14 ms·
Brains are the last frontier of privacy
- SubiculumCode 7y agoYou can have brain privacy, no problem, just as long as the FBI gets a master encryption key, just in case.
- taneq 7y agoJust make sure you only install TSA-approved implants.
- Mirioron 7y agoI'm far less worried about commercial companies doing this than I am worried about governments doing this. Usually when it comes to privacy I can begrudgingly accept that governments will violate it to some degree. This is a field, however, where I think governments must be outright banned from. We must not allow a situation to appear where the TSA or the police will run a quick "brain check" on somebody. It must be avoided. This would be a one way ticket to disaster.
- devoply 7y agoI will bet my left nut that if such a technology exists TSA may use it based on their discretion on any person entering the US including citizens and most citizens will be okay with it and the Supreme Court will hem and haw about it for years before giving some weak half ass decision against it that won't be enforced at all.
- bboygravity 7y ago> I'm far less worried about commercial companies doing this than I am worried about governments doing this. I don't understand this statement. I hope after Snowden we all know that data at a commercial company = data at government? What's the difference? I don't see any practical barriers to various government agencies having access to all data at all companies. With and without company knowledge, mostly secretly, with and without company and customer consent, legally and illegally. This goes for the US, all US allies and all US enemies. The intentions of commercial companies when it comes to data protection from government are pretty irrelevant. If you (as a people) want to ban your government from access to anything specific, you must first have control over your government. Which is inherently impossible in a system that is anything other than a direct democracy. Just my very unpopular opinion. There is no nation in the world that comes close to a people having control over a government, except arguably Switzerland. But even there I have my doubts...
- atemerev 7y agoI live in Switzerland. Direct democracy works perfectly well. I don't understand why it is not the default mode and no other country uses it -- to me, it is the obvious way of running things.
- bboygravity 7y agoI don't live in Switzerland and I completely agree and it blows my mind as well. The standard, surprisingly popular, rhetoric I hear against direct democracy in other European countries is really very unconvincing to me: people are too stupid to vote, people can't know enough about specific subjects to vote well, people aren't interested in politics (duh, why would you in a system where you can't influence politics), people can be influenced too easily through propaganda and other nonsense arguments which would all apply to a representative democracy as well. People don't like change I guess and they (want to) love their country the way it is. On top of that I get a feeling that people somehow look up to politicians subconsciously as somehow being above them or at least being above their neighbors. They seem to equate leadership and sales skills to being able to take hard decisions and being incorruptible / divine. It's like the "king effect" (just made this up): everybody hates the king's decisions, but at the same time the king is the hero and pride of the nation and who could possibly want any other king?
- AmericanChopper 7y agoPeople only have so much attention to give to operating their democracy. Which is why in most instances, the more local you get, the less efficiently government operates. Participation in local elections tends to be a complete joke, and as such those local government bodies tend to only represent a very narrow set of interests. In any case, this form of direct democracy wouldn’t solve the problems the parent is talking about. To achieve that, you’d need to vote on every decisions made by every public official ever.
- atemerev 7y agoThis is how it works here. We have local, cantonal and federal laws; the laws to vote on are presented in packages once every two months (so every time, people vote on both local and federal laws). Our participation is not a joke. Every Swiss citizen can propose a law to be voted on one of the next referendums, provided that they will collect the appropriate minimum number of signatures in its support.
- justinmk 7y agoI agree, but it's inevitable. The state has claimed all conceivable cut-points or transitions: - Transportation. Any time you want to go somewhere by car or plane (and potentially bus/train[1]), the government has decided it has the right to search you. - Interstate commerce. Most economic activity is taxed, and may be searched passively or actively to ensure that the state gets everything it wants. - Communication. TV, radio, telephone, and now the internet are monitored and adjusted by the state. Brain-to-network communication will eventually be commoditized, and the state will transitively invent some justification for monitoring it. Thus you may think thoughts which are shared with the network and for which you will be held liable. The only difference is that today you type the thoughts on a keyboard. I wrote an essay about this in 2011, for university. [1] http://news.antiwar.com/2010/11/25/napolitano-eyes-full-body-scans-for-trains-ships-mass-transit/ http://news.antiwar.com/2010/11/25/napolitano-eyes-full-body...
- bostik 7y agoNow, do you really think it would be something as straightforward and innocent-looking? A much more likely scenario is that brainstreams would be stored in various tech giants' systems (and because analytics is important, ~nothing is discarded). Instead of running a quick check, the police or official would pull your thought history. But no, not directly from the source. Of course not. To maintain a veneer of legitimacy, the actual tech companies will not sell to governments or law enforcement. There will be a forest of brokers, who sell to anyone. And if you thought advertising was invasive or creepy now, with this kind of technology we would be entering a world Philip K. Dick would have found too depressing to write about.
- mattlutze 7y agoCurrent laws would make it even simpler. In the US at least, an agency could simply have subpoenas approved by a judge, and then require the disclosure of whatever brain info any number of companies have for a person. The companies could of course sue to not disclose, but there'd be enough firms that would comply as to make access trivial for whichever agency wanted the info.
- bostik 7y agoWarrants and subpoenas are inconvenient. They are targeted and may take time to be issued. And observing from the outside, US as a nation is still years - likely decades - from being able to stomach general warrants. But you are already well on your way towards something like that: reverse warrants are now a thing. Law enforcement in US has already issued a warrant for recorded information on all persons who were near an event after the fact. The logical conclusion with brain data archives will be to issue warrants for full mental activity history for X years on people who have had thoughts on a given unwelcome subject. But even then, warrants are inconvenient. It'll be much simpler and easier to just buy access to the data in bulk, all the time. That avoids the awkward questions on storage, access and oversight.
- mbeex 7y agoNo ban will stop that. Whatever is possible will also be done, that has always been the case. As usual, there will be an arms race and possibly, for example, meditation teachers will open up completely new fields of activity.
- _Microft 7y agoMy european take on this: governments are the only entities that can keep companies in check. A completely free, unregulated market is a bit like anarchy: it might work well if all of the actors were mature and aware of their responsibilities. Unfortunately the ones who wish for that the most are usually the ones least suited for it. They support these ideas not because of a noble goal of perfect freedom but because they are annoyed that there is a more powerful entity that gets in the way of what they want to do with/to others.
- wongarsu 7y agoI would go a step further and say the only completely free and unregulated market is anarchy. Take a regular state and strip away all those regulations about consumer protection, environment protection, substance abuse, contract enforcement etc, and stop all this socialist stuff like public healthcare, public unemployment insurance, and public roads, and you are left with is stateless anarchy. If you remove anything less you can always claim there's regulation and no truly free markets.
- mantas 7y agoI'd rather see free market as fair playfield for all players. With clear rules that equally apply to each without special treatment. Wether written or not.
- wongarsu 7y agoYou could start with a minimum viable capitalistic state (enforcement of property rights and contacts through police and courts, some sort of government to update laws as necessary, taxes to pay for it all) and from there add basic infrastructure where competition is impractical, like roads, subsurface conduits for laying electricity and data lines, sewage systems, etc; investments that are beneficial to the overall economy but not rewarded by the market like parks, public transportation, and dams; things that ensure a good work force like public education (to supply educated workers) and public healthcare (to keep workers healthy and productive). Optionally you can add laws to improve the free market: consumers can't reliably judge food safety or environmental impact, so make the worst things illegal and improve transparency on the rest (food labeling etc), or impose taxes to mirror true costs to society. All of this is a free market in your definition, and is essentially how European states are run. But it's somehow not what "free market" advocates in the US want today.
- sorokod 7y agoDo not governments have access to the same data given the right paperwork?
- emptyparadise 7y agoIf companies invent the tech, the governments will be able to use it no matter what. 90% of all the things China is using are based on Silicon Valley research. Plus, even if you don't let TSA or the police have the scanners, it would still be possible to subpoena companies for your latest thoughts as they happen. /The only/ way to not allow this to be the absolute end of privacy is to have the technology be shaped in an incredibly ethical way that makes such privacy violations fundamentally impossible. Store close to no data. Constantly encrypt whatever data you do store and keep it on the device itself. Constantly cycle keys. Make brain scanners absolutely worthless unless the user consciously authenticates themselves. Requiring all brain scanners to be 100% fully open (full on GPLv3 including the hardware plans) and physical networking kill switches would be a good start. All of this is not even new advice - there are quite a few outspoken people out there against any sort of data collection. But whether you agree with them or not, you must agree that the line in the sand must be drawn somewhere - and it definitely should not allow collecting people's thoughts. Trying to extend the Google and Facebook model of siphoning as much of your data as possible to also include thoughts should literally be a crime against humanity.
- koboll 7y agoIn theory, we should already disallow this. The foundational law of the United States prohibits "unreasonable" searches of "persons, houses, papers, and effects". In practice, this has been eroded to the point of practical meaninglessness, such that the FBI director can issue a statement that clearly violates both its spirit and its letter, and few people bat an eye.
- octosphere 7y agoWell to some degree you might be right, but don't forget the USG is in bed with the private sector and regularly sends out NSLs[0] to companies asking for back doors and full access to customer/user data [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_security_letter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_security_letter
- entropea 7y agoA lot of modern privacy violations come from private companies like Facebook, Equifax, Google, etc. Government or Corporation should never have access to anything like this. They _never_ use it for good.
- thrwayxyz 7y agoAnd people laughed when I surgically installed a farady cage inside my skull.
- lostlogin 7y agoSome decent orthodontic braces and a couple of little screws in the skull and you’ll keep the fMRI at bay for a while yet. Though it might be cheaper to just move a little and ruin it that way instead.
- juanuys 7y agoNeuralink will give the border agencies good bandwidth on our brains, so at least the queue will move quickly!
- octosphere 7y agoFor those needing to know more about Neuralink: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuralink https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuralink
- idclip 7y agoI am not worried about this. More amused and excited about the future of cognitive exploration and expansion. I believe in the way, and all that’s happening is natural. I don't think the collective organism of us would really create a hell for itself. Human civil courage and compassion is a golden guard against the truly reprehensible. Let them try. Also +1 switzerland. Hope to see that style of being on a global scale.
- wongarsu 7y agoIt's much easier to get into power if you are ruthless and without empathy. As a consequence we are mostly ruled by psychopaths who don't have a problem with creating hell for other people if it benefits them
- guerrilla 7y agoThey already do...
- plaidfuji 7y agoJust out of curiosity, when you say “I believe in the way”, is that in reference to Taoism?
- arugulum 7y agoIAGO Good my lord, pardon me: Though I am bound to every act of duty, I am not bound to that all slaves are free to. Utter my thoughts? Why, say they are vile and false; As where's that palace whereinto foul things Sometimes intrude not? who has a breast so pure, But some uncleanly apprehensions Keep leets and law-days and in session sit With meditations lawful? (Othello 3.3.135-141)
- mplanchard 7y agoFor folks on mobile: IAGO > Good my lord, pardon me: > Though I am bound to every act of duty, > I am not bound to that all slaves are free to. > Utter my thoughts? Why, say they are vile and false; > As where's that palace whereinto foul things > Sometimes intrude not? who has a breast so pure, > But some uncleanly apprehensions > Keep leets and law-days and in session sit > With meditations lawful?
- segfaultbuserr 7y agoI remember some tweets from DJB. https://twitter.com/hashbreaker/status/709314886384427008 https://twitter.com/hashbreaker/status/709314886384427008 > Fun game to play: Take statements from Comey et al. Replace "smartphones" with "brains"/"memories"/"thoughts". Technology will get us there! > "Everybody is walking around with a Swiss bank account in his brain if government can't get in. You cannot take an absolutist view on this." > "How do we solve or disrupt a terrorist plot if law enforcement can't access the memories and thoughts inside suspected terrorists' brains?" Both funny and scary. Time to rewatch the TV animation version of Ghost in the Shell [0] again. Released in 2000s, it portrayed and predicted our world remarkably well, and it'll give you a lot of inspirations of what would the future society look like when everyone uses an electronic brain. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghost_in_the_Shell:_Stand_Alone_Complex https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghost_in_the_Shell:_Stand_Alon...
- marmaduke 7y ago> Technology will get us there! Perhaps but not quickly. Decoding brain activity is still a hard thing to do.
- JrProgrammer 7y ago(Insert any cipher) was too at its time.
- marmaduke 7y agoBrain activity isn't a cipher.
- segfaultbuserr 7y agoThere can be a cipher, if we are talking about electronic brains from GiST. But it doesn't change the issue nor the jokes.
- segfaultbuserr 7y agoYou should remember that the context of the jokes was about the statements from ex-FBI's head James Comey on encryption backdoor in the middle of the Crypto War 2 back in 2016. > "(with encryption) Everybody is walking around with a Swiss bank account in his smartphone if government can't get in. You cannot take an absolutist view on this (, and we must add backdoors)." Replace "smartphones" with "brains". > "(with encryption) Everybody is walking around with a Swiss bank account in his brain if government can't get in. You cannot take an absolutist view on this (, and we must add backdoors)." Get the joke now?
- needle0 7y agoWow, thoughtcrime is ceasing to be fiction. Even in the original 1984 novel, they could only be detected when those thoughts manifested as actual words and action. This goes further. I fear for how much restraint we will show when we become technologically able to detect thoughts that are deemed reprehensible in current society. Some ideas that were considered reprehensible in the past have become part of ordinary norms in the modern day; I still don't consider ourselves today to be infallible in always making those decisions correctly. For now, even having ideas currently considered most heretical/reprehensible is still legal, as long as it never leaves your head - but I'm not quite confident it will stay that way in the face of mounting pressure.
- wongarsu 7y agoPrivacy is essential to progress. The moment we punish deviant thoughts society will stagnate
- sriku 7y agoJust for argument, what if removal of privacy is the "deviant thought" that this thinking is trying to punish?
- wongarsu 7y agoI don't know. I can't even say if society stagnating is bad. I think society improved over the centuries and millennia, but of course I agree that the values I was raised into are the right ones. I don't have objective measures to verify this. I think I have good reasons and could argue them for hours, but in the end it's no different than arguing religion. The best chain of reasoning is worthless if the axioms are chosen arbitrarily.
- zaroth 7y agoThis makes about as much sense as being intolerant to intolerance. You’re free to privately believe that privacy shouldn’t exist. That is materially different from trying to eradicate privacy to cement state control over a populace — in an age where the State has almost immeasurably great power to track, monitor, and police its citizens.
- perfunctory 7y agoThe title reminded me of the sci-fi novel The Dark Forest, where potential alien invaders could read all human communication accept of human mind. The UN selects four men to be "Wallfacers". Each one of them is supposed to devise a defence strategy known only to himself and they are granted access to UN resources to carry out the plans.
- ausbah 7y agoWhat's also worth noting about the Wallfacers is how for 3/4 of them, the aliens and their human supporters were still able to figure out their "inaccessible plans" simply by deducing from their actions. In some ways it feels like a waste to try and directly read the mind when humans can be pretty well predicted by their outside thoughts alone.
- mattlutze 7y ago> And next month Chilean lawmakers will propose an amendment to the country's constitution enshrining protections for neural data as a fundamental human right, according to Yuste, who is advising on the process. In the US, I have a right against forced self-incrimination. The rights against indiscriminate search and seizure and protection of speech also seem to apply. Being able to read my thoughts would seem to negate my protection against the disclosure of self-incriminating speech (presuming thoughts are considered speech). This frontier is all the more concerning while our dominant model of commerce on the internet is the exchange of content for attention. The attention market already drives businesses to develop sophisticated, targeted models of users, so that the businesses can most efficiently encourage addiction to their services. Being able to tune those mechanisms in real-time could be disastrous. It is encouraging to see at least one government making an effort to get ahead of this, and their work can be an example for the rest of the world on how to protect people from a looming dystopia.
- buboard 7y agoWell, actually ... you d have to incorporate the peripheral Neural system. People may start using that to think, in an attempt to escape brain surveillance. And also any extracorporal BMI device they might use to augment their mind.
- cam_l 7y agoWas thinking about why privacy is important, reading the Snowden post on HN this morning. And it stupidly occurred to me, the privacy is only important insomuch as it is related to power. I say stupidly, because it is such an obvious thing, but one that might be ignored or forgotten, without a sustained reminder. In the face of such an understanding, the distinction between government or commercial privacy is meaningless. If that lack of privacy can have significant power over your life, the source doesn't matter. The content doesn't matter.
- matz1 7y agoThen, instead of privacy, we should make government (and company) as open and as transparent possible to level the playing field.
- nnd 7y agoCould you share the link to the post?
- cam_l 7y agohttps://theintercept.com/2019/09/21/edward-snowden-permanent-record-book/ https://theintercept.com/2019/09/21/edward-snowden-permanent...
- andrewfromx 7y agofrom https://cyborg.st https://cyborg.st FAQ: Q. What exactly is the surgery? A. You can think "type these letters" and make your fingers type them, or you can route that same electronic message via bluetooth to the phone near you. This surgery is like going from dial-up internet speed to broadband. You can type much faster without fingers!
- rothron 7y agoWe used to laugh at the tin-foil hat people. Maybe they were just ahead of their times.
- helpPeople 7y ago"History repeats itself" Although technology is new, spying is not.
- abacadaba 7y agoNo the brainwave satellites have been operational for quite a while now.
- quickthrower2 7y agoAnd sadly they could have used those satellites for faster rural internet instead.
- helpPeople 7y agoQuestion for today's Privacy thread- Why is there an expectation of privacy? If I talk loud, people will hear me. If I drive across the country, I'll be seen. Why is internet traffic any different? Sure it might be good to have Privacy, but I'm not sure why HN think it's natural or something. I can only think of a few rare circumstances where people are anti government and need to hide their tracks for everyone's benefit. But given PRISM, those people already know they are being watched. Who are we protecting with "Privacy"?
- etiam 7y agoThere is certainly the disturbing possibility that "Welcome to Life" [ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IFe9wiDfb0E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IFe9wiDfb0E ] will rapidly be looking less and less like satire.
- foxhop 7y agoI would say, this will never be socially acceptable ... Until my parents in law installed multiple Alexa microphones in their house, and my family of origin all submitted DNA to ansestry.com to be indexed forever... Generally speaking, the way to buy a soul is to offer convinieance. It doesn't even have to be major. For all those thinking there will be regulation or protections, where are those protections for consumers of the current privacy violating services and products? You sign on the dotted line and are bound by the terms, there is no big other to protect you from you own choices. You choose whether you sell yourself, but once you do, don't expect a bigger force to keep you protected... You are the only person who is going to advocate for you and the people you care about.
- jcims 7y ago>Generally speaking, the way to buy a soul is to offer convinieance. Or safety.
- GordonS 7y agoYes, but only along with a constant barrage of FUD that demonises other nations, and has people in fear about things that are unlikely to happen.
- jcims 7y agoTotally agree but that hasn’t been a barrier in the past.
- jeffdavis 7y agoWhy do you think this is limited to fearing other nations? Say the word "drugs" or the word "guns" and watch the people rush to throw the Bill of Rights away.
- GordonS 7y agoYou're right, it's all about the "boogeyman de jour" - at present that's China and Russia, but it could just as easily be drugs, Islam, whatever.
- andrerm 7y agoWhy worry? Facebook's Privacy Police says they value our privacy. And Neuralink's home page doesn't even have a Privacy Police. And Neuralink's paper [1] doesn't even mention the word privacy once. My point is, we will never have privacy from tech because tech's most valuable field is ourselves. So we all respect others people privacy but we need to harvest every data point we can because otherwise what will we do, kernels and drivers? [1] https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/703801v3.full https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/703801v3.full
- plaidfuji 7y agoIn principle this makes sense; where the line around “your thoughts” is drawn is much more difficult to define in practice. What is a thought? Is it the words you hear inside your head as you think? The images? Do those even have a concrete biological representation? Are we just talking about patterns in neural signaling cascades? If so, I doubt that “thinking about a tree” looks the same from one person to the next. Which means that these patterns will have to be learned from training data (once the sensing technology exists). Brains exist to decide to take actions. In the above case, companies with an interface to your brain will only “understand” your thoughts insofar as they map to actions you can take through their services, or “API”, so to speak. In that sense, It feels like we’ve already crossed this line. Let me be more concrete: unless there were, say, a bomb manufacturer with a brain-API that you “trained” and used regularly, nobody will be able to decode that you think about bombs in your spare time. Unless, of course, a (hypothetical) brain computer interface just translates your thoughts into “stream of consciousness” strings of words - but if that were the case, how does that add value over a speech-to-text google search? TL;DR, if you’re worried about the thought police, look around you - we’re already there. Your “thoughts” are just the actions you decide to take using technology.
- aasasd 7y agoI don't agree that it's the ‘last frontier.’ Let's say the government and corporations watch everything you do outside of your house, both physically and on the web. What's left for you to do in your brain has a term, ‘mental masturbation.’ It doesn't matter what you're imagining in your head if you can't act on those thoughts.
- carapace 7y ago"The computer says you're lying."
- Medicalidiot 7y agoWe're getting close to being able to tell whether someone is lying based off of an EEG, it seems like it's just a matter of time until we're able to read other people's thoughts. No one in this thread will see that happen in their lifetime.
- almost_usual 7y agoThe only interface that makes sense to me for this kind of application is something non-invasive and can be removed like headphones. Governments could still forcibly apply it to you under certain circumstances but you might be able to retain some semblance of privacy otherwise.
- titzer 7y agoOur society still hasn't processed just how fundamentally different the psychological experience of today is from the rest of humanity's existence, just as recently, say the 1980s or 1970s. Prior to the advent of smartphones and ubiquitous computation and surveillance, social media and the narcissism economy, one could actually live their own lives from a first person perspective without worrying about people looking over their shoulder every single second. Now, today, we are literally carrying around an audience with them everywhere, whether that be the photos they may consider posting to Instagram, or the machine learning algorithms monitoring their location to figure out what advertising to direct at them, or government surveillance to determine if they are some kind of threat. Heck, people even install apps that monitor their sleeping patterns and upload that data to a third party. It's almost as if we have created either the all-seeing eye of Sauron, or a tiny portable film crew following everyone around all the time for our egos. I, for one, do not plan to put anything in my brain I have not designed myself, and for sure nothing that auto-updates!
- sixstringtheory 7y agoHell, it took me hours to straighten out my update to iOS 13 because my backup had trouble restoring... not the first time that’s happened either! Can’t remember the last workday (programmer) where I got through the whole thing without encountering bugs in my tools, bugs in my bank’s app/website, bugs while trying to text a photo to a friend, and on and on and on. If I want to hack my consciousness, I’ll go read a book. Naked Lunch was enough of a brain bug, thanks. Or how about Black Mirror? And once we get past not knowing wtf we’re doing, take a look at how we’ve weaponized every major scientific advance and tell me this would be the exception. Rabble-rousing and voter manipulation on social media will look like arts and crafts hour.
- m3kw9 7y agoNot really, there will probably still be ways to keep secrets, as that’s what privacy basically are
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- drdeadringer 7y agoThere are reasonable people today who buy "RFID wallets" and are not generally considered to be overly paranoid. It seems at least a possibility that we will enter a future where similar people will buy the related product of "RFID hats" [as branded with whatever acronym this technology adopts, and perhaps as an "also suggested by Amazon" to boot].
- nnd 7y agoJust out of curiosity, does anyone have a comprehensive argument of why absolute privacy is essential? I understand the possibility of abuse of the power granted to governments, but is there a solution for identifying malicious actors that doesn't involve privacy compromises?
- numbol 7y agoCGP grey have a cool short video "I, phone" about that topic https://youtu.be/e-ZpsxnmmbE https://youtu.be/e-ZpsxnmmbE
- lchiang 7y agohttps://www.wsj.com/video/under-ais-watchful-eye-china-wants-to-raise-smarter-students/C4294BAB-A76B-4569-8D09-32E9F2B62D19.html https://www.wsj.com/video/under-ais-watchful-eye-china-wants... The intrusion to brains has already started. Schools in china are experimenting on using brain-wave trackers to track whether students are paying attention in class. But the parents do not seem to care. It is likely to give false readings so the accuracy is unclear. The picture is scary. They do not seem to care about the privacy issue even though the benefits are unclear. They are OK to sell out for ... maybe nothing.
- gateKeeper 7y agoFrom the article: • Driving the news: Neuroethicists are sounding the alarm. • Earlier this month the U.K.'s Royal Society published a landmark report on the promise and risk of neurotechnology, predicting a "neural revolution" in the coming decades. • And next month Chilean lawmakers will propose an amendment to the country's constitution enshrining protections for neural data as a fundamental human right, according to Yuste, who is advising on the process. • A major concern is that brain data could be commercialized, the way advertisers are already using less intimate information about people's preferences, habits and location. Adding neural data to the mix could supercharge the privacy threat. • "Accessing data directly from the brain would be a paradigm shift because of the level of intimacy and sensitivity of the information," says Anastasia Greenberg, a neuroscientist with a law degree.
- LocalH 7y agoI don't have much faith for governments to get this right. They already infringe on mental autonomy heavily.