17 ms·
Looking Back at the Snowden Revelations
- raxxorrax 7y agoIsn't the practice of the NSA just plainly treason? And why would it not be?
- em3rgent0rdr 7y agoHypothetically, a benevolent NSA would primarily develop cryptographic security tools for the populace.
- raxxorrax 7y agoTrue. But besides their interest in acquiring exploits, I think their data collection seriously collides with peoples amendment rights against arbitrary state surveillance. I know there are some judges and institutions that enabled this madness, but I think they might be guilty as well. These judges should be accountable to the public in theory. I am not saying the everyone working at the NSA is a criminal. But maybe Snowden was the only one with perspective. The NSA as an institution certainly did more damage to the US than most of its enemies.
- Craighead 7y agoYou must not understand how cyber war works. The US has judges and legislation to enable the NSA. Russia, China, Iran, NK, and many other authoritarian states seek to use their power to attack America 24x7 and do so without any oversight.
- anilakar 7y agoA few countries actively try to hurt us, so let's spy on everyone, including our own citizens and allies!
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- raxxorrax 7y agoI am not disputing other countries to not have bad intentions, but as a justification to breaking the law, this seems to be a defense where the guilt has already been determined. Personally, I think the "cyber war" is the typical scare to reduce civil rights. That is a pretty common pattern to bolster and justify disregarding the law. In reality, the cyber war is probably still focused on the classical industrial espionage. I fail to see the need to subject citizens to mass surveillance.
- hos234 7y agoNot that I want to spend time defending the NSA, but back then collecting all data happened because it was the easiest thing to do, more as a reaction than an actual solution to certain threats. When society has no great way of preventing, let's say for example, the Boston Marathon bombing or the Las Vegas Concert shooting, providing an appearance of activity, however mindless, like a bunch of ants feverishly running around when a stone is thrown into the anthill, is just the default setting of the security establishment. You can't blame them for that because we aren't yet psychologically, socially or politically sophisticated enough to do anything better. But today after collecting and sitting on top of shitloads of useless data they themselves admit its unnecessary. You don't find who the best Tennis player in the neighborhood is by monitoring the entire neighborhoods conversations but by just watching the local tennis courts. What you can do is ask why it took so long, with that nudge from Snowden, for the establishment to admit this. That kind of questioning prevents them jumping into further "we can do it so lets do it" bullshit projects down the road.
- bayesian_horse 7y agoIn fact, there is no clear indication that they did not act in what they perceived as the interest of the US and its citizens. Many would disagree with that perception, and I also believe that amount of surveillance to have been wrong and counterproductive, but there hasn't been any evidence or significant hints into possible corrupt motivations. One mustn't forget that all of this was put into motion after the 9/11 attacks, and both the Bush and Obama administrations where still working under (somewhat irrational) pressure from citizens afraid of a repeat performance.
- ncmncm 7y ago"They" is an expansive word. We could better say there is no indication that nobody who had access to illegally-obtained information misused it. We have plenty of evidence of cops misusing databases they have access to, and that stuff is way less juicy.
- oh_sigh 7y agoWouldn't those same tools make it easier for the baddies to do their bad things?
- Cthulhu_ 7y agoAh but they tried to, there's been proposals for cryptography that had NSA approved backdoors but they were never accepted or widely used. (IIRC / I believe)
- auiya 7y agoThey do. https://cryptome.org/2016/01/CNSA-Suite-and-Quantum-Computing-FAQ.pdf https://cryptome.org/2016/01/CNSA-Suite-and-Quantum-Computin...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- SomeOldThrow 7y agoTypically you define treason in terms of the needs of the state, not the populace. You can come to your own conclusion how well the state interests align with its peoples’.
- freddie_mercury 7y agoNo, it isn't plainly treason. This is the definition of treason: Treason against the United States, shall consist only in levying War against them, or in adhering to their Enemies, giving them Aid and Comfort. No Person shall be convicted of Treason unless on the Testimony of two Witnesses to the same overt Act, or on Confession in open Court. Did the NSA levy war against the US? Did the NSA give aid & comfort to the enemies of the US?
- bayesian_horse 7y agoParticularly it has been ruled that "treason" as per the US constitution or laws is impossible unless war has been declared on a foreign nation.
- raxxorrax 7y agoMakes sense. So that means Snowden cannot be a traitor either or are there exceptions?
- bayesian_horse 7y agoNot in the criminal sense. He violated several laws around the general topic of national security, he made the work of US intelligence agencies harder and he did endanger US troops abroad. He also helped along Putin's general interest of destabilization. So colloquially, there may be a case to call him a "traitor". It's impossible to clear him from the accusation that he worked with/for a foreign government, maybe even before he fled to Russia. And at the current point in time, he wouldn't be able to refuse any request the Russian government made of him. He also featured in a fake "ask-me-anything" with Putin, just to make that point.
- raxxorrax 7y agoMy initial statement was nothing else as colloquial and should be regarded as such of course. I would say implementing mass surveillance would equally make it impossible to clear the NSA from such accusation.
- maze-le 7y agoDo you really want to think and judge people/institutions in these terms (traitor/non-traitor etc.)? I doubt this is in any way helpful to find a political solution. I know that this is being done with Snowden -- but lets not resort to this level of (hyperbole) accusation -- else the sanke pit is open to everyone to be define the other side as "traitor" in one way or another.
- chrisco255 7y agoIt could be argued unconstitutional, under the 4th amendment. But so far as I know, no one's brought a case against the NSA to the Supreme Court.
- bayesian_horse 7y agoIt's quite common to confuse breaking laws with treason, but that just isn't the same. Accusations of treason at every corner hinder rational democratic discourse.
- narrator 7y agoWhat if Snowden was a deep state pawn sent to take down the NSA, or at least give other agencies total control over it? It is holding the crown jewels after all. The rabbit hole on this one is extremely deep. Hint: What agency did Snowden work for before the NSA?
- ncmncm 7y agoIt doesn't matter if he was put up to it. The facts are the same. That criminal misuses of the data were not also exposed suggests that he knew what line not to cross.
- mistermann 7y agoSnowden's revelations proved once again that conspiracies are all false, because it is literally impossible for large numbers of people to keep their mouth shut. Exactly as we're told on forums, exactly as we're told on TV. This is how you know Epstein is also innocent and why it won't be investigated, because we know people cannot keep silent about committing crimes, therefore we know no crimes were committed.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dang 7y ago"Eschew flamebait. Don't introduce flamewar topics unless you have something genuinely new to say. Avoid unrelated controversies and generic tangents." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- SomeOldThrow 7y agoYou know this is just as effective if you don’t pretend to provide a substantial justification. Flamebait can be anything you want it to be. Seize the power, dang.
- luckylion 7y ago> Snowden's revelations proved once again that conspiracies are all false, because it is literally impossible for large numbers of people to keep their mouth shut. That's both a good point and not so much. In the end, they didn't keep their mouths shut, Snowden spilled the beans and uncovered the large conspiracy. It's a good point with regard to "that would require a large conspiracy, and those don't work" not being a good argument against theories: there might be a large conspiracy that just hasn't failed yet. And who knows how many more years or decades the large conspiracy would have worked just fine if Snowden hadn't leaked.
- throwaway2048 7y agoIts also important to note Snowden wasn't the first NSA person to warn us about this, there were a handful in the 2000s before him.
- codeulike 7y agoThis is a good article. Everyone has forgotten how much has changed since Snowden.
- 9dl 7y agoActually, nothing changed Some Laws was created. Some revelations was made. But even manipulations with elections did not kill any company
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jasonvorhe 7y agoLet's Encrypt brought TLS to the masses, browsers are bringing focus to sites still not using transport encryption, https is a signal for Google ranking. Don't be so defeatist.
- luckylion 7y agoMore SSL traffic gets terminated at CF, AWS & Co. Build a data center next door, mail them the NSL and off you go. Much easier than running covert operations hooking into lots of CIX and providers world wide.
- cremp 7y agoThat's non-targeted attacks. Nothing stops the targeted attacks. Sure, they might not be able to listen in on those https connections, but if they wanted to attack/listen to this Joe Smith over here, they are more than capable, and still do it.
- hobs 7y agoWorld governments can also just generally have you arrested or killed without a ton of fuss if you are a big problem. The problem with the NSA revelations wasn't that the NSA spies on people - that's their job. It was about mass warrant-less surveillance of the american public, not individual targeted surveillance.
- stephenitis 7y agoI needed clear recap like this to put it in perspective. Thank You Matthew Green.
- pascalmahe 7y agoAs someone not from the US, the passages about how easy it was are clear reminders that just because only the NSA got caught, does not mean only the NSA was doing it. Even if they have by far the biggest budget...
- DanielBMarkham 7y agoYeah, there's a severe danger here that only the stories that are worthy of media play are going to be discussed. Snowden has been proven to generate clicks, so we'll probably continue to see a lot of Snowden stories. We're in a multi-party cyberwar. We have been for years. It involves both governments and NGOs. Most of the players are pushing as hard as they can, short of real warfare, to gain the advantage over the others. That's a much tougher story to tell, since it doesn't have clear heroes and villains. Also it involves a lot of technical stuff Joe Layman doesn't want to process. Because of this, media outlets are always going to tell the simpler story. The overwhelming danger here is that nobody learns what is going on, which presumably is the point of having a media outlet in the first place.
- parsimo2010 7y agoWe’ve seen other stories, Stuxnet in particular that implicate other countries like Israel. Anyone that thinks that the USA and Israel are spending money on cyber warfare but China and Russia are not is living in a fantasy world. Maybe some small countries like Andorra don’t have a cyber warfare division, but all the big countries do. Everyone is being spied on. Perhaps the only distinction worth making is whether you’re being spied on by your own government in addition to foreign governments.
- ncmncm 7y agoIn fact, once the content and data are liberated, there is no reason to assume it is well-protected from criminal access. Personal facts that are not directly incriminating are often just as valuable for extortion. Those facts need not be about you, to affect you. They could be about a federal judge's brother. As extortion is the central procedure of spycraft, people trained in its use by the government also have access to the "goods". Criminal intent is no bar to employment by Booz Allen, or by NSA or FBI proper, never mind Russian GRU or FSB or their Chinese counterparts. Extortion works for anybody.
- BlueTemplar 7y agoOh yeah : - Before Snowden, if you spoke about these issues, you were dismissed as paranoid. - After Snowden, if you dismiss these issues, you are dismissed as hopelessly naive... Oh, also - considering all this - you can bet that Intel's Management Engine has likely been backdoored by the NSA, so using Intel's processors is not recommended, especially if you're a non-US company... (industrial espionage !) https://blog.invisiblethings.org/papers/2015/x86_harmful.pdf https://blog.invisiblethings.org/papers/2015/x86_harmful.pdf
- Hendrikto 7y ago> Before Snowden, if you spoke about these issues, you were dismissed as paranoid. I’ve been telling people for years, but nobody listened. Now everyone knows it’s true, but still nobody seems to care…
- stiray 7y agoDescription of my life. I was telling people for years what is going on, not from position of daydreaming, but what I would be able to pull off. I got back everything from tin foil hat to "I have nothing to hide". Snowden changed that and I am gratefull to him for exactly that... And for one more sentance, that is a work of pure genius: “Arguing that you don't care about the right to privacy because you have nothing to hide is no different than saying you don't care about free speech because you have nothing to say.” <3 And how the world is changing, from GDPR to California privacy law... I would just love to shake hand to this guy.
- Darkstryder 7y ago> “Arguing that you don't care about the right to privacy because you have nothing to hide is no different than saying you don't care about free speech because you have nothing to say.” I find this sentence interesting because it is very specific to the American public. I am European and personally I care a lot more about privacy than free speech, and America's obsession with free speech boggles my mind. It might have to do with the last time we in Europe experimented with unadulterated free speech, and got Hitler and WW2 as a result. We might have dialed it back a bit after that. But what do I know ? There seems to be some a profound divide between America and Europe on this front and I haven't quite put my finger on why yet.
- saalweachter 7y agoThe article mentions MUSCULAR, but neglected the follow-up: shortly after the leaks, Google began encrypting all of its internal traffic over its own fiber links.[0] First, it's worth pointing out that "encrypt everything in flight always" is not prohibitively expensive on modern hardware; also that your own internal network should not be viewed as an impenetrable bastion where you can let down your guard, just because you keep a close eye on the external routers. [0] https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/technology/google-encrypts-data-amid-backlash-against-nsa-spying/2013/09/06/9acc3c20-1722-11e3-a2ec-b47e45e6f8ef_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/technology/google-en...
- andy_ppp 7y ago“Security of organisations should be done in layers” and each layer makes breaking into your (whole) organisation harder, but comes with friction for your staff.
- kerkeslager 7y agoIt should be noted that your staff are a key attack vector.
- e12e 7y agoNo, I think the new consensus is that all systems are vulnerable (obviously true if all systems have users with access, whom may be compromised) - so not layers: compartments (and need to know;need to access). I believe this is part of eg google/alphabet's new model: no hard wall, soft "inside" (egg model). Just stand alone secure sub-systems with ACL (access control lists) mediating access on a user-by-user, sub-system by sub-system level. No real trust in "location" as proof of authorization (I assume truly, off-grid clean rooms are excepted) - because "everything" needs access to networked resources. Ah, I guess they call it BeyondCorp: https://cloud.google.com/beyondcorp/ https://cloud.google.com/beyondcorp/
- andy_ppp 7y agoSure, I used (or the person I’m quoting used) the wrong term, thanks for the clarification. I did mean and he meant compartmentalising :-)
- upofadown 7y ago> ... — the agency spent $250 million per year on a program called the SIGINT Enabling Project. Its goal was, basically, to bypass our commercial encryption at any cost. Now that things have actually started going dark for these overfunded and completely unaccountable entities this is where the biggest danger lies. They have become so desperate for continued access to endless funding that they are actually turning against the people they are sworn to serve. The most dangerous time will come when the governments of the world start the task of trimming down such entities to something proportionate to their worth. That process has not really even begun yet...
- ncmncm 7y agoThere is no reason to think that didn't happen long ago. Indeed, MK-ULTRA was directed at the American public, and its perpetrators were never even demoted, never mind prosecuted. Everybody who believes the CIA had ESP teams, trying to use clairvoyance to extract secrets and kill goats, is evidence of the program's success.
- peterkelly 7y agoLast year the Australian government even went so far as to pass a law allowing them to force companies to sabotage their own products/services in cases where a government agency wants to get access to someone's communications. https://www.engadget.com/2018/12/07/australia-access-assistance-bill-now-a-law/ https://www.engadget.com/2018/12/07/australia-access-assista...
- SAI_Peregrinus 7y agoFor an extra scary thought: Atlassian are Australian. Jira tickets can be forced to be altered or deleted, and codebases hosted on bitbucket shouldn't be assumed as trusted. You'll never see a Jira ticket about a 0-day the Australian government doesn't want you to fix if they decide to utilize this law.
- inanutshellus 7y agoNaive question: This cryptography blog seems to, but... is WhatsApp really trusted as secure end-to-end encryption chat client? Colloquially, for one thing it's now owned by one of the biggest personal-data collection companies in the world, which would have little interest in owning a chat client it couldn't benefit from data-wise. For another, I read an article mentioning it was "known" that WhatsApp decrypted your message, stored it, then resubmitted it encrypted to the destination. (Inconveniently, I can't seem to find the article now.) If, say, your life relied on privacy, would you trust WhatsApp, and if not, why?
- epmaybe 7y agoWhile I don't know much about how secure the messages are in WhatsApp, it's easy to imagine other ways Facebook could harvest data from users. They could track what you tap on in the screen, or how much you scroll, or what buttons you click on. They could still use that information to serve ads effectively in the future. Like, how many people click on forwarded messages or pictures.
- lozf 7y agoIt stands to reason that for every WhatsApp conversation they'd have access to: - who is communicating with whom, - dates, times, and durations, - method (text / voice / video), - amount of data transferred, - type of attachment if applicable, and - location of each device, along with unique device identifier, and perhaps other information. See the Privacy International report[0] or video[1] on how much data FB glean from on other apps that merely use the Facebook SDK, each time an app that uses it it opened for a clue... how much more will they want from a service they paid billions for? [0]: https://privacyinternational.org/report/2647/how-apps-android-share-data-facebook-report https://privacyinternational.org/report/2647/how-apps-androi... [1]: https://media.ccc.de/v/35c3-9941-how_facebook_tracks_you_on_android https://media.ccc.de/v/35c3-9941-how_facebook_tracks_you_on_...
- anilgulecha 7y agoGiven that it was built by a highly trusted cryptography team, plus the fact that the protocol can be reverse engineered to confirm encryption and decryption on device, and that over-the-wire traffic has no plaintext, the trust in this is indeed very high. WA has a lot to lose, and big enough target on it for a backdoor to have been found, if E2E is false.
- geggam 7y agoI have often wondered why everyone simply doesnt use Pidgin OTR ... or OTR for every communication
- 693471 7y agoBecause the UI/UX is terrible, and XMPP is not mobile friendly at all
- geggam 7y agoBeing ugly and functional is fine with me. Pretty and exploitable seems a bit silly as a reason for use. Pidgin does so much more than xmpp
- BlueTemplar 7y agoHmm, what is not mobile-friendly with, say, Conversations ?
- 693471 7y agoIt's not an app that can be awakened by a push notification.
- BlueTemplar 7y agoWhat ? https://github.com/siacs/Conversations/issues/1759 https://github.com/siacs/Conversations/issues/1759
- Andrew_nenakhov 7y agoThat is a big fat lie right here.
- 693471 7y agoNo it's not, setting up proper push notifications (Google/Apple) with XMPP is a nightmare and the XEP is not well supported anyway
- DrScientist 7y agoThere are two problems - surveillance itself and the lack of democratic oversight and control. Most people would agree that the state should be able to deprive people of their liberty ( prison ), but that stringent controls should be in place, with that process being public and involve peers ( though that is being slowly undermined in the west ). What are the controls around surveillance? What processes stop abuse? Who is accountable? Where is the transparency? You could argue that you can't be public about intent to spy, but there is a lot more that could be done. https://www.theguardian.com/news/defence-and-security-blog/2015/mar/12/britains-spy-agencies-the-only-watchdog-is-the-workforce https://www.theguardian.com/news/defence-and-security-blog/2...
- najan 7y agosnowden = ehrenmann
- ryacko 7y agohttps://archive.org/details/PikeCommitteeReports/page/n19 https://archive.org/details/PikeCommitteeReports/page/n19 >NSA's work necessarily brings it in possession of the private communications of Americans. This is so because in order for NSA to monitor international lines of communications for foreign intelligence, NSA must intercept all communications transmitted over such links. ... >First, it suggests that NSA is able monitor virtually every international communication entering or leaving the United States. At present, some 24 million telegrams and 50 million telex (teletype) messages enter, leave, and transit the United States annually, and most of these are sent or received by private citizens. Millions of additional messages are transmitted over leased lines, including millions of computer data transmissions electronically entering and leaving the country each year. International telephone calls are yet another potential source of intelligence.
- kevintb 7y agoExcellent article, and great blog find.