5 ms·
This is the second reason why indexing outperforms actively managed funds over the long term (The first reason is the fees). Price weighed index fund rebalance
by nabla9 7y ago
This is the second reason why indexing outperforms actively managed funds over the long term (The first reason is the fees).
Price weighed index fund rebalances regularly and never misses out those best-performing four percent. Actively managed fund manager might do a good job valuing companies and might catch some success stories, but it's unlikely that they catch them all consistently.
- digianarchist 7y agoIsn't there only a handful of hedge funds that have posted profits every year of operation?
- nradov 7y agoYes but most of us aren't allowed to invest in them.
- iamlucaswolf 7y agoI don't pretend to know the numbers, but my guess is that Survivorship Bias might account for that to a substantial amount. I just can't imagine that there are people with glass bowls that good to make consistent alpha over the long term.
- Scoundreller 7y agoIn my dreams, I create 1024 stock-recommending twitter bots. If half beat the market in a year and half don’t, i’ll Still have one that goes up every year after 10 years, and sell it for a fortune.
- Majromax 7y ago> If half beat the market in a year and half don’t As per this article, that wouldn't happen: more than half of the bots would fail to beat the market. This article finds that the vast majority of the positive return is explained by relatively few stocks, leading to a positive skewness. The median random choice has a below-mean outcome.
- Scoundreller 7y agoRight. Regression toward the mean is inevitable. But I think people appreciate a story about picking the right stock more than the right stocks, which helps that problem.
- lonelappde 7y agoPlease read Paulos's classic book Innumeracy, on its 30th anniversary https://math.temple.edu/~paulos/oldsite/scam.html https://math.temple.edu/~paulos/oldsite/scam.html
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- johnrgrace 7y agoALmost all have posted profits, only a very few have posted profits higher than their risk adjusted peers.
- topmonk 7y agoWhen companies have now started to go into debt to buyback shares and artificially raise their EPS, who are they targeting? The people who are actively evaluating what they're buying, or those asleep at the wheel buying index funds? Index funds might have been a good investment in the past, before wallstreet has figured out how to exploit it like they're doing today.
- buttcoinslol 7y ago> When companies have now started to go into debt to buyback shares and artificially raise their EPS, who are they targeting? Their shareholders, which includes management. Buybacks are essentially dividends in another form. Buybacks have the upside of not being expected to go up indefinitely, and there are no dividend cuts to upset investors.
- topmonk 7y agoWhy does everyone ignore the second part of my point? Corporations are going into record debt to do this. It is one thing to pay back shareholders by a dividend or buyback or whatever, if the company has extra profits, but it is quite another to borrow money to do it. That works for now, but as soon as those interest rates tick up...
- buttcoinslol 7y agoMoney is extremely cheap to borrow, and companies have decided the interest rate risk is lower than the short-term share price gains from borrowing money to do buybacks. Perhaps current management assumes they won't be the ones left holding the bag. I agree with you, when rates go up a large amount of zombie companies being held up by cheap money are going to go bankrupt, and it will have large ripple effects.
- glofish 7y agoFrom what I understand this exact same argument is reiterated every decade. "It worked in the past but today is different" - invariably ending up with a suggestion to give up increasingly large amounts of your profits to someone that "manages your investments" for you. I would do it if the fees were fixed, once someone asks for a "percent" I call BS. There is no difference between managing 100K and 1M yet you pay 10 times more. I'll stick with Vanguard.
- PorterDuff 7y ago" indexing outperforms actively managed funds" Most index funds are actively managed.
- buttcoinslol 7y agoSeeking to replicate the performance of an index by trading a basket of stocks/futures/options is not active management. For instance, when an institutional investor gives SPDR say, $300,000,000 for a million shares of SPY, the fund goes out at purchases the underlying stocks in proportions that match the composition of the S&P 500, and then issues the SPY shares and holds the underlying and dividend payments in trust. SPDR does not have the option to choose the shares, they purchase a basket that replicates the S&P 500. This is passive management, there is no one actively picking stocks, and when to buy/sell them.
- PorterDuff 7y agoSo who decides what the DJIA and S&P 500 stocks actually are? A random number generator?
- buttcoinslol 7y agoI will assume your interest is genuine, here are links to the documents explaining the methodology behind the various S&P[0] and DJ indices[1]. I'm sure you can find documents for /RUT and IWM (Russell 2000), as well as /NQ and QQQ (Nasdaq 100) if you would like to see those as well. [0]https://us.spindices.com/documents/methodologies/methodology-sp-us-indices.pdf https://us.spindices.com/documents/methodologies/methodology... [1]https://us.spindices.com/documents/methodologies/methodology-dj-averages.pdf https://us.spindices.com/documents/methodologies/methodology...
- navigatesol 7y agoThe point, with which I agree, is that it's still active, just much less so. It's a bit pedantic, but assuming ETFs are passive by definition could get people crushed when these themed tickers get outflows.