been protesting very strongly in the past year. Because simply this government doesn't serve the iraqi people.
- ur-whale 7y ago>There will continue to be unrest in Iraq until an all-Shiite government is in control. There will continue to be unrest in Iraq and the rest of the middle-east (and I'm including Israel in this, they are as bad as the others on this point) until A) tribalism and B) religion is taken out of politics once and for all. A democracy is simply not possible unless it's built on an ethical bedrock that has entirely done away with both of these primitive and childish moral systems.
- trust07007707 7y agoLORA based mesh could help here https://nootropicdesign.com/projectlab/2018/10/20/lora-mesh-networking/ https://nootropicdesign.com/projectlab/2018/10/20/lora-mesh-...
- ineedasername 7y agoIs it any more difficult to jam than other network technologies?
- trust07007707 7y agoNo, and they have a large attack surface thru various techniques, so not a good choice for anything but keeping touch with friends and relatives (assuming no mass usage occurs)
- aaron695 7y agoThis has worked no where in the world that I know of. Sneakernet in Cuba might be close to the concept in practice. It's been tried multiple times in stable environments with plenty of time to get it to work using experts. Meshes might and should have a use, but I'd like to see it outside of libertarian dreams.
- viraptor 7y agoLora is not for general usage / internet. Basic messaging - maybe. But it achieves a few kbps in good conditions.
- trust07007707 7y agoRecall we had a whole interactive/social world in the 80s with BBSs with 300 baud acoustically coupled modems.
- yorwba 7y agoI recall reading somewhere that internet shutdowns during protests are usually counterproductive. People who were previously only voicing their frustration online or passing the time with entertainment are suddenly left with a lot of free time on their hands. While a shutdown can prevent coordination on the national scale, it can't stop people from taking to the streets and organizing spontaneously. EDIT: Found my source: https://www.iafrikan.com/2019/05/06/shutting-down-social-media-does-not-reduce-violence-but-rather-fuels-it/ https://www.iafrikan.com/2019/05/06/shutting-down-social-med... "Under a blackout, each successive day of protest had more violence than would typically happen as a protest unfolded with continued internet access. Meanwhile, the effects of shutdowns on peaceful demonstrations, which are usually more likely to rely on careful coordination through digital channels, were ambiguous and inconsistent. In no scenario were blackouts consistently linked to reduced levels of protest over the course of several days. Instead of curtailing protest, they seemed to encourage a tactical shift to strategies that are less orderly, more chaotic and more violent."
- HNLurker2 7y agoExcept when Russia does it: https://www.forbes.com/sites/zakdoffman/2019/08/08/russian-security-agencies-secretly-shut-moscows-mobile-internet-to-control-protestors-report/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/zakdoffman/2019/08/08/russian-s...
- utrack 7y agoThey didn't really shut it down for the whole city though - they only took down cell stations for a couple of blocks around the protest; wired connection and cellular for those in the rest of the city was just fine.
- ineedasername 7y agoIf you were in Iraq, would there have been any reasonable countermeasures, accessible to the average person, that could have preserved access? Or is it limited to something like a sat phone/sat internet?
- toast0 7y agoIt's not apparent from the article if phone calls are blocked. It's probably not cheap, and it's certainly easy to track, but you can run data over international voice calls. Probably works better on a real landline, but should work a bit over mobile too.
- jacobush 7y agoYou'd have to know a modem pool to call and have an account there, I wouldn't even know where to start. Especially if I was already cut off from the Internet.
- toast0 7y agoThe question was asking about prep work that could have been done. Now is the time to print out some modem pools and get an account ;) However, if you know someone technical out of the country, you can call them and ask them to set something up and get you the details. (Or you can't call them, and there you go). If you're talking with people on things like Signal or WhatsApp, where phone numbers are user ids, you automatically know their phone number to call them in case the chat service is unreachable.
- aezakmi 7y agoGreat, more zog bots operating. Brace yourself yanks, you're going to die for 3rd party interests again.
- howtofly 7y agoConsidering this country is literally liberated by the US, it is totally hilarious!
- trust07007707 7y agohey guys, I want to take this opportunity to ask if anyone here was born in the early 70s in Baghdad and went to Baghdad College high school (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baghdad_College https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Baghdad_College) in the early to late 80s. We left in 87 to London, UK then Boston, US after that, just before the end of the war with Iran, and I'd like to reconnect with any classmates/old friends who may also be into tech... I'm sure everyone is all over the world by now, in different places. Thank you, and take care wherever you are.
- TenJack 7y agoI really hope the SpaceX satellite internet works.
- gregknicholson 7y agoIf anyone in or near Iraq can read this, you can spread messages using person-to-person tools that don't need the internet at all. For example, using the Scuttlebutt network (SSB), you can deliver messages from your contacts, using Bluetooth or just by being on the same wifi. They can be public messages, or encrypted private messages so only certain recipients can decode them. Manyverse (https://manyver.se https://manyver.se) is a decent Android app for SSB. There are other tools like Briar, which I don't know much about, but other people here may be able to help...
- wiz21c 7y agoI guess the freedom box was for such issues : https://www.freedomboxfoundation.org https://www.freedomboxfoundation.org but I guess it needs internet at least...
- betimsl 7y agoLet's try to deconstruct an oxymoron here: So all these protests are happening because Iraq is blocking a multi million dollar company? Right? I know it is bad, but there are alternatives and we as people living on this planet should not narrow ourselves down to only one channel of communication that is operating on one channel that is internet.* And let's face it: because it is so easy to use facebook, people are getting lazy and numb, more and more dumb and numb people scrolling through other peoples shit, they don't try to figure out a more complex system where at the end frees the individual from a controlling state. Just wake up already. * Not to mention the fact that facebook reads your messages and all your shit so it can feed you some more shit.
- zahrc 7y agoStop reading just the headlines. They are protesting against poor government performance, corruption, and all of this stuff. Iraqi government shuts down the internet as they want, in this case, possibly, to stop the protesters from organising.
- divbyzer0 7y agoCui bono? Whom would benefit from a social media organised protest/riot against the government? This comes as the Iraqi president Mahdi anounces a potential arms deal with Russia as part of a diverification of strategic allies. Until now, arms deals were exclusively with US. Mahdi has campaigned on a theme that US invlovement in Iraq has not been entirely positive.
- wazoox 7y agoThe US (and allies) pushed Saddam into war against Iran. Then there was the Gulf War, then sanctions that reportedly killed hundred of thousands of people (remember Madeleine Albright testifying that it was "worth it"?). Then the unforgivable, unjustifiable war of 2003. Then civil war and unrest, then ISIS. Iraq has been constantly at war and suffering for 39 years and counting because of the US. Isn't imperialism wonderful. It makes me sick and I don't even know a single Iraqi :/
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- stefek99 7y agoJust from the past couple of months: • Kashmir: https://netblocks.org/reports/pakistan-shuts-down-internet-in-kashmir-restricts-access-in-punjab-and-beyond-3Anw7dB2 https://netblocks.org/reports/pakistan-shuts-down-internet-i... • Russia: https://netblocks.org/reports/evidence-of-internet-disruptions-in-russia-during-moscow-opposition-protests-XADErzBg https://netblocks.org/reports/evidence-of-internet-disruptio... • Bangladesh: https://www.economist.com/news/2019/09/04/bangladesh-bans-mobile-phones-for-1m-rohingya-refugees https://www.economist.com/news/2019/09/04/bangladesh-bans-mo... • Sudan: https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2019/06/13/end-mass-protests-sudan-has-cut-off-internet-access-nationwide-heres-why/?noredirect=on https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2019/06/13/end-mass-... • London: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/london-tube-wifi-down-internet-not-working-underground-protest-extinction-rebellion-a8873681.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/london-tube-... "Shutting down digital infrastructure in response to a peaceful protest is deeply authoritarian," said Griff Ferris, legal and policy officer at Big Brother Watch." I've heard they did not shut down internet in Hong Kong as lots of mainland China is routed via Hong Kong...