10 ms·
The IT revolution and southern Europe's two lost decades
- icebraining 7y agoTo me, the most relevant quote is: > Subsidising IT adoption actually lowers southern productivity even further. Likewise, subsidising education has negative effects, as it is effectively becomes a transfer to the north through high-skilled migration. These surprising results are due to the fact that, in our model, low IT adoption and low education are a symptom, rather than the cause, of low productivity growth in southern Europe. Indeed, given management efficiency, southern workers and firms behave optimally. There is no further room for improvement. As a citizen of a Southern EU country, this feels painfully true. Having worked a year in the Benelux, returning here just heightened that sense: the culture of hiding information, trading influence and promoting mediocrity. And I fear those EU funds for creating startups will just be consumed by the forces, being used by founders who have only known this reality. Working abroad beforehand should be, if not mandatory, at least strongly encouraged.
- grenoire 7y agoI think the north and the south both have a lot to learn from each other, unfortunately the economic discrepancies make it less and less likely for this exchange to happen. It's a sad state of affairs, but just as the southerners can learn a lot from the northerners, vice versa should definitely be encouraged as well.
- ptr 7y agoIt's such a shame; having a work/management culture like in the northern Europe would make the south unstoppable -- it might even cause a north-to-south brain drain. I know I'd move, and the EU makes that easy.
- galfarragem 7y agoBeing over-simplistic: Southern Europe lacks good management. Southern Europeans workers are wanted everywhere - they are productive when working in a different environment - so the problem must be extrinsic. It's very common that they are more educated than their bosses in their home country.
- ajsnigrutin 7y ago> they are productive when working in a different environment As someone from the balkans... it's not the enviroment that makes people productive (it can make them unproductive though), but the productive people choose to change their enviroment to one, where they can be more productive. And this is true for both plumbers and engineers. Just take a successfull good worker (and a bad one if you want), and put them into a shitty low-paying government job, where it takes three weeks to order a replacement computers mouse... shitty workers stay there ("i'm waiting for a mouse, can't work now, but i'm still getting paid") and good ones try to find a better oportunity elsewhere (and for shitty locations, that means far away, in a different country).
- xondono 7y agoI've been on this situation (except it was not a government job), I use my own mouse, keyboard, and I've had to upgrade myself the hdd and RAM on the laptop provided to get any job done. BYOD is heavily frowned in Spain, but employers insist on giving me home-grade cheap laptops for CAD work. It's madness.
- ajsnigrutin 7y agoGovernment jobs are really really bad at this. Small companies are a lot better at this (atleast here).. the last time i worked at an international one, they sent me an email two weeks before i started there, saying basically "we don't choose the devices, but we have a 5k(eur) budget for a work computer, and you pick everything yourself - we suggest two monitors and a 'real' (non laptop) keyboard and mouse + a docking station", I emailed them the list, and everything was waiting on my desk. There was also a policy of buying small stuff we needed ourselves and getting paid back (keyboard stopped working?, don't ask, just buy/order it, and sent the receipt to accounting to get reimbursed). And after two years, we were allowed to buy the written off equipment for 5-10eur/piece. It has a lot of potential for abuse, but in that setting it worked great.
- xondono 7y ago
- pjc50 7y agoHow on earth can this be changed, though? Culture is extremely resistant to being changed by fiat, and the governance and leadership of Italy isn't up to achieving a national transformation either.
- Inthenameofmine 7y agoMy opinion isn't really scientific, but I think this has primarily to do with the demographic pyramid in Italy and most of Southern Europe, not much with economic development. Kosovo is a clear example that economic development isn't important for IT development and adoption, it's how much youth you have.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ciguy 7y agoI'm American but also an Italian citizen and have lived there for many years. I have zero hope that Italy will reform in the next few decades unless something incredibly radical like a war breaks out. Cultural apathy and corruption runs far too deep, and anyone who could reform simply leaves for Germany or the UK. Italy is a good place to live if you already have money. If you are a young enterprising person it's hell.
- tim333 7y agoI rented a Fiat last week and the quality is way up from the old days. I gather the headquarters have moved to Holland. Maybe a bit of foreign control is the way forward. I think Lamborghinis are also now reliable since VW took over.
- bitL 7y agoIt's quite shocking to see that Italy and Spain will be overtaken in GDP PPP per capita by second-world countries like Czechia, Slovenia and Slovakia in the next ~5 years (all of them went through an economic collapse that set them 15 years back, followed by massive brain drain).
- nikanj 7y agoEU subsidies and funds can turn into a form of the resource curse ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resource_curse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resource_curse ). When the biggest money is earned from writing grant applications, the best and the brightest are going to focus on that.
- kakoni 7y agoWhy bother with writing, nowadays there are many grant-applications-as-a-service companies. "We provide a range of services, from defining your funding strategy to writing your funding proposal. " [1] [1] https://www.zazventures.com/ https://www.zazventures.com/
- xondono 7y agoAs a someone working in hardware development (PCBs & firmware) in Spain, from the 5 companies I worked: - Only one used version control, the rest I had to introduce them (and fight management fears) to set it up. - Only two had onsite backup using RAID or similar - None had out-of-site backup - Only one had a system that supported shared libraries (for hardware), the rest resorted to email or a shared drive and a LOT of back & forth to ensure no one overwrote past edits. - I started working in 2010, yet I've managed to found "goto" statements (the "jump out of this function to some weird place in code" type) in the wild. But by far, the most damaging practice that I see around is how pointless much of the work done is. Given the amount of investment required for developing your own hardware, knowing that less than 40% of the products I have worked on are on the market because they were pointless in the first place (and everyone knew it) is the most demoralizing. EDIT: I always forget to double the break lines
- raverbashing 7y ago> yet I've managed to found "goto" statements (the "jump out of this function to some weird place in code" type) in the wild. I might just add that this is not wrong and actually expected in some places. Linux uses it. It helps with some error handling situations. But yeah with the other points I agree.
- golergka 7y agoWhile I've seen a few places where goto made sense (as in, "goto fail" in C), a goto that lead somewhere out of a function has never been one of them.
- xondono 7y agoThat’s what I’ve added the parens, I know there’s some very limited edge cases were it makes sense to tradeoff clarity for speed and use a goto. To clarify, I’m talking about stuff that could be easily done with functions or loops being done by random goto statements.
- uxp100 7y agoto further nitpick and distract from the main conversation, it sounds like they are talking about non-local goto (setjmp etc in c), which, just like an actual goto statement, is useful for error handling, but is much more difficult to deal with that a normal goto.
- TheOtherHobbes 7y agoHaving some experience of living in one of those Southern countries, IMO consumer/infrastructure/gov IT is at least as good as the UK's. Broadband is patchy, but where it exists it's often faster than the products available in the UK, and service call-out times are better. (I've had next-day engineer visits after reporting an outage, which would be unheard of in the UK.) Major and minor services all have apps and web sites, and online shopping is very much a thing. There's also a single unified government-administered ID system that works with the major government portals, banks, and some other services. Small biz sites are some way behind, but design agencies are growing at a healthy pace in the major cities. There isn't much of a startup culture in the Bay Area sense, but that probably has more to do with lack of a strong investment culture than lack of talent or ability. So I'm certainly not seeing evidence of "low IT adoption" or generally poor performance. I'm not even seeing unusual evidence of corruption, nepotism, or incompetence. They certainly exist, but not at the scale the UK is currently experiencing.
- icebraining 7y agoWhere is online shopping very much a thing? Eurostat reports the following percentages for the question "Have you purchased something online in 2018": Greece: 36%, Italy: 36%, Spain: 53%, Portugal: 37%. For comparison, the UK is at 83% and the EU average is 60%. In any case, my experience with consumer or government IT isn't bad either. And I don't disagree there's talent and ability - unfortunately, half of it leaves, and the other half is squandered. My beef is with poor management, not lack of talented people. And unfortunately here I can't say there is lack of corruption and nepotism either, but I acknowledge different Southern countries are different.
- playing_colours 7y agoI met many engineers here, in Germany, from Italy. There are a lot of them, young and educated. I heard their stories why they left. * Salaries and status of software engineers are low, you'd want to switch to management asap, * There are very few interesting tech companies, * Corruption and bureaucracy doesn't help with innovation and starting your own businesses.
- oriettaxx 7y agoYes, Italians abroad can all sure confirm, but add: * Social security/pension: if you work on IT in Italy, and have any degree but an Engineer one, you must pay 26% (and is planned to rise to 33%!) of your income to a pension public fund called "Gestione Separata": add to this your income tax and see how you say goodbye more then 50% of your money. That pension fund is a total robbery since it is well known not to be sustainable, so just a miserable pension will come just from that fund. Even the director of the national pension institute (to which the fund belongs) once stated in the press: "I don't even understand why all subscribers to the fund 'Gestione Separata' are not protesting on the street!" (btw: subscribers are millions!). Even more: * the fund does not give you anything if you are sick: are you sick? you have to work and pay your pension (no concession!): yes, seriously! * until 2 years ago that fund did not even give a woman any contribution at all for maternity (!) Angry with their embarrassing political scenery, many Italians give up and, as they have been doing for centuries, go abroad: "voting with their own feet" sources: * https://www.informazionefiscale.it/gestione-separata-INPS-aliquote-contributive-2019-minimale-massimale https://www.informazionefiscale.it/gestione-separata-INPS-al... * https://books.google.com.tr/books?id=ZrI_6jPOiWEC&pg=PA431&lpg=PA431&dq=direttore+inps+come+fanno+gli+iscritti+alla+gestione+separata+a+non+andare+in+piazza+a+protestare&source=bl&ots=4vs5TwvOOQ&sig=ACfU3U1Qw2BEZnkaSosuABba9tCyWZ2pGA&hl=it&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwjpx5Og2frkAhXRyKQKHUR8DjUQ6AEwCHoECAgQAQ#v=onepage&q=direttore%20inps%20come%20fanno%20gli%20iscritti%20alla%20gestione%20separata%20a%20non%20andare%20in%20piazza%20a%20protestare&f=false https://books.google.com.tr/books?id=ZrI_6jPOiWEC&pg=PA431&l...
- ajsnigrutin 7y agoThis (the amount of taxes, and shitty predictions for the failure of this system) is true for most european countries (although you get more and better stuff in some countries). When the system collapses in one country, the others will go down fast, and we'll have a huge problem then.
- tim333 7y agoHis graphs all seem to start from the 90s and he assumes slower growth is down to IT but I think the phenomena has been going on much longer and predates IT. Back in the 60s say Germany and northern Italy had manufacturing industries and the like while southern Italy and places like Greece and Portugal remained doing mostly agriculture and tourism. For better or worse industries seem to concentrate in certain areas - I imagine California will have more tech industry than Nebraska say for a while yet.
- icebraining 7y agoLater the article says it's due to management, not IT. I agree that in the 60s-70s there was a tremendous difference (hence the massive migrations from e.g. Portugal to France and Germany at the time), but I think there was also some convergence in the 90s. I fear the divergence has just been increasing from then on.
- tim333 7y agoThe Euro crisis didn't help of course. Many used cheap Euro loans to buy overpriced property in the bubble. That doesn't really go away till the mortgages are paid off in a decade or two.
- saykou 7y agoSouthern European here have worked with Nothern European companies and southern European ones. I can attest that management is the greatest difference. It is part due to HR how the hire and check people for management position ( it is loosely a series of questions + his CV) while even for the Junior developer role you can have developer programming tests plus theory question. It is more reliable, and I have seen time and time again bad management that his hired due to the cv and it is just bad professional, can't organize anything doesn't take decisions etc etc and the problem is that it can't be fired. But also Capital accumulation, when you start from a good starting point where you have the capital to invest in IT. The earnings are exponentially greater, so the effects on Germany from the IT revolution should be greater then in Southern Europe. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_accumulation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_accumulation
- theK 7y agoI’m with you in the hiring fallacies. From personal experience northern countries have proven much more “adventurous” regarding IT hiring. Still, even fixing that will probably only get you onto sinking ships. Sure Spain and Portugal have some unicorns but missing VC and the heavily tourism-take-all-their-money-asap management mentality of big capital and administration seem to be setting up a bad environment. But that’s only personal experience not a thorough analysis...
- m00dy 7y agoTurkey has now the biggest brain drainage ever in its history [0]. Most of them prefer western countries. [0]: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/02/world/europe/turkey-emigration-erdogan.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/01/02/world/europe/turkey-emigr...
- mschuster91 7y agoYeah because everyone with a brain is being accused of being a Gulen terrorist, or knows someone who is being accused. The downfall of the justice system as Erdogan makes himself a dictator causes everyone who can to vote with their feet. This especially includes foreign investors who were responsible for a large part of the economic rise of Turkey in the last decade - when investors cannot be sure that the government will randomly imprison their workers, they retract their investment. Erdogan really sets up Turkey for doom.
- bump64 7y agoCan't speak for all southern countries in EU but here are my impressions. * At least from the people I know during the summer productivity drops because everyone is on a vacation to the seaside. * People here seem to much more enjoy live. It is much more common to see young people just hanging around and socializing than doing anything productive. * Tourism is usually the priority for those counties, not IT. This leads to high number of seasonal workers. Lots of people don't want to work in factories and offices. They just work a few months during the summer in the tourism and during the rest of the time they enjoy life and do nothing. * EU allows everyone to work everywhere and smart people want to be part of the technological hubs of Europe which just happen not be here. It is the same as in USA. I haven't heard about any startup from Kansas, but plenty from Silicon Valley. My two cents for the situation. EU has poured lots of money to these regions but very few productive things have come out. People just learned how to manipulate the system to get more funds. They are not thinking how to solve real problems and make people lives better, everyone is just trying to get money, spend them and then asks for more. The funds should be restructured to allow entrepreneurship grow. You cannot make inefficient system better by just giving it more money, you need to change the system.
- icebraining 7y agoThe long vacations (often a whistle word for "laziness") is a common refrain, but as far as I know the numbers don't bear that out: the vacation days are not very different, and the working hours are actually longer.
- TheNorthman 7y agoSpain has 30 days required paid leave. In Denmark 25 is required, most IT workers have 30, some (e.g I) have 35. Spain has a 40 hour work week, Denmark has a 37.5 hour work week. Yes the numbers don't add up to OPs claim. Yes, it's a dog whistle.
- adventured 7y agoThat's correct. People proclaiming that it's about quality of life are mistaken, other nations have overwhelmingly demonstrated that you can have both in abundance. Portugal works more hours (1,842) than the US does (1,783; average labor hours per worker per year). Yet US output per capita is nearly three times higher. Greece works far more hours than the US. The US is near the OECD average for hours worked, Greece is 15% higher than the OECD average. Spain works 4% fewer hours than the US, with 1/2 the output. Italy works 3% fewer hours with close to 1/2 the output. Forget about the US though, it's nowhere near the best example of this in action. Germany is at $48k GDP per capita, over double that of Portugal or Greece, while working 1363 hours per year. About 20% fewer hours than Spain and Italy. That's nearly 500 fewer hours of annual work versus Portugal. The Germans are averaging 26 hours per week across a year, Greek workers are at 39 (which in real terms means once you remove vacation time, the average worker in Greece is pulling well over 40 hours per work week). The Greeks are among the worst off in hours worked, at 2035 hours. 672 more hours than the Germans. That's a strong indictment of the quality of life argument usually tossed about regarding countries like Spain, Portugal, Italy and Greece. Some of the countries near the bottom in hours worked in the OECD: Germany, Belgium, Denmark, Netherlands, France, Austria, Sweden, Finland, Australia, UK. They're all simultaneously very high output countries, working fewer hours than Spain, Portugal, Italy, Greece. Norway and Switzerland are near the bottom in hours as well, however their context are rather unique.
- amiguel 7y agoThis seems about spot on the related issues with Southern European Countries, although after the big debt crisis we can see that some, namely Portugal and Spain raised their bar on the IT revolution. They have seen a big startup boom in AI, ecommerce, SaaS, even blockchain. Portugal: Farfetch (unicorn, IPO'd), Talkdesk (unicorn), Unbabel, Apptoide, UTRUST Spain: Glovo, Typeform, Spotahome, Travelperk They came late to the game, but now their tech scene is rising.
- saykou 7y agoHum, don't want to name companies, but I know that management in some of the companies you mentioned are really shitty.
- ptah 7y agoproductivity gains typically translate into greater profit and not much wage increase so from a worker's perspective: shrug
- hevi_jos 7y agoAll of those ideas are generalizations of complex realities. For example saying that people in Spain or Portugal love living the good live and not working is a generalization. Today, when most work is actually done by machines and not humans, you could actually be way more productive not burning yourself out than burning. In Germany they have more machines, because they have more capital and because they forced the Southern countries to destroy its industries. That happened with Spain and specially Italy for entering the EU. 32-36% of the Spanish economy was industry before joining the UE, now it is 12% and going down. For example, In Spain they put quotas(limits) in the milk that every milk producer could generate in the north of Spain, that has a wet climate, like France, UK, or Germany. Those countries of course had not quotas. This way European companies(specially French companies) could enter the Spanish market and have bigger markets, but the Spanish companies could not compete because they had to reduce production. With bigger markets, they had bigger mass scale productions, more efficiency and could put prices that put out of the market Spanish companies. On the other hand, the South of Spain was benefited as it produces things that Europe do not. They also flooded the real state market with easy money coming from European banks that will lend outrageous amount of money to anybody with a pulse. That made year to year profits of 20-30% in real state in the bubble, further increasing the desinvestment in industry, that could only give moderate 3-4%. Of course lending to people that could not pay back was a bad idea, and when the bubble burst lots of banks from Germany, UK, or France should have gone down. But of course the governments of those countries forced the Spanish government to buy the bad debt, making the Spanish Government bankrupt itself. Reality is complex, but we love simple arguments.
- pjc50 7y agoThe milk quota system applied to every country, including the UK: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-32136218 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-32136218 (It's important to be accurate about what the EU actually does and does not do, otherwise you get Brexit)
- danmaz74 7y agoI think that one very important factor, at least in Italy which is where I lived for a long time, is the culture about processes and organisation. In Italy there are lots of very talented people, but very often they work best in a self organised/ad hoc way. "Just following the rules" is mostly thought of as something stupid people do. It's very difficult to automate processes which were non standardised or haphazard in the first place.
- CaciaraAsAServi 7y agoThe major reason in Italy is enormous fragmentation of capital. We lost most big concentrations in the years following the 1970s crisis because the direction the post-crisis restructuration took has been towards very small enterprises and not the consolidation of big groups. Reasons for this are complex, but I would call as the two most important 1. the way the urbanisation process during Les Trente Glorieuses didn't push people into working for big companies as much as in other European countries, leaving more room for small companies in later years (there are also historical reasons for this unusually stronger weight of small capital, of course, which go long back to the past); 2. how the political cadres didn't have enough, basically, courage, to push for the consolidation of bigger companies, if not in a way that amounted to stitching some smaller low-productivity companies together - pushing for an increased industrial productivity would have meant that many smaller enterprises would have gone out of business, that would have meant the loss of MANY votes from those social groups! Excuse me if I say something controversial, but just read up on the Reggio Calabria riots in 1970, especially the afternath. The 1980s have been characterised by the widespread diffusion of the SME model (the meme was "piccolo è bello" - small is beautiful), also with remarkable examples like Veneto which saw a real facelift, turning from a somewhat still rural region into the homeland of the "capannone" (the small industrial shed) in little less than 10 years! Personally I think that all of this has been a major mistake, but maybe unavoidable due to the social structure and history of the country. But in all of this, consider also that northern Italy is basically Europe's second most important industrial zone (we serve as component makers for the larger industries of northern Europe) So.. it is very complicated.
- Discombulator 7y agoOne of the best explanations of the issues of Southern Europe, and Italy in specific, that I read about during my studies, can be found in the book “The Moral Basis of a Backward Society” (Banfield). It describes a village in southern Italy in which inhabitants are unwilling to contribute anything that does not immediately and directly benefit their own family. For example, they are unwilling to build a road to the next town, even given the large benefits the village overall would gain, because “only fools would do so” (paraphrasing here). Seen with a game theoretic lens, and extending beyond Italy, it appears that there are low trust and high trust (or “social capital”) equilibria in societies, and it is especially difficult to go from the low trust to the high trust one. Secondly, these cultural norms and institutions (in a broad sense) are extremely persistent over time. Of course, this is only one aspect of a multifaceted problem, but I find it particularly enlightening.
- LeanderK 7y agothe game-theoretic aspect is certainly interesting. A more formal study would certainly be worth reading.
- LeanderK 7y agoWhat about southern Europe's technology hubs (Milan, Barcelona, Madrid, Lisbon)? Are they evolving differently? I don't remeber it exactly, but I spoke recenetly on a party with somebody who lived for a few years in Lisbon and he quite liked it (and didn't spoke negativly on the IT-enviroment there, be it management or other stuff like meetups). Their universities are also not to underestimated (at least what I've heard from barcelona and lisbon. I've heard bad things from the CS at one of the universities around madrid).
- rasz 7y agoI find game development as a good proxy for the overall level of CS in a region. Can you name, from the top of your head, a Spanish game studio? or Italian? or Portugal? or even a single game? I could only come up with Commandos/Runaway series (Spanish) and Screamer/Assetto Corsa (Italian) on my own, plus knowledge Screamer developer is the only notable one still making racing games to this day. I couldnt remember a single game studio name :( and Im an avid current/retro gamer. Even looking up https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Video_game_companies_by_country https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Video_game_companies_... is not that helpful. You know its bad when you get results like https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_age_of_Spanish_software https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_age_of_Spanish_software. Thats really not that great compared to the rest of Europe.
- LeanderK 7y ago> https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_age_of_Spanish_software https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_age_of_Spanish_software. Thats really not that great compared to the rest of Europe. Wow, this is shocking. Every wikipedia article about the spanish companies mentioned is worded in the past. None survived. Crazy how they not only declined, but disappeared. But I am not sure whether game dev is a good proxy for the overall CS level of a region.