8 ms·
Plastic bottled water is not bought because it is higher quality. People buy it because it comes in a disposable container.
by cortesoft 7y ago
Plastic bottled water is not bought because it is higher quality. People buy it because it comes in a disposable container.
- thelittleone 7y agoIn Bali, Indonesia (and many developing countries) you have no choice. Drinking tap water is also health hazard in some countries.
- Scoundreller 7y agoDepending on what the hazard is, disinfection tablets can be effective and much cheaper than buying water. Or SODIS sunlight disinfection.
- thelittleone 7y agoHaven’t tried those tabs for many years but I recall them tasting terrible. Good for emergencies perhaps. Filtration systems are available but cost several thousand dollars and require core replacements every two years for around $300-400. On the other hand, a gallon of potable water from one of the few springs in Bali costs around $3.
- Scoundreller 7y agoThe NaDCC tablets leave no taste.
- Ayesh 7y agoWater purification tabs, straws, and bottles are not practical unless you are in an extreme environment to find clean water (hikes, for example). - They tested awful. Iodine tablets have an awful taste after. We often use orange flavored powder to hide it. - They are expensive in third world countries. You have to use one tablet per liter, and it costs about 10 cents USD per tablet. In comparison, you can buy a 1L plastic bottle of water for 30 cents. - it takes about half an hour to work, so you can't use them immediately. - Even if you buy those straws, they have a maximum lifetime before you have to replace the filter (about 1000l). You will need to replace about twice a year if you were to use as the daily drive.
- Scoundreller 7y agoI couldn’t tell any taste with the NaDCC based chlorinating tablets. They’re not household bleach. Iodine is old tech, and has other issues. 10cents < 30cents. And don’t underestimate the logistics of transporting bottled water.
- mastazi 7y agoIn Bali, Thailand and many other places in SE Asia, you can get water that comes from local treatment plants (it usually looks like this[1]) instead of "brand" bottled water (like these ones[2]), the former is almost always bottled locally (at the nearest water treatment plant, they are ubiquitous in SE Asia even in regional areas, sometimes they are subsidised by governments), as a result the water tends to stay in the bottle for a much shorter time whereas "brand" water is not sourced locally and it travels long distances after being bottled. In addition the employees of the local water treatment plant will often come and take back empty bottles to use them again, so in those cases you have nearly 100% recycling and very little plastic waste. I don't have any evidence that [1] contains less microplastics than [2] unfortunately, but I think it could be the case. (I have lived in Indonesia for about one year and part of my family is from Thailand). [1] http://www.nomad4ever.com/wp-content/uploads/2006/12/bottle_handling_at_bintang_supermarket_legian_bali2.jpg http://www.nomad4ever.com/wp-content/uploads/2006/12/bottle_... [2] https://www.bali.com/media/image/865/plastic-bottles-waste.jpg https://www.bali.com/media/image/865/plastic-bottles-waste.j...
- thelittleone 7y agoThere’s also a system where Nestle gallon containers are filled by small merchants with local filtered bore water and recapped and sold (often as original).
- mastazi 7y agoIn many places in SE Asia, Nestle "gallon containers" are sold at a premium compared to locally purified water (often 3X - 4X the price), but I would be curious to see side-by-side water analysis results...
- fouc 7y agoThe 18.9L/5 gallon water jugs are common even in Canada and US also, it's not unique to Asia. They do get washed and re-used also. It's an interesting question if they'd be at risk for microplastics as well.
- peteretep 7y ago
- peteretep 7y agoIf you have money, you can buy a small water filtering unit for the house that gives you drinkable “tap water”. We had one in our fridge in the early 90s in Bangkok.
- aqme28 7y agoThat's how I buy it, but I've encountered plenty of people who think it's of higher quality and prefer it.
- zeptoon 7y agoIgnorant comment from someone who's clearly never travelled anywhere. It's actually the exception to be able to drink tap water around the world, not the rule.
- JohnFen 7y agoI know lots of people who buy it because they believe it's higher quality. They don't care about the container.
- hu3 7y agoThat would be me and my family over the last decade. We buy bottled water hoping it would benefit our health over tap water.
- JohnFen 7y agoThe tap water in the vast majority of the US is superior to bottled water. There are exceptions, though, so if health is your concern, you might want to test both your tap and bottled water.
- fingerlocks 7y ago> The tap water in the vast majority of the US is superior to bottled water. I'm surprised this myth gets repeated so often on HN. It's not true- the standards for purified bottled water are quite high[0]. [0]https://www.fda.gov/consumers/consumer-updates/bottled-water-everywhere-keeping-it-safe https://www.fda.gov/consumers/consumer-updates/bottled-water...
- dual_basis 7y ago1. The link you provided suggests that some bottled water comes from Municipal sources, ie. it is tap water. This would logically imply that the standards for bottled water are <= the standards for tap water, at least in those locations. 2. The original article you are commenting on suggests that bottled water contains more microplastics than tap water.
- fingerlocks 7y agoDo you have your sign reversed on that inequality? If the water comes from municipal sources, and the standards are higher for bottled water than tap (clearly stated in the link), then the quality of bottled water can be, at worst, equal to tap water.
- nomel 7y agoI buy 2.5 gallon plastic jugs of water from the store. It tastes much better than the many "fill" services/stations around the city that exist because this cities water tastes absolutely terrible, and that's what they're filtering.
- davchana 7y agoSame, Arrowhead Brand water tastes better than any other local or other water, & my wife wants that water only. I myself couldn't care less about brand.
- chiefalchemist 7y agoI live in central NJ. I buy bottled water because we notification about the local "city water" having some issue or another. I'd use tap water if it was safe.
- riffraff 7y agoWhen in italy, I buy bottled water because i like natuRally sparkling water, rather than still. I would welcome going back to glass bottles.
- glennpratt 7y agoThis isn't true in my experience. I've witnessed plenty of people in wealthy US suburbs that stock bottled water at home and even stock up on vacation. They claim it's for the taste and purity.
- mehrdadn 7y agoI don't know about purity but the taste can indeed be better than tap.
- Judgmentality 7y agoIt can also be worse. I'd guess for almost everybody the difference in taste is dominated by the placebo effect. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xIJEw5aDzOo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xIJEw5aDzOo
- mehrdadn 7y agoI mean, maybe to you it's a placebo effect, but I know I can at least smell the chlorine in my tap water... which I suppose isn't strictly "taste" but basically the same for the point of the discussion.
- dottrap 7y agoA lot of bottled water comes from municipal water plants (aka tap water). That Penn & Teller YouTube link even has a section showing this, though you only need to go to the supermarket and look closely at the fine print of all the different brands of bottle water. You'll quickly find a lot are tap water.
- grandmczeb 7y ago"Tap" doesn't always have a uniform flavor, even in the same city. It's perfectly possible that bottled tap might taste better than the tap water at your house.
- 7y ago
- elif 7y agoFor the majority of the population of South America, it is bought because the tap water is not potable. I imagine that is the case in other continents as well.
- seppin 7y agoAfrica, Asia too
- fleetingmoments 7y agoReally? On a recent trip to Chile and Argentina I only drank tap water everywhere and had no issues.