6 ms·
>The investigators are also allegedly instructed to “first to protect Uber” and make sure it is “not held liable” for any crimes that are committed by people us
by duxup 7y ago
>The investigators are also allegedly instructed to “first to protect Uber” and make sure it is “not held liable” for any crimes that are committed by people using the company’s ride-hailing platform.
This doesn't seem much different than say interacting with HR inside your own company or anything like that.
Still a bad look and morally questionable, but at the same time I do agree that the victim can / should go to the police if they wish to.
If Uber did go to the police I wonder what guidelines there would be. Only if there is a confession?
"Enough" evidence? Or just any accusation?
I can imagine a situation where a victim doesn't want to go to the police, and that is their call. I'm not sure it is Urber's job to do it for them.
- eli 7y agoThis is a stereotype of HR that IMHO is not representative of the majority of people in the profession.
- duxup 7y agoThe majority of people in the profession don't change the incentives. They work for the company, push comes to shove that is their job. They might help me figure out some insurance thing here or there and really care, but when it comes to something important they are there for the company, not me.
- eli 7y agoDoesn't everyone at the company... work for the company? An Engineering Manager has an incentive to overwork engineers to a hit a deadline -- and, yes, sometimes that happens! -- but in addition to just being a bad thing to do, that comes at a huge long term cost to the business. It's much better for the company and the employees to not overwork them. If HR is doing it right, supporting the company and supporting its employees are compatible goals.
- falcolas 7y ago> supporting the company and supporting its employees are compatible goals. Until an employee does something that puts themselves at odds with the company. At which point HR is the tip of the spear when it comes to protecting the company from that employee. "Here's how to let them go legally." "Here's how we bribe them into not talking bad about us." "Here's our zero tolerance policy we can fit our employee firing into."
- mdorazio 7y agoPeople =/= department. That goes for many things beyond HR as well, but in general you'll often find good HR people with good intentions who nonetheless end up doing shitty things to employees when it's a choice between being nice and protecting the company.
- jimmydddd 7y agoCould you please clarify? My understanding is that HR's job is to protect the company, not the employee. If the employee is "helped," it's typically to shield the company from lawsuits. So, acting in the employee's best interest is often aligned with helping the company. But, if the employee's interest is seen as diverging from that of the company, HR will "side" with the company against the employee. Do you disagree?
- michaelt 7y agoLet's say there are several independent reports of an important, senior manager sexually assaulting employees, and the HR manager wants to cover it up. They only need a one or two people able and willing to deliver a cover-up, not the entire department. It could well be 95% of people in the profession would categorically refuse if asked to do so.
- luckydata 7y agoIn my experience the stereotype is well deserved. I have in the past reported impropriety during a company conference, and specified I was doing it to make sure people were advised to knock it off and avoid getting ourselves a Uber style scandal, I was put on probation right away (the CTO was involved) and I had to leave the company right after that. It wasn't worth to sue them and frankly the job sucked, but that taught me the valuable lesson that even if you're looking out for the business, HR is still not your ally. HR serves executives and nobody else.
- bluntfang 7y ago>I do agree that the victim can / should go to the police if they wish to. It's really important for a victim to maintain autonomy when dealing with traumatic events. Uber's move should be to contact the victim and ask them what they would like to do and offer them all the information they need to (reasonably) facilitate that in regards to criminal investigation.
- mkolodny 7y agoFrom the article: > the company has started giving people the “option to allow [Uber] to contact law enforcement on their behalf” if the customer is reporting an incident that may be a crime
- bluntfang 7y agoGiving an option to click a button is not the same as supporting the victim by listening to their concerns and acting appropriately. It's a very inhumane approach to a problem that requires compassion, tact, and awareness.
- shakna 7y ago> I can imagine a situation where a victim doesn't want to go to the police, and that is their call. I'm not sure it is Urber's job to do it for them. I don't think Uber or any company should be making a decision whether to or not - reporting should always be mandatory. Especially if anyone may be in danger. The company does not have, or cannot be expected to have, the training or knowledge to make the call whether or not there is a problem. That should be passed on to the people have the knowledge to make that call, and that training is part of their job. The police are the ones who get to look at the report and decide if something is worth investigating, and whether there is enough evidence, or what even is evidence, to lay charges. The best way to remain impartial and not endanger the company, is for the company not to make the call.
- chrisseaton 7y agoI'm not so sure - reporting things to the police without thought seems to end up with getting people killed in parts of the US.
- GhostVII 7y agoHow many examples to you have of someone being killed after filing a police report?
- chrisseaton 7y agoThere's tons of stories from the last few years about police being called when not required to situations, and it turning lethal.
- reaperducer 7y agoPolice responding to a 911 call, and a company filing a police report are not the same thing. Not even remotely.
- chrisseaton 7y ago
- Scoundreller 7y agoNo different than say, a telecom or bank’s “fraud department”. It’s not there to protect the customer, it’s there to protect the company.
- jacquesm 7y agoBanks fraud departments are there to comply with the law as well as to protect the company and are in many countries legally compelled to contact the authorities.