17 ms·
Australia uses new technology to catch drivers on phones
- GrumpyNl 7y agoIn Holland they just put a few people on a bus and they look in the cars on the highway, very high score results.
- y4mi 7y agoSo they're ramping up the detection of people using their phones while waiting for the traffic light to turn green? Doesn't really sound like this is actually about safety. I doubt these cameras can capture the photo do a decent quality on that angle for anything but standing or very slow moving cars But I guess we can hope it will stop some people, even if there will be a lot of people caught that weren't really endangering anyone
- javagram 7y agoPeople using their phones while waiting for the light is absolutely a safety issue. They aren’t paying attention and when the light turns green they may either hit a pedestrian as they hurry to move , or not notice the green and be rear ended by a driver who expects them to begin moving.
- yonaguska 7y agoTo second your point- I'd hazard that people using phones at lights are also using them in between lights. I filter at lights despite it being illegal where I live- because I've already been rear ended twice by people on phones. And by filtering I get a great view on people using their phones. They are nine times out of ten using their phones leading up to the light, during the light and during takeoff. I've also noticed that when they notice movement in their peripheral, they start driving forward even when the light is red. I filter much slower now so as to keep people from blindly thinking the light is green and shooting out into traffic or into a pedestrian.
- letmeinhere 7y agoWhat do you mean by "filter"?
- jachee 7y agoI believe they mean riding a motorcycle in the gap between two lanes of traffic, thus "filtering" through the static traffic to the front.
- reaperducer 7y agoIt's worth noting that this is legal in some places. Not everyone on HN may be aware of that. I know I was surprised when I first saw it.
- ludston 7y agoIt's legal in NSW Australia so long as traffic is not moving.
- hnick 7y agoIt's legal in traffic moving up to 30 km/h (including the rider) actually. https://roadsafety.transport.nsw.gov.au/stayingsafe/motorcyclists/lanefiltering/index.html https://roadsafety.transport.nsw.gov.au/stayingsafe/motorcyc...
- cmroanirgo 7y agoThe long name is "lane filtering". I've seen an increase of motorcycle cops lane filtering at traffic lights, looking into the laps of the drivers. If there's a phone there, they're booked.
- Doxterpepper 7y ago> "I've also noticed that when they notice movement in their peripheral, they start driving forward even when the light is red." This has been the case for years. When people aren't paying attention they are pavlovian in staring forward when they notice movement around them. But this doesn't necessarily have to coincide with cell phone usage, just bad driving.
- quotemstr 7y agoDo you have any data to back up this assertion?
- delfinom 7y agoJust not moving at a turn lane because they are texting is big deal. Turn lights are timed precisely to let X number of cars go through. Dick butt takes up most of the time texting and now traffic is stuck backing up from the turn lane into the normal straight traffic lane and onwards.
- paggle 7y agoSure, but it perverts incentives when a crime is punished only when it is a certain level of severity but not when it's more severe than that. For the people who are looking at their phones at red lights today, what percentage of them will stop because of this, and what percentage will say, "Oh there's a camera here, I'll wait until I'm on the highway to check my texts."
- derekp7 7y agoNot only that, but even for those checking while driving, how many people now put the phone down below the dash, where they really can't see traffic when looking at it, vs. holding it up in the air where they can glance back an forth (not that this is really safe either, but looking down at your lap is much worse).
- Doxterpepper 7y ago> They aren’t paying attention and when the light turns green they may either hit a pedestrian as they hurry to move... This sounds like a different issue that can arise without phones being involved. Just because you look at your phone does not mean you need to be sheepish when you look back up. The problem is people are more worried about getting going than being safe. > ...or not notice the green and be rear ended by a driver who expects them to begin moving. If someone rear ends you when the light turns green that is 100% their fault. You can't start moving if the car in front of you is stopped. This has been the case long before the existence of phones.
- SamReidHughes 7y agoAssigning fault has nothing to do with safety.
- kazinator 7y agoIn this case, the fault assignment correctly identifies as unsafe that driver who started moving and rammed a stopped vehicle immediately in front.
- SamReidHughes 7y agoThe stopped vehicle at a green light also increased the probability of collision. Most collisions require two unsafe drivers. One to swerve out of their lane, another who thoughtlessly drive down the highway alongside another car; that sort of thing.
- kazinator 7y agoThere is no excuse for hitting something unmoving, right in front of your vehicle, which has been there the whole time. Vehicles can remain standing on a green for reasons like the engine having stalled, or there still being a pedestrian in front of them. It is not comparable to doing something poorly considered for which there cannot be a good reason, like driving in someone's blindspot on the freeway for hundreds of meters, in low traffic.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- spike021 7y ago>or not notice the green and be rear ended by a driver who expects them to begin moving. That wouldn't be the front driver's fault at all. What if there's someone crossing the road in front of that person and they can't drive off. The person behind them shouldn't be so focused only on the color of the traffic light that they start moving the moment it turns green. That'd be even more unsafe.
- berns 7y ago> or not notice the green and be rear ended by a driver who expects them to begin moving. What? If you ever hit someone like that, I'd say you're ten times more dangerous than anyone texting.
- javagram 7y agoThe driver behind them might be texting too! They see in their peripheral vision that the car next to them is moving and hit the gas without properly looking around.
- brokenmachine 7y agoWell, that's more dangerous than texting while stopped.
- megablast 7y ago> Doesn't really sound like this is actually about safety. Wow, what an ignorant statement. I get a lot of people like to drive without following the rules and think there should be no consequences. Even though driving a car is usually the most dangerous thing you will do today.
- Sendotsh 7y agoI lived in NSW (the state in the article) for a while, and had my car rammed into from behind 3 times in 2 years while I was stopped at a red light, all 3 times the drivers admitted they were checking their phone and hadn't noticed the light go red or me stop. They're not even shy about it, and the casualness at which people use their phones in cars is shocking. I got front and rear dash cams after the 1st hit, to protect myself for insurance claims etc, and caught the following 2 + uncountable near-misses almost all of which were people using their phones, doing make-up, or at one point eating a bowl of cereal while driving. People don't take it seriously at all, and having had a close family member killed by someone blowing a red light while playing on their phone, and my best mate killed by a truck driver mounting the footpath because he was checking his job computer, I'm 100% for stricter punishment against people who don't take driving seriously. Mobile phones, drink driving, all of them can and do lead to people dying and should be treated as such.
- contingencies 7y agoAustralian, but my immediate family and mother in law were in a taxi on a highway in China a few weeks ago and were rammed by a truck from behind. The driver was on her phone. Two broken ribs, neck injury, cuts and bruises, missed flight, missed work. To date, zero insurance payout.
- clairity 7y agoi perused the article and saw nowhere that it said that this would only be used at red lights, which i'd oppose, since that's relatively safer (to look at a phone) than while actually driving (perfect shouldn't be the enemy of better). apparently some cameras are fixed and some are mobile, but presumably they're checking cars that are both moving and stationary (if it so happens to be in view of the camera when/where it stops). distracted driving is a real problem, and phones are a large part of that problem. genuine efforts at curbing distracted driving are welcome, as long as we don't have to trade away all our privacy in the process. i'm generally against camera surveillance for that reason. in any case, continuing improvements in voice control will go a long way toward reducing distracted driving via mobile devices.
- angry_octet 7y agoYou are correct, it is designed to catch moving traffic, but it would also catch someone going underneath in a stationary traffic jam. Actually studies have shown that people on (hands free) phone calls are also very distracted from the task of driving, driving slower than the traffic, around corners etc. [Haque et el at QUT. A small study in a simulator, but it certainly matches anecdotal observation... https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0001457518301246?via%3Dihub https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S00014... ] Just tuning the radio or even listening to the radio can increase response times. Unsurprisingly, having children in the car can also significantly increase risk. [MUARC] Remember that next time you see a Baby On Board sign.
- brokenmachine 7y ago>in any case, continuing improvements in voice control will go a long way toward reducing distracted driving via mobile devices. It'd have to be a lot of continuing improvements because at the moment, voice control is an absolute shitshow and IMO way more distracting than pushing predictable buttons.
- modzu 7y agoi also wonder what the real motive is. just expanding surveillance tech? ceo of this company pals with govt officials?
- 6nf 7y agoThese photos were taken on the Sydney Harbour Bridge, there's no traffic lights on there and there's rarely any stop and go traffic.
- jaimex2 7y agoIt's never about safety. These cameras bring in billions in revenue. If you want to argue that they're not about revenue raising tell me why the Police here strike for pay rises by warning motorists of where the cameras are? https://www.theage.com.au/national/victoria/police-threaten-to-stop-issuing-speeding-fines-over-pay-dispute-20190825-p52kig.html https://www.theage.com.au/national/victoria/police-threaten-... They've done this for at least 3 pay rises in the past and they actually have followed through.
- tebs1200 7y agoHow would you propose authorities stop people from using their phones while driving without: 1. Detecting when people are using their phone while driving? 2. Imposing a penalty when people are caught? Applying a high fine for infringements is a good deterrent. It's definitely about safety as much (if not more) than revenue raising. If people don't want to give revenue to the government, it's simple - don't use your phone while driving.
- fraudsyndrome 7y agoAgreed. You have to draw the line somewhere and I can't believe people are actually arguing against this like they have a leg to stand on.
- read_if_gay_ 7y agoFor these cameras (and speeding cameras, too) to be effective at all, you either: A) need a huge volume of them so people assume they will certainly get caught if they use their phone even just once B) place them at critical spots and make them very clearly visible e.g. via adding signs Otherwise, they're just hidden and rare enough that nobody actually changes their driving style. Now neither A nor B are the case. So what's their use besides making money? Also, why take money only? Off the top of my head, why not something like each time you get caught, you get a "buffered" 1-day driving restriction and once it adds up to some amount it's applied? Currently you can just speed all the time as long as you're not grossly over the limit. All you need to do is pay a little money which might be trivial for some people. A driving restriction might not be. These cameras obviously aren't implemented with safety as a priority. It's about money first and foremost. Safety is just a pretense. Same thing for govt surveillance and so on. It's surprising to me that the same excuse can be used over and over effectively.
- wbercx 7y agoI cross a particularly busy intersection here in Melbourne as a pedestrian every day. At least once a week I see people who are too busy playing with their phones to realise all the cars in front of them had already driven off, the traffic light was now red again, and pedestrians were about to start crossing. The sudden realisation then makes them slam the accelerator without checking their surroundings first. At the same intersection I witnessed an accident where the first driver in line was playing with their phone, got spooked by someone honking, and ran the red light straight into traffic. It's like they're tricking themselves into thinking they're paying enough attention.
- brokenmachine 7y agoThe example pictures they showed on the news reports had cars doing at least 80kmh. It was in the info at the top of the pictures.
- ryandrake 7y agoThey don’t need new technology, just a bus. Sit a few officers in it where their vantage point is about a meter over the top of cars, drive around the highway a bit, and mail merge a bunch of citations. I was bored on a 2 hour bus ride the other day and easily spotted hundreds of drivers fooling around in their phones while driving at highway speed. Mostly texting. Insanity!
- dmix 7y agoThe police do use buses here in Ontario. My friend got a ticket after following behind a bus which had a single officer in the back and a trailing car. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yuJf8ZyjVVg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yuJf8ZyjVVg https://www.narcity.com/ca/on/toronto/news/ontario-police-are-now-riding-transit-buses-near-toronto-to-catch-distracted-drivers-in-the-act-video https://www.narcity.com/ca/on/toronto/news/ontario-police-ar...
- mikeash 7y agoTraffic police around here seem uninterested in enforcing any rules other than red lights and speed limits.
- journalctl 7y agoHonestly, it might be cheaper and easier to just issue tickets to everyone. I’m mostly kidding, but the number of people I see daily driving distracted because of their phones is enormous.
- smileysteve 7y agoStop, why! Aiming to catch people on their phones is a perversion of the laws because we have made it too easy to get away with driving while distracted. It used to be that distracted driving was subjective; but with dash cams on police cars, why can't police crack down on actual distracted indications objectively. All of us anecdotally can guess that someone not moving on green, going slow in the left lane, crossing multiple lanes at the last minute is on their cell phone; So let's start enforcing a law that applies more broadly (eating, intoxicated, cell phone, distracted by passengers, rubber necking) and start seriously enforcing it. If we seriously enforced distracted and reckless behavior, maybe cities wouldn't even have to worry about congestion taxes.
- javagram 7y agoGreat. We need this in every US city ASAP. Walk around in a downtown area and it’s blatantly visible how many drivers use their phones while driving , often performing illegal maneuvers due to their distraction.
- homonculus1 7y agoWe don't need police-connected camera networks running machine learning in any US city.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoEspecially when a officer on the street corner will do the job (and prevent a ton of other petty law violations) just as well without being Orwellian about it. Edit : Do the down-voters care to explain how a networked camera system is somehow better or less orwellian than a human cop?
- javagram 7y agoThis problem is so widespread you would need a lot of cops. Frankly I’d rather have things like automatic cameras than police posted at every intersection. Look at how stuff like speeding works. Putting cops on the highways just makes people alert each other on waze to slow down in one specific area.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoThat's why I'm in support of automated linear speed checks absolutely everywhere.
- pbhjpbhj 7y agoYou mean interval speed cameras? I'd be fine with that if we first can have a conversation on speed limits. It seems on the road network places put in interval cameras and drop the speed limit by 10+mph. On motorways we get a de facto 80mph road going down to 50, regardless of conditions and traffic flow. That seems way to extreme a limitation IMO. Though if the trains were cheaper it wouldn't bother me!
- fooblitzky 7y agoExcellent. I hope the technology also works for truck drivers.
- gruez 7y ago>But it is illegal to touch a phone while driving except to pass it to a passenger. The ban even applies to drivers who are stationary at red lights or stuck in traffic jams. This sounds like a hassle for anyone trying to use gps on their phones. Also, doesn't this essentially outlaw rideshare drivers? How can you accept rides or confirm a pickup if you can't touch the phone? I never saw any driver use voice commands for uber.
- dsfyu404ed 7y ago>This sounds like a hassle for anyone trying to use navigation systems. That's a key feature. It creates probable cause to pull over a huge chunk of drivers and possibly (at the discretion of the cop/department) rake in some revenue while doing it. Screw the poors and their non-integrated GPS. I'm sure someone will tell you it's about safety but if it didn't also please the pro-revenue crowd and the pro-control crowd it wouldn't get done. There's plenty of ways to be pro-safety that are better bang for your buck. This gets done because the other two groups like it too.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jjulius 7y ago>Screw the poors and their non-integrated GPS. "The poors" can still use their non-integrated GPS, just in a safe (set your destination before you drive, pull over to adjust) manner. That's what everyone should be doing anyway.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoPeople who don't drive new enough cars to have integrated GPS buy a suction cup mount for their phone. It's not 2012 anymore, everyone has smartphones, nobody but truckers uses standalone GPS. I know this crowd is too high class to know what it's like but something like using your phone for GPS can be the difference between leaving a fishing stop with a warning or a ticket depending on what kinds of citations the department is trying to prioritize.
- throwaway5752 7y agoHas anyone bought a new car recently? Many essentially have a center mounted full size tablet. Yes, police phone usage. But car newer car interfaces cause a lot of distraction on their own.
- switch007 7y agoNo. The horrific interfaces being one of the reasons :P I've suffered with various hire vehicles though. Some are literally tablets I think (or very good imitations?) - the interfce had pull-down menus, swipe left/right app screens/desktops.
- dsfyu404ed 7y agoKinda funny how HN is normally anti-surveillance and against automated law enforcement unless you frame it as something pro-social. At the end of the day this is still a camera network capable of being repurposed for more sinister means of revenue generation at the whim of the government. If you really want to stop this behavior post a cop on the corner. His presence will prevent people from all sorts of other minor traffic violations too.
- quotemstr 7y agoIt's simpler than that: a lot of HN posters are just anti-car, and anything that makes driving less convenient is a good thing in their eyes.
- hombre_fatal 7y agoThat doesn't fly, because you could dismiss your posts in this comments section the same way: you're pro-car and anything that makes driving less convenient is a bad thing no matter what. It's not very productive discourse to make these claims about others.
- ticmasta 7y agoHave just one experience with an inattentive driver for you or a loved one and then tell me the priority should be "driving convenience".
- maximente 7y agomotor vehicle accidents/deaths are a public health crisis in the US: 30K deaths/yr, $300mil direct medical costs/yr (more indirect obv.) if you are between 18-34 in the US your highest probability of death was/is motor vehicle accident i'm guessing most people here are anti bodily harm/death/opportunity loss due to stupidity/impatience more than anything else
- megablast 7y agoOf course, there are a lot of smart people here.
- 7y ago
- ticmasta 7y agoOne thing that is unclear is that the two independent images, one showing an individual using a phone where they may be personally identifiable and a second showing the car's license plate. So they fine the registered owner of the car for the driver being distracted? What if I'm in a car share? Do they subpoena the companies records or just fine them and have it passed on a la rental cars and speeding tickets? I think distracted driving is a real problem but just like photo radar this punishment weeks after the fact when you get a fine in the mail will have very little impact on the underlying behavior. It's like watching your kids do something unacceptable and then grounding them a week a later as punishment. If they wanted to really change behavior they need to get in the faces of drivers like drinking and driving check-stops; pull them over, ask them if their using their phones, warn them of the danger (they could check for impaired driving at the same time). The problem is cops on the ground costs money; this makes money.
- carterehsmith 7y ago>> So they fine the registered owner of the car for the driver being distracted? Yes, I think that makes sense. If the car owner is a car share company, they will know who the car was shared to, at the time, and then they will send the ticket to that person. And if the car owner just borrowed the car to a spouse/child/friend/whoever, they can pass the ticket to the borrower.
- shoshino 7y agoIn London the rules are really stupid. Using smart-devices while driving is allowed as long as the device is mounted. Woe betide anyone caught with a phone to their ear.
- johnisgood 7y agoYeah, if the reason is attention (and safety), then it does not matter whether it is mounted or not. Your attention is still elsewhere.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tenebrisalietum 7y agoThe only technology needed to solve bad/dangerous driving is a cheap camera phone. Allow people to turn in video of people violating traffic laws in public places for money. Receive more money if it leads to prosecution/fine. Rewards split amongst all who submit videos. Big bonus if person is DUI/OUI/OWI prosecuted. If it's too much to have just anyone do this, then have some sort of minimal-requirements program where you sign up, pay $X, get registered and a permit, and do it. This can help homeless people.
- lukeylunchbox 7y agoThis does not work. A similar system is currently in place in Shenzhen and it is overrun by scammers deliberately running people off the road and doctoring the footage. Many are making a mint from it.
- xur17 7y agoYou could sit at intersections and make bank recording videos of people driving through. So many people are holding their phone in the hand and interacting with it.
- hnick 7y agoAbsolutely. Give the public a cut of the fine, have some rules to avoid abuse, and we'd all be buying dashcams. It'll help so much. A friend told me Taiwan did something similar to great effect (perhaps it was for littering from vehicles) but I'm struggling to find a reference.
- Sendotsh 7y agoGood. People in Australia don't take driving seriously. I spend a lot of time on the road, and have lived all over Australia, and the one defining thing I've found in common all over the country is that people are WAY too casual about driving. Sydney and Melbourne being the worst by far, with it being so bad it has become entertainment[0] On any given commute you'll see dozens of people playing with their phone while doing 110km/h down the freeway, doing make-up, eating cereal out of bowl, reading, blowing red lights (not "late orange" but "it already went red and now the other direction who got a green have to hit the brakes to not get t-boned", ignoring lane lines, ignoring indicators, and/or ignoring the existence of any/every rule or nearby vehicle. It's like a national sport. How much of a dickhead can you be in your car then get violently angry if anyone dares even tap their horn at you to remind you the light has been green for 30 seconds now and you're still flicking through Facebook. [0]https://www.youtube.com/user/DashCamOwnersAustral https://www.youtube.com/user/DashCamOwnersAustral
- GordonS 7y agoTrue story, in the UK: I once saw a guy using an electric razor while driving - and overtaking at ~80mph. I regularly see women doing makeup while driving, stretching up to see their face in the mirror, their car often drifting from left to right. The things some people do while driving are... amazingly fucking stupid.
- brokenmachine 7y agoI'm in Australia and I once saw a lady in a 4WD holding coffee and a cigarette in the one hand, and a phone in the other. She had kids in the back and looked to be driving only using her elbows.
- wiredone 7y ago>People in Australia don't take driving seriously. Honestly, as an Australian living in the US, i'm not sure you have enough context. After living in both Asia and the US, we're a nanny state on this stuff. In the US, people barely ever get breathe tested and often drive drunk, speed everywhere (70-80mph is a lot faster than 110-120kmh). I've also seen Facetime in use multiple times while on the freeway.
- anotherevan 7y agoOn a related note, Dash Cam Owners Australia[1] just put up their monthly video of collected accidents and near misses. I watch these with my kids, who recently started driving, as it is a good lesson in why you drive defensively and not be too arrogant about your own abilities and reaction times - because you have to take into account the abilities, reaction times, and occasionally the boneheaded idiocy of any other driver in your immediate vicinity. “If it weren’t for physics and law enforcement, I’d be unstoppable.” [1] https://www.youtube.com/user/DashCamOwnersAustral/videos https://www.youtube.com/user/DashCamOwnersAustral/videos
- anewguy9000 7y agowhat a waste of money. studies show its not the lack of a free hand that causes accidents, but lack of attention. and hands free is legal. also day by day more cars will have phone paired with the infotainment system
- andrewstuart 7y agoNo fancy technology is needed. All they need is inspectors on motorbikes riding between cars that are stopped at traffic lights. Large number of people are using their phones when waiting at the lights. A motorbike inspector riding between cars would make an infinite number of catches.
- meerita 7y agoPretty much this. Same for bikers with headphones and phones. Just put more cops on intersections and you can feast all day.
- NikolaNovak 7y agoBut; are those really the people you WANT to catch as a matter of priority? What is our goal - sheer income, or safety? :-/ In my mind, I'd rather people check their phone at a stopped traffic light, going 0kph; then while driving at 100kph or turning etc... Ultimately tickets should have a purpose - prevent the most atrocious behaviour we see. There's a poorly marked off-ramp from a major freeway in Toronto; and after off-ramp it's still a divided highway that basically looks like freeway. Cops are constantly staking out this exit because they know they'll get tickets - but what are you teaching? Most of these people were honestly trying to do the relatively right thing. There's no lesson or behaviour modification, just income. (if you want to modify behaviour at that particular offramp, add signing and/or lights etc). Understanding that it's against the law in most places (because technically you are "operating a motor vehicle", I honestly don't have a problem with people glancing at their phone on a red traffic light. Others, I suppose, may vehemently disagree.
- srwx 7y agoIf the motive was to actually stop the behaviour then you'd be correct, however if the motive is simply to collect as many fines as possible then what they're implementing is the best solution.
- andrewstuart 7y agoI turned on the iPhone "do not disturb while driving" functionality which is awesome. It helps me not fiddle with the phone whilst in the car.
- Phillipharryt 7y agoWhat's ridiculous is you can't turn in any footage you take yourself. As a cyclist with a camera on my bicycle I have hundreds of drivers on their phone, yet the police has nowhere for me to turn this in.
- FlagsAreFun 7y agoThis is simply not true. You can report any incidents via Crime Stoppers here: https://www.crimestoppers.com.au/give-information#block-views-block-report-crime-block-1 https://www.crimestoppers.com.au/give-information#block-view.... Each jurisdiction's specific reporting forms are different, but you can usually upload small files as attachments. If you do want the footage to be useful though, you'll have to be willing to put enough personal information in so the police can use you as a witness in court. Your witness account is the primary evidence and the footage the supporting evidence.
- Phillipharryt 7y agoYeah so if I want to give up a lot of personal information, then give up my time appearing in court, and have the guilty party know who I am, then yes, there is a way to report it. But if I don't want that massive impact on my life just to share my clear video and photo evidence, then I can't do anything. But you can report littering easily. No reason I shouldn't be able to do the same for people on their phone. They've made it prohibitively difficult to share my evidence, so I think I'm fine saying there's no way for me to just turn in my footage.
- hnick 7y agoThat seems strange to me. Based on that logic, security camera footage (which has no witness at the time) couldn't be used to solve a crime. But surely it is?
- mikhailfranco 7y agoThe technology is from Acusensus: https://www.acusensus.com/ https://www.acusensus.com/
- aussieguy1234 7y agoAustralian drivers aren't the best, but they're better behaved than drivers in SE Asia. I've driven in Australia and the Philippines. In the Philippines, road rules aren't enforced. In Australia they are, but people don't always follow the rules anyway.
- zmmmmm 7y agoMy prediction is that this initiative will kill people by encouraging phone apps to build in complex voice interaction features that are almost as dangerous but undetectable and therefore will be used indiscriminately by drivers. To those arguing this is a good thing in a black and white manner, please have a think about whether the convenience of that simplistic approach is worth the lives of the people who may die through unintended consequences.
- lsllc 7y agoAbout time. I'm not worried about terrorists, not worried about mass shootings, I'm not worried about meteors or sharks. I'm worried about other drivers using their phone while driving -- that's the existential threat right now by far, and they're everywhere!
- bogomipz 7y agoThe new New South Wales Roads Minister Andrew Constance emphatically states: “>There is no doubt drink-driving as far as I’m concerned is on a par with mobile phone use, and that’s why we want everyone to be aware that you’re going to get busted doing this anytime, anywhere,” Constance told Australian Broadcasting Corp." But the further down we read: >"Photos that show suspected illegal behavior are referred for verification by human eyes before an infringement notice is sent to the vehicle’s registered owner along with a 344 Australian dollar ($232) fine." I'm guessing the penalty for being caught driving under the influence in Australia is far greater than $344 AUD. Why wouldn't they price the infraction for driving while texting similarly then?
- brokenmachine 7y agoAs an Australian, I'm happy they're doing something about stopping stupid/distracted drivers. I'm also very nervous because I'm 100% sure this will end up being abused or "enhanced" in some scary way in the future, or used as an argument for more government AI cameras to police other transgressions.
- Guthur 7y agoAnd yet in the same state, NSW, they could do nothing when my car was stolen and recorded speeding on the motorway. And took nearly a year to apprehend a suspect in the shooting of a fast food restaurant worker when it was caught on multiple cameras. I'm not saying that people should be free to use phones but it's increasingly obvious to me that the police's main objective is to keep mostly lawful people in line, pursuing criminal activity is a secondary concern.
- donatj 7y agoUnpopular opinion, but vehicle deaths are at basically the lowest they’ve been since the introduction of the car. I honestly believe phone use while driving hasn’t had a major effect on safety overall. The statistics certainly don’t indicate it. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_fatality_rate_in_U.S._by_year#/media/File%3AUS_traffic_deaths_per_VMT%2C_VMT%2C_per_capita%2C_and_total_annual_deaths.png https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Motor_vehicle_fatality_rate_...
- dbuder 7y agoI called up an Australian Government agency today, the robot on the phone made me repeat "In Australia, my voice is my identity" three times. There was no skip option, afterwards it said an operator would ask if I consented! I told them no, but it's already gone into the ML engine and they will keep some part of it forever I bet. It didn't even provide any information on who was collecting the audio and what they can do with it outside of the service they are providing to the govt. Australia has become a weird surveillance state for no reason.
- nemdub 7y agoChina has been doing this for years! How can they say they are first in the world? This is an article from 2016: http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2016-08/08/content_26391919.htm http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2016-08/08/content_263919...